Pirates: The Russian Solution

Hostis humani generis (Latin for "enemy of mankind") is a legal term of art, originating from the admiralty law, and referring to the peculiar status, before the public international law, of maritime pirates, since time immemorial.

Do you regularly enjoy shooting yourself in the foot? You do know that hostis humani generis requires that pirates be tried by court martial? If you would like to invoke that, rather than Russian admiralty law, then be my guest. The outcome is the same--they were entitled to a trial.

Russia in any case has signed the conventions that assert such trials will be conducted according to Russian admiralty law.... so we're back to what I was telling you, no?

And how idiotic are you when you keep tying the "rule of law" with "democracy"?

Democracy fundamentally depends on the rule of law.
 
Oh and one more thing about the Pirate's Law. It had a provision for "marooning".

Again, which requires a court martial, and under modern conventions that Russia has signed that court martial process would be held under Russian admiralty law, as it was a Russian ship that captured the pirates. No such court martial trial under Russian admiralty law was held, was it?

You've shot yourself in the foot pretty severely here.
 
All I'm saying is that unarmed, captive pirates deserved due process of law rather than being murdered at sea.

They weren't murdered. The Russians released them. They just "forgot" to give them supplies or navigation equipment. I assume they must have taken...I mean forgot...their communication gear too.

I don't see any country complaining about it.

It won't deter pirates, except perhaps from taking Russian vessels, since it is still the best occupation in Somalia. Not many pirates have been captured, killed, or died from other causes. It's cheaper to pay the ransoms and patrol, compared to eliminating the causes of the piracy.
 
They weren't murdered. The Russians released them. They just "forgot" to give them supplies or navigation equipment. I assume they must have taken...I mean forgot...their communication gear too.

That is what the Russians say, but several have speculated on this thread and elsewhere that they actually murdered them. Moreover if they intentionally released them into conditions that they knew would be hazardous to life that's almost as bad.

They should have at a minimum run a court martial per the admiralty process that Russia has agreed to under international law.
 
I'm sure some of them are up to no good. Maybe a couple of them got dragged along without really having done anything criminal, or at least not seriously criminal. They executed all of them AFTER they had surrendered WITHOUT considering who was guilty of what.

Couldn't let this one go by. I nominate this one for the 2010 top ten fujiisms of the the year right up there with the definition of class.
 
Couldn't let this one go by. I nominate this one for the 2010 top ten fujiisms of the the year right up there with the definition of class.

Do you disagree with it? Are you claiming that you have proof beyond a reasonable doubt that all of them were equally guilty of crimes that deserved the death penalty?
 
Fuji is a pirate. Capture him, then release him in international waters.
 
Do you disagree with it? Are you claiming that you have proof beyond a reasonable doubt that all of them were equally guilty of crimes that deserved the death penalty?

No, there is every reason to believe half of them were entirely innocent and thought they were invited to go fishing with AK47's. :D

Did I say anything about them deserving to die? No I didn't- hadn't really gotten that far because I was doing the proverbial ROFLMAO while marvelling at how incredibly naive you are ( and I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt with that adjective 'cause the other choice begins with s) to describe them as "up to no good".

I suppose the Russians could have handed them over to the NDS to question them about their choice of fishing locales if that makes you feel better.
 
This thread is dissolving into a Fuji Lovefest, ad hominem at it's worst. Stop it now! He'll get upset. HeHe! You might hurt his wittle feelings and he might go away. Hmmmmmm!

Don't stop on my account.
 
No, there is every reason to believe half of them were entirely innocent and thought they were invited to go fishing with AK47's. :D

Did all of them have AK47's, or only some of them? Did all of them commit crimes, or only some of them? How many were only guilty of some lesser crime than a capital crime? Maybe one of them was a fisherman who not happy about being made to come along. Do you know? I don't, and since they were apparently murdered without any trial whatsoever, no-one knows whether that was a just outcome or a crime against humanity.

