Pirates: The Russian Solution

Isn't Russia a signatory to a variety of conventions that outlaw murdering prisoners?

They weren't prisoners, they were pirates. And the Russians let them go (before they killed them).

I have no remorse. Wipe 'em out. You wanna play pirates then don't be surprised when the world powers string you up like pirates.
 
Something to consider...

It's very easy for us to judge these Somali "pirates" from the comfort of our homes, with snacks on our knees...

But consider that much of Europe, in particular eastern Europe, and many Asian countries have been using the waters around Somalia for many years as dumping grounds for hazardous and probably nuclear waste.

In addition, many countries fish these waters with equipment that is banned worldwide. Because the Somali government doesn't exist, there is no way to defend these waters.

While I don't agree that piracy is a viable solution to these problems, when you get a country as desperate as this one, you had better expect criminal activity to flourish.

http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5gVV_gQDsp1m8v7nPcumVc5McYV-Q
 
It's very easy for us to judge these Somali "pirates" from the comfort of our homes, with snacks on our knees...

But consider that much of Europe, in particular eastern Europe, and many Asian countries have been using the waters around Somalia for many years as dumping grounds for hazardous and probably nuclear waste.

In addition, many countries fish these waters with equipment that is banned worldwide. Because the Somali government doesn't exist, there is no way to defend these waters.

While I don't agree that piracy is a viable solution to these problems, when you get a country as desperate as this one, you had better expect criminal activity to flourish.

http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5gVV_gQDsp1m8v7nPcumVc5McYV-Q

Are the same countries that are dumping toxic and nuclear waste doing the fishing?
 
I'm surprised that our Fuji hasn't drag out his favourite argument, which is that all the Somalis were innocent civilians or farmers and just happened to drift 1,000 miles out to sea and inadvertently boarded a foreign vessel while looking for a pair of lost eyeglasses. Fuji is so predictable now. Everything bad that happens anywhere in the world is the fault of the "White Man".
 
While I don't agree that piracy is a viable solution to these problems, when you get a country as desperate as this one, you had better expect criminal activity to flourish.

What exactly do these pirates do with the loot? Do they use the money to buy food, water and shelter for their fellow countrymen? Or, do they keep the money for their own pleasure:mad: (which might include trips to the fleshpots of Europe)?
 
1. The pirates were on board the hijacked oil tanker. They were not in the "pirate boat".

How do you know? Moreover, since when is that worthy of the death penalty? Good grief.

2. The Russians fought their way aboard the hijacked ship while taking fire. They put the pirates back onto their boats without their weapons and without their GPS and radios that they considered tools of their pirate trade as much as their weapons.

Maybe. The speculation on this very thread is that they did more than that.

What the Russians did in "releasing" the pirates back into the sea without adequate modern equipment to navigate to a safe port could (admittedly) be considered a de facto death sentence. But Maritime Law only requires a vessel to assist another vessel in distress. Possibly, the Russians had departed the vicinity of the pirate boat prior to any subsequent distress signal from the pirate boats. It may be unsavoury and distasteful but I'd think it was within the "rule of law".

If it's a defacto death sentence it is de facto murder.

3. So you don't want to apply Canadian terrestrial law, but "might think" that Russian law applies?

To the same extent that all nations expect their soldiers to abide by their own laws, of course. Is it your opinion that, say, Canadian soldiers operate independent of Canadian law? Perhaps mention that notion of yours to Captain Semeru.
 
Are the same countries that are dumping toxic and nuclear waste doing the fishing?

Not primarily, but even so, it would be different peoples from those different countries. Italy is the country accused of doing most of the dumping. Spain is a leader among those accused of the illegal fishing, among many others.
 
Ahhhhh so by your logic then, what of the innocent Spanish and Italian citizens who must now pay for the organized criminals hailing from those ports who pollute and poach?

What of the Spanish and Italian and other citizens who stole $300 million per year from the Somalis? What of the Italian citizens who illegally dumped toxic waste in Somali waters?
 
fuji fianlly stfu

I find it somewhat plausible that at least some of the people in the pirate boat might have been along for the ride, and done nothing much criminal, while other people in that boat were hardened criminals who accomplished the feats you described.

What a fruitcake you are! ROTFL.

