MLB Free Agent Season

Nope.

January 14, 2001, the Blue Jays traded David Wells and Matt DeWitt to the White Sox for Kevin Beirne, Brian Simmons and Mike Sirotka. DeWitt and Simmons were re-traded for each other before the 2001 season, so it was effectively Wells for Beirne and Sirotka.

Wells had been acquired from the Yankees in February, 1999, with Homer Bush and Graeme Lloyd, for Roger Clemens, who had won the AL Cy Young Award in 1997 and 1998. Wells had won 37 games for the Blue Jays in 1999-2000, (including 20 in 2000), and he would go on to win 90 games in the Majors after this trade.

Kevin Beirne had a 12.86 ERA in 7 innings for the 2001 Blue Jays and was non-tendered after that season. Mike Sirotka was injured at the time of the trade, (but apparently not badly enough that he couldn't pass the Blue Jays physical), and never pitched again in professional baseball.

View attachment 401342

Left-handed starting pitcher Adam Macko is one of the Blue Jays' top 15 prospects, which isn't saying much. He was acquired with Erik Swanson from the Mariners in the Teoscar Hernandez trade. The Jays will have six years of club control, if and when Macko reaches the Majors; he's expected to start 2025 at AAA. If he pans out, this will end up being a great deal for the Jays, even if Swanson continues to suck.

What might ultimately be be worst trade in Blue Jays' history was the August 2, 2022 trade where the Jays sent
Nick Frasso, (a 6-5 starting pitcher, and a top 30 prospect of the Los Angeles Dodgers, injured all of 2024), for Mitch White, (0-6 with 7.50+ ERA in parts of two seasons with Toronto). I have a very high opinion of Fraaso, and we can all agree that Mitch White was dog shit.
When all is said and done the worst trade in Blue Jays history will be Moreno and Gurriel Jr. for Varsho. A Shatkins monstrosity.
 
Nope.

January 14, 2001, the Blue Jays traded David Wells and Matt DeWitt to the White Sox for Kevin Beirne, Brian Simmons and Mike Sirotka. DeWitt and Simmons were re-traded for each other before the 2001 season, so it was effectively Wells for Beirne and Sirotka.

Wells had been acquired from the Yankees in February, 1999, with Homer Bush and Graeme Lloyd, for Roger Clemens, who had won the AL Cy Young Award in 1997 and 1998. Wells had won 37 games for the Blue Jays in 1999-2000, (including 20 in 2000), and he would go on to win 90 games in the Majors after this trade.

Kevin Beirne had a 12.86 ERA in 7 innings for the 2001 Blue Jays and was non-tendered after that season. Mike Sirotka was injured at the time of the trade, (but apparently not badly enough that he couldn't pass the Blue Jays physical), and never pitched again in professional baseball.

View attachment 401342

Left-handed starting pitcher Adam Macko is one of the Blue Jays' top 15 prospects, which isn't saying much. He was acquired with Erik Swanson from the Mariners in the Teoscar Hernandez trade. The Jays will have six years of club control, if and when Macko reaches the Majors; he's expected to start 2025 at AAA. If he pans out, this will end up being a great deal for the Jays, even if Swanson continues to suck.

What might ultimately be be worst trade in Blue Jays' history was the August 2, 2022 trade where the Jays sent
Nick Frasso, (a 6-5 starting pitcher, and a top 30 prospect of the Los Angeles Dodgers, injured all of 2024), for Mitch White, (0-6 with 7.50+ ERA in parts of two seasons with Toronto). I have a very high opinion of Fraaso, and we can all agree that Mitch White was dog shit.

