Whiskey/Scotch Recommendation?

I mentioned earlier in the thread that I preferred my 12 year old Chivas Regal to Johnnie Walker Blue or even to several other very expensive single malt scotch whiskeys. I fine these to be too smokey or peaty for my taste.It is all a matter of taste and preference. I have six bottles of these expensive whiskeys that have been presented to me over the years but they are not to my liking. I have been recently been experimenting with modifications to these whiskeys so that they might suit my taste. I have succeeded in making a very fine Franken whiskey I have served to several self proclaimed experts and they have all agreed that it is a very fine high quality whiskey.

am5rn9.jpg


One of my Franken whiskeys is a concoction of Johnnie Walker Blue mixed with 40% Alcool ( neutral grain alcohol ) and 5% Southern Comfort and 5% Canadian whiskey to give it a little sweetness. If your scotch does not suit you, modify it to your taste.
 
Aushentoshen 12 year old $53. Outstanding single malt.
Danfield 21 rye whiskey at $45 is a great canadian whiskey
 
I mentioned earlier in the thread that I preferred my 12 year old Chivas Regal to Johnnie Walker Blue or even to several other very expensive single malt scotch whiskeys. I fine these to be too smokey or peaty for my taste.It is all a matter of taste and preference. I have six bottles of these expensive whiskeys that have been presented to me over the years but they are not to my liking. I have been recently been experimenting with modifications to these whiskeys so that they might suit my taste. I have succeeded in making a very fine Franken whiskey I have served to several self proclaimed experts and they have all agreed that it is a very fine high quality whiskey.

am5rn9.jpg


One of my Franken whiskeys is a concoction of Johnnie Walker Blue mixed with 40% Alcool ( neutral grain alcohol ) and 5% Southern Comfort and 5% Canadian whiskey to give it a little sweetness. If your scotch does not suit you, modify it to your taste.

So you drink what commonly known as hootch. Nothing like taking a work of art and butchering it to suit your medieval tastes. I suspect when you get a meal at a fine restaurant or someone's home you put salt and /or pepper on it before you even taste it; the ultimate neanderthal insult.

Wasn't it you that whined about the pretentiousness of Scotch drinkers and yet your starting point is JW Blue Label and then screwing with it with neutral spirits and then claiming to add Southern Comfort for sweetness(?).

Why not start with Spirytus vodka, 75% alcohol with a neutral flavour, and add some Barley wine to taste, much cheaper and the end result is the same, shite to get you shit faced.
 
Forty Creek Double Barrel Select and FC Copper Pot Reserve with a little ice. Glenfiddich 12 or 15 neat.
 
So you drink what commonly known as hootch. Nothing like taking a work of art and butchering it to suit your medieval tastes. I suspect when you get a meal at a fine restaurant or someone's home you put salt and /or pepper on it before you even taste it; the ultimate neanderthal insult.

Wasn't it you that whined about the pretentiousness of Scotch drinkers and yet your starting point is JW Blue Label and then screwing with it with neutral spirits and then claiming to add Southern Comfort for sweetness(?).

Why not start with Spirytus vodka, 75% alcohol with a neutral flavour, and add some Barley wine to taste, much cheaper and the end result is the same, shite to get you shit faced.

I do not hold the drink of scotch whiskey in as high an esteem as you do, that is why I do not feel that I am doing wrong by changing its character by adding other spirits. The drink does not make the man, just as a fine suit does not elevate a common criminal. I may not know as many scotch whiskeys as you do, but I know what I like. I have been checking on the internet and have found that there is no other whiskey that has more recommendations and tasting awards than Chivas Regal. I do not mind that they deliver it to me in a combination of whiskeys that are the best of the best and sourced from many distilleries. I think that would be hard to match if a brand was restricted to one distillery.
 
I do not hold the drink of scotch whiskey in as high an esteem as you do, that is why I do not feel that I am doing wrong by changing its character by adding other spirits. The drink does not make the man, just as a fine suit does not elevate a common criminal. I may not know as many scotch whiskeys as you do, but I know what I like. I have been checking on the internet and have found that there is no other whiskey that has more recommendations and tasting awards than Chivas Regal. I do not mind that they deliver it to me in a combination of whiskeys that are the best of the best and sourced from many distilleries. I think that would be hard to match if a brand was restricted to one distillery.

Even though it's been discussed a few times on TEERB, it's clear you don't understand the science/purpose of blending different Scotches/alcohols and apparently even if you did, it would be lost on you, as you just wouldn't care. There is nothing wrong with Chivas, it is an excellent blend. Your Frankin Scotch is no different then taking Dom and adding orange juice to it, a pseudo Mimosa, what a waste of a fine bubbly. Just take a reasonable sparking wine and add the juice, no one, but you, would tell the difference and 'that' would just be for bragging rights.

The claim is not that the drink makes the man, just don't screw with excellent product, turning it into hootch, not a cocktail, and defend it as enlightenment. I laugh when I see people order Kettle One or Grey goose and add cranberry juice.
 
You might consider The Glenlivet Nadurra 16 y o 'cask strength'. It's 57.7% alcohol by volume, and you water to taste. Not a lot left in Ontario, but it is absolutely wonderful. By adding a bit of water, you actually get it back to a decent cost, say equivalent to 70 bucks.
 
