Some American's Lose.....

MLAM said:
...it didn't matter to me. I said it was irrelevant to this discussion - because this discussion isn't about me, despite the best efforts of others.

The majority of American feel that marriage is defined as being between one man and one woman...and every time this has been put to a vote, they have reaffirmed this. So...what does it matter what I think? making this about me doesn't change that...Prop * will still stand regardless of what is posted here, because the majority of the opposing posts fall into the same trap homosexually fell into the "How can you think / belief / feel that way?? That is crazy. You are stupid"

How's that working for homosexuals so far?

Again, I don't think this should be a political discussion, I think it should be a civil rights discussion.

OTB
 
MLAM said:
the majority of the opposing posts fall into the same trap homosexuals fell into - the "How can you think / believe / feel that way?? That is crazy. You are stupid" argument.

It's been pointed out to you many times that there are numerous other examples of the majority being prejudiced. A majority of Americans used to think black people should not be entitled to vote.

Did that make it right?

The tide of history is against you. In vote after vote on this issue the number supporting gay rights has increased, from 40% last time out to a hair under 50% this time. That is because the lights are coming on, and the dark, twisted, and wrong things you believe are being shown for what they are--prejudice at its worst.

If you want to deny rights to others I suggest you forfeit your own. I really see no difference here between offering additional rights to blacks or to gays.

That the black community is among the most prejudiced is well known and you're a shining example of it. It's odd, given the extent to which blacks have been subject to discrimination, that they are among the most prejudiced members of our society, no?
 
MLAM said:
..read for yourself

http://www.bible.com/bibleanswers_result.php?id=246

Regarding the passing of propositions...I do not know...that would sound pretty damn unconstitutional to me...but whatever. I suppose anything in this world is possible. Is your premise that we should be accepting of everything if we want people to be tolerant anything?

And I think most of us know what happened to the cities of Sodom and Gommorah and their inhabitants...


Well. I read for myself as you suggested.

What a pile of BS

Leviticus - I already commented on this(leviticus is derived from a set of rules for Jewish behavior), but the author of the vile "bibleanswers" that you recommend suggests that AIDs is God's punishment for homosexual behavior. Took him a long time to get around to it. God, however is sorry about the innocents that have died - those doing normal sex, one supposes or maybe drug users(God is not clear on this part), and the interpreter of ' bibleanswers' compares innocents of Aids to cancer victims of second hand smoke.

Corinthians - Its not just Homosexuals that God doesn't like. It turns out that drunks, thieves and adulterers are lumped in with Homosexuals. Guess proposition 8 needs to be reworded.
In this section we learn the cause of Homosexuality. Gay people are not born that way. It seems they are inhabited by Demon spirits which spread Sodomy. So rather than a gay marriage they need an Exorcist. All of this nonsense is an interpretation that to me does not follow at all from the scripture itself.

Romans - Turns out that God only permits face to face sex. Oral sex, doggy, etc, between man and woman are verboten. Once again, time to rework that proposition 8.

Somewhere in this tripe is a suggestion that Homosexuals(and I think people who partake of oral sex) are condemned to eternal perdition. Goodness, you would think that would be enough punishment - we don't need proposition 8.
 
You don't need to delve into the details of the Bible, the Koran, or any other religious texts. Whether homosexuality is right or wrong according to j-random-religion is completely irrelevant.

Marriages are not a religious matter. They are registered by the government, they are legally defined, and they can be presided over by a judge.

They may have religious aspects for SOME people, but that is the business of those individuals, not the business of the state.
 
Hence...

chiller_boy said:
Well. I read for myself as you suggested.

What a pile of BS

...I was not and am not going to get into a debate over it.

But I will again point out that such an attitude is how gays got where they are now.

Keep calling people who have no obvious reason to work to your benefit "stupid", and they will keep not working to your benefit. The issue went from a small handful of states having civil union provisions, with other states considering it, to 30 states now having out and out bans.

These tactics are working so well for gays...and they are so lucky to have many of you guys to support them...
 
MLAM, since you will not listen to others...

...I will use your own words to get the point across, since you seem to be so steadfast in your beliefs:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?p=2307595#post2307595

MLAM said:
(You are)...a sad...sad person.

I have tried to keep in mind that often your agenda is tongue in cheek...but when I read this store on www.msn.con, I knew there would be a reaction here...hence I came to see it.

