Whiskey/Scotch Recommendation?

I do not know scotches, wines, or cognacs, I just know what I like. There is pretentiousness in many things in life. If you want the best, then you must seek it out for yourself and your own taste. I can tell you that a Gaston De Lagrange X.O. Cognac @ $100 a bottle will be as good as a Hennessy Cognac X.O. @ $250 or a Courvoisier Cognac X.O @ $200 a bottle. I have done taste test with many people and they were all surprised by the results. BTW - Gaston De Lagrange Napoleon Cognac will blow you away if you can get a bottle. Price is not an indicator of quality. The region of Cognac and the distilleries in Scotland actually limit their production to keep prices high. Their excess stock is bottled and sold in other regions at a lower price.
 
Last edited:
Glen Morangie for the $70 range.

Nothing wrong with GlenLivet or GlenFiddich for everyday kind of drinking.

I have tried a $30 dollar range bottle of blended Scotch called Te Bheag (Apparently pronounced: "chey vek") http://www.connosr.com/reviews/te-bheag/te-bheag-nan-eilean/a-real-gem/. Highly recommend it over any of the blended JW which does in fact taste like lighter fluid as mentioned above.

Klute
 
Oh my. I never developed a taste for Scotch, but I suspect what I learnt about brandy and cognac would apply.

The value of a given spirit is determined by the taste, the quality of ingredients, how well it is prepared, how it is aged, and the skills of the producer.

The cost of a given spirit is based on its value, its rarity, its reputation, its advertising budget, and how it is packaged.

Many merchants tend to suggest a high cost product because it is considered high end by the customer.

A wise consumer has to realize that their tastes have a sweet spot and spending more money on a product will not add significantly to the taste experience, although it may add more to the ‘social pride’ of drinking a more expensive or famous product. Please do not assume I am putting anyone down with this statement. Drinking cognac or scotch or wine and enjoying its subtleties is not something that we are born with. It is a skill that grows slowly over the years.

So if I may be so bold, here is a guide line shared with me years ago.

The key virtue of blended Brandies and Scotches and wines is they are consistent. You will get the same experience bottle after bottle. That experience can range from a harsh raw product to an exquisite melody. But next time you buy a bottle you get the same experience. Single cask or single malt or vintage products share a basic taste but will have their own personality. Every time you buy a bottle unless it is from the same bottling you will have a new experience. That experience can range from a harsh raw product to an exquisite, but it will be in flux.

Single malts have a lot of panache and bragging rights associated with them, but some blends are actually much more sophisticated and desirable than many single malts.

Ageing is another factor, it allows the character to mature and to emerge. Sort of like men. Younger ones tend to be stronger but not as subtle ;).

So how do you pick a sprit that provides the best value for you? Start with a blend. That way you can create a base line of “good” to permit you to explore the more exotic world of single malts.

You need to pick a brand and a level of quality. For example Johnny Walker has Red, Black, Gold, Platinum and Blue. (avoiding their single malts for now). They use pretty words to describe them but for a novice you can just pretend they are the steps up a ladder of complexity and subtle tastes. To be honest, as a Scotch novice I cannot taste a significant difference between any of the top 3. My Father can recognize each of them. The only way to be certain you are responding to the taste and not the bottle is to do a blind side by side test. Someone already mentioned going for a tasting. Great idea. Money well spent.

Once you pick your level of taste maturity, compare it to the other companies offering. And get the product that is the best value for you. Every few bottles try a glass of the next one up and see if you have developed the pallet to justify the added cost.

Too complicated? Buy a Chevas 12 year old or a Johnny Walker Black. Both are great entry level products. Want to use a bottle to impress people. Buy something expensive :).

If you like Brandy or Cognac you can find a Whiskey that will be to your taste. Never done a head to head but with a 100+ distilleries, and multiple choices from each of them, there is a taste for you.
 
Glen Morangie for the $70 range.

