Pirates: The Russian Solution

We all deserve the assurance that we will not be mistaken for pirates and murdered at sea by rogue Russian soldiers without so much as a fair hearing at which to argue our case.

Is my Boss's Canadian flagged yacht in danger of being attacked by Russian naval forces? Or, is the much greater danger of being attacked by Somali pirates?
 
The most ironic thing about it is that all the blood thirsty right wingers here on terb are rooting for the russian system and are wishing they lived under similar conditions.

No, we just wish our "justice" system had some balls. Are you rooting for Karla Homolka to get a full pardon soon too?
 
No, we just wish our "justice" system had some balls. Are you rooting for Karla Homolka to get a full pardon soon too?

People who call for authoritarian laws believe that they would be the ones metering out misery to the rest of the population. In reality, if an authoritarian state was to be put in place, they would of course be at the receiving end like the majority of others. Be careful what you wish for; I doubt you would want to live under Putin's rule.
 
Be careful what you wish for; I doubt you would want to live under Putin's rule.

Agreed but the pendulum has swung too far in favour of the criminals in some cases. I think there are stats that show 80% of the crimes are commited by 20% of the criminals and many of those crimes are commited while out on bail.
 
Sorry, wait--are you telling me the Russians were in a rowboat?

Aardvark you didn't respond to this, probably because you didn't understand the significance of the point, so let me spell it out:

Even in the 18th century you could only hold a barrel head trial if you were in a situation such as you described--where it was just impractical to hold a proper court martial hearing due to difficult logistics. Even back then if it was practical to have a properly constituted court martial it was required. These days two things have changed: (1) The practical/logistic issues simply do not exist 99% of the time, and (2) we have tightened up the conventions since then to insist more strongly on a court martial.

There is really no good reason why the Russians could not have constituted a court martial and done things properly. Hell they could even have brought these guys back to Russia for a trial. It's not like the logistics would be difficult for them to accomplish that.

In any case those prisoners were owed a fair trial and didn't get one. Next time maybe it'll be your fair trial that's skipped.
 
Seeing how I posted this news over in the P&IA forum a week or so ago, here's some points to consider:
The Russkies say they released the remaining Somalis back into the boat they originally used to approach the tanker (minus weapons and navigational aids). So the craft is obviously seaworthy. And it ain't a "rubber dinghy", it's a Zodiac (or Zodiac-style) boat: very tough craft, nearly impossible to sink one of those things (multiple independant air chambers). The incident took place somewhere around the Socotra islands, which isnt that far from either the Horn of Africa countries or Yemen. An experienced seaman in the boat could easily navigate to land (according to the head of Navfor, the EU's naval protection force around Somalia). The Russkies said they did not have sufficient grounds to detain the group any longer (no witnesses to the "crime" as the tanker crew was holed up inside a safe room and couldn't possibly identify any of the Somalis as the ones who attacked the ship originally......(isn't it possible that the 1 Somali killed by the Bears forced the other ten to accompany him onto the boat in the first place....didn't someone already use a scenario like that???). Just as there's no evidence that the Russians killed anyone, the Russians felt they had no evidence this group of Somalis did anything wrong, so they sent them back on their way.
Although there are imperfections with the system, as noted by the Russian authorities, it sounds like the system worked as intended in this case!! The boys are probably back in Mogadishu as we discuss this, planning their next careers as Qat growers.
 
Although there are imperfections with the system, as noted by the Russian authorities, it sounds like the system worked as intended in this case!! The boys are probably back in Mogadishu as we discuss this, planning their next careers as Qat growers.

Does this mean Fuji should get off his soapbox and stop lecturing us on the morality of releasing pirates?
 
Sorry fuji, but I used to observe your arguments and thought you were good, and even thought you knew what you were talking about. But wading into this argument with you and knowing what I know and what I've seen in your posts... the others who denigrate you are better judges of character than I.

Rubmeister takes away the soapbox. Insert "soapbox" smilie here.
 
Just as there's no evidence that the Russians killed anyone

You're happy with a world in which security forces get away with murder, so long as they're careful to cover their tracks?

the Russians felt they had no evidence this group of Somalis did anything wrong

BS. I bet with forensics they could have got all the evidence they needed.
 
It means Professor Wikipedia decided to get schooled around Post #72 in this thread when I challenged him on some latin I googled and followed a link to wikipedia myself.

You literally quoted from the wikipedia page but neglected the bit where it said a court martial is required. Prior to that my view was that Russian law applied. After that my view was that... Russian law applied. The only difference is that you shot yourself in the foot by quoting the bit about hanging pirates but neglecting the bit about having a trial first.

