Arrest warrant issued for Constable Forcillo

then the cop was supposed to drop the gun, get his own knife and have an honest fight!

The cops aren't there to fight. Unless there is an immediate threat they should talk him down. If he is lying on the ground yelling threats but physically unable to threaten anyone, they can wait all day for him to drop the knife before approaching. Or if he stayed in there, at least have some calm discussions to decide how to get him out.

Obviously if he got back on his feet then he becomes a threat again. But he didn't.
 
I was listening to someone on the radio (ex-police union boss perhaps, can't remember who) essentially blaming the shooting on police budget cuts. He said they need to hire more officers who would be specially trained to deal with situations like SY. Really? What a crock of shit!
 
Not a safe assumption. Look at how many times the SIU has laid charges against police officers only to have the charges either thrown out by a Judge or the officer found not quilty by a Jury. How many successful prosecutions has the SIU achieved? I believe most investigations by the SIU are meant to intimidate the police and have nothing to do with the legal facts. It is my belief that this was the policy adopted by Marin when he headed the SIU - if possible lays charges as soon as possible, if not then drag the "investigation" out as long as possible. It is interesting that these charges were laid within days of Marin sticking his nose into this case.

It was in the paper today that since 1990 SIU have laid 2nd degree murder or manslaughter charges in on the job shootings 10 times, of those only one resulted in conviction and that one was overturned on appeal. So the crown is batting 10%(really zero with the appeal) on their conviction rate in these scenarios. The national average for homicide conviction rates in Canada off the government website is over 45%. I know a lot of you will say this obviously proves the judges and crowns do the wink/wink and let the boys in blue off, but isn't it more reasonable to believe that this shows that charges are laid due to public outcry and not on merit?
 
It was in the paper today that since 1990 SIU have laid 2nd degree murder or manslaughter charges in on the job shootings 10 times, of those only one resulted in conviction and that one was overturned on appeal. So the crown is batting 10%(really zero with the appeal) on their conviction rate in these scenarios. The national average for homicide conviction rates in Canada off the government website is over 45%. I know a lot of you will say this obviously proves the judges and crowns do the wink/wink and let the boys in blue off, but isn't it more reasonable to believe that this shows that charges are laid due to public outcry and not on merit?

You are seriously suggesting that this charge was not laid based on merit???
Given the corruption and collusion that has been PROVEN within many Canadian police forces, I believe the wink/wink is MUCH more reasonable to believe... as I'm sure most people with at least half a pre-frontal cortex would agree.
 
I am happy he was charged, but I do not see how 2nd degree murder can stick here. It is either man slaughter or criminal negligence causing death. In any case his career in law enforcement and a lifetime ban on weapons possession should also be included. I am concerned the crown deliberately selected a charge they could not make stick.
 
I am happy he was charged, but I do not see how 2nd degree murder can stick here. It is either man slaughter or criminal negligence causing death. In any case his career in law enforcement and a lifetime ban on weapons possession should also be included. I am concerned the crown deliberately selected a charge they could not make stick.

Conviction on a lesser charge (by judge or jury) is an absolute possibility.
 
^As a civilian with a PAL with restricted and non-restricted classifications, you're allowed 10 rounds in a handgun
Therefore the 15 round magazines they carry are prohibited devices...see where I was going?

5 in a rifle, and 3 in a shotgun. Not to nit-picking or anything.
Nitpicking's not a bad idea, where'd you hear that shotguns can only carry 3? This could be a hunting regulation in your WMU or something, but as per the Firearms Act, semi-auto shotguns can hold up to 5 rounds of the longest shell they're chambered for. Manual action, non-restricted firearms have no magazine capacity restrictions.
 
Therefore the 15 round magazines they carry are prohibited devices...see where I was going?


Nitpicking's not a bad idea, where'd you hear that shotguns can only carry 3? This could be a hunting regulation in your WMU or something, but as per the Firearms Act, semi-auto shotguns can hold up to 5 rounds of the longest shell they're chambered for. Manual action, non-restricted firearms have no magazine capacity restrictions.

It's at the top of the third paragraph. Ontario regulation, not just in my WMU, but the whole province.

http://www.ohep.net/Info.cfm?ID=3

And it's a big fine if the game warden catches someone with a shotgun that has the plug removed. Police riot guns hold ten 12-gauge shells.
 
Therefore the 15 round magazines they carry are prohibited devices...see where I was going?

They typically only load 14 to avoid putting extra strain on the spring. Watch part of his defence be "okay, he fired 9 rounds, but he could have fired 5 or 6 more, so there"!
 
They typically only load 14 to avoid putting extra strain on the spring. Watch part of his defence be "okay, he fired 9 rounds, but he could have fired 5 or 6 more, so there"!

Probably more like to avoid putting extra strain on the thumb. It bloody well hurts forcing that last round in!
 
I believe that's what the police will be counting on. Colour me a cynic, but I simply don't believe a cop in Toronto will be put in jail for this charge.

You might have been one of those people who said that he would not even be charged. I know that I was surprised he was charged.
Just the fact that they laid the charges is a positive step.
 
