They need a good clean-up hitter to insert some power into the middle of their lineup. Short-term, I think Schneider needs to re-jig the lineup. I think a little less so since Springer has started to hit lately but still, remember when Schneider dropped Bo down the order last August.
Bo got the message and went on a tear in September which has continued through to this season, and returned to the top of the order. I think Belt and Vladdy Jr. need to be separated in the order as they are not the quickest base runners and Merrifield is hitting 20 points better than Springer. Also, Springer hits more power than Merrifield, so putting Whit in leadoff and Springer between Belt and Vladdy Jr. would make sense.
Finally, Springer is now alone in second for most leadoff homers and won't catch Ricky Henderson, so he's not owed anything (if he ever was as it's a team sport). Remember, every leadoff home run is only a solo homer.
So, after this post I was thinking about what "my order" would look like. I know batting average is no longer the best indicator in the age of analytics, but I'm old school and I still think batting average tells a whole heck of a lot (and don't really understand all the new analytics - I'm a simple guy).
Leadoff - Whit Merrifield - Batting Average .288
2nd - Bo Bichette - Batting Average .319, top of the AL in hits
3rd - Brendon Belt - He's on the team so you have to use him, and at least he strikes out vs. hitting into double plays which Vladdy leads the league in doing.
4th - George Springer to clean it all up.
5th - Vladdy - He hits well with runners in scoring position, and because all his double play balls don't factor in when the runners are on 2nd, or 3rd vs. 1st. If he wants to hit 3rd again he will have have to earn it through hitting more effectively.
6th - Chapman - Because where else are you going to put him.
7th - Jano - He can clean-up anyone who's left on base, has clutch hitting and some power, and he's not the worst hitter in the lineup. Sub Kirk in for when he's catching, or swap him with Varsho if someone (that's Varsho) needs a "cookie".
8th - Varsho - He's a great defender, but not hitting well (.213) so he gets the worst hitter spot (unless he swaps with 7th when Kirk is catching).
9th - Kiermaier - A .275 hitter to get on base for when the lineup flips to the top of the order.
There you go Blue Jays. I'm going to sit back and wait for my cheque.