Whiskey/Scotch Recommendation?

Cobu

New member
Jul 12, 2011
588
0
0
I got a half a bottle left of Canadian Club 20 years old whisky from my thanksgiving weekend and now deciding to either pick up another bottle or try something new, preferably get back into a single malt, if at a comparable price of 50-70ish dollars.

I am uncertain on the year but preferably something drinkable for sipping.

Any recommendations on scotch/whisky please?

Thanks.
 
I got a half a bottle left of Canadian Club 20 years old whisky from my thanksgiving weekend and now deciding to either pick up another bottle or try something new, preferably get back into a single malt, if at a comparable price of 50-70ish dollars.

I am uncertain on the year but preferably something drinkable for sipping.

Any recommendations on scotch/whisky please?

Thanks.
I think you are either a Scotch drinker or a Rye drinker,but not both. That's how it should be imho. Pour the Canadian Club down the sink and buy Johnny Walker Black Label. I guess lots of knowledgeable Scotch drinkers are going to pitch in, but for me Scotch is like pizza. Even when it's bad, it's still Scotch.
 
I think you are either a Scotch drinker or a Rye drinker,but not both. That's how it should be imho. Pour the Canadian Club down the sink and buy Johnny Walker Black Label. I guess lots of knowledgeable Scotch drinkers are going to pitch in, but for me Scotch is like pizza. Even when it's bad, it's still Scotch.

Not a Rye fan but the LCBO has many a fine Scotch whisky on hand. JW Black is okay but far from my favourite. JW Red is lighter fluid. I do love Oban though, bit pricey but lovely. Some Scotch whisky distilleries, such as those on Islay, use peat fires to dry malted barley. This gives some Scotch a distinctive smoky flavour which I'm not a big fan of, but everyone has different tastes. Try the tasting counter at Queens Quay, they usually have a few you can try for a small fee.
 
If you're more accustomed to CC, I'd recommend Glenmorangie (smooth) or a nice bottle of Bowmore (a bit more flavourful). Macallan is nice, too.

If you like a blend, or want it on ice, you can go with The Famous Grouse.

Just remember that when sipping a proper Scotch, you don't bring a "full sip" into your mouth - just enough to dampen the lips and let the flavour fill your mouth.
 
Pinch Scotch or Bushmills Wiskey
 
my favourite scotch is Macallan 18

my favourite as well. I'm not sure the 18 is worth the extra money though as the 12 is excellent too.

Oban was given to me as a gift and it's quite excellent too. Cobu is looking for something cheaper though...I'd recommend the Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban - from port casks, velvety goodness for about $80.
 
Lots of scotch recommndations but if you like whiskey Id suggest Crown Royal Black. Nice on the rocks. My fav
 
I have tried the Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban, it is very good but it is very expensive for what you get compared to a blended scotch.
I like Chivas Regal. In the end it is all about the quality of the drink.

Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban - $80
Chivas Regal - $45/$30 USA
 
I have tried the Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban, it is very good but it is very expensive for what you get compared to a blended scotch.
I like Chivas Regal. In the end it is all about the quality of the drink.

Glenmorangie Quinta Ruban - $80
Chivas Regal - $45/$30 USA

Chivas is a great Scotch for the dollar.
Ballentines compares favorabley to it for a few bucks less.
 
my favourite scotch is Macallan 18

A very nice selection.

Lots of scotch recommndations but if you like whiskey Id suggest Crown Royal Black. Nice on the rocks. My fav


You are soo right on this Mojo.


You can't go wrong with The Glenlivet 12 or Glenfiddich 12. Both are clean and cerisp and fall into you price range. They are my everyday sip.

I am not a big blend guy, but JW Gold or Blue are what I reach for here.
 
A very nice selection.









I am not a big blend guy, but JW Gold or Blue are what I reach for here.

I have had JW Blue, I was disappointed. Being that it is so expensive I was expecting much more. It was too smokey for my taste.
 
Oh my. I never developed a taste for Scotch, but I suspect what I learnt about brandy and cognac would apply.

The value of a given spirit is determined by the taste, the quality of ingredients, how well it is prepared, how it is aged, and the skills of the producer.

The cost of a given spirit is based on its value, its rarity, its reputation, its advertising budget, and how it is packaged.

Many merchants tend to suggest a high cost product because it is considered high end by the customer.

A wise consumer has to realize that their tastes have a sweet spot and spending more money on a product will not add significantly to the taste experience, although it may add more to the ‘social pride’ of drinking a more expensive or famous product. Please do not assume I am putting anyone down with this statement. Drinking cognac or scotch or wine and enjoying its subtleties is not something that we are born with. It is a skill that grows slowly over the years.

So if I may be so bold, here is a guide line shared with me years ago.

The key virtue of blended Brandies and Scotches and wines is they are consistent. You will get the same experience bottle after bottle. That experience can range from a harsh raw product to an exquisite melody. But next time you buy a bottle you get the same experience. Single cask or single malt or vintage products share a basic taste but will have their own personality. Every time you buy a bottle unless it is from the same bottling you will have a new experience. That experience can range from a harsh raw product to an exquisite, but it will be in flux.

Single malts have a lot of panache and bragging rights associated with them, but some blends are actually much more sophisticated and desirable than many single malts.

Ageing is another factor, it allows the character to mature and to emerge. Sort of like men. Younger ones tend to be stronger but not as subtle ;).

So how do you pick a sprit that provides the best value for you? Start with a blend. That way you can create a base line of “good” to permit you to explore the more exotic world of single malts.

You need to pick a brand and a level of quality. For example Johnny Walker has Red, Black, Gold, Platinum and Blue. (avoiding their single malts for now). They use pretty words to describe them but for a novice you can just pretend they are the steps up a ladder of complexity and subtle tastes. To be honest, as a Scotch novice I cannot taste a significant difference between any of the top 3. My Father can recognize each of them. The only way to be certain you are responding to the taste and not the bottle is to do a blind side by side test. Someone already mentioned going for a tasting. Great idea. Money well spent.

Once you pick your level of taste maturity, compare it to the other companies offering. And get the product that is the best value for you. Every few bottles try a glass of the next one up and see if you have developed the pallet to justify the added cost.

Too complicated? Buy a Chevas 12 year old or a Johnny Walker Black. Both are great entry level products. Want to use a bottle to impress people. Buy something expensive :).
 
I have had JW Blue, I was disappointed. Being that it is so expensive I was expecting much more. It was too smokey for my taste.

Proof that price isn't an indication of quality or more rightly put, agreeable taste. If you stuck on JW, try Gold or Green for something different for a lot less.