typical toronto blue jays bad deal........we are really good at getting rid of players.
It's not a great deal but it's not a bad deal if it sets up further moves. If nothing else happens then I agree that the move is a below average/average one but not a bad one. Aside from Randy Wynn to Seattle for Lou Pinella, Aviles is the most significant player moved in such a trade (to steal a line from Jays Journal) with nothing of note going back in return from a player standpoint.
If we strung the Farrell situation along we may have ended up ridding out next season and losing him for
nothing as the BOSOX pull the trigger on another Manager or an Interim one and wait for Farrell. Other Manager candidates are finding homes so the pool will dry up quicker than the player market will. If nothing else happens we have a serviceable utility player without many questions to him that hits arbitration next year and will earn $4-5m less than Kelly Johnson would get and is a big upgrade defensively while delivering similar stats in 2012. So from that perspective anything is better than nothing and at worst it's a below average deal that frees up some cash for the next guy. But, if that's all there is to the story, the Jays should have pushed harder given up a pitching prospect with a mid-rotation ceiling about 2-4 years away to get Buchholz in return (but that puts the risk on the BOSOX which is unlikely to get a deal done).
With Aviles, options arise:
- We let Johnson walk and free up $4-5m/year in salary for players we really want
- We can flip Aviles in another deal if necessary
- Mike McCoy becomes expendable and could be dealt in a package
- We are free to trade Escobar for the right deal
- We stick with Hech and Escobar and Aviles is insurance if we have to send Hech back down to AAA
Only time will tell if this is a good or bad deal once the dominos fall. Remember, in the Halladay deal the 3rd guy we got was Micheal Taylor (now 26 and has 17 games in the bigs) who we flipped for Brett Wallace in a 1-for-1 deal (now 25 with below average stats on a crappy team) who we then flipped for Anthony Gose in a 1-for-1 deal (now 22 with alot of hype behind him).