Interesting logic and values taking into consideration the massive depreciation hit you took on your 2008 car and when you drove your 2010 (already a model year old) off the lot.
We place more value on our "new" car than operating what we have. And we will always find ways to justify what we want.
Not sure I'm following you. From Car A to Car B I moved up to a better car, my monthly pmts went up $4.34, my insurance went DOWN by $250/yr and I didn't put a penny out of my pocket to do so. Other than not getting full value out of my tires what financial error did I make?

