Pirates: The Russian Solution

It is never the criminal's fault, is it? It is always the fault of society, the hood, his/her race, his height, his low IQ, his mother didn't love him, he wasn't breastfed, etc., etc. Never any individual accountability. Always blame something and sonebody else.

Have it your way. Put people away for good, or release them without any retraining and rehabilitation, with the result that they will be back soon. Happy with that?


Well, I am not, because I do not like paying taxes for keeping twice as many inmates in prison than is necessary. Remember, when someone is in prison, he lives in our taxes, and you need somebody else to guard him. If on the other hand, he was rehabilitated and became a productive member of society, he would be helping us pay taxes.
 
If on the other hand, he was rehabilitated and became a productive member of society, he would be helping us pay taxes.

I think the stats are that 80% of criminals are one time offenders and they rehabilitate themselves with very little if any help. The other 20% are hardcore criminals who game the system. Actually many "criminals" are actually arrested for "soft" crimes like smoking weed or engaging in wambo minki with another consenting adult.

BTW Do you think that sexual animals and peds can ever be rahabilitated? Castration?
 
I think the stats are that 80% of criminals are one time offenders and they rehabilitate themselves with very little if any help. The other 20% are hardcore criminals who game the system. Actually many "criminals" are actually arrested for "soft" crimes like smoking weed or engaging in wambo minki with another consenting adult.

You think wrong.

The few studies that do attempt to track prior convictions across jurisdictions peg recidivism at alarmingly high rates. Six out of every ten convicted offenders aged 18 to 25 in 1999/2000 had at least one previous conviction, according to a new pilot study of court-based recidivism in seven provinces and two territories. Among these repeat offenders, 72% had multiple prior convictions. Nine out of ten offenders sentenced to a federal corrections facility (meaning at least a two year sentence) had at least one prior conviction either in adult or youth court. (Source: Statistics Canada)
 
As much I don't like to encourage you, please explain the forensics involved to gather the evidence needed to successfully prosecute this case.

Fingerprints would go a long way. If you don't know much about modern forensics, and how police go around solving murders they weren't there to see themselves--well, I suggest you read up. Or simply understand that's what they do for a living.

Also, who did the security forces murder? 1 pirate was killed in a fire-fight, while 10 other men where released

Almost no-one believes that the other 10 died natural deaths at sea. Proof? Well we need an investigation. Hence my question: Are you happy living in a world where security forces get away with murder, just so long as they cover their tracks?
 
An interesting article, the international piracy court is probably a good idea so long as the death penalty is allowed. I don't believe that an U.N. prison island would be a great idea.

I'm not a big fan of the death penalty, it's never done any good. All the studies show that it only makes things worse and does not have the effects claimed of it by its supporters. Not statistically.

That said it's a damn sight better to execute someone after a free and fair court martial than to murder them at sea. If it's true that the Russian soldiers murdered unarmed prisoners and then pretended that they simply didn't have enough navigation--what almost everyone believes but few can prove--well let's investigate that. Let's dredge up their craft and the bodies of the lost Somalis and see whether the forensic experts can figure out where they simply got lost at sea in a very seaworthy vessel or whether they were murdered.

If the Russians did murder them in cold blood the death penalty should be appropriate for them as well, no?
 
If the Russians did murder them in cold blood the death penalty should be appropriate for them as well, no?

Isn't there a law that says you can lawfully kill someone (justifiable homicide) if they invade your house or your ship?
 
Fingerprints would go a long way. If you don't know much about modern forensics, and how police go around solving murders they weren't there to see themselves--well, I suggest you read up. Or simply understand that's what they do for a living.

Ha ha ha. That a good one Fujster. How long until this ends up in your hall-of-fame thread?
Seriously....fingerprints? Seriously??
The Russians took those 10 guys off the tanker....of course their fingerprints are going to be on the ship....the men were onboard the ship, their fingers are attached to their bodies that were on the ship, their fingerprints are the marks left behind from what their fingers touch. What will fingerprints prove??? That they were on the ship????? Did you think this through before you replied, or did you just jump into it blindly?
Fingerprints.........good answer!!! Take your own advice and read up before you embarrass yourself any further. At the very least read that piece from Foreign Policy (especially the part where the guy with more expertise on the topic than I or certainly you have, describes some of the difficulties in getting evidence & witnesses).
Fingerprints.....thanks for making my day a happy one with that little joke, but please feel free to make a serious attempt at it.
 