Now you think he should be accountable for the actions of someone who is his elder...who is related to him by birth via a father he had little to no relationship. Indeed...you imply that his accountability is through his blood lineage...that it is in his DNA...that he is doomed to display whatever behaviors you are alluding he will display simply because of who his blood relative are. You know he was neither born nor raised in Kenya...you know his birth father had little to no influence on his life, as the man left the country before he was even one year of age. But - you insist that the actions of his aunt are an indication of what sort of actions we can expect from him, because this predilection for lawlessness is clearly in his blood, and despite the fact that the man has never even been arrested, let alone convicted of a crime...he will only be able to resist for so long.

You might as well have said he was a descendant of the great apes of Kenya, at that is true barbaric nature will one day show itself, manifested as a blood lust for young white women.

It saddens me deeply to my core that I have to raise a Black male child in a world with people like you in it...and while you might think there is a distinction between actually believing such things to be true and thinking so little of the of the people such vile filth would offend that you are comfortable speaking it as humor, I can assure you most of "us" do not. It doesn`t sting any less when you call me a "baboon nigger" with a smile versus spitting it from between your teeth in anger.

Your professed attitude is probably that you hold no ill will against those you earn your respect...that you can break bread and do commerce with anyone of any race, creed, color or religion, so long as they subscribe to some very broad and general notion of what decency and civilized behavior is. That you can a respect a good man.

But this post - and others - reveal something. Barrack Obama....whether you agree with his politics and perspective or not...is a good man. He was a good student...good enough to be admitted to what many would argue was is the finest institution of higher learning in the world. While there, not only did he succeed, graduating Magna Cum Laude...but he earned the respect of his equally bright peers of a diverse background...who elected him to the most prestigious student post at the university.

After a brief career in his chosen profession, he took a path that turned him away from what surely would have been great financial gain and instead elected to do things that might more benefit a broader swath of people. Did he do so with so a political agenda in mind? Probably - politicians ALWAYS have a plan. But that does not mean he still did not do good.

He married a decent, smart, hard working woman, who has received accolades similar to his own. I have never met the woman, but I can tell you I feel I know a bit about her character, since she attended the same high school as I. That tells me she chose to attend the most rigorous public high school in the city of Chicago, that she chose to endure a long commute to do so, and that she wanted to benefit from the education she received that she could have secured no place else. It tells me that like me, she wanted to be able to compete in this world, she didn`t want or ask for a "hand out", that all she EVER WANTED...like me...was to be judged for her intellect, for the content of her character, and she was prepared to pay the price necessary to gain the respect of those whose respect she would need.

He and this woman have children. Two of them. They have been married for 20 years. Despite what I am sure has been a WEALTH of dirt digging, there has been no hint of impropriety in the Obama marriage.

He attends church, professes to believe in God, and to be a Christian. He has denounced and distanced himself from things the leader of his church has said that did not align with his views, much as John McCain did when one of his religious supporters was revealed to be an anti-Semite.

Barrack Obama has played by the American script as well as it can be played.

And yet you still condemn him because of the DNA in his veins. There is NOTHING he could do to earn your trust and respect...because you simply can`t. He is who he is....his name...his parentage....and that is all that is important to you.

Note - I did not say you disagree with him...civil discourse and divergence of POVs are to be expected in this world. We do not have to agree in order to respect each other, and frankly, I am going to respect you less if you some how manage to agree with everything I do.

No, everything you have posted implies that your issue with him is fundamental - that to you, his crime is the color of his skin, the name he bears, and the linage of his fraternal half. All things he cannot change.

How am I supposed to raise a son in a world where a man like you can come into considerable wealth and political influence while believing these things? How am I supposed to tell him that he can and will get a fair shake in this world when a man who looks like him that possess credentials that mark him as the best of the best amongst us...still is judged as a person for his name and skin color?

If Barrack Obama....with all that he has going for him...is still nothing more than a nigger to more people who will admit as much, how is my regular everyday normal kid supposed to feel that the world is indeed a level playing field? I didn`t say FAIR...I said LEVEL.