Prior to the diversion onto the law about pirates we were talking about my original point, which is that the Russian soldiers need to be investigated and if they really did kill unarmed prisoners then they need to be charged with murder under Russian law. If Russia won't do it,the ICC could.
 
Agreed but the pendulum has swung too far in favour of the criminals in some cases. I think there are stats that show 80% of the crimes are commited by 20% of the criminals and many of those crimes are commited while out on bail.

That is in great part a product of a penal system that does not put rehabilitation first. Instead, penal institutions are "criminal universities"
 
Even in the 18th century you could only hold a barrel head trial if you were in a situation such as you described--where it was just impractical to hold a proper court martial hearing due to difficult logistics.
And you missed the point that the properly constituted Naval Court (IF provided for in the present day under Russian Law) could be held aboard the squadron's flagship - there would have been no reason to bring everyone back to a courtroom on shore - which in the Anglo-American-Canadian naval tradition is in any event a 20th century development.
 
And you missed the point that the properly constituted Naval Court (IF provided for in the present day under Russian Law) could be held aboard the squadron's flagship - there would have been no reason to bring everyone back to a courtroom on shore - which in the Anglo-American-Canadian naval tradition is in any event a 20th century development.

I have no problem, provided it is a properly constituted naval court, and it follows a free and open process. The Russians didn't do that, which is my issue.
 
You're happy with a world in which security forces get away with murder, so long as they're careful to cover their tracks?
BS. I bet with forensics they could have got all the evidence they needed.

As much I don't like to encourage you, please explain the forensics involved to gather the evidence needed to successfully prosecute this case.
Also, who did the security forces murder? 1 pirate was killed in a fire-fight, while 10 other men where released as there was insufficient evidence to detain them. As already pointed out, you are doing pretty much what you are accusing the Russians of doing.
Finally, here's a link to an interesting article that predates most of this situation.....although it refutes lots of statements, I'll wager a round of drinks at the 1st TERB party I attend (whenever that becomes possible) that someone will claim that it supports his opinions: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/04/30/lawyers_vs_pirates
 
Yeah, as Mike Myers said


But before that, he was talking out of his ass. Making murder accusations against Russian sailors, the country itself and the entire population's disregard for the "rule of law", all the while not recognizing his own arguments mirrored the ones he was convicting in absentia .

Sorry fuji, but I used to observe your arguments and thought you were good, and even thought you knew what you were talking about. But wading into this argument with you and knowing what I know and what I've seen in your posts... the others who denigrate you are better judges of character than I.


I thought the same, and that's when I realized I didn't have enough time on my hands to show him all his contradictions. He won't and can't see how we all see him, so I choose not to go on in an endless circle.

This thread, I have come to realize, is pretty much like all his other threads. Start an argument and then argue in circles.

I too agree, that others have seen his true colours before I did.
 
As much I don't like to encourage you, please explain the forensics involved to gather the evidence needed to successfully prosecute this case.
Also, who did the security forces murder? 1 pirate was killed in a fire-fight, while 10 other men where released as there was insufficient evidence to detain them. As already pointed out, you are doing pretty much what you are accusing the Russians of doing.
Finally, here's a link to an interesting article that predates most of this situation.....although it refutes lots of statements, I'll wager a round of drinks at the 1st TERB party I attend (whenever that becomes possible) that someone will claim that it supports his opinions: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/04/30/lawyers_vs_pirates

Let me take a stab at this is my best Fuji squeal.

When maybe not in this case but in 1000s of other ones they get away with it. Look at Afghanistan, Iraq, Panama,the Solomon Islands, the Spanish American War and then the Trojan Wars. The preponderance of evidence is clear, terrible atrocities were perpetrated on the Trojans by those sneaky Greeks at night in the dark, WHILE THEY SLEPT.

Maybe there were more than 11 pirates and the Russian killed a couple of more, maybe 100's and only reporting 11. Maybe those that were returned were beaten by the Russians for shits&giggles, explaining that there was a black cat on the gangway and they all fell down a couple of times.

There Fuji, I saved you some ATP.
 
That is in great part a product of a penal system that does not put rehabilitation first. Instead, penal institutions are "criminal universities"

It is never the criminal's fault, is it? It is always the fault of society, the hood, his/her race, his height, his low IQ, his mother didn't love him, he wasn't breastfed, etc., etc. Never any individual accountability. Always blame something and sonebody else.