Arrest warrant issued for Constable Forcillo

I don't know what the SIU thinks but what I saw on the video was him stop, take careful aim at a guy who was clearly down, and finish him off.

Are we to assume that all 8 rounds struck. What if first 6 rounds missed?
 
Again -- don't know what SIU has based their charge on.

What I think: Had he fired nine shots in succession you might just say, hey, adrenaline got the better of him, and he kept blasting away until the gun was empty. But that is not what he did. He stopped shooting after three shots, spent some time assessing the situation, yelled at the victim, took careful aim and finished him off.


Could it have been the first three shots missed, as Sammy Dove for cover...then yelled " I'm gonna knife you pig" and upon moving was taken out with the other 6? I guess a trial will determine that.
 
Are we to assume that all 8 rounds struck. What if first 6 rounds missed?

It doesn't matter. After the first three Yatim was lying on the ground. It doesn't matter why he was on the ground, from that position he wasn't a threat to anyone. Maybe they did miss, maybe he lay down to avoid being shot. The point is he was down.

Obviously the most likely reason why he was lying on the ground is that he was shot down.

At that point the cop stopped firing, observed that Yatim was down, deliberately lowered his aim, clearly aiming at a target on the ground, and finished him off with six more shots.
 
Feline, and others. . . there are several different issues here. One of the training videos showing how quickly a person with a knife or sword can be within lethal range has already been posted on one of these threads. From what little I know, entirely based upon press coverage, the initial shooting may well have been and probably was justified. It was what happened when Yatim was no longer actively resisting that appears to me to be the crux of the matter.

That was with the officer's gun holstered, not quite the same as JF's weapon was drawn. And he had a couple dozen other officers there that presumably would have fired if SY somehow descended upon JF.
 
I've not looked at the video, but that really has nothing to do with it.

Say you have a sword and I say "drop the sword, if you advance I'll fire" and you do and I do - what does that have to do with justification - were you half a kilometer away or were you ten meters away?

Were you a bank robber or am I the bank robber etc. . . ?

I think it was the wording, "Move again and you die," and then JF following through almost immediately that has caused the most uproar.
 
Are we to assume that all 8 rounds struck. What if first 6 rounds missed?

No one wearing a badge and a gun, not even JF, would likely miss from that range.
 
Or he may not be put in jail because the evidence, not seen on YouTube, proves him innocent.

JF has been charged, so the SIU must have seen something they deemed illegal from the evidence that was gathered. My guess is footage from the TTC video.
 
Could it have been the first three shots missed, as Sammy Dove for cover...then yelled " I'm gonna knife you pig" and upon moving was taken out with the other 6? I guess a trial will determine that.

A bit speculative, and unrealistic, wouldn't you agree? Unless you think that SY can dodge bullets like Neo from The Matrix, I would say it's a safe bet that SY was struck with most (90-100%) of those shots.
 
A bit speculative, and unrealistic, wouldn't you agree? Unless you think that SY can dodge bullets like Neo from The Matrix, I would say it's a safe bet that SY was struck with most (90-100%) of those shots.

Considering the speculations that has run rampant in the various threads on TERB, not any crazier than those.
 
^Yeah but even with minimal training, it's hard for me to imagine a police officer missing at that range.
 
^Yeah but even with minimal training, it's hard for me to imagine a police officer missing at that range.

The forensic analysts know exactly how many bullets hit him and from what angle.

But even if for the sake of argument he wasn't hit, he may have dropped to the ground to avoid being hit.

At that point there is no justification for shooting him. He was down, and while lying on the floor he isn't an immediate threat to anyone.
 
^Yeah but even with minimal training, it's hard for me to imagine a police officer missing at that range.

Try it some day. Go to he CNE, after hit the targets with the air rifles for the first time, do 20 push ups, assuming you can do 20 push ups, and then try and hit the same targets with the air rifles.

Or try it at home with a dart board.
 
I think the charge has to do with Forcillo telling Yatim if he takes one more step he dies. I never knew cops actually said this retarded shit from films and TV. But looking at Forcillo's lame selfie he looks like the type.
I think it was the wording, "Move again and you die," and then JF following through almost immediately that has caused the most uproar.

I agree. I don't think it was the extra shots. I think it was the cop being too macho, with his "take one more step and I'll plug ya!" Then the kid takes the step, and the cop shoots him.

The "one more step" thing sounds like a dare. Perhaps the cop didn't want to shoot the kid when he said the words, but then, having said them, and the kid took the step, he's gotta shoot the kid, just to save face. That's in line with the 2nd degree murder charge. There's more intent than manslaughter, but not full premeditation required for 1st degree.


JF has been charged, so the SIU must have seen something they deemed illegal from the evidence that was gathered. My guess is footage from the TTC video.
I'm sure the SIU has video from the streetcar cameras but we'll probably never see that footage.

The prosecution should publish the TTC video right now. There's no downside. The danger with holding back until trial is that the defence might come up with a reason to suppress it.
 
^Yeah but even with minimal training, it's hard for me to imagine a police officer missing at that range.

Granted, having to only fire like 60 rounds, once a year is pretty minimal and makes a really shitty case for police being above the law to possess and use prohibited devices, in all fairness the shot isn't as easy as you make it sound. I'm sure the lack of training can be cause for some of the misses, but shooting a handgun well, is more difficult than the movies would lead you to believe.
 
Try it some day. Go to he CNE, after hit the targets with the air rifles for the first time, do 20 push ups, assuming you can do 20 push ups, and then try and hit the same targets with the air rifles.

Or try it at home with a dart board.

Don't need to go to the CNE. I go to the shooting range with real guns. Not air rifles.
 
I agree. I don't think it was the extra shots. I think it was the cop being too macho, with his "take one more step and I'll plug ya!" Then the kid takes the step, and the cop shoots him.

The "one more step" thing sounds like a dare. Perhaps the cop didn't want to shoot the kid when he said the words, but then, having said them, and the kid took the step, he's gotta shoot the kid, just to save face. That's in line with the 2nd degree murder charge. There's more intent than manslaughter, but not full premeditation required for 1st degree.





The prosecution should publish the TTC video right now. There's no downside. The danger with holding back until trial is that the defence might come up with a reason to suppress it.

I think it was a combination of both the initial actions of the officer and the extra shots he took after SY was down.
 
Granted, having to only fire like 60 rounds, once a year is pretty minimal and makes a really shitty case for police being above the law to possess and use prohibited devices, in all fairness the shot isn't as easy as you make it sound. I'm sure the lack of training can be cause for some of the misses, but shooting a handgun well, is more difficult than the movies would lead you to believe.

I believe that only the officers with tactical training are allowed to carry prohibited (automatic) firearms. Handguns with a barrel over 4" long are classified as restricted, not prohibited.
 
I believe that only the officers with tactical training are allowed to carry prohibited (automatic) firearms. Handguns with a barrel over 4" long are classified as restricted, not prohibited.

Yabbut... they load their pistols with more than five rounds. This guy fired nine!

Still I think this is a side topic. The only real questions are:

1. Was there justification for the first three shots

2. Was there justification for the last six

I don't know about 1 that could go either way based on what SIU conclude, but I just don't see any justification for 2.