And what is more sadly, painfully ironic about all this is that it is people like you who will SCREAM at the unfairness of affirmative action, will INSIST that it is not right that anyone be given an edge or preferential treatment...even while knowing you have the very biases that affirmative action was intended to compensate for. One the one hand, you would tell my kid "Look son...if you work hard...keep your nose clean...demonstrate yourself to be a man of character and decency...you will get a fair shake from me. You will get no favoritism....so don`t be expecting any. But you will get a fair shake".

And then you would laugh with your friends over beers later as you regal a tell about the nappy headed darkie who came to you today asking about an internship with your firm.

This is where you get into a huff and insist you aren`t a racist and rant that I don`t know you. That you would never do such a thing. This is where you will make claim that you seek only to stir the pot...to make trouble.

And you might actually believe this. You might actually have convinced yourself that what you think and feel is not really racism. That because you have acquaintances and business partners who are Black and Muslim that you know what is in your heart.

But this post is so revealing - so revealing. As I said...whether or not you actually believe what you have espoused here really isn`t the point. It is the comfort level that you exhibit in saying it that is so telling...

You once told me that perhaps it was time to take a pause from all this. You might consider that - consider what and how it has changed you, and how that change is projected into the world. This was sad. If it is not who you are, then you need to look in the mirror and find that man, because he is lost.
Now, replace any reference to black or African-American with gay or lesbian.


This issue is not about one group saying that another are stupid. It is simply one of fundamental human rights as protected under the Constitution. Once you deny or take away the rights from one group of people, particularly a relatively large group like gays or blacks, you remove them from any and all. That is and always will be my concern.

Your religion is exactly that. YOUR religion. Not mine and not everyone else`s. The Constitution is supposed to ensure that there is the separation of your religion from our state, particularly in issues where the two do not fundamentally align. Constitutional powers are to supercede those of the church in matters where there is conflict.

I don`t want my son, be he a minority, gay or (knocking on wood) disabled / deformed to have to face bigotry or racism, although I am resigned to know that it`s inevitable on some level. What I want to be sure of is that his RIGHTS are protected by the Constitution, and not defined by any religion. That`s what Canada and the United States are all about, and if that basic premise ever changes, I`m outta here...
 
Yes...

Captain Fantastic said:
This issue is not about one group saying that another are stupid.

...it is.

You can dress this up, play socially morally outraged, intellectually superior and stunned at my ignorance all you want.

The point...THE REALITY...still remains that the reason why gays do not have the rights they seek is because rather than pursue them through cultural and social change and dialogue, that sought to force the over turning of a basic centric principle and belief that the majority of the people in the world hold...and didn't even bother to show respect for those beliefs in doing so. In the space of 20 years gays went from mocking the institution of marriage to wanting in on it. Stuff like that is probably going to make people suspicious and concerned.

Even in this thread...the constant references to being gay being analogous to being Black...do you REALLY think that isn't going to offend Black people? Of course...it is nothing new...white people have been telling Black people since the beginning of time "oh...it isn't that bad for you...just suck it up". I wonder how many thousands of Black people would have loved to have had the opportunity to "stay in the closet" when convenient....like when someone was about to lynch you, or when you were trying to secure a job that you needed to provide for your family. Funny how I have never heard a Black person...even the Black gays I know...draw that analogy. In fact, I knew one in New York who felt it was offensively absurd.

This very discussion points out the issue - the question was "how could Prop 8 have passed in a climate that elected Barrack Obama". I gave the answer...and then suddenly it was a referendum on MLAM and what he thinks and believes. Because that was going to change anything?

Keep thinking being "right" gives you the license to be dismissive of what and how other people feel....it is working out well to date. Winning friends and influencing people all over.
 
I find it interesting that on one hand, you complain about racism and your (African-American) rights being trampled on, yet on the other hand, don't give a damn about others and the plight they go through to attain their inalienable rights. Last I heard, gay people have been victims of violent hate crimes (including lynchings) and discriminated against as well... but they should just hide in the closet, wait for everything to blow over, and hope that their rights are recognnized, right?

People's "feelings" on this issue really shouldn't matter, just as the feelings of the racist crackers didn't matter during the civil rights movement. I'm sure the views of MLK, the Black Panthers, Nation of Islam and others weren't too popular with whitey in the 1960s. But they were on the side of right, no matter how they delivered the message.

This issue is about an inherent right that is protected by the laws of the land, not up for debate or vote. Last I checked, rights are rights, are they not?

