Canada Wildfires Irk Some Repugnicans

niniveh

Well-known member
Jun 8, 2009
2,322
1,382
113
Michigan lawmakers press Carney on poor air quality from wildfire smoke
London, ont.
The Canadian Press
Published Yesterday
Open this photo in gallery:

A woman bikes along the waterfront in Toronto as wildfire smoke fills the city on Wednesday.Laura Proctor/The Canadian Press
202 Comments

05:04
1x
Some U.S. lawmakers on Thursday threatened to sanction Canada – or even possibly annex it entirely – as they raged about wildfire smoke blanketing many parts of Canada and swaths of the United States.
Dozens of fires burning in northern Ontario have forced people from their communities and destroyed homes in Namaygoosisagagun First Nation north of Thunder Bay. Smoke from those fires is causing air quality warnings including across Ontario, and in multiple states including Michigan, Ohio, Illinois, New York and Indiana.
“Hey Canada, ‘just let it burn’ is not a solution. Unless you want to become the 51st state, learn to manage your forests,” Aric Nesbitt, a Republican state senator in Michigan, said in an online post.
Ohio Sen. Bernie Moreno said in a post he will introduce a bill next week “to sanction Canada and the responsible Canadian government officials for this atrocity.”
Four Republican members of Congress in Michigan called on Canada to act on the smoke Wednesday, saying their patience has run out.
“We are done accepting apologies in place of action. If Canada will not manage its forests to prevent these fires, the United States will look elsewhere, and act on our own, to protect our people,” they said in an open letter to Carney.
Wildfire smoke from Ontario, northern Minnesota turns air hazardous in the U.S. Midwest
Asked about the U.S. criticism during a Thursday news conference in London, Ont., Carney brushed it off. He said Canada is pursuing investments in clean energy, while the U.S. is actively working against clean energy.
“Fighting climate change is the responsibility of all countries, including the United States,” Carney said in French.
U.S. environmental group BlueGreen Alliance this week said President Donald Trump’s policies have cancelled or delayed 139 clean energy and industrial projects worth almost US$31 billion.
Carney was forced to defend his own government’s record on the environment Thursday.


In a video posted in late June, the prime minister acknowledged that his policies will lead to higher greenhouse gas emissions than had been forecast under his predecessor. He insisted Canada needs to balance resource projects – including a new pipeline – with environmental investments.
Responding to reporters’ questions Thursday, Carney said the government is taking an investment-driven approach, which includes plans to double the size of Canada’s electricity grid. He told reporters his government is building preconditions to reduce climate-altering carbon emissions into investments like the new pipeline agreement with Alberta.
“What you see is the investments or the major projects that we’re helping to catalyze are low-carbon,” he said.
Carney said Canada has “relied too much on targets, laws, that weren’t driving the actual investment that’s necessary to reduce emissions. So we’ve shifted our focus.”
He said his government’s climate strategy is focused on affordability in the short term. “We have amongst the lowest electricity costs in the world. We want to keep those,” Carney said.
Fires across northwestern Ontario force evacuations, trigger air quality warnings
In their letter, the four members of Congress said their constituents in Michigan were living under air quality alerts.
“Our hospitals are once again treating children, dialysis patients, and older residents for the effects of smoke that did not originate anywhere near them,” the letter said.
“This is the third consecutive year we have had to write to Canadian officials about a crisis that Canada has the tools to prevent and has chosen not to.”
One of those members of Congress, John James, wrote in a post Thursday: “FINAL WARNING TO CANADA: Manage your forests to prevent these fires. American lungs are paying the price for Canadian inaction, year after year.”
He followed that up with another post later in the day saying that it “smells like Baghdad outside.”
The United States is grappling with its own fires this season. The National Interagency Fire Center says 39,764 fires have burned more than 3.67 million acres.
“Firefighters continue responding to incidents from Minnesota to the Pacific Northwest, Great Basin and Rocky Mountain areas,” the centre said Thursday.
A 56-year-old Canadian helicopter pilot from British Columbia died on July 12 when the aircraft he was piloting crashed while he was helping to fight fires in Colorado.
 
I find it endlessly hilarious when people who have no clue what's involved with "putting out" fires of this magnitude. Water bombers don't work as the fires are burning so hot the water vaporizes before it even hits the ground. It's almost impossible to put enough men on the ground to create a fire break ahead as there is little, if any, infrastructure up there that would support such an endeavor and even if there were your fire break would need to be damn near 10km wide as sparks from the fire that's burning behind it can easily travel several kms and start another fire.

