Ft.McMurray is burning.......

Has anyone here, or in the media, mentioned that it could be arson, due to the oil industry tanking and the houses being severely devalued?
 
 
Huh??

the place is surrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres of dry tinder, trees, leaves etc- starting small fires would only make the big fire bigger.


I meant controlled fires every year to get rid of the buildup of tinder, not backfires

3- there may be no demand for a golf course (or at least so many that they surround the entire town) in Fort Mac....why build useless things like empty non used golf courses as a source of fire prevention??. It is doubtful Fort Mac is a good place to raise cows...I am not a farmer however weather and terrain in Fort Mac would suggest raising cows there may be difficult....also it may not be profitable or any demand for farmers to be there (it is an oil town not a farm town) and alot of meadows form naturally...putting in meadows would have challenges....the entire town is sorrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres on bedrock
However your question seem pointless....all the places you mention would have trees, leaves, dry grass etc. There is no way a golf course or meadow (full of grass etc) would stop that fire.
Your question seems to indicate you have never been to a northern town or city.

4- Fire resistant roofs cost money....housing prices were already way out of control in Fort Mac...why add to the cost? Fire resistant roofs are not mandatory anywhere for residential homes (as far as I know) why single out Fort Mac. As far as commercial buildings are concerned I believe they do have some form of fire resistant roof (some coating) that follows Alberta and Canada building codes/ standards.
However even if fire resistant roofs were installed it would be pointless....key word is RESISTANT they are not fire proof. Fire resistant roofs are only rated to stop fire for a set period of time....enough time to evacuate the building and try to fight the fires. There is no way in hell a fire resistant roof is stopping those fires


6- yes it is too late.....kind of answers question 5 what is everyone doing....they are evacuating and providing shelter.



My point is, there should be no trees within a kilometer of the town. It is called a firebreak. Now turn that area into meadow or park or whatever, the main point is no trees! The cost to build this firebreak is pennies. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS BULLDOZE THE FUCKING TREES! With the fire stopped so far away few embers would reach the houses, that along with fire resistant roofs would stop disaster, no???

"Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing is if there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that, the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off."

5- what can the govt or oil companies do. The answer to your question is the same as question 1...what can the army do.....answer is nothing .

They should have been proactive

To build a town for workers that you will make billions and billions from and not consider such obvious "acts of god" and then provide proactive solutions that will cost pennies is criminal negligence


Am I wrong?
 
I meant controlled fires every year to get rid of the buildup of tinder, not backfires





My point is, there should be no trees within a kilometer of the town. It is called a firebreak. Now turn that area into meadow or park or whatever, the main point is no trees! The cost to build this firebreak is pennies. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS BULLDOZE THE FUCKING TREES! With the fire stopped so far away few embers would reach the houses, that along with fire resistant roofs would stop disaster, no???

"Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing is if there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that, the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off."



They should have been proactive

To build a town for workers that you will make billions and billions from and not consider such obvious "acts of god" and then provide proactive solutions that will cost pennies is criminal negligence


Am I wrong?

1- they do do controlled fire burns every year. How can someone predict exactly where the next fire will break out?? Again Fort Mac is surrounded by 1000s and 1000s of acres of wilderness. There is fire control done all across the province (and country) every year.....they missed the spot the fire started this year.....who knows maybe they prevented it in the past but nobody would ever know because one cannot predicted what didn't happen and there is no way in hell that anyone could ever manage 1000s and 1000s of wilderness

2- No trees within a kilometer of town?? So you suggest that every little town across Canada should level the trees for one kilometer around their city?? Do you not understand what that would take?? Where do you draw the line on "city" in some cottage areas and in Fort Mac sure there is a city "boundry" however people spread past that. Just look at Northern Ontario cottage country. If a fire like the one at Fort Mac breaks out then there is going to be a lot of lost cottages and there is no way you could cut all the trees down around them
If you refer to only Fort Mac then 1- why single them out?? I am sure there are the same hazards around many northern towns (and logging communities, mining communities etc) can't single out only one of them and 2- the terrain around Fort Mac is not just flat land it is rough bedrock with many steep and drop off areas.

