Ft.McMurray is burning.......

off the top of my head


1 The army should be ready to go in hours not days, for all possible mmcontingences. I do not believe they know WTF to do

2 Why have they not controlled growth with smaller fires?

3 As fires spread form treetop to treetop, why are not the towns surrounded by cow pasture, golf courses, farming fields, meadows etc to stop the fires from tossing their embers into the towns ?

4 Why are not fire resistant roofs mandatory?

5 Why has not the government or oil companies been proactive?

6 Too late now

Because everyone was too busy making and enjoying money to worry about the future. Plus, once an economy tanks, usually the liberals are voted in to beef up social programs for all the people that worked hard to make the previous (conservative) government rich. It's just really odd how perfect the timing was when Harper was ousted and then the Alberta economy tanked. Basically his parting gift to JT was a shit Alberta economy and oil sands that aren't going to be profitable for another 5-10 yrs
 
off the top of my head


1 The army should be ready to go in hours not days, for all possible mmcontingences. I do not believe they know WTF to do

2 Why have they not controlled growth with smaller fires?

3 As fires spread form treetop to treetop, why are not the towns surrounded by cow pasture, golf courses, farming fields, meadows etc to stop the fires from tossing their embers into the towns ?

4 Why are not fire resistant roofs mandatory?

5 Why has not the government or oil companies been proactive?

6 Too late now

Huh??

1- even if the army was ready in hours what would they be able to do?? Fire is too far out of control for anyone to do much of anything

2- the place is surrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres of dry tinder, trees, leaves etc- starting small fires would only make the big fire bigger

3- there may be no demand for a golf course (or at least so many that they surround the entire town) in Fort Mac....why build useless things like empty non used golf courses as a source of fire prevention??. It is doubtful Fort Mac is a good place to raise cows...I am not a farmer however weather and terrain in Fort Mac would suggest raising cows there may be difficult....also it may not be profitable or any demand for farmers to be there (it is an oil town not a farm town) and alot of meadows form naturally...putting in meadows would have challenges....the entire town is sorrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres on bedrock
However your question seem pointless....all the places you mention would have trees, leaves, dry grass etc. There is no way a golf course or meadow (full of grass etc) would stop that fire.
Your question seems to indicate you have never been to a northern town or city.

4- Fire resistant roofs cost money....housing prices were already way out of control in Fort Mac...why add to the cost? Fire resistant roofs are not mandatory anywhere for residential homes (as far as I know) why single out Fort Mac. As far as commercial buildings are concerned I believe they do have some form of fire resistant roof (some coating) that follows Alberta and Canada building codes/ standards.
However even if fire resistant roofs were installed it would be pointless....key word is RESISTANT they are not fire proof. Fire resistant roofs are only rated to stop fire for a set period of time....enough time to evacuate the building and try to fight the fires. There is no way in hell a fire resistant roof is stopping those fires

5- what can the govt or oil companies do. The answer to your question is the same as question 1...what can the army do.....answer is nothing

6- yes it is too late.....kind of answers question 5 what is everyone doing....they are evacuating and providing shelter.
 
2- the place is surrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres of dry tinder, trees, leaves etc- starting small fires would only make the big fire bigger

Actually, starting smaller fires in advance of the big fire to burn the fuel away is a very legitimate and commonly used tactic to tackle this kind of situation.
Thanks for showing up though.
 
off the top of my head

Why are not fire resistant roofs mandatory?

4- Fire resistant roofs cost money....housing prices were already way out of control in Fort Mac...why add to the cost? Fire resistant roofs are not mandatory anywhere for residential homes (as far as I know) why single out Fort Mac. As far as commercial buildings are concerned I believe they do have some form of fire resistant roof (some coating) that follows Alberta and Canada building codes/ standards.
However even if fire resistant roofs were installed it would be pointless....key word is RESISTANT they are not fire proof. Fire resistant roofs are only rated to stop fire for a set period of time....enough time to evacuate the building and try to fight the fires. There is no way in hell a fire resistant roof is stopping those fires


Actually you can use steel panels for roofs instead of shingles . They look pretty good and you can get all sorts of colours. Many roofs are done that way in the Northern Bush of Ontario . People who build a cottage , cabin or homes use steel roofing . It is not that much more expensive than asphalt shingles and it last at least 5 times longer than asphalt shingles . How many years does an asphalt shingled roof last. Lucky if you get 15 years . Steel roofing panels , at least 50 years . You would have to replace your asphalt shingles at least 3x before you would steel roofing . The original cost of the steel roofing would be made up in years by not having to shingle your roof every 15 or 20 years .

Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing ??? If there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off the roof . No heavy build up of snow to contend with during the winter months.
 
Actually you can use steel panels for roofs instead of shingles . They look pretty good and you can get all sorts of colours. Many roofs are done that way in the Northern Bush of Ontario . People who build a cottage , cabin or homes use steel roofing . It is not that much more expensive than asphalt shingles and it last at least 5 times longer than asphalt shingles . How many years does an asphalt shingled roof last. Lucky if you get 15 years . Steel roofing panels , at least 50 years . You would have to replace your asphalt shingles at least 3x before you would steel roofing . The original cost of the steel roofing would be made up in years by not having to shingle your roof every 15 or 20 years .

Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing ??? If there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off the roof . No heavy build up of snow to contend with during the winter months.

Problem is, how many people plan on spending more than 15 years in a house?
If I need to change my roof, I'm much less likely to spend the extra money for a 50 year roof when I don't plan on staying there for more than a decade or so.
Doesn't really add much to resale value either.
If it is your forever home, I get it... otherwise, it makes much less sense.
And from what I hear anecdotaly, steel roofs are very loud when there is rain.
 
