Some American's Lose.....

MLAM said:
...disagree....and the reasons why are not something you would subscribe to, so there is no point in trying to explain it.

thats convenient. you know the catholic church's views have changed over time.

The early Church approved slavery, as seen by St. Paul’s command for slaves to obey their masters (Col. 3:22-25; Eph. 6:5-8). Furthermore, the Catholic Church didn’t get around to repudiating slavery until the 1890s and prior to that actually supported it.

so is slavery wrong? I think so.

Let me understand your position: you are not opposed to gay civil unions, and so I also assume you are not opposed to gays living together and having gay sex. it is only calling those gay unions a marriage that you oppose? is that right?
 
I guess I'm a little slow here but seeing as how the US recognizes jewish, muslim, hindu or non-demominational marriages what exactly has the church or Christianity got to do with this issue ?
 
MLAM said:
...would have to ask him why.

And yes it is...and if you were raised Catholic and took it seriously (I take it you did not and have since rejected it), you know WHERE in fact in the Bible Christ rejects homosexuality.

BTW....Christ rejected no one...who was prepared to come to Christ. He welcomed everyone...who was prepared to reform their ways and live for Him. Non believers like very much to twist that into "everything is ok because Christ was ok with everybody". Not true....he hated sin and sinners....but loved those who were prepared to make a change from a sinful life to a Christ like one.

Your very general premise is remotely correct, and is in fact where many religions fall short...they judge and reject people based on their past. Christ did not. But be ye no fool...all are judged on what is in their heart...or in other words...the "current".
I am a little confused about your post. Where in the Bible does Christ reject homosexuality? I know of two non - Christ anti homosexuality statements:

(1) in Leviticus Homosexuality is 'an abomination'. But this is a statement made about how Jews should behave, along with a whole bunch of other strictures that were not included in the Christian old testament. Jewish dietary rules were dropped from the old testament. In Leviticus this section professes no rules about how non Jews should behave.

(2) in Paul's gospel he speaks of the evils of Homosexuality. But Paul regarded homosexuality as a punishment for some transgression, administered by God, one supposes. So, preventing a Homosexual from following his instincts would be an affront to God.

Isn't Sodom and Gommorah in the bible? Could a proposition be passed that would prohibit sexual acts between men and women that some of us(gasp) sometimes indulge in?
 
The Catholic Church....

red said:
thats convenient. you know the catholic church's views have changed over time.

The early Church approved slavery, as seen by St. Paul’s command for slaves to obey their masters (Col. 3:22-25; Eph. 6:5-8). Furthermore, the Catholic Church didn’t get around to repudiating slavery until the 1890s and prior to that actually supported it.

so is slavery wrong? I think so.

Let me understand your position: you are not opposed to gay civil unions, and so I also assume you are not opposed to gays living together and having gay sex. it is only calling those gay unions a marriage that you oppose? is that right?

..has a man at its head, who (apparently) has provisions within its doctrine to allow said man to change its position (and accordingly God's position) on issues as it sees fit.

I don't think much of the Catholic church. With good reason, in my opinion...and you gave one...but that is just my opinion.

BTW..the scripture you quote is not an "approval" of slavery....but if you are a slave...you should obey. It...and the surrendering verses...speak more to having a respect for authority...what ever that authority in your live might be.

And...you misunderstand my position. And my position is somewhat irrelevant to this discussion. What *I* said...was that the American people reject gay marriage because it runs counter to their Judo-Christian beliefs...even those who are not practicing Christians. I haven't said what MY views are...because they aren't relevant....
 
This great land of ours is a land of laws, not of a single religion.

Our laws, rights and responsibilities need to be open to all - full stop, end of fricking conversation.

OTB
 
You can...

chiller_boy said:
I am a little confused about your post. Where in the Bible does Christ reject homosexuality? I know of two non - Christ anti homosexuality statements:

(1) in Leviticus Homosexuality is 'an abomination'. But this is a statement made about how Jews should behave, along with a whole bunch of other strictures that were not included in the Christian old testament. Jewish dietary rules were dropped from the old testament. In Leviticus this section professes no rules about how non Jews should behave.

(2) in Paul's gospel he speaks of the evils of Homosexuality. But Paul regarded homosexuality as a punishment for some transgression, administered by God, one supposes. So, preventing a Homosexual from following his instincts would be an affront to God.

Isn't Sodom and Gommorah in the bible? Could a proposition be passed that would prohibit sexual acts between men and women that some of us(gasp) sometimes indulge in?