If any of them were killed in the attack BEFORE they were captured I don't care--they shouldn't have been there. It's quite a different thing to kill unarmed prisoners: AFTER they surrendered any punishment should have fit their own individual crime as determined by some sort of legal process. MAYBE they were all guilty of capital crimes. Maybe not. No due process of law was followed.

Did I say anything about them deserving to die?

Well THAT is the only issue I've been talking about.

to describe them as "up to no good".

You do know I was quoting someone else's words, that that was not my phrase??? If your issue is with the phrase "up to no good" you need to be criticizing The Fruity Hare, not me. I used it in my reply to him only because it's the phrase that he used.

Maybe you owe me an apology?
 
This thread is dissolving into a Fuji Lovefest, ad hominem at it's worst. Stop it now! He'll get upset. HeHe! You might hurt his wittle feelings and he might go away. Hmmmmmm!

Don't stop on my account.

You need to grow up, you're behaving like a child.
 
Stabilizing the country and creating viable jobs for these people doesn't strike you as a lasting solution?

No, not a solution at all.

First of the Somalis will do exactly what they've always done: take as much of the aid infusion as they can get unconditionally, then turn against the providers once it's time to make some hard changes.

...At some point it dawned on them that they could simply rob the trawlers, which they initially called a tax on their illegal fishing. Eventually they started "taxing" any vessel they could find, regardless of whether it had anything to do with fishing or not...


Bull. "At some point" the so-called piracy became a completely organized operation to fill the coffers of Al Quaeda's Somali satelites with booty and ransom momey. Nothing is going to change that until the population is compelled to sell them out...probably thorugh extreme coercion.
 
First of the Somalis will do exactly what they've always done: take as much of the aid infusion as they can get unconditionally, then turn against the providers once it's time to make some hard changes.

When you say "always", are you talking about before or after colonization? Before or after the British made a deal with Ethiopia to hand over Somali land to Ethiopia in exchange for Ethiopian support in plundering Somali resources and cities? Before or after European countries illegally stole $300 million per year in fish stocks from exclusive Somali fishing areas? Oops it can't be after that last one--they're still doing it!

Secondly, this so called piracy is nothing more than a completely organized operation to fill the coffers of Al Quaeda's Somali satelites with booty and ransom momey.

It may well turn into that, that is certainly not how it started out. The Somali piracy is very much a creation of illegal European fishing. Having been created that way, though, it may well grow into a monster such as you describe.
 
When you say "always", are you talking about before or after colonization?
.
Malaysia, Hong Kong, Cuba & Brazil are among the many other places that were also colonies up until a few decades ago. That can't be the only excuse.


The Somali piracy is very much a creation of illegal European fishing. Having been created that way, though, it may well grow into a monster such as you describe
Again, that's can't be a blankt, all-absolving excuse. The Europeans fish illegally wherever there is water.
 
Malaysia, Hong Kong, Cuba & Brazil are among the many other places that were also colonies up until a few decades ago. That can't be the only excuse.

Sure, and even if it's all someone else's fault, at some level they have to step up and take responsibility for their own lives. At the same time Europeans can't just walk away and claim to have had nothing to do with the problem: They STILL take $300mil/year of fish illegally out of Somali waters. The Somali's don't have any coast guard capable of fending them off. A resolution was brought to the UN Security Council to try and block the illegal fishing but it was vetoed and opposed by the nations that engage in the illegal fishing. So it continues.

When you deprive a man of his livelihood--say by destroying the fish stocks on which he relies for sustenance--you can't claim to be completely innocent of blame if you later find he's been forced into crime to survive--say piracy. Especially if he started out in that piracy activity as a sort of policing of his own livelihood: Arguably originally the fishermen were well within their rights to attack European trawlers illegally fishing in their waters. Initially the Europeans paid out Somali demands for payment rather than fight the attacks because they knew their own behavior was illegal and did not want it exposed.

Yes what they've grown into since is criminal, and much worse, and needs to be vigorously opposed: Now nations are being victimized by the pirates who had nothing whatsoever to do with the European assault on the Somali's livelihood. But restitution and reparations are also owed the Somalis by the Europeans who have stolen from them and destroyed their livelihood.