Nothing wrong with GlenLivet or GlenFiddich for everyday kind of drinking.

I have tried a $30 dollar range bottle of blended Scotch called Te Bheag (Apparently pronounced: "chey vek") http://www.connosr.com/reviews/te-bheag/te-bheag-nan-eilean/a-real-gem/. Highly recommend it over any of the blended JW which does in fact taste like lighter fluid as mentioned above.

Klute

Te Bheag is a acquired tasted as it unfiltered, but if you like it's a steal. At the less expensive range the one I've found to be really a joy, is Glen Orde, a round green label.
 
I do not know scotches, wines, or cognacs, I just know what I like. There is pretentiousness in many things in life. If you want the best, then you must seek it out for yourself and your own taste. I can tell you that a Gaston De Lagrange X.O. Cognac @ $100 a bottle will be as good as a Hennessy Cognac X.O. @ $250 or a Courvoisier Cognac X.O @ $200 a bottle. I have done taste test with many people and they were all surprised by the results. BTW - Gaston De Lagrange Napoleon Cognac will blow you away if you can get a bottle. Price is not an indicator of quality. The region of Cognac and the distilleries in Scotland actually limit their production to keep prices high. Their excess stock is bottled and sold in other regions at a lower price.

Pretension is something that can be observed very quickly after a short discusion. If you want a treat attend a fine dinner put on in Toronto by The Companions of The Quaich.They offer up three different choices through various stages of an amazing dinner.

I really don't want to pay more than $100 dollars for a bottle at this time and have had to say goodbye to many fine brands as a result.
The difference in prices as more t do with local market pricing of alcohol than some time of price fixing in NA. How is it you can get some Scotches cheaper in Canada, than in the US or even Britain? Years ago I purchased a bottle of MaCallum anniversary in Canada at 30% less than the same one I purchased in the UK?
 
my favourite scotch is Macallan 18

Me too.

I blame Mordecai Richler and Solomon Gursky.

My everyday scotch is Famous Grouse. Read somewhere that it is 40% Macallan. Probably not the expensive Macallan, but Macallan nonetheless
 
Has anyone tried Collingwood Rye? Had it recommended, but don't necessarily trust the recommendation.
 
If you like Brandy or Cognac you can find a Whiskey that will be to your taste. Never done a head to head but with a 100+ distilleries, and multiple choices from each of them, there is a taste for you.

Just down the road from the castle in Edinburgh their is a tasting bar and museum/tour. They claim to have the largest collection of samples anywhere in the world. If you get a change you should visit it. :)
 
I do not know scotches, wines, or cognacs, I just know what I like. There is pretentiousness in many things in life. If you want the best, then you must seek it out for yourself and your own taste. I can tell you that a Gaston De Lagrange X.O. Cognac @ $100 a bottle will be as good as a Hennessy Cognac X.O. @ $250 or a Courvoisier Cognac X.O @ $200 a bottle. I have done taste test with many people and they were all surprised by the results. BTW - Gaston De Lagrange Napoleon Cognac will blow you away if you can get a bottle. Price is not an indicator of quality. The region of Cognac and the distilleries in Scotland actually limit their production to keep prices high. Their excess stock is bottled and sold in other regions at a lower price.

I sort of prefer Armagnac not many dollars spent on marketing, and taste is comparable. My personal favourite is a blond cognac. During the war the supply of molasses from the new world was restricted so they made blond cognac. I adore it. Sadly it is getting very hard to find.
 
First of all Canadian whisky is not rye whisky it is barley whisky. Alberta Premium is the only Rye I am aware of. Unless you are drinking that, you are not drinking rye. Second of all, American whisky sucks donkey balls, just like their cigarettes, strip bars and beer. If you want a real whisky, single malt scottish is the only way to go. Glen Morangie is a good choice. If you have to mix it with anything but ice and or water, you are drinking crap.
 