Then there's the fact that the smoke from these fires are creating lightning storms in the area that are lighting more fires.... it's just a perfect storm of dry conditions, location and atmospheric conditions. Fact is there's no putting these fires out till they run out of fuel to burn. The good news is that they are buring towards Lake Nipigon and once they hit the lake there's a good chance for fire fighters to be able to do something productive at that point but the bad news is there's gonna be a lot more poor air quality a head of us and several communities in that area will be burnt to ashes
 
The wildfires to bring into question our carbon reduction efforts. In 2023 1 gigaton of carbon was released by wildfires in Canada. Pathways will cost 20-30B and will at most sequester 16m tons a year. So it will take 62.5 years just to offset the 2023 release. Can that 30B be better spent on forestry to reduce carbon emissions?
 
Trump should call out ICE to kill the smoke and deport.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: mjg1 and jalimon
yip, it was reported that the wildfire smoke blowing into the US was reduced significantly. It was due to the FN hot air that was coming out of the US politicians big yaks including their PEDO leader.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mjg1
most wild fires are man made
 
I find it endlessly hilarious when people who have no clue what's involved with "putting out" fires of this magnitude. Water bombers don't work as the fires are burning so hot the water vaporizes before it even hits the ground. It's almost impossible to put enough men on the ground to create a fire break ahead as there is little, if any, infrastructure up there that would support such an endeavor and even if there were your fire break would need to be damn near 10km wide as sparks from the fire that's burning behind it can easily travel several kms and start another fire.

Then there's the fact that the smoke from these fires are creating lightning storms in the area that are lighting more fires.... it's just a perfect storm of dry conditions, location and atmospheric conditions. Fact is there's no putting these fires out till they run out of fuel to burn. The good news is that they are buring towards Lake Nipigon and once they hit the lake there's a good chance for fire fighters to be able to do something productive at that point but the bad news is there's gonna be a lot more poor air quality a head of us and several communities in that area will be burnt to ashes

And this is still likely the coolest summer of the rest of our lives.
Its only going to get way, way worse.

 
If things are going to get "way worse" why are they allowing data centers to be built since they're incredibly environmentally destructive?
Funny how governments turn a blind eye to that isn't it?

Billionaires, you think they care about you?
They want data centres so they don't need you at all for anything anymore, to replace your jobs.

Same billionaires who became billionaires selling oil$gas causing climate change.
 
No, that's ridiculous.
Most of the fires are hundreds of Km from people.


Some are natural, most are man made. Per the old timers I know who used to be fire fighters in their youth, at lot of fires started in that part of North Western Ontario are done by first nations so they can be hired by the government to work the fires.

And this is still likely the coolest summer of the rest of our lives.
Its only going to get way, way worse.


This is bullshit. There are hundreds of forest fires every year. Most years they don't rage out of control because local conditions prevent such a thing from happening. This year was different because the conditions on the ground were perfect and the area that has burn hasn't had a major fire in over 50 years. 50 years of dead fall and standing trees equals a lot of fuel for a fire. Blaming this on climate change is retarded.
 
Some are natural, most are man made. Per the old timers I know who used to be fire fighters in their youth, at lot of fires started in that part of North Western Ontario are done by first nations so they can be hired by the government to work the fires.



This is bullshit. There are hundreds of forest fires every year. Most years they don't rage out of control because local conditions prevent such a thing from happening. This year was different because the conditions on the ground were perfect and the area that has burn hasn't had a major fire in over 50 years. 50 years of dead fall and standing trees equals a lot of fuel for a fire. Blaming this on climate change is retarded.
Does dressing as a fireman at your local gay bar actually qualify you as a fireman ? Just asking for a gay friend
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
Does dressing as a fireman at your local gay bar actually qualify you as a fireman ? Just asking for a gay friend

That's a question you should ask a homosexual. Wouldn't know. The geezers I know in some summers worked nearly 500 hours in three and a half months if it was a really bad season like this year is turning out to be
 
Some are natural, most are man made. Per the old timers I know who used to be fire fighters in their youth, at lot of fires started in that part of North Western Ontario are done by first nations so they can be hired by the government to work the fires.

What a ridiculous theory.


This is bullshit. There are hundreds of forest fires every year. Most years they don't rage out of control because local conditions prevent such a thing from happening. This year was different because the conditions on the ground were perfect and the area that has burn hasn't had a major fire in over 50 years. 50 years of dead fall and standing trees equals a lot of fuel for a fire. Blaming this on climate change is retarded.