Your sweeping generalizations and tone lead me to think that you are no better than the white people that you referenced who talk down to black folks. So to me, that means that either you're selective in who you feel should have their rights defended, which would make you somewhat of a hypocrite, or you sir are a bigot, plain and simple. Which is it?


Edit: The reason I have pressed you on this issue is simply because I usually respect, if not agree with, your opinions, even if your tone can be a little coarse and blunt. On this particular issue, I'm vexed that you have taken such a hard-line stance against an issue of fundamental rights, and I'm trying to understand the genesis of it. "Fuck 'em" doesn't give me a lot to work with, you know?
 
fuji said:
You don't need to delve into the details of the Bible, the Koran, or any other religious texts. Whether homosexuality is right or wrong according to j-random-religion is completely irrelevant.

Marriages are not a religious matter. They are registered by the government, they are legally defined, and they can be presided over by a judge.

They may have religious aspects for SOME people, but that is the business of those individuals, not the business of the state.

Everything you say is true, but it is the religious groups which push the kind of thinking which leads to Prop 8. It is when you look at the basis for the religious(christian in this case) hatred of Homosexual marriages that you see that it is all nonsense.
 
MLAM said:
...it didn't matter to me. I said it was irrelevant to this discussion - because this discussion isn't about me, despite the best efforts of others.

The majority of American feel that marriage is defined as being between one man and one woman...and every time this has been put to a vote, they have reaffirmed this. So...what does it matter what I think? Making this about me doesn't change that...Prop 8 will still stand regardless of what is posted here, because the majority of the opposing posts fall into the same trap homosexuals fell into - the "How can you think / believe / feel that way?? That is crazy. You are stupid" argument.

How's that working for homosexuals so far?


do you personally oppose gay marriage? have the courage of your convictions and say it.
 
Wrong...

Captain Fantastic said:
I find it interesting that on one hand, you complain about racism and your rights being trampled on, yet on the other hand, don't give a damn about others and the plight they go through to attain their inalienable rights. ?[/I]

...I guess you missed the part where I actually joined a PAC to work to fight against the movement to ban gay marriage as a constitutional amendment.

I give a damn. Plenty. But in typical left wing radical fashion, anyone who isn't as left as the most left are is viewed in a harsh light. And hence, their potential allies become enemies.

I will again say...MOST AMERICANS have no issue with complete and total marital rights being granted to homosexuals. They simply wanted the term "marriage" reserved for heterosexual couples. Gays weer dismissive of that desire, and the reasons behind it.

People in this thread keep wanting to make this a religion issue spawned from the religious right. It isn't. They simply benefit from the arrogance of those on the left who insist that EVERYONE think EXACTLY as they do, or esle you are evil.

Had gays not challenged the definition of marriage...not simply accepted and not turn the other cheek...but not CHALLENGED IT....I'd bet there would be 30 states with civil union laws now instead of 30 with gay marriage bans. What would have followed was more civil discourse...some changes in leadership...some changes in the make up of society and its mores, POVs, etc...and the next logical step would have been taken.

But nope. Disregard and disrespect was shown for how people felt and what they believed. They were told their feelings didn't matter.

Do you REALLY think 52% of the people in California are regular church goers? Are evangelicals? In CALIFORNIA???

Nope...they are just regular everyday more than likely very tolerant people. They have nothing against gays. They just think marriage...the institution....has a definition.

Could that change? Absolutely. Will you change it by beating people over the head with a hammer? Absolutely not.

Gays wanted a fight. They got one. In their myopic arrogance they ASSUMED that since they were "right" that was all that mattered, so those who were "wrong" were not of consequence.

"I'm sure the views of MLK, the Black Panthers, Nation of Islam and others weren't too popular with whitey in the 1960s. But they were on the side of right, no matter how they delivered the message."


And to this day the Nation of Islam and the Black panthers are vilified. MLK...who DID understand that the delivery matters...is now recognized as a great man of great vision.

Only a fool thinks that being right is enough...and that you can rip from a person's mind and heart what you want from them.

Gays would have been wise to have to followed the MLK script of quiet and dignified social protest, or engaging those who would have them in intelligent dialogue, or winning friends and influencing people. The civil rights movement succeeded not because Blacks were "right"...they had been right for 200 damn years. It succeeded because someone came along who was able to led focus and persistent change, while at the same time allaying the fears of those who did not oppose his cause...but were simply scared of what a new future might hold. He made them his allies...instead of calling them his enemy when they weren't prepared to get fire hosed and mauled by dogs right beside him.

