Ft.McMurray is burning.......

What do u think a forrest fire emits? CO2 as it is burned fossil fuels. I would like to see some info on the CO2 emitted in this fire vs industry and cars. I suspect manmade pollution pales in comparison

Man-made pollution is incremental on top of the CO2 already produced naturally.
 
Man-made pollution is incremental on top of the CO2 already produced naturally.

I think the argument is this incremental addition is the tipping point

Considering the random nature and the massive CO2 produced in forrest fires, volcanoes ....
 
I think the argument is this incremental addition is the tipping point

Considering the random nature and the massive CO2 produced in forrest fires, volcanoes ....

This is why you can't really just look at a single year, but you need to look at the effects over a decade or longer, for all these natural effects to even out over time.

Not just the other sources of CO2 but many other factors influence temperature. The additional warming from human created greenhouse gas is a small incremental effect but it adds up over time.

Human caused global warming only adds 0.2 watts of additional heat per square meter per decade. But over the decades that is additive, after fifty years it's an additional watt of heat per square meter, etc.
 
could be over soon


30% chance of rain tomorrow, Tuesday ,Wednesday and thursday
 
I have no idea about fire science so I asked the question about a fire break

You did not "ask the question". Here are your exact words.

"My point is, there should be no trees within a kilometer of the town. It is called a firebreak. Now turn that area into meadow or park or whatever, the main point is no trees! The cost to build this firebreak is pennies. ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS BULLDOZE THE FUCKING TREES!"



Now that the Fire Chief has spoken I understand that embers can travel for kilometers. I have learned from the Chief, I learned nothing from you

Well that is a clear demonstration of your celebrating ignorance and being governed by your dislike of someone.



It was you who never knew the answer as to why a firebreak would not have worked in this case . I was asking the question

That firebreaks were seriously studied is proof my idea is an intelligent one, an idea that you dismissed with zero knowledge of the distance embers can travel and it is this extraordinary distance - that you had zero knowledge of - that makes firebreaks impractical but that is just in this extraordinary fire

Fire breaks do work , just not in " an extreme, rare, rare fire event. " which leads me back to my question, if this was a normal fire and not " an extreme, rare, rare fire event. " would a fire break have worked? Now that the trees are gone, will they create a firebreak by stopping regrowth? If not, why not?

Again, you just don't get it nor grasp the scale, power and unpredictability of forest fires.

To the best of my knowledge, there are NO settlements of any scale that have firebreaks. They are impractical. I won;t say they "don't work" because the variables are so enormous as to make the discussion moot. But I will say that forest fires jump across highways, rivers and lakes.

The science of fighting forest fires essentially comes down to having enough resources on hand to respond to, and control the initial fire within a day. Problem is that there are so many fires that it is not possible to fight every one. So they have to figure out where to deploy resources based on risks and consequences. IN the case of the Fort McMurray fire, the initial fire posed no danger to the city at first. Only when there was an unexpected change in the wind direction did it become a danger to Fort McMurray.

And that wind was so strong that no firebreak would have stopped it. Which is what I was saying from the beginning when I shot down your proclamation that "they" should bulldoze a 1km firebreak around the city for "pennies" and because they hadn't that the oil companies and governments were "criminally negligent". Your words, not mine.
 
You did not "ask the question". Here are your exact words.






Well that is a clear demonstration of your celebrating ignorance and being governed by your dislike of someone.





[/B]Again, you just don't get it nor grasp the scale, power and unpredictability of forest fires.

To the best of my knowledge, there are NO settlements of any scale that have firebreaks. They are impractical. I won;t say they "don't work" because the variables are so enormous as to make the discussion moot. But I will say that forest fires jump across highways, rivers and lakes.

The science of fighting forest fires essentially comes down to having enough resources on hand to respond to, and control the initial fire within a day. Problem is that there are so many fires that it is not possible to fight every one. So they have to figure out where to deploy resources based on risks and consequences. IN the case of the Fort McMurray fire, the initial fire posed no danger to the city at first. Only when there was an unexpected change in the wind direction did it become a danger to Fort McMurray.