That seems like a fantastic, fail-safe system. :rolleyes:



People with law degrees.

People with Law Degrees have completely F'ed up the legal system, I can see how they would be qualified.

I would hope that the SIU is not entirely made up of former police officers, but I don't know the facts.
 
People with Law Degrees have completely F'ed up the legal system, I can see how they would be qualified.

I would hope that the SIU is not entirely made up of former police officers, but I don't know the facts.

Doesn't take long to find things like this out.

Led by the Director, the SIU consists of roughly 85 staff members. Members bring with them a wide breadth of knowledge and experience in both the investigative and administrative roles.

The SIU’s civilian investigators are the front line of the Unit, its "face" in the community. In compliance with the Police Services Act and internal operating procedures, investigators conduct objective, fair, unbiased and timely investigations into incidents of serious injury and death which may have resulted from criminal offences committed by police officers.

Four investigative supervisors (three full-time and one acting supervisor position), two forensic identification supervisors and 14 investigators work out of the SIU’s Mississauga head office. Of the 14 investigators, 8 have no previous policing backgrounds. Rather, their investigative experience comes from having worked in areas such as national security and intelligence, immigration, the legal profession, workplace health and safety, and professional regulation.

Further to this, a total of 39 regional investigators and 10 forensic investigators are stationed across the province and deployed on an as-needed basis. This blend allows the head office to oversee and manage investigations, while retaining the flexibility to respond quickly to incident scenes across the province with investigators who reside closer to the scenes.

To fulfill its mandate effectively, the SIU is also supported by an Executive Officer, Legal Counsel, Administrative Manager, Communications Coordinator, Outreach Coordinator, Training Coordinator, and an administrative staff composed of transcribers, a central registry clerk, a budget and inventory clerk, an information technology systems analyst and administrative assistants.
For an in-depth look at the various roles at the SIU, please click on the corresponding job title on the org chart below.

http://www.siu.on.ca/en/org_chart.php

So much for the wannabe experts on TERB who think it's just cops investigating cops.
 
citizens who don't have a conflict of interest like former police officers would be a good idea.

They may be a good idea in theory but not in practice. You need people with realistic understanding of police work, and not idealists.
 
Conviction on a lesser charge (by judge or jury) is an absolute possibility.


The judges instructions or lackthereof can easily remove that possibility as can the usual intentional prosecutorial errors.If you try and prove murder 2 in a manslaughter or criminal negligence case..your chance of conviction on the lesser charges is severely hampered and wide open to appeal.
 
There is a possible justification for your theory as posted. He missed the first three shots. And the live threatening thug was still on the floor, or crouched, hiding, and was still a deadly threat. So the policemen, feeling threatened, finished the thug off.

in my opinion, this charge was laid due to public opinion and pressure as displayed by YouTube convictors. For those of you looking at a grainy video and convicting, shame on you. The real evidence will come out at trial.

and I do take ownership of my own bias......that being my disdain for wannabe gangsta thugs.

As much as I want to defend the police, the initial 3 shots were questionable, the final 6 are very questionable.
Even the officer missed with the first 3 shots, unless Yatin was rushing at the officer, there is no justification
to fire off another 6 rounds without trying to negotiate or letting the kid have a chance to surrender.

My personal belief is that if you have a weapon in your hand, have threatened people with the weapon, and a police officer with a gun
tells you to drop your weapon, you should drop your weapon. If you make any move that does not involve dropping the weapon,
the officer should have the right to make a decision to end the threat. If that officer does decide to end the threat by
shooting the person, then society and the courts should back him up. The reality is that our officers always get second guessed, and while that is
fair, it is not always reasonable.

I believe that it is a positive step to press charges and let the jury decide on this case.
 
They may be a good idea in theory but not in practice. You need people with realistic understanding of police work, and not idealists.

in practice its a good idea. i am not asking for police haters or hipster dufuses but trained investigators from something other than a police background. its not only important that they are free of conflicts but the perception of being free of conflicts is important.

i don't think you need to be a police officer to judge whether procedures were followed and whether excessive force was used. any trained investigator can interview witnesses, and learn the police act and procedures.
 
Just to humor your ridiculous scenario, even if JF missed the first three shots and SY was crouching behind a seat with a knife, where is the justification to shoot him six (more) times?

You are assuming and you know what that means... At the time of the shooting, JF has no way of knowing if SY has a knife, pistol, shot gun, bazooka, grenade or bomb.
So yes, SY is a threat, and given that JF just shot at him, the assumption must be that SY is a threat.

Having said that, I don't believe that the evidence will show that SY was posing a threat to anyone when the final 6 shots were fired.
 
in practice its a good idea. i am not asking for police haters or hipster dufuses but trained investigators from something other than a police background. its not only important that they are free of conflicts but the perception of being free of conflicts is important.

i don't think you need to be a police officer to judge whether procedures were followed and whether excessive force was used. any trained investigator can interview witnesses, and learn the police act and procedures.

Point taken...