Let's dredge up their craft and the bodies of the lost Somalis and see whether the forensic experts can figure out where they simply got lost at sea in a very seaworthy vessel or whether they were murdered.

Okay, you've just outdone yourself here......dredge up the craft??? Seriously???? You think thats a feasible idea????
I've got to stop reading your stuff for awhile otherwise I'll break out laughing at some inopportune moment if I think about what you've just written.
Since you've given me such a good laugh with these last two gems, I'll return the favour and allow you to claim "victory" in this "debate".
 
Isn't there a law that says you can lawfully kill someone (justifiable homicide) if they invade your house or your ship?

The ships probably a different thing being pirates and all, but in your home if someone breaks in you just can't kill them . They have to be threatening you well being or other occupants of your house. So shoot him in the front and put a screwdriver in their hand. It's less of a problem.
 
Okay, I'll admit it, I'm inspired by Fuji's earnestness (but a bit concerned as to his naivete), and I'm offering a reward to anyone who can help me get my hands on this pirate:
Sexy-Pirate-Costume.jpg
 
Isn't there a law that says you can lawfully kill someone (justifiable homicide) if they invade your house or your ship?

Yes you can. While they are in the act of invading you can shoot them dead, and not have the slightest problem from me. If they didn't want to get shot dead, they shouldn't have invaded your house or your ship.

That is not what happened here--they surrendered, and were taken into captivity by the Russians. At that point they were no longer invading anyone's house or ship they simply became prisoners accused of piracy. They were then, so far as I undestand--and no investigation has been done to prove it one way or the other--they were then murdered by the Russians, a crime against humanity.

All the more the worse in that they presumably COULD have held a court martial hearing and condemned them to death legally. Or at least most of them--maybe one or two would have turned out to have not done anything deserving of the death penalty. Or maybe not. But we will never know, due to the Russian crime.
 
Ha ha ha. That a good one Fujster. How long until this ends up in your hall-of-fame thread?
Seriously....fingerprints? Seriously??

Yup. If fingerprints of a guy are found on a gun, whose ballistics match a shell casing and a slug found in a wall--well, I'm convinced that guy fired a weapon. Aren't you? These are uneducated, illiterate probably, Somali pirates. Not the sharpest knives in the drawer. I doubt they did *anything* to cover their tracks.

The Russians took those 10 guys off the tanker....of course their fingerprints are going to be on the ship....

You plainly, very plainly, do not have the least clue what is typically done with forensics in a police investigation. None whatsoever.
 
You plainly, very plainly, do not have the least clue what is typically done with forensics in a police investigation. None whatsoever.

And we're back full circle; I asked you to please explain the process involved to successfully prosecute this case, and the best you can do is start with the putdowns....thats okay Fuj, I'm an adult & I can take it. But now, back to the original question which you will likely now go to great lengths to avoid answering. So, please explain the forensics involved to gather the evidence needed to successfully prosecute this case. And the case originally was regarding the 10 Somali men that the Russians released, but you can also explain how you'd gather the evidence to prosecute the Russians, if you so wish. You can surely do better than fingerprints. I'm surprising smart (although I don't feel the obsessive need to continually try to prove it to overcome my insecurities), so try your best if you're up to it.

I actually like you Fuji; you never fail to crack me up. And, when I saw this posting (in Foreign Policy, an excellent publication that I suggest you start reading), I thought of you:

Executive Director, Africa Division Posted May 12
Human Rights Watch
icon_company_insider_in_12x12.gif
, New York, NY (New York, or other locations)