First of all Canadian whisky is not rye whisky it is barley whisky. Alberta Premium is the only Rye I am aware of. Unless you are drinking that, you are not drinking rye. Second of all, American whisky sucks donkey balls, just like their cigarettes, strip bars and beer. If you want a real whisky, single malt scottish is the only way to go. Glen Morangie is a good choice. If you have to mix it with anything but ice and or water, you are drinking crap.

Thank you for all the responses, I haven't gone thru all the replies yet.

Glen Morangie and Macallan currently stands out, as I haven't tried those yet and want to break away from Glenfeddich and Glen Livet as my single malt.

Good point on the Alberta Premium as being the most rye composite, I may peak at their Dark Horse brand as well.
 
I do not know scotches, wines, or cognacs, I just know what I like. There is pretentiousness in many things in life. If you want the best, then you must seek it out for yourself and your own taste. I can tell you that a Gaston De Lagrange X.O. Cognac @ $100 a bottle will be as good as a Hennessy Cognac X.O. @ $250 or a Courvoisier Cognac X.O @ $200 a bottle. I have done taste test with many people and they were all surprised by the results. BTW - Gaston De Lagrange Napoleon Cognac will blow you away if you can get a bottle. Price is not an indicator of quality. The region of Cognac and the distilleries in Scotland actually limit their production to keep prices high. Their excess stock is bottled and sold in other regions at a lower price.

I agree with "go with what you like" and spend within your budget. Price is not always indicative of quality/taste. Have you ever tried Hennessy Black? $75 at the LCBO I prefer it over some of the $200 Cognacs.
 
I've had the collingwood whiskey and I really liked it. I don't drink much whiskey anymore, the bottle I had was about 10 months ago or so - but I am about due for another bottle and will certainly be picking more of it up. crown, cc, wisers....all seem like a step down from collingwood.

as far as scotch goes i used to be really into it. my favs used to be glenlivet and lagavulin. haven't had a scotch in at least 5 years, may need to break that spell.
 
My input - single malt and experiment. I don't recall any single malts in the $40+ range that disagreed with me. The rest just depends on my mood. With a nice meal vs. a relaxing night vs. summer cottage vs. winter camping.
 
I have recieved many expensive bottles of scotch and cognac as gifts. When I am done with them. I refill the cognac bottles with Gaston De Lagrange X.O. Cognac. No one has ever noticed the difference. I put Chivas Regal 12 year old into the used single malt bottles.
Last year, I was hosting a dinner party, of husbands with wives and GFs. I pulled a fast one one everybody. I had a tasting of ice wine and then brought out a second bottle to offer in the tasting. The second bottle was actually high end grape juice mixed chilled to almost 0 c. and mixed with some Chivas Regal. Nobody figured it out and they all preferred the fake ice wine over the real one.
 
Famous Grouse is one of the few blended scotches that lists some of the single malts in the blend. The label on the bottle says it contains Macallan and Highland Park single malts, plus some other stuff. It is a nice smooth scotch that costs half as much as a single malt.
For a single malt, I like Glenkinchie.
 
C.C., you are a swindler of epic proportions. ;)

What you did just shows how poor most peoples sense of taste really is. People who buy because of price and name recognition, but can't tell the difference between shit and piss. They think they have a refined palate, but they are just fraudsters themselves.
 
As Basketcase says, single mats and experiment. Many prefer blends, smoother and usually less peaty and often less expensive than single malts. Tough to go wrong with Glenlivet and Glenfiddich, although single malts such as Oban and Strathisla are wonderful, the price of $100+ per bottle puts them out of your price range
 
C.C., you are a swindler of epic proportions. ;)

What you did just shows how poor most peoples sense of taste really is. People who buy because of price and name recognition, but can't tell the difference between shit and piss. They think they have a refined palate, but they are just fraudsters themselves.

You should be so lucky to be swindled by me in this way.

25yvm6q.jpg