Some American's Lose.....

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,880
197
63
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
This really surprises me, in a state that went 60/40 for Obama you have this:

California set to pass Prop 8 ban on gay marriage

By Peter Henderson Peter Henderson – 1 hr 36 mins ago
Voters line up to cast ballots as polls open in Boca Raton, Florida November 4, Reuters – …

SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) – Two U.S. states rejected proposals to limit abortion rights while others said no to gay marriage, in a mixed message over contentious social issues as Americans elected their first black president.

Results of votes on more than 150 proposed state measures across the country showed a more complex cultural map than Tuesday's historic election of Democrat Barack Obama might indicate.

In California, same-sex couples were poised to lose the right to marry, while Florida and Arizona voted to ban gay marriage outright, joining dozens of other states that define marriage as only between a man and a woman.

Attempts to restrict abortion in South Dakota and Colorado met strong voter resistance.

Halting abortion and same-sex marriage are key issues for many conservative Christian voters, an important base for the Republican Party.

With 93.6 percent of precincts reporting, the California proposition to stop same-sex marriage -- which came about half a year after the state court opened the way to gay marriage -- was ahead by 4.2 percentage points.

"We have Obama," Noelle Skool, 29, said of her hopes for change as she checked identification at a popular lesbian bar in San Francisco's Mission district. "It's small steps. Eventually they'll warm up to the fact that, hey, we're all equal."

Mathew Staver, founder of the conservative Liberty Counsel, had success as a proponent of the Florida gay marriage ban but saw the state vote for Obama the Democrat.

"The passage of this amendment is a bright star on an otherwise dismal night, in which America elected the most liberal President in her history," Staver said in a statement.

Colorado voters rejected a measure that would have made abortion the legal equivalent of murder by defining human life as beginning at conception.

South Dakota defeated a ban on abortion that, if passed, had been expected to spark a court battle leading to the Supreme Court.

"We defeated it here, and it won't spread to other states," said Sarah Stoesz, president of the local Planned Parenthood chapter. "And now we've started a counter movement in a very conservative part of the country."

In other state ballots, Michigan voted to allow medical use of marijuana, Nebraska ending affirmative action to help minorities and Washington allowing doctor-assisted suicide.
 
The lack of tolerence in California is surprising but not in Florida or Arizona.

But what about the important stuff. Did New Hampshire vote to decriminalize marijuana ? ( Probably just to boost maple syrup sales but hey us aging capitalist hippies will need something and somewhere to go -closer than Amsterdam - when we can no longer have single malt ). :D
 
It doesn't....

...surprise me.

History will tell a tale of how homosexuals WAY over reached on the gay marriage thing...and it cost them. Had they went for civil unions and all the rights associated thereof first...they would probably be civil union laws in the majority of states, versus the majority of states having gay marriage bans as they do now.

Americans just were not ready....and it did not help that the same people who previously mocked their institution of marriage were now asking to be a part of it.

I still would like to have a CIVIL conversation with a gay person who could explain to me what gay marriage was supposed to do for them that civil unions did not, other than to try to force a change in my religious thinking....and associated acceptance.
 
MLAM said:
...surprise me.

History will tell a tale of how homosexuals WAY over reached on the gay marriage thing...and it cost them. Had they went for civil unions and all the rights associated thereof first...they would probably be civil union laws in the majority of states, versus the majority of states having gay marriage bans as they do now.

Americans just were not ready....and it did not help that the same people who previously mocked their institution of marriage were now asking to be a part of it.

I still would like to have a CIVIL conversation with a gay person who could explain to me what gay marriage was supposed to do for them that civil unions did not, other than to try to force a change in my religious thinking....and associated acceptance.

how does two gay people getting married impact your religious thinking and even if it did why should that stop them?
 
MLAM said:
...surprise me.

History will tell a tale of how homosexuals WAY over reached on the gay marriage thing...and it cost them. Had they went for civil unions and all the rights associated thereof first...they would probably be civil union laws in the majority of states, versus the majority of states having gay marriage bans as they do now.

Americans just were not ready....and it did not help that the same people who previously mocked their institution of marriage were now asking to be a part of it.

I still would like to have a CIVIL conversation with a gay person who could explain to me what gay marriage was supposed to do for them that civil unions did not, other than to try to force a change in my religious thinking....and associated acceptance.


I agree with almost everything you said except I don't think you accounted for the possibility that some gay couples are also religious.

For a religious gay couple, a civil union may not be enough.

Just a thought.....
 
Unless you share the same faith...

red said:
how does two gay people getting married impact your religious thinking and even if it did why should that stop them?