Sigh...I am guessing gays cost themselves 15 to 20 years.
 
Last edited:
MLAM said:
MOST AMERICANS have no issue with complete and total marital rights being granted to homosexuals. They simply wanted the term "marriage" reserved for heterosexual couples.

If "married" is such a religiously loaded term then it has no business appearing ANYWHERE in the constitution of any state or in any law on the books. It should be dropped, and universally replaced with the term "civil union" for EVERYONE.

Whether any individual wants to go around calling themselves "married" would then be their own business, and they could use, for themselves, whatever definition of the word fit their particular world view or beliefs.

Getting registered as a civil union would be something you do for tax purposes and other dealings with the government.

Getting married would then be something you do with your church, unrelated to whether or not you register your relationship as a civil union.

You could have married people who have not registered with the government; and you could have civil unions that had not gone and called themselves married.

Gays (just like hetros) could then get married in churches that accept that, whether or not they go and register the marriage as a civil union with the government. Other churches that do not accept homosexual marriages would be free not to conduct any, even if they might have some gay congregation members who had registered civil unions.

The state has NO business imposing religious views on people one way or the other. It shouldn't be telling people they have to conduct gay marriages if they don't want to, and they shouldn't be telling people they can't if they do want to.

they are just regular everyday more than likely very tolerant people

There is evidence that black voters are more homophobic than the average voter, and the large turnout of black voters contributed to this proposition being passed. I continue to find it ironic that a group that has been subject to so much discrimination is, in general, so extremely bigoted in its views of other groups.
 
The key principle here is this:

One law for everyone.

If you can't see the value in that, if you continue to support this "seprate but equal" notion of a civil union, if you fail to see the value of NEVER having a law written in a way that discriminates, no matter how harmelessly, then you don't really grok the concept of equality.
 
MLAM said:
...I guess you missed the part where I actually joined a PAC to work to fight against the movement to ban gay marriage as a constitutional amendment.

I give a damn. Plenty. But in typical left wing radical fashion, anyone who isn't as left as the most left are is viewed in a harsh light. And hence, their potential allies become enemies.

I've seen no mention of your involvement in gay rights, but I will take your assertion at face value.

I think I'm probably closer to the centre than you think - I believe in the Constitution and upholding the basic laws of the land.
MLAM said:
I will again say...MOST AMERICANS have no issue with complete and total marital rights being granted to homosexuals. They simply wanted the term "marriage" reserved for heterosexual couples. Gays weer dismissive of that desire, and the reasons behind it.
This is where I must beg to differ. A couple of hundred years worth of laws have been written with the word "marriage" or married or other derivatives of the word used. And we know the legal community are sticklers for the usage of words. "Civil union" or other terms other than marriage allows for legal loopholes the size of the Holland Tunnel that has and will affect the rights of homosexuals.

That is the issue for the majority of gays and lesbians - it is not a "we'll show you" point for most. For "civil union" to work, every law that contained the term marriage, etc., would have to be changed to include the term civil union and domestic partnership and whatever else it may have been called in a respective jurisdiction. It has already reared its head in many court cases where fundamental marriage rights were ignored because the term "civil union" did not meet the standard for "marriage" in the eyes of the courts. That is why civil union has been rejected by many in the gay community - because it would have meant that they would have had to accept not being afforded the same rights, benefits and privileges that others had. It was, in essence, a bargain that they would have been forced to live with for a long time - because once you make a set of laws, it is nearly impossible to "upgrade" - without gaining the same rights, all the while having huge technicalities that could come back and bite them in the ass (and not in a fun way - LOL!) in the long run.

MLAM said:
People in this thread keep wanting to make this a religion issue spawned from the religious right. It isn't. They simply benefit from the arrogance of those on the left who insist that EVERYONE think EXACTLY as they do, or esle you are evil.

Had gays not challenged the definition of marriage...not simply accepted and not turn the other cheek...but not CHALLENGED IT....I'd bet there would be 30 states with civil union laws now instead of 30 with gay marriage bans. What would have followed was more civil discourse...some changes in leadership...some changes in the make up of society and its mores, POVs, etc...and the next logical step would have been taking.