Kudos to those who have finally beaten you into silence. Usually you're like a vampire that can't be killed by logic but this time they shut you up.

The only downside to this cleaning up by the Russians is that in the future the pirates [excuse me, "not doing much criminal" sailors] might not want to surrender or negotiate if they know they are going to be exterminated.

Still, it's a good way of dealing with the pirates and they will get the message. They will be scared of the Russians and will stay away from them. The pirates are looking for easy marks to rob, not looking for scores to settle.

If there is any truth to the problems of the Somalias being caused by the colonizing nations then perhaps the Western powers should use both the stick and the carrot to change the situation. In any case though, the pirates should be exterminated as much as possible while offering help to let Somalis help themselves out of poverty.

D.
 
If there is any truth to the problems of the Somalias being caused by the colonizing nations then perhaps the Western powers should use both the stick and the carrot to change the situation. In any case though, the pirates should be exterminated as much as possible while offering help to let Somalis help themselves out of poverty.

Rule of law be damned then?
 
Rule of law be damned then?

Justice and respect for innocent people is much more important than debating points about rules of law.

20 odd hardworking sailors being terrorized versus maybe, possibly, an innocent 'pirate' or two. Seems pretty clear to me which way the odds are tilted.

You have to break some eggs to make an omelet and if we lose a few marginally guilty pirates in the pursuit of justice and safety then that is a tradeoff I am totally comfortable with.

"rule of law": the law is an idiot. I am concerned with justice and the welfare of innocents.

D.
 
"rule of law": the law is an idiot. I am concerned with justice and the welfare of innocents.

You're entitled to your view. You reject wholesale every single thing that Canada stands for, and put yourself on the side of dictators and oppressors, and against all those who fought and died for our freedom. I don't, but you're more than welcome to your view that the foundations of democracy are idiotic.
 
You reject and ignore wholesale any challenge anyone puts to you regarding this "rule of law" you mindlessly yap about. You balance yourself on the side of pirates to the ongoing peril of clearly innocent sailors and idiotically tie western democracy to ancient Maritime Law

All I'm saying is that unarmed, captive pirates deserved due process of law rather than being murdered at sea.
 
All I'm saying is that unarmed, captive pirates deserved due process of law rather than being murdered at sea.

And when they were armed, threatening thugs and in charge of the ship they had just commandeered, terrorizing the crew who had to lock themselves into a safe room, what did they deserve then?
 
And when they were armed, threatening thugs and in charge of the ship they had just commandeered, terrorizing the crew who had to lock themselves into a safe room, what did they deserve then?

I have no problem with soldiers shooting armed, threatening thugs. My only issue here is what happened after they apparently surrendered.
 
Russian soldiers are subject to Russian law, just as Canadian soldiers are subject to Canadian law. You might want to ask Captain Semeru whether or not Canadian law applies to Canadian soldiers.

Can you quote the exact Russian law that the Russians were not conforming to? As I recall, as previously mentioned here, when the movie cinema was taken by the Chechnyans, the Russians gassed and shot their own people.

They may have an entirely different set of rules/laws than us, and you can leave Cpt S. out of the discussion as you have been asked directly a number of times to supply the particular Russian law that the Russians did not follow.
 
PIRATES: THE FUJI SOLUTION

Send all your money to Somalia. Repeat. Send all your money to Somalia. FujiLaw, Section 1, Paragraph 1.

Sorry, got to go. Amanda Lindhout is on the other line.
 
Can you quote the exact Russian law that the Russians were not conforming to?

You're missing the point. I'll give you two answers, first an answer to your question, and then an explanation of why you're missing the point.

First I am willing to bet that Russia has a law against murder, and under admiralty law, that would be in force on a Russian controlled ship. Even if, amazingly, the Russians do not have an explicit law against murder there are many such provisions under the International Criminal Court, under ius cogens, and so on--it could be tried as a crime against humanity, for example, at the Hague. However, I suspect that is not necessary--I am willing to bet murder is illegal in Russia and therefore illegal under Russian admiralty law.

Second I am aware that not all nations in the world enforce or adhere to the rule of law, and Russia may well be one of those dispicable nations that does not uphold democratic principles--in fact, almost certainly is. We who support democracy decry that.