Pirates: The Russian Solution

Maritime laws allows for necessary force to repel or counter acts of piracy.
That's why I said the ship/pirate situation may be different. I'm surprised to learn that even in the different states in the Union, it's not a cut and dry thing.

In canada it is clear.

Not only can you defend your life with deadly force, but you may defend
your home. Sections 32 and 40 of the Criminal Code (CC) allow use of
deadly force;

yet only

1) where you fear death or grievous bodily harm, and
2) to keep persons from illegally entering your home.

If Fugu wants to argue this further, I'll let the lawyers tackle it.
 
That's why I said the ship/pirate situation may be different. I'm surprised to learn that even in the different states in the Union, it's not a cut and dry thing.

In canada it is clear.

Not only can you defend your life with deadly force, but you may defend
your home. Sections 32 and 40 of the Criminal Code (CC) allow use of
deadly force;

yet only

1) where you fear death or grievous bodily harm, and
2) to keep persons from illegally entering your home.

If Fugu wants to argue this further, I'll let the lawyers tackle it.
A Captain needs to move to trial to a Maritime Court and they can ten use deadly force.
 
So, please explain the forensics involved to gather the evidence needed to successfully prosecute this case.

What the police would typically do in any such case is start out by gathering as much hard physical evidence as they can, fingerprints, ballistics, any video that might be present, hair fibres, things that establish who was where at what time, who did what, and so on. They would then interrogate all the participants separately. Usually someone will crack and fess up to what happened.
 
Maritime laws allows for necessary force to repel or counter acts of piracy.

Absolutely. As I've said repeatedly, I have no problem with armed pirates getting shot by soldiers. If they don't want to get shot by soldiers, they shouldn't have attacked a ship.

Now when they cease being armed pirates, when they surrender, are disarmed, and become prisoners--I have a problem if at that point they are shot in cold blood without a trial. Maybe with a proper trial they can be hung from the yardarm or whatever--but only after a proper court martial trial. I'm not really a big fan of the death penalty but I would agree if they were executed after a fair trial that is at least due process of law.
 
What the police would typically do in any such case is start out by gathering as much hard physical evidence as they can, fingerprints, ballistics, any video that might be present, hair fibres, things that establish who was where at what time, who did what, and so on. They would then interrogate all the participants separately. Usually someone will crack and fess up to what happened.

So that's the first 15 minutes of CSI gone, now what?
 
That's why I said the ship/pirate situation may be different.

You can use deadly force against armed pirates, it's very clear that you can. Some of the conventions go so far as to say that you have an obligation to hunt them down and attack them. The right of nations to actively attack pirates and kill them is not in doubt: My issue on this thread is restricted to the treatment of prisoners who have surrendered and are now unarmed and in custody. I suspect the Russians shot them in cold blood without a trial.
 
We should ship them off to "boot camp". These are probably the 20% repeat offenders. The old "80/20" rule.

Can you not read? It is not 20%.
 
You can use deadly force against armed pirates, it's very clear that you can. Some of the conventions go so far as to say that you have an obligation to hunt them down and attack them. The right of nations to actively attack pirates and kill them is not in doubt: My issue on this thread is restricted to the treatment of prisoners who have surrendered and are now unarmed and in custody. I suspect the Russians shot them in cold blood without a trial.

Thanks for your two cents. I didn't say you couldn't use deadly force, numb nutts, PS made that clear in #153, long before your braying. My comment was that ship was probably not the same as the home invasion situation, see post #146, therefore different. You're trying TOO hard fuji, you might burst a blood vessel and we may have to cauterize it.
 
Thanks for your two cents. I didn't say you couldn't use deadly force, numb nutts, PS made that clear in #153, long before your braying. My comment was that ship was probably not the same as the home invasion situation, see post #146, therefore different. You're trying TOO hard fuji, you might burst a blood vessel and we may have to cauterize it.

I was agreeing with you and adding on to what you said, but you are such a disagreeable person that you figure you need to start an argument and insult people even when they are agreeing with you.

Sad.
 
I was agreeing with you and adding on to what you said, but you are such a disagreeable person that you figure you need to start an argument and insult people even when they are agreeing with you.

Sad.

Agreement from you, with anyone, is so rare, that sometimes it hard to recognize. Next time try, 'I agree with what you say' instead of making it sound like you're just stating a fact. I know, you're out of practice, you're sorry, and you'll do better next time.
 
What the police would typically do in any such case is start out by gathering as much hard physical evidence as they can, fingerprints, ballistics, any video that might be present, hair fibres, things that establish who was where at what time, who did what, and so on. They would then interrogate all the participants separately. Usually someone will crack and fess up to what happened.
You know what? Assign some professionals to the job, some police, and let them investigate the Russian soldiers. I bet they know how to do it.
That certainly seems circular.
 
That certainly seems circular.

Not in the least. I related what I know, which is pretty general, about how the police conduct an investigation--collect as much hard evidence as they can, interrogate people. He asked me for more details and I don't know more details, but it's their job and I'm pretty sure that if we assigned some cops to investigate these soldiers that they would know how to do their jobs.
 
Not in the least. I related what I know, which is pretty general, about how the police conduct an investigation--collect as much hard evidence as they can, interrogate people. He asked me for more details and I don't know more details, it's their job, I'm pretty sure that if we assigned some cops to investigate these soldiers that they would know how to do their jobs.
In other words you have a lot of wishful thinking as to how these crimes could be proved.
 
Absolutely. As I've said repeatedly, I have no problem with armed pirates getting shot by soldiers. If they don't want to get shot by soldiers, they shouldn't have attacked a ship.

Now when they cease being armed pirates, when they surrender, are disarmed, and become prisoners--I have a problem if at that point they are shot in cold blood without a trial. Maybe with a proper trial they can be hung from the yardarm or whatever--but only after a proper court martial trial. I'm not really a big fan of the death penalty but I would agree if they were executed after a fair trial that is at least due process of law.

I believe that under MARITIME LAW if tried in a Maritime Court they can be hanged if found guilty of piracy.

Problem here is every country involved wants to bring them back to home soil for attacking a Flagged ship.

I say turn them over to a Maritime Court.


My vessel is a US Registered ( DOCUMENTED) vessel and as such is US soil under Maritime Law.
 
In other words you have a lot of wishful thinking as to how these crimes could be proved.

Which is only surpased by the wishful thinking of other posters (including you) about how western powers should deal with piracy and crimes in general.
 
I believe that under MARITIME LAW if tried in a Maritime Court they can be hanged if found guilty of piracy.

Problem here is every country involved wants to bring them back to home soil for attacking a Flagged ship.

I say turn them over to a Maritime Court.


My vessel is a US Registered vessel and as such is US soil under Maritime Law.
Any births, deaths or marriages which occur on her is registered in her home port.