You do know that the Somali pirates started out as an ad hoc coast guard? That is why they are named things like "Somali coastguard" or "Somali marines" or what have you that these gangs call themselves. They aren't an ad hoc coastguard anymore but it's interesting to note that is where they came form.

Again, that's can't be a blankt, all-absolving excuse. The Europeans fish illegally wherever there is water.

Other countries, however, have viable coast guards and are able to fend them off to a large extent. They plundered and pillaged the Somalis owing to their defenselessness both in terms of illegal over-fishing and in terms of dumping toxic waste in their waters.
 
Sure, and even if it's all someone else's fault, at some level they have to step up and take responsibility for their own lives. At the same time Europeans can't just walk away and claim to have had nothing to do with the problem: They STILL take $300mil/year of fish illegally out of Somali waters. The Somali's don't have any coast guard capable of fending them off. A resolution was brought to the UN Security Council to try and block the illegal fishing but it was vetoed and opposed by the nations that engage in the illegal fishing. So it continues.

When you deprive a man of his livelihood--say by destroying the fish stocks on which he relies for sustenance--you can't claim to be completely innocent of blame if you later find he's been forced into crime to survive--say piracy. Especially if he started out in that piracy activity as a sort of policing of his own livelihood: Arguably originally the fishermen were well within their rights to attack European trawlers illegally fishing in their waters. Initially the Europeans paid out Somali demands for payment rather than fight the attacks because they knew their own behavior was illegal and did not want it exposed.

Yes what they've grown into since is criminal, and much worse, and needs to be vigorously opposed: Now nations are being victimized by the pirates who had nothing whatsoever to do with the European assault on the Somali's livelihood. But restitution and reparations are also owed the Somalis by the Europeans who have stolen from them and destroyed their livelihood.

You do know that the Somali pirates started out as an ad hoc coast guard? That is why they are named things like "Somali coastguard" or "Somali marines" or what have you that these gangs call themselves. They aren't an ad hoc coastguard anymore but it's interesting to note that is where they came form.



Other countries, however, have viable coast guards and are able to fend them off to a large extent. They plundered and pillaged the Somalis owing to their defenselessness both in terms of illegal over-fishing and in terms of dumping toxic waste in their waters.

Your argument is one of morality and civility rather than rule of law. The Russians in particular are democratic in name only. They operate today as they did as Communist USSR, with utter impunity. Look at what they've done in Chechnya and the Caucuses. Had it been a real Democratic country they would have been taken to the Hague for crimes against humanity, and genocide.

In Russia there's no free press. Everyone and everything is censored. As such the Military has full reign to use whatever force necessary to complete missions.

You make me laugh about their signatory to international law. Just like the Chinese, they operate at their own will.
 
Your argument is one of morality and civility rather than rule of law. The Russians in particular are democratic in name only. They operate today as they did as Communist USSR, with utter impunity. Look at what they've done in Chechnya and the Caucuses. Had it been a real Democratic country they would have been taken to the Hague for crimes against humanity, and genocide.

In Russia there's no free press. Everyone and everything is censored. As such the Military has full reign to use whatever force necessary to complete missions.

You make me laugh about their signatory to international law. Just like the Chinese, they operate at their own will.

The most ironic thing about it is that all the blood thirsty right wingers here on terb are rooting for the russian system and are wishing they lived under similar conditions. That have no clue what they are wishing for.
 
You do know that hostis humani generis requires that pirates be tried by court martial?
Hence presumably if Russian Naval Regulations provided for the despensement of justice to captured pirates as were provided for in the Naval Articles of War and the Articles for the Government of the United States Navy during the Napolionic Wars/War of 1812 period that would satisfy your objections.

"It is the universal right and the universal duty of all nations, regardless of whether their ships have been beset by the particular pirate captured, to capture, try by naval court and, if found guilty, to execute the pirate(s) by hanging."