Ignoring climate change is retarded. You really have to be totally clueless not to see it happening around yourself daily, to believe that scientists are lying or wrong or to think that its not going to totally screw over humanity for hundreds or thousands of years at this point.

 
What a ridiculous theory.




Ignoring climate change is retarded. You really have to be totally clueless not to see it happening around yourself daily, to believe that scientists are lying or wrong or to think that its not going to totally screw over humanity for hundreds or thousands of years at this point.


Nearly all of the First Nations reserves up in that area are only accessible by plane, they don't really have options as far as gainful employment are concerned so they do what they feel they must. It's also something they've been doing as a matter of forest management for millennia long before Europeans showed up here. Forest fires break up the canopy, clear out dead wood and allow for new growth to come up afterwards. In less than ten years the areas that are being devastated by fires today will be almost completely indistinguishable from the areas that were not

As for your bog standard Twitter brain climate change malarkey, the moment you actually look into what the scientists who study the planets climate you see that it's not as cut and dry as you so desperately wish it to be. The so called consensus is not there at all and that is largely driven by the fact that climate scientists do not full understand the how's and whys of the planets climate.

Of course you'll reach up your ass and pull out all kinds of twitter nonsense to support your dogma but the fact remains that forests in North America have been burning every summer since the glaciers receded at the end of the last ice age over ten thousand years ago and will continue to do so ten thousand years into the future.
 
Nearly all of the First Nations reserves up in that area are only accessible by plane, they don't really have options as far as gainful employment are concerned so they do what they feel they must. It's also something they've been doing as a matter of forest management for millennia long before Europeans showed up here. Forest fires break up the canopy, clear out dead wood and allow for new growth to come up afterwards. In less than ten years the areas that are being devastated by fires today will be almost completely indistinguishable from the areas that were not

As for your bog standard Twitter brain climate change malarkey, the moment you actually look into what the scientists who study the planets climate you see that it's not as cut and dry as you so desperately wish it to be. The so called consensus is not there at all and that is largely driven by the fact that climate scientists do not full understand the how's and whys of the planets climate.

Of course you'll reach up your ass and pull out all kinds of twitter nonsense to support your dogma but the fact remains that forests in North America have been burning every summer since the glaciers receded at the end of the last ice age over ten thousand years ago and will continue to do so ten thousand years into the future.

I see, so now indigenous tradition controlled burns have become arson for fire fighting jobs to you.
They do the same controlled burn ceremony at High Park now too, its pretty shitty to call those 'arson'.

Its also idiotic to see the world getting warmer every year and then declare that it won't change anything in the world around us, like drying out forests, increasing extreme weather or crop failure. Scientists have been warming us about this for more than 50 years now.

HNbZ0Y0WIAE8yay
 
I see, so now indigenous tradition controlled burns have become arson for fire fighting jobs to you.
They do the same controlled burn ceremony at High Park now too, its pretty shitty to call those 'arson'.

Its also idiotic to see the world getting warmer every year and then declare that it won't change anything in the world around us, like drying out forests, increasing extreme weather or crop failure. Scientists have been warming us about this for more than 50 years now.

HNbZ0Y0WIAE8yay

I never called it arson Frank you did, I merely pointed out that they are doing it and have been for a very very long time. Your shitty little graph also fails to point out several realities where global temperatures are concerned. Mainly the fact the the world was just coming out of a cold period (aka the little ice age) at the turn of the last century and the fact that the earth operates on time lines lasting centuries and millennia not the fleeting decades is humans live for
 
I never called it arson Frank you did, I merely pointed out that they are doing it and have been for a very very long time. Your shitty little graph also fails to point out several realities where global temperatures are concerned. Mainly the fact the the world was just coming out of a cold period (aka the little ice age) at the turn of the last century and the fact that the earth operates on time lines lasting centuries and millennia not the fleeting decades is humans live for

You claimed that indigenous traditional burns were to cause forest fires so that they'd get hired to put them out. That's one of the stupidest theories I've heard hear in a while, which is an impressive goal. Traditional burns are used to control the spread of fires by making fire breaks.

The little ice age theory is also really quite stupid, that was a European and not global event.

We've now had fires across North America, there have been fires in the Amazon, the UK, northern Europe and all across the globe. Here we've still got stupid right wingers like Doug Ford who cut fire fighting massively. All these fires and the rise in ocean temps mean that they are no longer as effective as carbon sinks, which means CO2 rates are going rise even more.


 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer