Pirates: The Russian Solution

When sending in the troops to retake, send them with orders ... shoot to kill, take no prisoners.
 
Hey Rocks, would you like to see the police in Canada authorized to shoot on sight anyone they suspect is a criminal? I mean we could save a lot of money by getting rid of those expensive courts with their fancy judges and juries.

What do you say? Let's just let the police play judge, jury, and executioner?

Who the hell needs laws anyway.
 
If they want to reduce piracy in the region, that is about the only thing that will do it, so I think the Russians were on the right track. Nothing else works.
 
If they want to reduce piracy in the region, that is about the only thing that will do it, so I think the Russians were on the right track. Nothing else works.

Stabilizing the country and creating viable jobs for these people doesn't strike you as a lasting solution?
 
Stabilizing the country and creating viable jobs for these people doesn't strike you as a lasting solution?

Who is going to strablize the country? Do they even WANT a foreign country to come in a stabalize it? They aren't doing it themselves very well.

I agree that having Somalia be a functioing country would be great, but isn't it up to the Somali people to do this?
 
Who is going to strablize the country? Do they even WANT a foreign country to come in a stabalize it? They aren't doing it themselves very well.

I agree that having Somalia be a functioing country would be great, but isn't it up to the Somali people to do this?

Well, Somali people plainly have to take responsibility for their own affairs in the end. It's worth noting that there has been a LOT of foreign interference in Somalia over the years, and that it is yet another one of those countries that was set up by European powers with idiotic borders that more or less guaranteed it would be in perpetual conflict with its neighbours. The British, the Italians, the Russians, and the Ethiopians have all played major roles in fucking Somalia over one way or another at different times.

With respect to the piracy in particular there are allegations that European firms (Achair Partners and Progresso in particular) illegally dumped toxic waste, including nuclear waste, off the Somali coastline rather than pay expensive processing fees to dispose of it properly. European countries are also accused of illegally fishing the undefended Somail fisheries until they were completely depleted. In combination these actions destroyed the traditional Somali fisheries, putting out of work the same people who are now engaged in piracy.

Initially Somali fishermen would go out in their speedboats to chase away the illegal European trawlers. At some point it dawned on them that they could simply rob the trawlers, which they initially called a tax on their illegal fishing. Eventually they started "taxing" any vessel they could find, regardless of whether it had anything to do with fishing or not.

Time Magazine wrote up a good story about how piracy developed in Somalia: http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1892376,00.html

I think after you read that you will have a hard time arguing that European nations, at least, don't share at least some blame for the situation and perhaps therefore owe Somalia some help.
 
Here we go.
 
Not really related to piracy but I remember reading about a mid level Russian bureaucrat on trial in the 70's or 80's who had been convicted of fraud or something by selling stuff to black marketeers. And not sure of the total amount of rubles or dollars involved but the fact that a communist party member was defrauding the state and people was seen to be a major offence. He received the death penalty, was escorted from the courtroom to an ante-room in the courthouse and executed. No long drawn out pre-trial jail time, no appeal. Simply swift justice.
 
In places like Russia 99% of people will agree with what was done. no arguments

my hat goes off to them
 
my retirement includes some serious sail through out the world
And that may include the defensive rocket launcher.


You come off my bow, starboard, larboard or stern and refuse to answer a uniform call.

I hope you can swim
 
What do you mean 99% of Russians ??

99% of Canada too!!!

I suspect the lads were put into the boats.....now they could have followed the sun to get directions.....so no GPS was not the issue.

I do suspect they quicky had 'engine troubles' upon their return.

ANd maybe even their boats suffered some 'pinhole leaks'...that could not be stopped...

Or maybe a gun went off 'accidently' and a bullet sized hole resulted in the boat. Now you could put your thumb over it....but that can get tiring!~!!

These things can happen when man made products are subjected to hot suns and salt waters on the open seas.


Just look at the Cubans..they too often run into boat problems crossing to Florida...it can happen!!

HONESTLY!!
 
Hey Rocks, would you like to see the police in Canada authorized to shoot on sight anyone they suspect is a criminal? I mean we could save a lot of money by getting rid of those expensive courts with their fancy judges and juries.

What do you say? Let's just let the police play judge, jury, and executioner?

Who the hell needs laws anyway.


No, not anyone they suspect. However, if a ship has the crew locked in a safe room and there are armed men on board who do not work for the shipping company, do you think they may be up to no good?
And armed as they are, do you think they just travelled up to 800km to give up without a fight? Wouldn`t the Russian forces look bad to their people, if they let the pirates go free and then the pirates stormed another Russian ship and possibly killed Russian sailors.

This wasn`t racial profiling at the shopping mall. High seas piracy. Live by the sword, expect the same in return.
 