Description: The Executive Director of Human Rights Watch’s Africa Division is responsible for developing effective research, advocacy and communications strategies for maximum impact on human rights in sub-Saharan Africa. S/he is responsible for setting priorities and responding to emergencies. S/he oversees detailed research on human rights issues in sub-Saharan Africa, the publication of analytical and credible reports and other advocacy materials on those issues, and the use of these materials to generate domestic and international pressure to curb human rights violations. S/he represents the organization frequently before the international media and advocates with high-level officials from governments, UN, AU and other international and regional organizations. S/he coordinates with key colleagues, both within HRW and externally with allied organizations and NGOs. S/he manages staff based in three continents, including offices in Nairobi and Johannesburg, supporting staff and office development and overseeing their security. The Africa Executive Director is also responsible for fundraising, identifying and recruiting donors, and drafting funding proposals. S/he has overall responsibility for projecting Human Rights Watch’s wider international concerns on the continent. The successful candidate will have excellent leadership skills and a depth and breadth of management and organizational skills, including the demonstrated ability to lead a team of talented professionals in multiple global locations. S/he will preferably be based in the organization's New York City headquarters or an office in Africa, but other locations may be considered. Frequent international travel required.

Qualifications: The ideal candidate will be a self-motivated, creative, strategic thinker with substantive, senior-level experience working on human rights issues in Africa and will have the capacity to serve as an effective advocate and activist. S/he will have excellent leadership, management and organizational skills, including the demonstrated ability to lead a team of talented professionals in multiple global locations. S/he will be able to juggle multiple tasks and work collegially in a demanding, diverse, and fast-paced environment. The ideal candidate will have excellent oral and written communications skills in English and ideally another relevant language, keen political judgment, proven initiative and follow-through, the ability to work quickly and well under pressure, and a commitment to human rights. An advanced degree in law, international relations, African studies, public policy, or a related field is desired, as is familiarity with international human rights law.

Salary and Benefits: HRW seeks exceptional applicants and offers competitive compensation and employer-paid benefits. HRW will pay reasonable relocation expenses and will assist employees in obtaining necessary work authorization, if required; citizens of all nationalities are encouraged to apply.

PLEASE APPLY IMMEDIATELY by emailing in a single submission: a letter of interest describing your experience, your resume, names or letters of reference, salary requirements and a brief writing sample (unedited by others) no later than May 31, 2010 to program@hrw.org. Please be sure to indicate where you learned of this vacancy. Please use “Executive Director, Africa Division Ref 10-1021-B” as the subject of your email. Only complete applications will be reviewed. It is preferred that all materials be submitted via email. If emailing is not possible, send materials (please do not split a submission between email and regular post) to:

Human Rights Watch
Attn: Search Committee (Executive Director, Africa Division Ref 10-1021-B)
350 Fifth Avenue, 34th Floor
New York, NY 10118-3299
Fax: (212) 736-1300

Human Rights Watch is an equal opportunity employer that does not discriminate
in its hiring practices and, in order to build the strongest possible workforce,
actively seeks a diverse applicant pool.

Its perfect for you - you can investigate suspected abuses against Somali pirates! Good luck during the interview! Let me know if you need a reference.
And I'm looking forward to a detailed, well-thought out explanation.
 
Yup. If fingerprints of a guy are found on a gun, whose ballistics match a shell casing and a slug found in a wall--well, I'm convinced that guy fired a weapon. Aren't you?

I woudn't be convinced until I see the gunshot residue tests
 
The ships probably a different thing being pirates and all, but in your home if someone breaks in you just can't kill them . They have to be threatening you well being or other occupants of your house. So shoot him in the front and put a screwdriver in their hand. It's less of a problem.

Maritime laws allows for necessary force to repel or counter acts of piracy.
 
Mother of Somali pirate appeals for his release
MALKHADIR M. MUHUMED
Associated Press Writer