...there is nothing I could say to you that would explain it sufficiently for you...so accordingly I won't.

The over arching point is that the American people got what they wanted...marriage recognized as ONLY being between a man and a woman.
 
Show me a religion...

lookingforitallthetime said:
I agree with almost everything you said except I don't think you accounted for the possibility that some gay couples are also religious.

For a religious gay couple, a civil union may not be enough.

Just a thought.....


...that endorse gay marriage in its mainstream.
 
MLAM said:
...surprise me.

History will tell a tale of how homosexuals WAY over reached on the gay marriage thing...and it cost them. Had they went for civil unions and all the rights associated thereof first...they would probably be civil union laws in the majority of states, versus the majority of states having gay marriage bans as they do now.

Americans just were not ready....and it did not help that the same people who previously mocked their institution of marriage were now asking to be a part of it.

I still would like to have a CIVIL conversation with a gay person who could explain to me what gay marriage was supposed to do for them that civil unions did not, other than to try to force a change in my religious thinking....and associated acceptance.

I think it's a separate but equal issue, it's always more separate than equal.

OTB
 
MLAM said:
...that endorse gay marriage in its mainstream.

We're a nation of laws, not religion. The latter need have no effect on the former other than to be a good moral example.

OTB
 
Actually...

lookingforitallthetime said:
Whether a religion endorses it or not is not the point. Unless you're saying no gay people are religious?


...that is EXACTLY the point. But again, if you don't subscribe, you probably won't get it, so there is no point in trying to explain.
 
MLAM said:
...there is nothing I could say to you that would explain it sufficiently for you...so accordingly I won't.

The over arching point is that the American people got what they wanted...marriage recognized as ONLY being between a man and a woman.

what is your religion?

The majority got what they wanted and its wrong
 
MLAM said:
...that is EXACTLY the point. But again, if you don't subscribe, you probably won't get it, so there is no point in trying to explain.

I'm not religious but was brought up Catholic, so you're probably right.

I will never understand why Christian religions have become so exclusive. Jesus Christ never judged or excluded anyone.
 
I never said...

onthebottom said:
We're a nation of laws, not religion. The latter need have no effect on the former other than to be a good moral example.

OTB


..there was a legal defense for the standing. I am explaining why the American people did not go for it. Americans believe that marriage is defined ONLY as between a man and a woman....and this belief is rooted in their Judo-Christian values.

This would also be the reason why polygamy is not legal in the U.S., nor is prostitution, and a host of other "laws" that have no "rational" defense beyond the legislation of morality.

Had not gays tried to force change onto the American people...they would have easily received what was critically important - all the RIGHTS of married couples. But...that was not enough...what they wanted was to say "Nah Nay...I'm married too...I'm married too...so you have to accept my relationship as being morally on par with yours"

And the American people said...."No I do not".

I am certain that one day this will change, just as many other things have. But the gay community probably delayed that change by at least a generation...20 or so years....until the current 18-29 voting block becomes the majority and also hold most of the financial and political power in the nation. Until then...the American people didn't care to have their beliefs mocked, so they changed the law to protect them.
 
I would call neither...

red said:
United Church of Canada.
United Church of Christ.


...mainstream. Those are splitters of Christianity...which CLEARLY rejects homosexuality.
 
They don't think so...

red said:
what is your religion?

The majority got what they wanted and its wrong


...and thanks to it still being a democracy...the majority rules.
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
I will never understand why Christian religions have become so exclusive. Jesus Christ never judged or excluded anyone.

But he will:

I believe in God, the Father Almighty,
creator of heaven and earth.
I believe in Jesus Christ, his only Son, our Lord.
He was conceived by the power of the Holy Spirit
and born of the Virgin Mary.
He suffered under Pontius Pilate,
was crucified, died, and was buried.
He descended to the dead.
On the third day He rose again.
He ascended into heaven
and is seated at the right hand of the Father.
He will come again to judge the living and the dead.
I believe in the Holy Spirit,
the Holy Catholic Church,
the communion of Saints,
the forgiveness of sins,
the resurrection of the body,
and the life everlasting. AMEN.
 
I....

onthebottom said:
I think it's a separate but equal issue, it's always more separate than equal.

OTB


...disagree.

No one (well...no one in the mainstream...their are right wing nut jobs everywhere) argued against homosexuals having access to any and all the same rights and institutions as heterosexuals. The point of civil unions was to grant ALL of the same legal standing to gay couples that married couples enjoy.

The reason for it being separate however was that the majority of Americans do not wish to change the definition of marriage...while a minority did.