And armed as they are, do you think they just travelled up to 800km to give up without a fight?

I'm sure some of them are up to no good. Maybe a couple of them got dragged along without really having done anything criminal, or at least not seriously criminal. They executed all of them AFTER they had surrendered WITHOUT considering who was guilty of what.
 
Some of them?

Do you have proof beyond a reasonable doubt otherwise? If not you don't give a flying fuck about the rule of law. Period.

Executed all of them after they surrendered?

Apparently so. The Russians claim that they put them back in their boat after they had surrendered, and that they subsequently all died in mysterious circumstances. What everyone on this thread seems to read between the lines is that the Russians captured the ship, took them prisoner, and then executed them.

What exactly do you propose be done to civilize Somalia and provide enough jobs to make being a pirate not pay well enough to consider in career choices?

I't's hard to say--hard situation, but I'm pretty sure that fairness and equity call out for the European countries that caused the problem to pay for the solution.
 
Proof beyond a reasonable doubt that anyone there was p to no good? How about that anyone who found themselves on that ship would have had to make more than a reasonable effort to make their way a thousand miles out to sea, then come alongside a huge ship while underway and probably taking evasive action and water cannons etc and then climb twenty of fifty feet up the side of the ship in the motion of the ocean. And then do anything other than grab some water and make a Mayday call to fix their "fishing boat"?

I find it somewhat plausible that at least some of the people in the pirate boat might have been along for the ride, and done nothing much criminal, while other people in that boat were hardened criminals who accomplished the feats you described.

As for surrendering, news reports that I read are clear that there was a firefight with the Somali pirates shooting at the approaching Russian commandos who were there to rescue the truly innocent seamen doing an honest day's work.

Sure, that's what I heard too. I also read that the Russians claimed to have subsequently captured the pirates, stripped them of their weapons, and put them on their boat, where they mysteriously died. It seems to me what is likely is that the Russians captured them, put them on their boat, and killed them.

As for my respect for the "Rule of Law". I guess we may differ on the applicable law. You may wish to extra-territoritorily impose Canadian terrestrial law on Russian military commandos rescuing and protecting their citizens from nationals from a lawless Somali state in international waters.

Well I wouldn't want to apply Canadian law to the Russian commandos. I might think that Russian law applies though. Isn't Russia a signatory to a variety of conventions that outlaw murdering prisoners?
 
Without any constraints of reality of having to put anything into action, you don't seem to be able to come up with anything.

Well, actually, I can think of a lot of solutions. None of them are quick, or cheap, though.

There are a lot of big problems facing peaceful people of Africa that are higher on the list of priorities that actually have solutions.

Sure, but in other cases it is less clear that the problems were directly caused by European malfeasance.
 
Do you have proof beyond a reasonable doubt otherwise? If not you don't give a flying fuck about the rule of law. Period.



Apparently so. The Russians claim that they put them back in their boat after they had surrendered, and that they subsequently all died in mysterious circumstances. What everyone on this thread seems to read between the lines is that the Russians captured the ship, took them prisoner, and then executed them.

In your own words: Do you have proof beyond a reasonable doubt that they were executed?

The money these pirates make from ransom... do you think each person on that boat was going to get a share? I don`t imagine they would have been there for any other reason. If that is the case, they are accomplices. If any of the sailors were killed, would all the pirates not have been deemed culpable?
 
In your own words: Do you have proof beyond a reasonable doubt that they were executed?

No, only enough of a concern that I think there should be an investigation. Of course, since it was done by a country that has no respect for the rule of law, that isn't going to happen. My real criticism is for those of you who pretend to believe in democracy but see this as anything but offensive.

The money these pirates make from ransom... do you think each person on that boat was going to get a share?

I don't know. Do you? If someone had never been out in the boat before, was promised a share, but did nothing criminal themselves, do they deserve to be murdered?
 
I don't know. Do you? If someone had never been out in the boat before, was promised a share, but did nothing criminal themselves, do they deserve to be murdered?


They were doing something criminal just by boarding the ship. As has been very-clearly explained (thank you, btw) Maritime law is different. By necessity.

Good for the Russians. They won't be housing, feeding and clothing those scum. It wasn't a situation where there were possible other suspects, or these might be the guys....these were the guys. Walk the plank, assholes.

btw, here is a list of the countries that participated in UNITAF, UN military operations in Somalia that began in 1992. These operations were preceded by significant UN humanitarian efforts. It's not like no one's ever tried.

In addition to the United States forces, UNITAF included military units from Australia, Belgium, Botswana, Canada, Egypt, France, Germany, Greece, India, Italy, Kuwait, Morocco, New Zealand, Nigeria, Norway, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Sweden, Tunisia, Turkey, United Arab Emirates, United Kingdom and Zimbabwe
.