NAIROBI, Kenya (AP) -- The mother of a Somali pirate who pleaded guilty to charges of hijacking a U.S.-flagged ship and kidnapping its captain appealed to President Barack Obama on Wednesday to pardon her son and grant him citizenship.
Abdiwali Abdiqadir Muse pleaded guilty in a U.S. federal court on Tuesday to several charges, including hostage-taking and conspiracy. He faces a minimum 27 years in prison. Sentencing is set for Oct. 19.
Reached by phone in the central Somali town where she lives, Muse's mother asked President Obama for leniency, saying her son is too young to have been tried as an adult.
"Please, please President Obama, please, American people, please release my son and grant him citizenship to help us," Muse's mother, Adar Abdirahman Hassan told The Associated Press by phone.
"You live in a safe prosperous country but we live in a chaotic country. With all your power and generosity and kindness, it will be a stain on your name to punish this child and throw him in jail," Hassan said.
Prosecutors say Muse led four pirates who stormed the Maersk Alabama in April 2009 as it carried humanitarian supplies 280 miles (450 kilometers) off Somalia's coast. Navy snipers fatally shot three pirates and freed ship Captain Richard Phillips of Underhill, Vt., to end the standoff.
Muse's age has been in dispute since the start of the case, with his lawyers insisting last April that he was 15 and should be tried as a juvenile. Prosecutors convinced a judge he was at least 18.
Muse's mother said her son is too young to stand trial.
"I shudder to imagine that Abdiwali will face a minimum 27 years in prison," she said, her voice cracking with emotion. "I don't expect Americans to punish this little kid. He was duped into piracy by adult friends."
Asked why she believes Muse pleaded guilty, Hassan said her son was afraid of a possible death sentence and believed a plea would save his life.
Muse said her son used to call her once a week from prison but that she hasn't heard from him in about three months. Hassan said her son ended past conversations with "soothing words."
"He always praised his life in America. He told me, 'I'm in a nice place, better than Somalia. Mom, I feel bad for you. I'm happy and studying,'" she said.
Muse told the judge on Tuesday that his crew had not intentionally targeted an American vessel.
The pirates held Phillips hostage for several days on a sweltering, enclosed lifeboat that was soon shadowed by three U.S. warships and a helicopter. The end came when Navy sharpshooters on the USS Bainbridge picked off the three pirates.
The American Navy has taken into custody more than 20 suspected pirates in the violence-plagued waters off Somalia and nearby regions, where U.S. warships are part of an international anti-piracy flotilla.
 
Mother of Somali pirate appeals for his release
MALKHADIR M. MUHUMED
Associated Press Writer

NAIROBI, Kenya (AP) -- The mother of a Somali pirate who pleaded guilty to charges of hijacking a U.S.-flagged ship and kidnapping its captain appealed to President Barack Obama on Wednesday to pardon her son and grant him citizenship.
Abdiwali Abdiqadir Muse pleaded guilty in a U.S. federal court on Tuesday to several charges, including hostage-taking and conspiracy. He faces a minimum 27 years in prison. Sentencing is set for Oct. 19.
Reached by phone in the central Somali town where she lives, Muse's mother asked President Obama for leniency, saying her son is too young to have been tried as an adult.
"Please, please President Obama, please, American people, please release my son and grant him citizenship to help us," Muse's mother, Adar Abdirahman Hassan told The Associated Press by phone.
"You live in a safe prosperous country but we live in a chaotic country. With all your power and generosity and kindness, it will be a stain on your name to punish this child and throw him in jail," Hassan said.
Prosecutors say Muse led four pirates who stormed the Maersk Alabama in April 2009 as it carried humanitarian supplies 280 miles (450 kilometers) off Somalia's coast. Navy snipers fatally shot three pirates and freed ship Captain Richard Phillips of Underhill, Vt., to end the standoff.
Muse's age has been in dispute since the start of the case, with his lawyers insisting last April that he was 15 and should be tried as a juvenile. Prosecutors convinced a judge he was at least 18.
Muse's mother said her son is too young to stand trial.
"I shudder to imagine that Abdiwali will face a minimum 27 years in prison," she said, her voice cracking with emotion. "I don't expect Americans to punish this little kid. He was duped into piracy by adult friends."
Asked why she believes Muse pleaded guilty, Hassan said her son was afraid of a possible death sentence and believed a plea would save his life.
Muse said her son used to call her once a week from prison but that she hasn't heard from him in about three months. Hassan said her son ended past conversations with "soothing words."
"He always praised his life in America. He told me, 'I'm in a nice place, better than Somalia. Mom, I feel bad for you. I'm happy and studying,'" she said.
Muse told the judge on Tuesday that his crew had not intentionally targeted an American vessel.
The pirates held Phillips hostage for several days on a sweltering, enclosed lifeboat that was soon shadowed by three U.S. warships and a helicopter. The end came when Navy sharpshooters on the USS Bainbridge picked off the three pirates.
The American Navy has taken into custody more than 20 suspected pirates in the violence-plagued waters off Somalia and nearby regions, where U.S. warships are part of an international anti-piracy flotilla.

She should be grateful it is a US court and he will not be hanged.