Pirates: The Russian Solution

The most ironic thing about it is that all the blood thirsty right wingers here on terb are rooting for the russian system and are wishing they lived under similar conditions. That have no clue what they are wishing for.
Perhaps it's because I'm not "blood thirsty" and am quite familiar with many of the problems of life in Russia that I haven't said that I wished to live under Russian Law?
 
Perhaps it's because I'm not "blood thirsty" and am quite familiar with many of the problems of life in Russia that I haven't said that I wished to live under Russian Law?

If you read up on the thread there are a lot of people who are asserting that the Russians did the right thing in trashing the rule of law. Presumably those people who are saying that would rather live under a dictatorship than a democracy.
 
"It is the universal right and the universal duty of all nations, regardless of whether their ships have been beset by the particular pirate captured, to capture, try by naval court and, if found guilty, to execute the pirate(s) by hanging."

Yes, exactly. Note the requirement that the executions are only permitted after having found them guilty of piracy by way of a properly constituted court martial hearing pursuant to the admiralty law of the nation that has captured the pirates. My whole complaint here is that the Russians did not do that. Instead without colour of right, and not under the authority of any law known to man, they murdered unarmed prisoners.

We do not know whether or not everyone that they murdered would in fact have been found guilty of piracy. Maybe some who were present but did not participate in the piracy, or only to such a minor degree that capital punishment was unjustified. Moreover even if every single one of them was deserving of capital punishment the complete disregard for the rule of law is nevertheless fundamentally offensive precedent--they deserved their day in court. We all deserve the assurance that we will not be mistaken for pirates and murdered at sea by rogue Russian soldiers without so much as a fair hearing at which to argue our case.

To be clear if they had held a free and fair court martial hearing at which they found the pirates guilty and subsequently executed them--I would have no problem with that.
 
Yes, exactly. Note the requirement that the executions are only permitted after having found them guilty of piracy by way of a properly constituted court martial hearing pursuant to the admiralty law of the nation that has captured the pirates. My whole complaint here is that the Russians did not do that. Instead without colour of right, and not under the authority of any law known to man, they murdered unarmed prisoners. . . .To be clear if they had held a free and fair court martial hearing at which they found the pirates guilty and subsequently executed them--I would have no problem with that.
So if they had been granted a drumhead naval trial as was not uncommon in the Eighteenth Century, found guilty and hanged within four or five hours that would satisfy your desire for the legal nicities?
 
So if they had been granted a drumhead naval trial as was not uncommon in the Eighteenth Century, found guilty and hanged within four or five hours that would satisfy your desire for the legal nicities?

Even back then a drumhead naval trial was only acceptable when there were extenuating circumstances that made holding a proper trial impractical, and more modern conventions make that clear as well. I would expect them to provide the same quality of hearing as they would provide to their own soldiers in capital cases when faced with the same practicalities.

In any case they did not even hold so much as a drumhead naval trial. At least at a drumhead trial some of the accused could have made a case to the officers that they were not actually involved in the piracy and received SOME hearing of their claims. Not really acceptable in modern days, but sure as heck better than what the Russians did!
 
I would expect them to provide the same quality of hearing as they would provide to their own soldiers in capital cases when faced with the same practicalities.
Ah, so we come full circle or pretty much so.

What you really want all States to do is to go to great expense to provide full blown trials for everyone found in flagrante in acts of piracy. This is precisely what the Russians declined to do.
 
Perhaps a better solution is arming some of these ships to be able to properly defend themselves...when attacked. This would probably deter the pirates over time.

There is precedent for this...a cruise ship successfully defended itself a few years ago.
 
Ah, so we come full circle or pretty much so.

What you really want all States to do is to go to great expense to provide full blown trials for everyone found in flagrante in acts of piracy. This is precisely what the Russians declined to do.

I do believe in the rule of law, yes. If you support the extra-judicial murder of unarmed prisoners without a trial then what you believe in is reprehensible. What should happen next is the Russians should get a fair trial for their crime against humanity.
 
ship was headed to my port beam and refused all contact efforts. I sounded the danger signal and seconds later it began to sink. We called out PAN PAN and began rescue efforts.............An indeterminate number of souls were lost. We will stand by to aid recovery efforts
 
Then fairly cut and dried naval trials of an eighteenth century style onboard ship should satisfy you for those taken in flagrante in acts of piracy.

Even in the 18th century a barrel head hearing was acceptable only when there were circumstances that made a properly constituted court martial impossible or impractical. Like, say, nowhere to keep the prisoners, an impending attack, etc., then they would short-circuit the process out of necessity. When it was possible to do so even the 18th century demanded a proper court martial, and of course, in 2010 we have a more nuanced view of admiralty law than in the 18th century and much stronger demands for freedom and fairness.
 
Ah, so we come full circle or pretty much so.

What you really want all States to do is to go to great expense to provide full blown trials for everyone found in flagrante in acts of piracy. This is precisely what the Russians declined to do.

We have indeed come full circle, councel. I wonder if you would change your views on this legal matter if you would happen to be boarded by a russian naval vessel while cruising on a pleasure boat somewhere in international waters. Or would you be happy with the russian navy accusing you of intent to piracy and shooting you and your shipmates?

I do not always agree with Fuji, but on the issue of rule of law, there cannot be too many grey areas between yes and no. I would have thought our learned councel would have been the first to insist on the rule of law.
 
Even in the 18th century a barrel head hearing was acceptable only when there were circumstances that made a properly constituted court martial impossible or impractical.
A properly constituted court would have been aboard the Commodore or Admiral's flagship.
 
We row (or these days motor or fly) over to the flagship and five or six hours later hanging from the yardarm (we could probably only hang them two at a time these days so there would have to be some pauses).
 
Read up on Piracy and Admiralty Law related to piracy Danmand.

No need to. The russians, instead of giving them due process, said they had set them afloat without navigation equipment or means of survival. If they had had a "trial" they would have said so. They did not.

It is a shame lawyers do not have to swear to an oath like medical doctors must, to always uphold the law etc. etc. But maybe you are one of these corporate lawyers spending your days inventing new sneaky ways of laying people off without paying severence payments.
 
We row (or these days motor or fly) over to the flagship and five or six hours later hanging from the yardarm (we could probably only hang them two at a time these days so there would have to be some pauses).

Sorry, wait--are you telling me the Russians were in a rowboat?
 
And we put Engineers underneath the bridge or building when it fails?

Engineers are held responsible for failures, just as lawyers and any other professionals.

My post was about something entirely different, namely that I think it is a pity that lawyers do not have to swear an oath to always uphold the rule of law.