3- even if you could bulldoze one kilometer around a town there would be no real effect and it would not cost pennies. Meadows, golf courses etc have grass, trees, and other tinder in them there is no way it would stop a fire seen in Fort Mac.
And the brush grows back quickly. It would be a constant maintenance or yearly expense. You would need a full time crew pretty much all summer long removing brush
And even if cost was not an issue just factor in something as simple as environmental concerns. The Tar Sands already have a bad rep for ripping out the trees, up rooting wildlife, tailings, polluted holding ponds, greenhouse gas emission etc etc etc etc. Just image adding in bulldozing the wilderness

4- again you mention resistant roofs however again you don't seem to understand what resistant means
Commercial buildings do have resistant roofs- they meet Canadian and Alberta Building codes and standards
Residencial are no different from any other home across the country...again why should Fort Mac be single out from another town or city. The cost of housing is (or at least was) already out of control why should they be singled out and expected to add more cost to their homes?
And again RESISTANT is the key word......resistant means rated to withstand "normal" fire conditions (a house/ business/ office etc fire) long enough to evacuate the building and start fighting the fires. You don't seem to understand how big and out of control the fires in Fort Mac are. Fire resistant means fuck all when a fire that size is coming at a house

5- How could the oil companies been "more proactive"???
I have never heard of anyone talking about a fire this size raging through Fort Mac. Nobody ever seemed to have taken it into consideration.....it is easy to be Monday morning quarterback and say "you could have...should have.....would have"
And why should Fort Mac companies be singled out anyway?? I don't see logging towns, mining towns, tourist/ cottage towns that are spread out all across Canada taking any or being forced to take any precautions...in fact their lack of doing anything seems to indicate what I stated....nobody seems to consider it (at least to that extent)
And there was some precaution as stated in point 1 above....they do prevention burns, they do advise on dry days no camp fire days, forest fire prevention ads etc etc etc however again you don't seem to understand just how big the fires are, how big the wilderness is, how dry and hot the weather is and how fast the fires spread

6- "Am I wrong"- in some ways yes or maybe.....I would say not as informed as you could be. Understand how truely big those fires are, how dry and hot the climate is, how fast it spread, how big the wilderness is around it (or how much flamable material there really is available) etc etc etc.
 
Man, these videos are so sad. It's unbelievable to see lines of cars on a highway and big fires so close.

The lines moved so slowly too that lots of people ran out of gas trying to drive to another town.....so they had no choice but to just ditch the car at the side of the road.
 
She recanted her statement:

“Some reports have suggested that the wildfires are directly caused by climate change. No credible climate scientist would make this claim, and neither do I make this claim. Rather, we must turn our minds in the coming days to the impact of increased extreme climate events, and what we can do collectively to respond to these events."

http://www.nationalobserver.com/201...ated-global-climate-crisis-says-elizabeth-may




I think there's some correlation with the increased incidence of brush and forest fires to climate change though.

BTW, saw your post #32. I saw the news about that arsonist kid and volunteer firefighter.
 
I meant controlled fires every year to get rid of the buildup of tinder, not backfires





My point is, there should be no trees within a kilometer of the town. It is called a firebreak. Now turn that area into meadow or park or whatever, the main point is no trees! The cost to build this firebreak is pennies. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS BULLDOZE THE FUCKING TREES! With the fire stopped so far away few embers would reach the houses, that along with fire resistant roofs would stop disaster, no???

"Why many homes in the bush have steel roofing is if there is a fire the steel roofing would protect the structure from embers . Not only that, the snow doesn't stick to the roof . It just slides off."



They should have been proactive

To build a town for workers that you will make billions and billions from and not consider such obvious "acts of god" and then provide proactive solutions that will cost pennies is criminal negligence


Am I wrong?


I don't even know where to start!

It is clear that you have no real world experience away from your computer, outside your mom's basement least of all anywhere north of Highway 401.

