Major League Baseball Trade deadline thread

onomatopoeia

Bzzzzz.......Doink
Jul 3, 2020
26,891
20,219
113
Cabbagetown
Top 100 Prospects, per mlb(dot)com

It's not uncommon for a name player to be traded for a player or player that none of us has heard of. Sometimes we'll never hear their name again. Sometimes they'll be a name player in the near future.

Toronto Blue Jays Top 30 Prospects

There isn't much in the cupboard in terms of immediate help, but if the Jays make moves, some new names may be added to this list.

Tarik Skubal, The Tigers, And The Luxury Tax

I found this link from mlbtraderumors(dot)com [on the main page of baseball-reference(dot)com], to be informative as to how a team's player moves late in the season may seem strange, but they have significant impact, going forward.

In the case of the Tigers, they are currently marginally above the Luxury Tax limit, (about $1.6 Million). There are enormous benefits to the Tigers if they don't trade Skubal, IF they can reduce their payroll for 2026 to a level below the Luxury Tax limit.

What I see happening after the trade deadline:

Teams in a similar position to the Tigers, re: the Luxury Tax threshold which are not in playoff contention will attempt to shred themselves of one or more contracts, either by making trades*, releasing players, placing them on waivers, or Designating them for assignment, not to add pieces of value, but solely to reduce their current year's payroll.

*Players can be traded after the August 3 deadline, but those players have to first clear waivers. Players not in a team's organization prior to September 1 are not eligible to play in the postseason.

Examples:

Team A believes that they have some hope of reaching the postseason prior to the deadline. At some point after August 3, they write off the current season. Any players on their current roster who have expiring or non advantageous contracts could be made available for nothing or next to nothing, with the hope than some other team will assume the contractual obligations for the remainder of the 2026 season.

If a player being paid $10 Million for the 2026 season is removed from the 40 man roster with 20% of the season remaining, (and replaced with a player with an $800,000 annual salary), if another team assumes responsibility for the remaining $2 Million owing, the payroll savings to Team A would be $1.84 Million, (20% of $10 Million, less 20% of $800,000). For most of the 18 teams which will not be in the postseason, a lower position in the standings in 2026 will be a benefit in next year's draft, and especially if they currently have pending free agents who they will not resign, but will be tendered a qualifying offer. This is explained in more detail in the 'Skubal' link above.

This salary dump strategy was used last year by the Angels, and also to a lesser extent by the Pirates in 2024.

From wikipedia:

Tellez was designated for assignment by Pittsburgh on September 24 and released the next day. At the time, he was four plate appearances away from receiving a $200,000 bonus for reaching 425 plate appearances in the season. He had batted .299 in July and August combined.

Toronto Blue Jays Salaries and Contracts.

I don't expect the Blue Jays to make any salary dump moves, mainly because they are so far above the Luxury Tax limit that such moves would have no impact on the future.

It appears that the Tigers are the only team who is BOTH not potentially a postseason contender, AND is currently slightly above the 2026 Luxury Tax limit. There is a small possibility that the Houston Astros might go above the limit, if and only if they were to acquire several large contracts for the stretch run, but given their current position in the standings and the club's general philosophy, (they tend to trade their pending free agents with one year of club control remaining, and their acquire rental players when they are strongly in contention), I can't see this happening.
 
If Shane Bieber's next start is anywhere near what he's done in the past two, I think he'll get the most in return at the deadline. He'll likely go to the team with legitimate World Series aspirations who doesn't obtain Skubal. A healthy Bieber could legitimately be part of a three man starting rotation in the 'final four'. I can't say that about Kevin Gausman.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
If Shane Bieber's next start is anywhere near what he's done in the past two, I think he'll get the most in return at the deadline. He'll likely go to the team with legitimate World Series aspirations who doesn't obtain Skubal. A healthy Bieber could legitimately be part of a three man starting rotation in the 'final four'. I can't say that about Kevin Gausman.
While I agree with you that Gausman has been relatively poor this year, his stuff is still good. And he's more durable than Bieber or pretty much almost any pitcher in baseball. I think we take advantage of moving both of them at the deadline if the value in return is sufficient. If we don't move Gausman then I would look to extend him for 2 or 3 years at a heavy discount.
 
While I agree with you that Gausman has been relatively poor this year, his stuff is still good. And he's more durable than Bieber or pretty much almost any pitcher in baseball. I think we take advantage of moving both of them at the deadline if the value in return is sufficient. If we don't move Gausman then I would look to extend him for 2 or 3 years at a heavy discount.

I don't doubt that Gausman can still pitch effectively, but I don't think any team could win a League Championship Series or the World Series this year if he's one of their top three starters. Recent performance just prior to the trade deadline is very important when it comes to deadline deals.

Gausman's recent numbers:

gausman.png

aren't pretty, and while we both would agree that he's a better pitcher than the numbers would indicate, a top contender's GM would want to haggle instead of offering some blue chip talent. Bieber, on the other hand, has had two superb outing in a row, and a third before the deadline could raise his trade value considerably.

sshot-4.png



Max Scherzer threw five no-hit innings for Buffalo a few days ago, but a three time Cy Young Award winner would be expected to be able to do that on a regular basis against AAA players.

Gausman likes Toronto, and Toronto likes him, but I think both Kevin and the Blue Jays would benefit more if he played some meaningful baseball later this year. Nothing would prevent him from coming back, if both parties were interested. The Jays aren't going to need him in October, but he might help them to acquire somebody who could help them in April, this year or next. He'd get a huge ovation if he left then came back.
 
Dodgers starting rotation when all is healthy, could well be the greatest rotation of all time?
Yamamoto, Ohtani, Skull, Snell, Glasnow