And that wind was so strong that no firebreak would have stopped it. Which is what I was saying from the beginning when I shot down your proclamation that "they" should bulldoze a 1km firebreak around the city for "pennies" and because they hadn't that the oil companies and governments were "criminally negligent". Your words, not mine.


My proclamation that " companies and governments were criminally negligent" (as they were in New Orleans and Fukushima as both could have been prevented ) was meant to spark a discussion that would lead to answers, which it has. My utterance was not meant to be seen as a statement of fact. I should have formatted it in a question


It is hard to listen to someone who has such a proclivity to insult, but in retrospect, insults aside I have learned from you.

My lack of understanding that forest fires can leap such dramatic distances was my downfall and I now wonder what the science is behind such a phenomena

They are now considering serious proposals to stop Hurricanes and Tornadoes and global warming, no doubt some ingenious person is considering how science can stop forest fires in ways we do not imagine


Stopping regrowth around the city still sounds like a legitimate idea to be considered as the less trees near the city can only be a positive in future fires
 
Last edited:
This is not a typical forest fire. This fire "jumped" the Athabaska River - A 1 kilometre wide body of water. This fire is so intense it is creating its own weather patterns including lightning. This lightning is adding to the problems by igniting more fires- essentially spawning itself. This fire would not have been stopped by any man made fire break imaginable. Fire fighters can only hope to strategically save certain locations as it progresses. This fire is an absolute monster. Stop ur fucking bickering and go donate some $ instead of sounding like a bunch of whiny ass kids.
 
I don't think firefighters can save any locations. I think they are spectators. I think all they can realistically do is forecast where it's going to go and evacuate people before it gets there.
 
This forest fire in itself is nothing unusual. It's a common enough occurrence. It's only a major story because of its proximity to the town. Right now all we can do is to evacuate and wait for rain and/or change of wind direction, but in the future months we'll have a full story about who dropped the ball on this one. Things like the lack of brush control, expansion of new neighborhoods in a forest fire areas, etc. And while it's true that intense forest fires can cross rivers, lakes and highways, it is also true that they need fuel on the other side. And that's a land management issue that clearly been neglected in Ft. Mac.
 
This forest fire in itself is nothing unusual. It's a common enough occurrence. It's only a major story because of its proximity to the town. Right now all we can do is to evacuate and wait for rain and/or change of wind direction, but in the future months we'll have a full story about who dropped the ball on this one. Things like the lack of brush control, expansion of new neighborhoods in a forest fire areas, etc. And while it's true that intense forest fires can cross rivers, lakes and highways, it is also true that they need fuel on the other side. And that's a land management issue that clearly been neglected in Ft. Mac.

I thought so as well but have changed my mind

They did a thorough analysis after the slave lake fires and there was nothing they could do except correct evacuation procedures and no one has been killed as a result

This is not your normal forest fire, it is exceptionally rare

I suspect it is the size of the area that makes controlled burns impracticable, unsure

Concerning backfires it seems to me they just start another fire when no one is sure where the winds will direct the fires that exist so the fires may not even come

if they knew absolutely the fires would come to the town then maybe backfires would have made sense

I am unsure and would like to know the answer

Also, why not dump all the water on the trees surrounding the town instead of on the fires they cannot control so when the fires do come the trees are wet? This makes sense esp if the water has a fire retardant in it

the green area is the boreal forrest


th
 
Last edited:
This forest fire in itself is nothing unusual.

Really?