You might consider The Glenlivet Nadurra 16 y o 'cask strength'. It's 57.7% alcohol by volume, and you water to taste. Not a lot left in Ontario, but it is absolutely wonderful. By adding a bit of water, you actually get it back to a decent cost, say equivalent to 70 bucks.

I have had Glenlivet Nadurra. I must say it is a very good scotch. It is sweet and spicy. Very smooth.
 
Recommendation? Never ever let it un down your tummy into you. It burns!
 
Quick, someone get this message to mrsCALoki ( she has me on iggy )

Tell her if it burns to see a doctor immediately, she has the clap.
 
My ex-husband was a whisky(scotch) connoisseur being a born and raised son of Glasgow, and his fave is 18 year old Highland Park.... Although the 12 year old is also good.... If you like something a little smokier, than go for Lagavulin.....
 
To clients, I'll give Johnnie Walker Blue or Highland Park Orkney (18 y.o.) depending on their tastes. Blue is more 'obvious' in a brand-snobbery sort of way if you're gifting. If thinking of a budget, I keep Glenfiddich at home as it is decent. (I'm more of an import/Ontario craft beer type of guy)

For scotch, buy 18 year old. At 21, the price becomes more 'bonkers' - reserved for a more 'sophisticated' palette.

Drink (not gulp) it straight and never have ice!
 
WTF, I've seen two examples of white whiskey, White Ghost and I think White Owl. What, in all that is scared, is white whiskey? I always thought so much of the flavour is from interaction with the barrels. Is this stuff being made in metal tanks and sold before it's time?
 
For scotch, buy 18 year old. At 21, the price becomes more 'bonkers' - reserved for a more 'sophisticated' palette.

The Chivas Regal 12 is fine by me, the Chivas Regal 18 is a real treat.

You are right about 18 year old plus scotch being stratospherically high in price. That is why I stay with the 12 and once in a while the 18 year old Chivas. Even then I buy mainly in the USA where the prices are much lower.



Chivas Regal 12 - 48.95 Can / 31.99 US

Chivas Regal 18 - 94.95 Can / 59.99 US

Chivas Regal 18 year old is one of the highest rated scotch at a rating at 100 in a taste competition. There are others like Old Smuggler and Duggan's Dew that rate very highly at 88 and 89 but at the price point of $11-12 US. per 750 ml. bottle. I would imagine price is taken into consideration. As a reference point, Johnny Walker Red is rated at 85 and sells for $24.95 US. per 750 ml. bottle.
 
I just got back from 4 days each in San Francisco and Las Vegas. The Scotch in California and Nevada is half the price it is here. Chivas Regal 12 goes for $49.95 Ont., $48.00 PQ, and $31.99 NY for a 750 ml. in the east. In California in goes for $22.99, and in Nevada $24.99. Chivas Regal 18 goes for $94.95 Ont.
but in California it is less than 60% of the price up here at $59.99 / 750 ml.

Of course it is not worth going there to buy booze, but if you are there for business or vacation then pick up a couple of bottles.
 
I recently had some Chivas Regal Royal Salute 100 Cask Scotch. Smooth and full flavoured at the same time.

Chivas%20Royal%20Salute%20100%20Cask_enl.jpg
 
The last time I bought a bottle of Macallan 18 yr, for myself at the LCBO, it was $160, when I purchased it as a gift for someone, it was $199. I just received recently a bottle of the stuff as a gift, I believe the price is now $260. It is nice, very nice, but I don't enjoy the company of pretentious scotch drinkers. Macallan 12 yr is good, but the LCBO does not carry it, another reason for private liquor stores! The LCBO monopoly and restrictions will soon fall as did the laws against Sundays shopping.
 
The last time I bought a bottle of Macallan 18 yr, for myself at the LCBO, it was $160, when I purchased it as a gift for someone, it was $199. I just received recently a bottle of the stuff as a gift, I believe the price is now $260. It is nice, very nice, but I don't enjoy the company of pretentious scotch drinkers. Macallan 12 yr is good, but the LCBO does not carry it, another reason for private liquor stores! The LCBO monopoly and restrictions will soon fall as did the laws against Sundays shopping.

I had to find out from a friend of mine where he acquired his Macallan12, as he enjoys the 12 and 18. He tells me that he gets it in NY state for $52 ( Macallan 12 ) a bottle.

I recently had some Chivas Regal Royal Salute 100 Cask Scotch. Smooth and full flavoured at the same time.

Chivas%20Royal%20Salute%20100%20Cask_enl.jpg

Beyond the Chivas 12 and 18, I am not willing to pay sky high prices for any Chivas above that. Even then, I buy in the US. I do have a bottle of Chivas Regal Royal Salute 21 ($175.95 / 750 ml. )that was gifted to me. While it is fine, I will not spend the extra money to buy it for myself.

* In case you are lucky enough to have a bottle of Chivas Royal Salute, know that the bottle cap is not very good and you may be loosing some scotch to evaporation.
I put on a piece of saran wrap on the neck of the bottle before I screw on the cap to have a better seal. I also dip the bottle neck in canning wax as I do not plan to have a taste of the Royal Salute for some time.