I meant controlled fires every year to get rid of the buildup of tinder, not backfires
My point is, there should be no trees within a kilometer of the town. It is called a firebreak. Now turn that area into meadow or park or whatever, the main point is no trees! The cost to build this firebreak is pennies. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS BULLDOZE THE FUCKING TREES! With the fire stopped so far away few embers would reach the houses, that along with fire resistant roofs would stop disaster, no???
"Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing is if there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that, the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off."
They should have been proactive
To build a town for workers that you will make billions and billions from and not consider such obvious "acts of god" and then provide proactive solutions that will cost pennies is criminal negligence
Am I wrong?
1- they do do controlled fire burns every year. How can someone predict exactly where the next fire will break out?? Again Fort Mac is surrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres of wilderness. There is fire control done all across the province (and country) every year.....they missed the spot the fire started this year.....who knows maybe they prevented it in the past but nobody would ever know because one cannot predicted what didn't happen and there is no way in hell that anyone could ever manage 1000s and 1000s of wilderness
2- No trees within a kilometer of town?? So you suggest that every little town across Canada should level the trees for one kilometer around their city?? Do you not understand what that would take?? Where do you draw the line on "city" in some cottage areas and in Fort Mac sure there is a city "boundry" however people spread past that. Just look at Northern Ontario cottage country. If a fire like the one at Fort Mac breaks out then there is going to be a lot of lost cottages and there is no way you could cut all the trees down around them
If you refer to only Fort Mac then 1- why single them out?? I am sure there are the same hazards around many northern towns (and logging communities, mining communities etc) can't single out only one of them and 2- the terrain around Fort Mac is not just flat land it is rough bedrock with many steep and drop off areas.
3- even if you could bulldoze one kilometer around a town there would be no real effect and it would not cost pennies. Meadows, golf courses etc have grass, trees, and other tinder in them there is no way it would stop a fire seen in Fort Mac.
And the brush grows back quickly. It would be a constant maintenance or yearly expense. You would need a full time crew pretty much all summer long removing brush
And even if cost was not an issue just factor in something as simple as environmental concerns. The Tar Sands already have a bad rep for ripping out the trees, up rooting wildlife, tailings, polluted holding ponds, greenhouse gas emission etc etc etc etc. Just image adding in bulldozing the wilderness
4- again you mention resistant roofs however again you don't seem to understand what resistant means
Commercial buildings do have resistant roofs- they meet Canadian and Alberta Building codes and standards
Residencial are no different from any other home across the country...again why should Fort Mac be single out from another town or city. The cost of housing is (or at least was) already out of control why should they be singled out and expected to add more cost to their homes?
And again RESISTANT is the key word......resistant means rated to withstand "normal" fire conditions (a house/ business/ office etc fire) long enough to evacuate the building and start fighting the fires. You don't seem to understand how big and out of control the fires in Fort Mac are. Fire resistant means fuck all when a fire that size is coming at a house
5- How could the oil companies been "more proactive"???
I have never heard of anyone talking about a fire this size raging through Fort Mac. Nobody ever seemed to have taken it into consideration.....it is easy to be Monday morning quarterback and say "you could have...should have.....would have"
And why should Fort Mac companies be singled out anyway?? I don't see logging towns, mining towns, tourist/ cottage towns that are spread out all across Canada taking any or being forced to take any precautions...in fact their lack of doing anything seems to indicate what I stated....nobody seems to consider it (at least to that extent)
And there was some precaution as stated in point 1 above....they do prevention burns, they do advise on dry days no camp fire days, forest fire prevention ads etc etc etc however again you don't seem to understand just how big the fires are, how big the wilderness is, how dry and hot the weather is and how fast the fires spread
6- "Am I wrong"- in some ways yes or maybe.....I would say not as informed as you could be. Understand how truely big those fires are, how dry and hot the climate is, how fast it spread, how big the wilderness is around it (or how much flamable material there really is available) etc etc etc.