The scale and size of the boreal forest in Canada is absolutely impossible to comprehend without both flying over it and hiking through it. And the power of a forest fire accelerated by wind is also impossible to comprehend without having some experience. When I was younger I "rode along" in a Jet Ranger working a forest fire for two days out of Chapleau. All we did was ferry in equipment, pumps, food, drinking water etc for the firefighters on the ground. But we landed real close to fires that were not even 5% as big as the ones in Ft Mac are and let me tell you, they are terrifyingly powerful . I also was on the ground when a couple of CL215 water bombers dropped water along the edge of the fire. Massive amount of water, yet was like spitting on a campfire.

And the scale of cutting down an acre of forest is also not comprehensible to someone who has never held a chainsaw, cut down trees in the bush, cleared brush and cleaned up the felled trees and branches etc.

Never mind clear cutting a couple hundred square kilometres to make a 1 km firebreak perimeter around the city. If you have ever been to Fort McMurray you might also realize what rough terrain there is there. Steep cliffs, steep river valleys, etc etc.

What are you gong to do with the underbrush, branches etc? Millions of cubic yards of it! It is ALL fuel for a fire if you just leave it on the ground.

I'm going to stop because it is just so preposterously ridiculous to address this. And, you will just come back wth some ridiculous argument founded in your weird way of thinking from behind the keyboard.

And Fort McMurray was NOT constructed by the oil industry as you understand it.

The oil industry has plants and facilities around the town, but the town itself has been there for a long time and simply has grown to service the oil industry and the people who now make it their home. They didn't build the houses or the hotels etc.
 
I don't even know where to start!

It is clear that you have no real world experience away from your computer, outside your mom's basement least of all anywhere north of Highway 401.

The scale and size of the boreal forest in Canada is absolutely impossible to comprehend without both flying over it and hiking through it. And the power of a forest fire accelerated by wind is also impossible to comprehend without having some experience. When I was younger I "rode along" in a Jet Ranger working a forest fire for two days out of Chapleau. All we did was ferry in equipment, pumps, food, drinking water etc for the firefighters on the ground. But we landed real close to fires that were not even 5% as big as the ones in Ft Mac are and let me tell you, they are terrifyingly powerful . I also was on the ground when a couple of CL215 water bombers dropped water along the edge of the fire. Massive amount of water, yet was like spitting on a campfire.

And the scale of cutting down an acre of forest is also not comprehensible to someone who has never held a chainsaw, cut down trees in the bush, cleared brush and cleaned up the felled trees and branches etc.

Never mind clear cutting a couple hundred square kilometres to make a 1 km firebreak perimeter around the city. If you have ever been to Fort McMurray you might also realize what rough terrain there is there. Steep cliffs, steep river valleys, etc etc.

What are you gong to do with the underbrush, branches etc? Millions of cubic yards of it! It is ALL fuel for a fire if you just leave it on the ground.

I'm going to stop because it is just so preposterously ridiculous to address this. And, you will just come back wth some ridiculous argument founded in your weird way of thinking from behind the keyboard.

And Fort McMurray was NOT constructed by the oil industry as you understand it.

The oil industry has plants and facilities around the town, but the town itself has been there for a long time and simply has grown to service the oil industry and the people who now make it their home. They didn't build the houses or the hotels etc.

Oh fuck off.


What I am doing is called brainstorming

This where you make suggestions, no matter how ridiculous, and from these suggestions quite often a practical idea can be created. It is done all the time by truly bright people

You do controlled burns, not clear cuts, to keep the underbrush from building up and feeding the fires

These burns are done around the world to keep fires under control when they occur and to protect wildlife


Perhaps they are not feasible in the Ft McMurray region, it is a suggestion (I never suggested you do controlled burns in the entire Boreal forrest)

It is not the underbrush that is the major problem anyways. It is the underbrush feeding the fires that burn the tress that is the issue. The trees burn and embers hop from tree top to tree top fed by winds that the fire itself creates. These embers land on structures and now the buildings catch fire. If there are no trees near the town then no embers are tossed by treetops to land on structures. Perhaps a firebreak of cleared trees from Fort McMurray is not feasible, as you mentioned the terrain would have a major influence on such a project, but considering the consequences of not building one. In such a case, partial clearings, where applicable, would ameliorate the fires effect. What I am suggesting is understanding the science of Boreal fires and creating counter measures to protect towns so I am brainstorming and appreciate reasoning to counter my layman speculation, insults are not required but insults are what you do best.

