Arrest warrant issued for Constable Forcillo

FYI:

The last 6 Toronto cops charged with manslaughter or murder were all acquitted
 
We will see at trial, however, I suspect it will be the final six shots.

I agree, The first three could have been argued as bad judgement regarding the actual threat and response but when he was on his back - the cop made a conscience decision to kill the kid.

What I am very curious is that this one individual obviously was rogue even among his fellow officers. Would they have ever reported this incident themselves ? At what point would a cop report a rogue cop ?
 
You guys are very jaded, indeed.

I have refrained from commenting on this case because I thought there must be some evidence of special circumstances we know/knew very little about that might offer an explanation for what, IMHO, is a very clear and strong case of second degree murder.

Now that the SIU has instigated charges, it is fairly obvious -- though not certain -- that there is no such evidence or explanation.

And you are mistaken if you think the Crown Attorney's office or the judiciary takes these type of cases casually... not in Toronto! If there is persuasive, cogent evidence, the Crown will put a huge effort into this prosecution...

On the facts that we know so far about this case, I think a jury will likely lean very strongly for conviction, and a judge even more so.

If there is no evidence of attenuating circumstances and there is an acquittal at trial, there will be huge demonstrations in Toronto and people like me will be part of them.

But let us wait until ALL the evidence is in before jumping to any conclusions.

Perry
 
I'm not sure where you get 'so much' video. As far as I know there are only two, one is very grainy with questionable audio and the other has no audio. As for the number of shots, we still have no idea where all the shots went and SY was still alive on his way to the hospital. The laying of charges and getting to court are often really far apart, if ever connected. It is far from a slam dunk certainty.

As far as lesser charges being the result, something like 80-90% of charges are pleaded down before they ever reach court, so this will not be unique to this case. Laying more severe charge and settling on a lesser plea is an old practise.

I'm sure the SIU has video from the streetcar cameras but we'll probably never see that footage.
 
I'm not sure where you get 'so much' video. As far as I know there are only two, one is very grainy with questionable audio and the other has no audio. As for the number of shots, we still have no idea where all the shots went and SY was still alive on his way to the hospital. The laying of charges and getting to court are often really far apart, if ever connected. It is far from a slam dunk certainty.

As far as lesser charges being the result, something like 80-90% of charges are pleaded down before they ever reach court, so this will not be unique to this case. Laying more severe charge and settling on a lesser plea is an old practise.

Gee maybe he will plead it down from murder to manslaughter. Clearly that means this cop did the right thing!

You are just fucking ponderous sometimes.

P.S., the SIU also has the ttc surveillance video from the ceiling cameras in the streetcar.
 
I'm sure the SIU has video from the streetcar cameras but we'll probably never see that footage.

Yes there is that, but we've never seen. I forgot about it. If this goes to court are you saying it won't be made available? That would be stupid, as almost everyone involved knows it exists.
 
so if he fired one or two shots its following the procedure. more than two shots is murder? Wow being a cop is almost like being a robot.

might be a good thing. at least a robot can be programmed with a directive, ala Robo Cop. we'd probably have loads less people being shot dead by police because they are armed with a little knife at the back of a closed empty bus, while the cops are at the very front, crouched low on the stairs, taking cover on behind the little barrier that the 1st seat on the passenger's side provides.
I'm of course referring to the case of the Chinese man who was shot on a TTC bus a few years back.

Before you start saying that the cops had all the right to shoot him, or that it's easy for us to find fault, ask yourself this, WHY THE FOCKERS DIDN'T THEY JUST CLOSE THE DOORS, SIT AND EAT SOME DONUTS, DRINK SOME COFFEE...AND WAIT HIM THE FOCKERS OUT TILL HE GOT TIRED?! Same for Yatin?! Me thinks this cop must have had plans to catch his fave show on tv and realized that he didn't set the PVR, so he blew the kid away in a matter of seconds, so he could get home to catch TMZ....or whatever the FOCK.
 
I'm guessing that the streetcar video shows that SY was no longer a threat after the first three shots. That is why the SIU is pursuing charges. The TTC has stated that they never release their video footage to the public. Does that mean athere will be a media or publication ban on this trail?
 
I'm guessing that the streetcar video shows that SY was no longer a threat after the first three shots. That is why the SIU is pursuing charges. The TTC has stated that they never release their video footage to the public. Does that mean athere will be a media or publication ban on this trail?

The video will obviously be shown at the trial but whether it will make it onto YouTube or not, who knows.
 
Not that I want to see the video or anything, but I think that it's the key to the entire case and shows what really happened that night.
 
1. SIU only lays the charges
2. If anyone is incompetent it is the Crown Attorney's office who have their "boys" who handle police charges.
3. The cop's life is ruined. His family is ruined. Convicted or not his life will never be the same and rightfully so.

At the very least a very dangerous man is off the streets.
 
Who do you think should be doing t the investigation, bakers and shopkeepers?
Even in jurisdictions where such investigations are conducted by the State Attorney General's Office, the Assistant Attorneys General (lawyers) are assisted by investigators who are almost always either still active police officers or retired police officers.
 
I agree, The first three could have been argued as bad judgement regarding the actual threat and response but when he was on his back - the cop made a conscience decision to kill the kid.

What I am very curious is that this one individual obviously was rogue even among his fellow officers. Would they have ever reported this incident themselves ? At what point would a cop report a rogue cop ?

I doubt it. Cops don't testify against other cops. Without the video, there is no charge. Even with the video, there is probably no conviction. I hope I am wrong about that, but how often do you see cops going to jail?


http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/2...er_charged_with_murder_in_shooting_death.html
University of Windsor law professor David Tanovich says Yatim’s shooting is a “watershed case” involving police.

“Simply because there is such strong video evidence showing exactly what happened,” Tanovich said. “I don’t see how anyone could come to a conclusion that the conduct was reasonable and necessary.”

<edit>

“I just don’t see how the SIU has any choice,” Tanovich said.
A Toronto police officer has never been convicted of murder. Lawyer Peter Rosenthal, who is representing the family of slain Toronto man Michael Eligon at an upcoming coroner’s inquest, said the video in Yatim’s case could make the difference.
“The video evidence is very compelling,” Rosenthal said.
He pointed to the fact that in one video posted to YouTube, Yatim is seen on the ground even as Forcillo continues to fire. In one bystander video, nine shots can be heard before Yatim is Tasered by a supervisor.
“And I would think that the officer’s going to have a very difficult time facing that,” Rosenthal said.
Tanovich obviously hasn't met Blackrock yet. LOL