What on earth are you talking about? Lol. You definitely know your stuff but Adam Macko being a good deal if he pans out, is an extremely far stretch. Ross Atkins went off and dealt Hernandez during the apparent “window to win“ and Hernandez then goes off to win a World Series in Los Angeles…. extending Hernandez and keeping him in that lineup was the right move…. The wrong move was getting rid of the protection for Guerrero and the mentorship and the clubhouse chemistry. It was completely idiotic. I don’t care if Adam Macko becomes the number one prospect in the world. That trade was stupid and the average onlooker can see the unnecessary holes it created. After the 2022 season the Blue Jays were not in a the Blue Jays were not in a position to build with prospects. They were in the position to win and win now. And the timing of the deal couldn’t be worse. If you’re going off the anger fumes of the loss to Seattle in the playoffs, Teo was the only guy that showed up in the elimination game because he hit two bombs. Getting rid of him after that game was some mad man with ridiculous thoughts of what the problem was.

The Roger Clemens deal was horrible. However, the Blue Jays were getting bullied to make that move because Roger was demanding a trade. So unfortunately, they were kind of fishing to get whatever they could, but all the pressure in the world was on the Jays to send him to New York and shut up and take where they can get. The Yankees were such a juggernaut at that time they were able to bully like that.

When all is said and done the worst trade in Blue Jays history will be Moreno and Gurriel Jr. for Varsho. A Shatkins monstrosity.

This was a very bad one as well.

Philip
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
Nope.

January 14, 2001, the Blue Jays traded David Wells and Matt DeWitt to the White Sox for Kevin Beirne, Brian Simmons and Mike Sirotka. DeWitt and Simmons were re-traded for each other before the 2001 season, so it was effectively Wells for Beirne and Sirotka.

Wells had been acquired from the Yankees in February, 1999, with Homer Bush and Graeme Lloyd, for Roger Clemens, who had won the AL Cy Young Award in 1997 and 1998. Wells had won 37 games for the Blue Jays in 1999-2000, (including 20 in 2000), and he would go on to win 90 games in the Majors after this trade.

Kevin Beirne had a 12.86 ERA in 7 innings for the 2001 Blue Jays and was non-tendered after that season. Mike Sirotka was injured at the time of the trade, (but apparently not badly enough that he couldn't pass the Blue Jays physical), and never pitched again in professional baseball.

View attachment 401342

Left-handed starting pitcher Adam Macko is one of the Blue Jays' top 15 prospects, which isn't saying much. He was acquired with Erik Swanson from the Mariners in the Teoscar Hernandez trade. The Jays will have six years of club control, if and when Macko reaches the Majors; he's expected to start 2025 at AAA. If he pans out, this will end up being a great deal for the Jays, even if Swanson continues to suck.



6-0, 170lb's with a 4.87 ERA in AA last year...Yeah I don't know about this one.

Teoscar was a main cog in a world series winner...That's hard to beat.
 
I trust them as much as the "it's a process" BS from Shatkins.

The team has steadily declined year over year since 2021 and their developmental program has been pathetic. And it seems that they're prepared to let the only 2 good players that they've developed, Bo and Vlad, walk.
Best to trust Jeff Passan. He's usually bang on with his sources.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
Nope.

January 14, 2001, the Blue Jays traded David Wells and Matt DeWitt to the White Sox for Kevin Beirne, Brian Simmons and Mike Sirotka. DeWitt and Simmons were re-traded for each other before the 2001 season, so it was effectively Wells for Beirne and Sirotka.


If I remember correctly Sirotka had a torn labrum in his shoulder....That's a career ender in those days.

You have to wonder what Ash was thinking.

The Halliday trade was a stinker as well...So was the Shawn Green one.

On a positive not they raped my Yankees in getting Fred McGriff... Traded by the New York Yankees with Dave Collins, Mike Morgan and cash to the Toronto Blue Jays for Tom Dodd and Dale Murray....I mean this one is terrible for the Yanks,lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76

6-0, 170lb's with a 4.87 ERA in AA last year...Yeah I don't know about this one.

Teoscar was a main cog in a world series winner...That's hard to beat.