At the start of the fire, an unusually hot, dry air mass was in place over Northern Alberta, which brought record-setting temperatures to Fort McMurray. On May 3 the temperature climbed to 32.8 °C (91 °F),[37] accompanied by relative humidity as low as 12%.[38] The situation intensified on May 4 when temperatures reached 31.9 °C (89 °F)[37] and winds gusted to 72 km/h (45 mph).[39] This significantly contributed to the fire's rapid growth.[7] The winter preceding the fires was drier than usual, leaving a paltry snowpack, which melted quickly. Combined with the high temperatures, this created a "perfect storm" of conditions for an explosive wildfire.[40][41]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Fort_McMurray_wildfire#Cause_and_contributing_factors
 
According to Fort McMurray residents this Fire has been going on for weeks, and the FD asked for help but was denied!! It was only until the fire got real bad that any one hears about it. I wonder if this fire was started by the kid who was arrested end of April and was charged with 18 counts of arson!! Could this fire have been the residuals from the fires the kid started?????? I believe it's possible. Anyone else think it could be related?

Time will tell!

Incase anyone is interesting excerpt from the news story.


A former Mayerthorpe mayor says he remains supportive of his firefighter son, who faces 18 counts of arson for a spree of major fires he allegedly started in the Alberta town.
The charges against 19-year-old Lawson Schalm are related to numerous suspicious fires in the area that began on April 19, including a massive one that destroyed the CN trestle bridge.
On Sunday, Mayerthorpe fire Chief Randy Schroeder confirmed Schalm was one of the volunteer firefighters called to actively battle that fire, as well as four other fires during the course of the spree.
http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/e...fire-1.3561417

 

Give it a rest, already. Forest fires are extremely common in the North. Right after I came to Canada I worked in the logging industry in northern Ontario. There were some ferocious fires up there, but as long as they were away from a highway, nobody cared down south. The summer of 89(I think) was particularly bad- it was all hands on deck and all machines in the air- especially in Manitoba. This fire, while large, it's far from the earliest or the largest. Actually, there's nothing out of ordinary about it except the location.
 
Give it a rest, already. Forest fires are extremely common in the North. Right after I came to Canada I worked in the logging industry in northern Ontario. There were some ferocious fires up there, but as long as they were away from a highway, nobody cared down south. The summer of 89(I think) was particularly bad- it was all hands on deck and all machines in the air- especially in Manitoba. This fire, while large, it's far from the earliest or the largest. Actually, there's nothing out of ordinary about it except the location.

32ºC on May 4th.

El Nino helped dry out the land quite a bit and set the stage. But extreme temperatures like that in May are unusual, and forest fires of this size this early in the year are unusual.
http://cwfis.cfs.nrcan.gc.ca/ha/fwnormals?type=fwi&month=5
 



I know this is going to come as a shock but wildfires like the Miramichi fire that happened in New Brunswick and the Peshtigo fire in 1871 have occurred throughout history.

Scientists that specialize in climate say global average temperatures have risen only one degree and that if human activity is the culprit in rising temperatures, it would have only been significant starting from 1960. A degree in temperature increase is not “catastrophic” and the argument that climate change causes wildfires is flawed simply based on the fact that there have been more catastrophic events throughout time.

So, what did cause the fires?

It all started with El Nino, the appearance of unusually warm water off of Peru and Ecuador that causes complex changes in climate. It meant winter ended a month earlier in Alberta, causing higher than average temperatures. This in turn caused dry conditions that have provided ample fuel in the form of tinder dry forest fires.

A report released in 2012 also found that our forests are aging and much drier than 50 years ago. For Fort McMurray, it was one of those times where the elements for a wildfire were present – dry fuel, low humidity and high winds.
 
32ºC on May 4th.

El Nino helped dry out the land quite a bit and set the stage. But extreme temperatures like that in May are unusual, and forest fires of this size this early in the year are unusual.
http://cwfis.cfs.nrcan.gc.ca/ha/fwnormals?type=fwi&month=5

Back then it used to be called an unusually warm spring or unusually cold spring. Some years there were few fires, other years there were so many fires we run out of Indians . It's a reality of that part of Canada . Get out of your basement and take a trip; get to know your country.