..read for yourself

http://www.bible.com/bibleanswers_result.php?id=246

Regarding the passing of propositions...I do not know...that would sound pretty damn unconstitutional to me...but whatever. I suppose anything in this world is possible. Is your premise that we should be accepting of everything if we want people to be tolerant anything?

And I think most of us know what happened to the cities of Sodom and Gommorah and their inhabitants...
 
What happened to the separation of Church and State? The religious views of some Americans should not have precedence over the inherent rights of all Americans.

It clearly states in the Declaration of Independence and in the Constitution's Bill of Rights that all men are created equal.

Not some. Not those we decide upon or who agree with our religion. All.
 
Captain Fantastic said:
What happened to the separation of Church and State? The religious views of some Americans should not have precedence over the inherent rights of all Americans.

It clearly states in the Declaration of Independence and in the Constitution's Bill of Rights that all men are created equal.

Not some. Not those we decide upon or who agree with our religion. All.

The irony of course is the guy who wrote that owned slaves.... ideas ahead of their time, and they still are.

OTB
 
Should that....

onthebottom said:
This great land of ours is a land of laws, not of a single religion.

Our laws, rights and responsibilities need to be open to all - full stop, end of fricking conversation.

OTB


...overide the will of the people?

Should we dispense with any and all mores and guidelines that are woven into the fabric of our laws?

What is the litmus test? What is something the exclusionary to "some" (less than all) and what is simply not acceptable in our society?

What about polygamy? What about indentured servitude? Forced marriage? Adult / Child relationships? All of these things (and many others) are embraced by others (not just a fringe few...MILLIONS) as part of their culture...but we ask people to forgo them to be part of ours, and have legal provisions with penalties to help insure they do and provide consequences if they do not.

Who gets to be the arbiter of what is legal and not legal if it isn't the people who are subject to the laws of the state?
 
MLAM said:
..I haven't said what MY views are...because they aren't relevant....

I took your comment below to mean you oppose gay marriage:

MLAM said:
...disagree....and the reasons why are not something you would subscribe to, so there is no point in trying to explain it.


If thats wrong, then I apologize. But please be clear - do you oppose gay marriage? yes or no?
 
And if....

onthebottom said:
I'm not sure a majority of Southern Whites thought integrating schools was a good idea in the 50s.... what the majority wants and what protect a minority deserves is the issue here. This is a civil rights issue to me, nothing more.

OTB


...the "separate but equal" school had in fact been that way...you would have a point. They weren't as Thurgood Marshall argued successfully.

It is a civil rights issue only if someones civil rights have been denied or diminished. Since civil unions and granting all the rights of marriage was in fact available to gays, I fail to see how this is a civil rights issue.

There are lots of persons who for various reasons are denied the right to marry, because they do not fit the definitions of what a suitable marriage is as decided by the elected government of the people. The citizens of the State of California has now decided to add "single man and woman" to that list of requirements. I do not think it is an has inherent innate requirement for life and the pursuit of.

That not withstanding....I also find it at best amusing and at worse insulting every time someone compares being a member of a visible minority group to being gay.

No one knows you are gay until you decide to tell them, and accordingly, your rights are not impacted until you do.

I do find it telling that I have NEVER heard a gay person of color make this comparison...and I'm thinking they are the only people who would be in a position to do so.
 
MLAM said:
...overide the will of the people?

Should we dispense with any and all mores and guidelines that are woven into the fabric of our laws?

What is the litmus test? What is something the exclusionary to "some" (less than all) and what is simply not acceptable in our society?

What about polygamy? What about indentured servitude? Forced marriage? Adult / Child relationships? All of these things (and many others) are embraced by others (not just a fringe few...MILLIONS) as part of their culture...but we ask people to forgo them to be part of ours, and have legal provisions with penalties to help insure they do and provide consequences if they do not.

Who gets to be the arbiter of what is legal and not legal if it isn't the people who are subject to the laws of the state?

In the US there are real legal consequences and rights associated with being married. Why we should artificially deny this legal status to a group of people is beyond me. In addition, we are denying this legal status and rights to parents of children who, I dare say, would be better off if their parents were married.

Your examples I think show the weakness of your argument. Forced marriage, adult/child relationships are not consenting adults having the same rights as all other citizens - which is what we're talking about here.

OTB
 
What...

red said:
I took your comment below to mean you oppose gay marriage:




If thats wrong, then I apologize. But please be clear - do you oppose gay marriage? yes or no?


...does it matter?

I am not a resident of California....I am not even a resident of the United States.