But nope. Disregard and disrespect was shown for how people felt and what they believed. They were told their feelings didn't matter.

Do you REALLY think 52% of the people in California are regular church goers? Are evangelicals? In CALIFORNIA???

Nope...they are just regular everyday more than likely very tolerant people. They have nothing against gays. They just think marriage...the institution....has a definition.

Could that change? Absolutely. Will you change it by beating people over the head with a hammer? Absolutely not.
It doesn't matter if it is a religious issue, a constituent issue or a Martian issue. The fundamental and Constitutional rights of gay Americans have been denied. Since that document is held sacrosanct by both the people and government, it needs to be upheld, above the interests of any religion or group.

Marriage has a different meaning for every religion and culture, with different ceremonies, vows and duties. It is not a singular institution, but a fluid one that is held together by a thread of two people who love each other and are committing themselves to one another for life. In most religions, divorce is not allowed, and yet the divorce rate is over 50%. That does not sound like an institution.

Gay marriage is fundamentally the same thing as any other marriage, except that the parties involved are of the same sex. People are not gay because they choose to be (every gay person I know have claimed they would never have chosen to be homosexual, but they accepted that is who and what they are and moved on) and as such, they want to have the same right to marry the person they love, with the same intention of spending the rest of their days with their loved one as any heterosexual couple. They just want the same guarantees that their rights are exactly the same as those in so-called conventional marriages.

Unfortunately there are those that have riled up the masses, spreading misinformation and outright lies about gay marriage, trying to influence those who are more moderate, using God and morality and even ideas like gays not taking marriage seriously and being a drain on the system to push their agenda. They preyed on the base fears that some have that gays are nothing better than child molesters and deviants. They have manipulated and bastardized the legal and political systems, using their "power" as church and community leaders to gain the ear of lawmakers. And yes, they have used some of the more vocal militant minority against the gay community's push for equal rights, ignoring the majority of more temperate homosexuals who just want what they consider fair - the same rights as others.
MLAM said:
And to this day the Nation of Islam and the Black panthers are vilified. MLK...who DID understand that the delivery matters...is now recognized as a great man of great vision.

Only a fool thinks that being right is enough...and that you can rip from a persons mind and heart what you want from them.

Gays would have been wise to have to followed the MLK script of quiet and dignified social protest, or engaging this who would have them in intelligent dialogue, or winning friends and influencing people. The civil rights movement succeeded not because Blacks were "right"...they had been right for 200 damn years. It succeeded because someone came along who was able to led focus and persistent change, while at the same time allaying the fears of those who did not oppose his cause...but were simply scared of what a new future might hold. He made them his allies...instead of calling them his enemy when they weren't prepared to get fire hosed and mauled by dogs right beside him.

Sigh...I am guessing gays cost themselves 15 to 20 years.
Actually, gays did try to quietly get the same rights, but were outright rejected at first. Then they tried lobbying, followed by using the media and other means to gain rights that others have had for many years. Frustrated by the unbending "civil union" legal language issue (and the hardcore right wing that have fought gay rights tooth and nail), some have now become more vociferous and have made this a constitutional issue.

My point is simply we are at a stage in our development as a nation that this issue should not even be on the table for discussion. Rights should be held sacred for all and there really should not be the begging others to respect these already inalienable rights, particularly since marriage as it were, is not the domain of any one group.

Would MLK have settled for a watered-down version of civil rights, where black Americans would have their own set of codified laws and rights that were mostly equal but different from the existing laws of the land?
 
Captain Fantastic said:
My point is simply we are at a stage in our development as a nation that this issue should not even be on the table for discussion. Rights should be held sacredHear hear for all and there really should not be the begging others to respect these already inalienable rights, particularly since marriage as it were, is not the domain of any one group.

hear hear
 
trufflepiggy said:
Being African American is a matter of birth..........
Being Gay is a choice.......

Oh please, go back to your cave.... did you chose to be heterosexual, or are you telling us you chose to be gay? I've never meet anyone who chose their sexual preference.

OTB
 
trufflepiggy said:
You have never met a Gay person?

So the neadrathal has comprehension issues.

Yes, I have many gay friends, none of which chose to be gay, they were born that way.

OTB