I didn’t even look up his stats. Yeah Hernandez winning the World Series with the Dodgers when he could’ve been extended by the Blue Jays, is that automatic winner in the shittiest trade in team history imho. However, obtaining him in the first place was actually a great move for Ross Atkins. When he was a free agent last off-season, he was undervalued and non-targeted. What stings even more is he said openly he would welcome a return to Toronto. It’s tough enough to swing free agents this way north of the border and here we had Hernandez openly saying he wants to come back. That goes ignored, and then he wins the World Series with the Dodgers and offers protection in that lineup. It really hurts, but since I love the Dodgers… I’m OK with it. I actually love Sandy Koufax that started my love of Dodger blue when I was a teenager. Now I have family that works high up in the Dodger head office, I’ve gone to so many Dodger games and I just love them. I’m cool & LA rocks. 😎 Now I like Teoscar being there.


Philip
 
Last edited:
... Ross Atkins went off and dealt Hernandez during the apparent “window to win“ and Hernandez then goes off to win a World Series in Los Angeles…. extending Hernandez and keeping him in that lineup was the right move….

Philip

Philip. you're assuming that it was up to the Blue Jays to decide if Hernandez stayed. They only had dibs on him for one year. This team doesn't have a long term strategy, they're just trying to delay the rebuild for as long as possible.

You were also bullish on acquiring Cody Bellinger long term. Look what the Cubs got for him, when he chose not to opt out.

Spend, spend spend works for the Dodgers because the individuals who own the Dodgers care more about winning that the financial bottom line. Ed Rogers doesn't own the Blue Jays. Most of Rogers Telecommunications is owned by investment groups who care more about stock dividends than championship trophies, and we've seen that top free agents want to play somewhere else.

The Jays get their man only when they overpay, when they are the last remaining suitor, or if there's a health gamble involved. If Toronto wants to field a winning team, rather than one competitive for the mid field, they'll have to do that by building from within, and concentrating on younger, inexpensive controllable talent.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
You were also bullish on acquiring Cody Bellinger long term. Look what the Cubs got for him, when he chose not to opt out.

My idea of acquiring Bellinger for 2023 would’ve been a good one…. But yeah, last year he was a stinker.. I’ll go on record saying right now however, Cody is going to have a monster year in New York in 2025. With that short porch in right he’s probably going hit 40. I’m excited to see what he can do hitting between Judge and Stanton. Most of the Yankee podcasts love this move.

Philip
 
My idea of acquiring Bellinger for 2023 would’ve been a good one…. But yeah, last year he was a stinker.. I’ll go on record saying right now however, Cody is going to have a monster year in New York in 2025. With that short porch in right he’s probably going hit 40. I’m excited to see what he can do hitting between Judge and Stanton. Most of the Yankee podcasts love this move.

Philip

Philip, my assessment of talent is based mainly on the difference between production and cost. Teoscar Hernandez was a good value player for the Jays:

teo-8.png

but would he have been a good fit for the Jays at 250%+ of his 2022 salary for several years?

I don't think trying to contend for a Wild Card playoff spot is a commitment to winning. I don't think a Wild Card contender should be signing free agents attached to qualifying offer compensation. If I want to get rich, I invest in stocks and bonds instead of a handful of scratch lottery tickets. I want to pay players based on what they'll do for me, rather than for what they did for someone else. I don't think the Jays can contend with Vlad Guerrero locked in for life, surrounded by seventeen guys named Raoul.

There's no way that the Jays will contend again during my lifetime, and possibly yours as well, if a good chunk of their budget is going to pay the salaries of players on other teams. Imagine a thirty-two year old Vlady, with six guaranteed years left at $45 Million per year, putting up Lyle Overbay numbers after eleven seasons playing on artificial turf most of the time have reduced his knee cartilage to cole slaw.

Re: Bellinger: I think he'll do well in Yankee Stadium, but look at his 'market value' as a trade piece: Cody Poteet, and the Cubs are on the hook for a big chunk of Bellinger's salary while he's playing for someone else.

bellinger1.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
There's no way that the Jays will contend again during my lifetime, and possibly yours as well, if a good chunk of their budget is going to pay the salaries of players on other teams. Imagine a thirty-two year old Vlady, with six guaranteed years left at $45 Million per year, putting up Lyle Overbay numbers after eleven seasons playing on artificial turf most of the time have reduced his knee cartilage to cole slaw.