The question was...how could Prop 8 be passed in an election where Brack Obama won?

The answer is because the majority of Americans.... including Californians.... believe marriage is defined as being between one man and one woman...and they believe that because of the Judo-Christian under pinnings of the U.S.

What you (and the others) seek to do is argue with me about whether or not this is right..whether or not my beliefs are right, etc. None of this matters to the question that was actually put forth. I am not even GOING to begin to take up a defense of either my beliefs or God for the benefit of some guys on a message board devoted to strippers and hookers. What a waste of time that would be...no?

It isn't about me.

The people have spoken. Should they chose to, they can speak again.
 
Obviously...

onthebottom said:
In the US there are real legal consequences and rights associated with being married. Why we should artificially deny this legal status to a group of people is beyond me. In addition, we are denying this legal status and rights to parents of children who, I dare say, would be better off if their parents were married.

Your examples I think show the weakness of your argument. Forced marriage, adult/child relationships are not consenting adults having the same rights as all other citizens - which is what we're talking about here.

OTB


...adult consent is not required in some societies. Which is my point - who gets to decide? We can't even agree on what an adult is.

beyond that, there are lots of things that are illegal even WHEN consenting adults are involved...because it is seen as not to the greater good of the whole. Drug trafficking, distributing and use come to mind.

That said..I agree with you...and gays were offered those right via civil unions. That wasn't good enough. Lesson learned - don't try to force your views down the throat of people who you do not respect. You mocked their religious beliefs? What did it get you?

It was EXACTLY this manner of thinking that led to the "W" era. As I have said in another thread...the people in the center got sick of the people on the left calling them crazy...so they aligned with the people on the right.

Eight years later...hopefully we can again have a moderate center without the radical elitist left belittling those in the middle for being so "stupid" as to having core beliefs.

Gays got what they got because rather than respecting the reality...that the majority of Americans were more than happy to grant the RIGHTS of marriage to homosexuals, but want the INSTITUTION of marriage saved for heterosexual men and women...they instead said "oh what you think is stupid".

I have no sympathy whatsoever. Fuck em.
 
MLAM said:
Gays got what they got because rather than respecting the reality...that the majority of Americans were more than happy to grant the RIGHTS of marriage to homosexuals, but want the INSTITUTION of marriage saved for heterosexual men and women...they instead said "oh what you think is stupid".

I have no sympathy whatsoever. Fuck em.
That's enlightened. And telling.

So my question is does/did the same hold true for African Americans? They are and were in the minority (about 12% of the population); the majority of white Americans were happy to see blacks as less-than-equal and not afforded the same rights and opportunities. Many others didn't care. It took the strength and perseverence of leaders in both black and white communities to change this - to enforce the inherent rights and freedoms of all American citizens, not just the select few based, in this case, on skin colour.

And that is the point: one person's rights (within reason) trampled are all peoples' rights trampled - and when (approximately) 10% of the population is involved, that is a reasonable amount to justify rights.

The problem with "civil unions", "domestic partnerships" and the like, compared to "marriage" is that homosexuals do not get the same legal rights, property rights, family benefits and other benefits and rights. Not to mention the nearly 1200 laws that make "marital" status a factor. Comprehensive legal rights and benefits are the main issue for the gay community, not some hogwash about institutions.

And to compare homosexual marriage rights to pedophiles, bestiality, polygamy and the like is not only incredibly insensitive, but outright insulting. (Aside: Please provide some sort of evidence that homosexuals have stated "oh what you think is stupid" regarding this issue.)

By your words and tone in this thread, I would guess that you just don't like homosexuals - nothing more, nothing less.
 
trufflepiggy said:
Wouldn't it be State interference with the Church to define marraige?
So does that mean that one can't get married at City Hall? Or in Vegas? (LOL!) I think you've got it backwards - where does it say that it's up to the Church alone to define marriage? :confused:

I'll say it again: in a constitutional democracy like the U.S., the Church has no business interfering in affairs of the State.
 
If gay marraige passed and a Church did not, rfor reason of consious, allow it would the Church be in violation?

Wouldn't the State be telling Churches that they have to marry gays?
 
trufflepiggy said:
If gay marraige passed and a Church did not, rfor reason of consious, allow it would the Church be in violation?

Wouldn't the State be telling Churches that they have to marry gays?
Are you being serious?

C'mon, do Jewish people get married in a Catholic church and vice-versa? And would said Catholic make an issue out of not being allowed to be married in a synagogue?

The issue is not about where someone is married, just their rights to get married and the benefits that go with it. :cool: