What evidence do you have to the contrary?But no links to check the authenticity or what you might be leaving out.
What evidence do you have to the contrary?But no links to check the authenticity or what you might be leaving out.
Do you really think the current Jewish populations in the Arab countries as estimated in the Wikipedia tables above are significantly understated?But no links to check the authenticity or what you might be leaving out.
Does he have a choice given western sentiment. Does he have much choice given a very recent screw up. Does he have much choice given the polls. While it is a far cry from his usual hopes and prayers with stand with Paris virtue signalling. Don’t give him too much. He is as credible as a drama teacher.
i'm going to give him more credit here. Mr. Trudeau being more forceful on his disdain for Hamas and those who have been publicly supporting them since the attacks.
No sources. No value. You are not providing sources for a reason.Do you really think the current Jewish populations in the Arab countries as estimated in the Wikipedia tables above are significantly understated?
Also, feel free to search the subject on Wikipedia yourself. I only copied and pasted what seemed to be the most relevant information to make my point, and to be brief enough to fit in my post and not overwhelm the readers.
If you can find something on Wikipedia, or some other non-biased source to contradict what I posted, please post it yourself...
Obviously not. If that was the case, why were they spread out into so many other countries. That's hardly living together.It is because of emigration to Israel. Israel's population has increased substantially since 1948 too and therefore less to do with intolerance. After all these people have lived together for centuries.
No evidence of error. No research on your part. Your objections are meaningless. You are objecting for a reason. Hatred.No sources. No value. You are not providing sources for a reason.
The 800,000 or so Jews in those Arab countries pre-1948 lived together with the Muslims for a great many years. After the State of Israel was created many Arab countries forced them to emigrate, either by direct edict, or by persecution. And even more so after the 1973 Yom Kippur war and other confrontations. Hence the further reduction in Jewish populations in Arab countries using 1972 as a baseline in the above tables.It is because of emigration to Israel. Israel's population has increased substantially since 1948 too and therefore less to do with intolerance. After all these people have lived together for centuries.
More from Wikipedia. I tried to edit as little a possible, and the "copy" function left only links in some cases. Read the text. For greater detail click on the links.I provided sources that show emigration to Israel and a corresponding and substantial increase in population in Israel. That is what Zionism was about, to form a Jewish state. So it is understandable especially in the backdrop of WW2 and the holocaust that Jews moved to Israel, because it was established as a Jewish homeland.
To say it was because of intolerance is ignorance. Stop making up stories in your head.
So instead of calling my post stupid, you should give your head a shake instead.
Related topics |
---|
Remembrance |
Exodus by country |
Antisemitism in the Arab world |
Background |
Jewish exodus from the Muslim world |
Part of a series on |
|
Show us the huge decline in numbers from North America or U.K. or Australia because of "Zionism" and a return to the homeland. If you can't then your claims are bogus.I provided sources that show emigration to Israel and a corresponding and substantial increase in population in Israel. That is what Zionism was about, to form a Jewish state. So it is understandable especially in the backdrop of WW2 and the holocaust that Jews moved to Israel, because it was established as a Jewish homeland.
To say it was because of intolerance is ignorance. Stop making up stories in your head.
Basketcase said Israel was at war with Gaza about two weeks ago, well before this round of violence.You have no point. This war was started by Hamas' terrorist attack on Israeli citizens. I am trying to get you to admit to that but you are failing gloriously.
No, I have never said either of those two things.So it is Frank's tactic of gaslighting a discussion, where he surreptitiously calls every Israeli a terrorist, while throwing in the perfunctory, "Hamas is a terrorist group" statement, because that is undeniable.
The other day he did the same thing, where he said Zionists and Nazis were the same thing. I mean Nazis who sought to wipe out Jews from the planet were the same as people wanting to establish a Jewish state (even if I do not agree with the non-secular nature of it)?
Don't mistaken war with massacre...Hamas didn't target military installations and out posts...they were out for blood...civilians or not....IDF don't target civilians....collateral damage is inevitable when your enemy uses civilians as human shields...Hamas are terrorists...NATO members said so...Biden said so... Trudeau said so....Basketcase said Israel was at war with Gaza about two weeks ago, well before this round of violence.
Get him to explain to you when he thinks the Gaza/Israel war started.
Otherwise, look at the Oct 4 storming of Al Aqsa as the start of this round of violence.
Oh, but you can't, you can't admit any wrongdoing by Israelis, can you?
Wrong twice.Don't mistaken war with massacre...Hamas didn't target military installations and out posts...they were out for blood...civilians or not....IDF don't target civilians....collateral damage is inevitable when your enemy uses civilians as human shields...Hamas are terrorists...NATO members said so...Biden said so... Trudeau said so....
Both Hamas and Israel are acting like terrorists so its fair to make that comparison on that level.I did. Read my posts. I called out both as racist and as violating each other's human rights as evidenced by the HRW article.
I was commenting on your argumentation style. You cannot compare Hamas to Zionists. That is not a valid comparison. Every Israeli or the majority of them is a Zionist. Every Palestinian is not a Hamas militant. Hamas is a faction. Zionism is an identity.
It is the same thing you were doing the other day calling Khalistanis Sikhs. Khalistanis are Sikhs. Sikhs are not Khalistanis.
Or your argument that Zionists and Nazis were the same, which is at the very least offensive.
Please read my p.s. to my post.I am sure North America had immigration post WW2. North America and Israel were the countries most Jews moved to post WW2. For a better life.
And am sure there was some retaliation after the 1948 ethnic cleansing allegations. But the majority wanted to move to more developed places or to their Jewish homeland.
Sorry. Which post # of mine was the one that you quoted?Basketcase said Israel was at war with Gaza about two weeks ago, well before this round of violence.
Get him to explain to you when he thinks the Gaza/Israel war started.
Otherwise, look at the Oct 4 storming of Al Aqsa as the start of this round of violence.
Oh, but you can't, you can't admit any wrongdoing by Israelis, can you?
It’s far less confusing when you putI don't follow much Israel news, so was the rocket attack a retaliation for storming the Al-Aqsa mosque? Not an unprovoked one?
I will add you to my list of peaceful oppositionI am SHOCKED that the righties are suddenly no longer interested in backing Muslim religious protests!!!
SHOCKED!!!!!
Unlike the anti LGTBQ Muslim protests which were applauded by the righties, I don't see a single Republican asshole parading with these Muslims and cheering them on. I guess the righties just exploit Muslim grievances when its politically useful, huh?