More data confirming that vehicle drivers are completely out of control, cause congestion, gridlock and mayhem within our city and the fucker standing in the way of getting Toronto traffic moving and obeying the rules.
Doug Ford won’t let Toronto use cameras to get traffic moving. The city should do it anyway
Sept. 10, 2024
By
Matt ElliottContributing Columnist
THE BIG NUMBER - 147,251, the number of automated tickets issued using bus-mounted cameras to drivers illegally using bus-only lanes in Washington, D.C. since November.
There have been a lot of bad stories about Toronto drivers lately. They’ve
killed cyclists. They’ve
run down pedestrians at pedestrian crossovers. They’ve
ignored transit lanes and
blocked intersections and somehow
gone the wrong way down highway off-ramps. But there is some good news amidst all this bad behaviour: it turns out there’s a ridiculously simple and obvious thing that would help stop it.
It’s cameras. The answer is cameras.
Lots and lots of automated enforcement cameras.
When it comes to traffic enforcement, the data suggests automated cameras are much more efficient and much more effective at catching bad behaviour than police officers.
That’s likely to be especially true in our city, where some police officers seem to regard traffic enforcement as an unwanted chore. In
an article last week by the Star’s Mahdis Habibinia about drivers who get away with “blocking the box” — stopping in the middle of an intersection during a red light — former Toronto police officer Matthew Wood said there’s a culture amongst officers that prefers “action-oriented, high-adrenalin, high-octane” calls and does not consider issuing traffic tickets to be “real police work.”
Acting Supt. Matt Moyer, the head of the Toronto police Traffic Services unit, also pumped the brakes on the idea of a police crackdown of drivers who block the box. He noted that the police generally need to block a lane of traffic for an extended period while pulling over a driver to issue a ticket, so a crackdown may not actually improve traffic conditions.
I’m not thrilled with either of those explanations. In my mind, any would-be candidate to be a Toronto police officer who says they want the job for the “high adrenaline” thrill of it should immediately get screened out of consideration.
And I’ve never really understood why, in my experience, cops spend an eternity sitting in their cars during traffic stops. It feels like the process could be sped up significantly with a bit of urgency.
But again, the good news is that automated cameras don’t have an adrenal system and are capable of issuing tickets in a literal snap.
Cameras work. I recently stumbled across a segment from a local news station in Washington, D.C. reporting that
cameras mounted on buses have resulted in a whopping 147,251 citations to drivers for improperly using bus lanes since last November.
And D.C. is not unique. New York City has long had bus-mounted cameras to catch bus lane violators through their Automated Bus Lane Enforcement (ABLE) program. In June,
the ABLE program was expanded to also issue tickets to drivers who are double parked. Chicago’s city council approved
an ambitious “Smart Streets” pilot last year that will see drivers mailed tickets when they’re caught on camera parking in bike lanes, across crosswalks and in other no-parking areas.
Compared to these cities, Toronto is way behind on automated enforcement. Sure, city hall complemented its long-standing red-light camera program with
photo radar cameras for speeding in 2019, and sure, they’ve been effective at issuing tickets and slowing drivers down, but city hall has been slow to roll out new ones. The program started with 50 cameras in 2020. These days, there are 75.
Another 75 are on order. It’s progress — but it’s slow progress.
And more importantly, there’s not been enough movement toward getting cameras that can enforce other traffic violations, like driving in transit lanes or blocking the box. That’s despite
TTC streetcars running with active external cameras since 2019, and the city’s speed camera supplier — Verra Mobility (formerly Redflex Systems) — offering tech that can also
catch box blockers and
transit lane violators.
At city hall, the explanation for slow progress is usually to blame Queen’s Park. But while it’s certainly frustrating that Premier Doug Ford government hasn’t yet passed legislation allowing vehicle owners to be charged for offences like blocking the box even if they weren’t behind the wheel, I’m tiring of that excuse.
If the legislation isn’t yet in place to allow automated ticketing of more traffic violations, I see no reason why the city couldn’t activate more cameras now to at least capture better data — and to ensure we’ve got the tech in place to immediately start issuing tickets whenever Ford gets around to changing the rules.
This would mirror the approach taken by former mayor John Tory when he was advocating for photo radar. When
Ford was dragging his feet on enabling the regulations to allow the use of cameras,
Tory pushed for council to move forward with the cameras anyway — almost daring Ford to stand in the way. After cameras captured some drivers exceeding 100 km/h in school zones, it got a lot harder to say no.
With city council set to debate a congestion management strategy later this fall, Mayor Olivia Chow should take a page from the same playbook: push forward aggressively and dare the provincial government to block it. Don’t accept a slow small-scale pilot project. Other cities have already tested this for us. And with the police abdicating responsibility, it’s so clear what Toronto needs to do to hold drivers to account: get the cameras rolling.