I do not believe you were a Jet Ranger


Of course Ft McMurray was not built by the oil companies, that is why it is called a Fort.




Brainstorming

Brainstorming is a group creativity technique by which efforts are made to find a conclusion for a specific problem by gathering a list of ideas spontaneously contributed by its members.

The number one rule is no idea is considered absurd because absurd ideas can often spark creativity and the absurd idea forms a modified idea that solves the problem
 
You have failed to reason why a firebreak of cleared trees, and underbrush, from around towns would not protect the settlements


Sure, such a firebreak f cleared trees and underbrush would dramatically reduce the risk of the town being burned. At least from wildfires that originate from outside the firebreak. But not from grassfires which can spread like "wildfire" too.

But the cost is not "pennies" to clearcut and maintain such a firebreak as you claim.

I know enough to know I have no idea how much it would cost to clearcut and then maintain hundreds of thousands of hectares of cleared land would be absolutely cost-prohibitive for any level of government. Just consider the cost of maintaining the ditches and shoulders along highways!
 
Of course Ft McMurray was not built by the oil companies, that is why it is called a Fort.


Well you were just whining about how the oil companies and gov't were "criminally negligent" not being proactive, and "to build a town for workers".




They should have been proactive

To build a town for workers that you will make billions and billions from and not consider such obvious "acts of god" and then provide proactive solutions that will cost pennies is criminal negligence


Am I wrong?
 
Well you were just whining about how the oil companies and gov't were "criminally negligent" not being proactive, and "to build a town for workers".

I spoke too quickly and should have been more precise

They took a town that had been built and expanded it and filled it with their workforce that they make billions in profit from

I feel they are now corporately responsible for considering the consequences of a once a century disaster ( like in New Orleans) and do all possible to create countermeasures

So, my question is did they behave is a corporately responsible fashion? This fire was going to happen ( as in New Orleans) it was just a matter of time and chance. Could they have done something proactive?

I feel the same way about Fukushima. New geological evidence demonstrated a once in 1000 year Tsunami would destroy the nuclear plants. They sat on this data for years hoping it would not occur.
 
I spoke to quickly and should have been more precise

They took a town that had been built and expanded it and filled with their workforce that they make billions in profit from

I feel they are now corporately responsible for considering the consequences of a once a century disaster ( like in New Orleans) and create countermeasures

So, my question is did they behave is a corporately responsible fashion? This fire was going to happen ( as in New Orleans) it was just a matter of time. Could they have done something proactive?


Who is "they"?

The oil companies?

Why should "they"be responsible for private homes and businesses and a city that is miles away from their remote locations?

"They" pay taxes for their operations and are responsible for their lands.

The government allocates those taxes as they see fit and as the budgets allow.

In this case, your Pie in the Sky keyboard fantasy of clearcutting firebreak perimeters around Fort McMurray (and by extension every city and small town in Canada) is so ludicrous and expensive as to not even warrant consideration by anyone with any perception of reality and cost/benefit/risk .
 
Paved a 1km circle around the city.
No trees, no underbrush, no fuel.

Sounds silly, doesn't it?


You know the fully thing is that YogaFace really does believe in his heart and mind that his is a serious proposal.

But without any sense of the enormity of such an undertaking, he thinks it would just cost "pennies".
 
Sure, such a firebreak f cleared trees and underbrush would dramatically reduce the risk of the town being burned. At least from wildfires that originate from outside the firebreak. But not from grassfires which can spread like "wildfire" too.

But the cost is not "pennies" to clearcut and maintain such a firebreak as you claim.

I know enough to know I have no idea how much it would cost to clearcut and then maintain hundreds of thousands of hectares of cleared land would be absolutely cost-prohibitive for any level of government. Just consider the cost of maintaining the ditches and shoulders along highways!

I do not consider grassfires to be a major issue, nor underbrush, as they do not toss embers hundreds of feet into the air that travel thousands of yards

So, a firebreak, or at least a partial firebreak where applicable, around a modest size town would involve hundreds of thousands of acres? Was such a study ever done? How expensive would such a study be for a company that made billions in profit?