That’s depressing to think that they will not contend again in our lifetime. You do make good points though especially about artificial turf.

Philip
 
Scherzer agrees to one year at $15.5 M deal with Jays

He's been hurt past 2 seasons, hopefully he's healthy and not washed up.

 
Scherzer agrees to one year at $15.5 M deal with Jays

He's been hurt past 2 seasons, hopefully he's healthy and not washed up.


If Max is healthy, and performs well, I think this is a great move. They'd be able to get some blue chip prospects for him at the trade deadline.
 
Yeah, he’s passed his twilight, but if he has anything left, he would make a great fifth starter. The problem is the fact that they have what six right handed starters in their rotation? We need at least one lefty starter to mix it up. Didn’t they make some signings with some international free agents and also a couple of minor-league deals with major league experienced players?

Maybe there is something there? Are they expecting someone to maybe have a good spring training? For the bullpen I’d really like to see them resign Yarborough.

Philip
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76
Yeah, he’s passed his twilight, but if he has anything left,

Philip
That's what I was thinking earlier. How much gas does he have left in the tank?

As I recall, analysts were saying that Scherzer would want the Jays to be competitive for him to sign and having Alonso on board would go a long way toward that. Just speculating here.

Looks like we'll have another Blue Jays cap in the HoF.
 
Yeah, he’s passed his twilight, but if he has anything left, he would make a great fifth starter. The problem is the fact that they have what six right handed starters in their rotation? We need at least one lefty starter to mix it up. Didn’t they make some signings with some international free agents and also a couple of minor-league deals with major league experienced players?

Maybe there is something there? Are they expecting someone to maybe have a good spring training? For the bullpen I’d really like to see them resign Yarborough.

Philip
I think Yariel is going to the 'pen.

So we have Berrios, Gausman, Bassitt, Scherzer and Francis? How much depth do we have?
 
I think Yariel is going to the 'pen.

So we have Berrios, Gausman, Bassitt, Scherzer and Francis? How much depth do we have?

Chris Bassett is cool with all his pictures and blah blah blah and he calls his own game and blah blah blah….. but he’s pretty useless at the end of the day. Trade bait?

Philip
 
I didn’t even look up his stats. Yeah Hernandez winning the World Series with the Dodgers when he could’ve been extended by the Blue Jays, is that automatic winner in the shittiest trade in team history imho. However, obtaining him in the first place was actually a great move for Ross Atkins. When he was a free agent last off-season, he was undervalued and non-targeted. What stings even more is he said openly he would welcome a return to Toronto. It’s tough enough to swing free agents this way north of the border and here we had Hernandez openly saying he wants to come back. That goes ignored, and then he wins the World Series with the Dodgers and offers protection in that lineup. It really hurts, but since I love the Dodgers… I’m OK with it. I actually love Sandy Koufax that started my love of Dodger blue when I was a teenager. Now I have family that works high up in the Dodger head office, I’ve gone to so many Dodger games and I just love them. I’m cool & LA rocks. 😎 Now I like Teoscar being there.


Philip
I could never cheer for a NY, LA, Chi Town or Philly based team ever.
 
My idea of acquiring Bellinger for 2023 would’ve been a good one…. But yeah, last year he was a stinker.. I’ll go on record saying right now however, Cody is going to have a monster year in New York in 2025. With that short porch in right he’s probably going hit 40. I’m excited to see what he can do hitting between Judge and Stanton. Most of the Yankee podcasts love this move.

Philip
Cubbies just weren't the right fit for him. I am going to target him in my fantasy baseball leagues this season. He's in for a monster campaign.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Toronto Passions
Scherzer signing is horrible. He's 40 years old and has pitched a total of 88 innings the past two seasons. I would have rather gotten Verlander for that same price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bemeup