Actually you can use steel panels for roofs instead of shingles . They look pretty good and you can get all sorts of colours. Many roofs are done that way in the Northern Bush of Ontario . People who build a cottage , cabin or homes use steel roofing . It is not that much more expensive than asphalt shingles and it last at least 5 times longer than asphalt shingles . How many years does an asphalt shingled roof last. Lucky if you get 15 years . Steel roofing panels , at least 50 years . You would have to replace your asphalt shingles at least 3x before you would steel roofing . The original cost of the steel roofing would be made up in years by not having to shingle your roof every 15 or 20 years .

Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing ??? If there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off the roof . No heavy build up of snow to contend with during the winter months.

sure it may protect from embers. But it sure is not going to stop fires like the ones seen in Fort Mac. That is not embers it is a raging inferno.
 
Actually, starting smaller fires in advance of the big fire to burn the fuel away is a very legitimate and commonly used tactic to tackle this kind of situation.
Thanks for showing up though.

I don't disagree that starting fires ahead of a fire is used to help try and stop the larger fire. Where you going to start these small fires in Fort Mac?? The fire is in the city-- start burning down people's houses to stop the fire?? Also the size of the fires in Fort Mac are out of control. If starting small fires were the best way to have stopped the fires then logic would make you think that the professional firefighters in Fort Mac that are trained in these situations would have started small fires instead of letting half their city burn down. Thanks for showing up though.
 
So my wife calls me at work today and says"A logging truck was involved in a head on collision and caught on fire and now it has caught the forest on fire just outside Lac la biche. We're evacuating one of our camps and they are evacuating the heartland reserve". "The chief refused to leave until his animals were able to taken with him.....his animals? 30 bison he kept on his agreage" " They are in trucks in a parking lot in Bonnyville. My boss just told me to find a place to put them:("...............................and hows all your nights going?:)

http://edmontonjournal.com/news/loc...ern-alberta-crash-that-closes-highway-stretch
 

She recanted her statement:

“Some reports have suggested that the wildfires are directly caused by climate change. No credible climate scientist would make this claim, and neither do I make this claim. Rather, we must turn our minds in the coming days to the impact of increased extreme climate events, and what we can do collectively to respond to these events."

http://www.nationalobserver.com/201...ated-global-climate-crisis-says-elizabeth-may


 
The hamlet of Anzac is being evacuated along with a camp they had set up there for Ft Mac Folks.They just got their 10 minute warning.Looks like this area will burn also.....
 
Im sure this is unrelated but weird nonetheless...

A former Mayerthorpe mayor says he remains supportive of his firefighter son, who faces 18 counts of arson for a spree of major fires he allegedly started in the Alberta town.
The charges against 19-year-old Lawson Schalm are related to numerous suspicious fires in the area that began on April 19, including a massive one that destroyed the CN trestle bridge.
On Sunday, Mayerthorpe fire Chief Randy Schroeder confirmed Schalm was one of the volunteer firefighters called to actively battle that fire, as well as four other fires during the course of the spree.
http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/...nds-son-accused-of-arson-in-cn-fire-1.3561417
 
She recanted her statement:

“Some reports have suggested that the wildfires are directly caused by climate change. No credible climate scientist would make this claim, and neither do I make this claim. Rather, we must turn our minds in the coming days to the impact of increased extreme climate events, and what we can do collectively to respond to these events."

http://www.nationalobserver.com/201...ated-global-climate-crisis-says-elizabeth-may



That's not recanting, that's the same statement.
Extreme weather lead to hotter temperatures, more pine beetles, more dry forests and more conditions to forest fires.
But did it cause this one fire specifically?
We don't know, we don't have the specifics.

But we do know that we expect and are seeing more extreme weather events, including creating situations for more forest fires.
http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warmin...global-warming-and-wildfire.html#.VyrJH6MrJE4
http://www.macleans.ca/society/science/did-climate-change-contribute-to-the-fort-mcmurray-fire/
 
That's not recanting, that's the same statement.

The "recant" was issued well after her "Of course" statement.

May is just another lawyer turned politician. It was not scientific of her, and the bigger issue is it looked like political opportunism based on a horrible tragedy still in progress.
Either way, she is an idiot.
 
That's not recanting, that's the same statement.
Extreme weather lead to hotter temperatures, more pine beetles, more dry forests and more conditions to forest fires.
But did it cause this one fire specifically?
We don't know, we don't have the specifics.

But we do know that we expect and are seeing more extreme weather events, including creating situations for more forest fires.
http://www.ucsusa.org/global_warmin...global-warming-and-wildfire.html#.VyrJH6MrJE4
http://www.macleans.ca/society/science/did-climate-change-contribute-to-the-fort-mcmurray-fire/

Frank please, let's try and save your climate cult religion comments for the 'other' climate threads ok
 
Evacuation order for Lac Ste. Anne County has been lifted. Hundreds can now return home.
http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/...rder-for-lac-ste-anne-county-lifted-1.3566724

More pictures of Ft.McMurray
image.jpg
 
You can't mess with Mother Nature.

Ice storm in Quebec. Floods in Manitoba. Some of us might remember our own ice storm 2-3 years ago when power was out for days for some people. Now, fires in Alberta and B.C.
 
Hey. I just donated $75 to the Red Cross. I was going to spend it on "You know what", but that idea went up in smoke. Sorry, couldn't resist. I really did donate, though. Anybody else up for the challenge? The government is going to match. So, you give them more of your money, but you get a tax deduction, at least.