Arrest warrant issued for Constable Forcillo

I want to make $100. anyone want to bet he either gets off, or he's found guilty, but gets off on appeal? it will be a few years before its resolved and ill start my bet fund now.

theres a war out there folks and the police view us all as the enemy.
 
I want to make $100. anyone want to bet he either gets off, or he's found guilty, but gets off on appeal? it will be a few years before its resolved and ill start my bet fund now.

theres a war out there folks and the police view us all as the enemy.

They are clearly out to get you man. I can hear the black helicopters coming now.
 
They may be a good idea in theory but not in practice. You need people with realistic understanding of police work, and not idealists.

A grand jury approach can work. The grand jury drives an investigation, compels witnesses, orders the production of documents. It can work with and oversee the work of police and other professionals who bring the domain knowledge and advise the grand jury on how to proceed.

Fundamentally the leg work is done by people with a police background but the oversight by a jury serves as a check against any corruption or bias in the investigation.

The output from the grand jury is a recommendation of whether to press charges, discipline the officer administratively, or maybe recommend changes in police procedures.

The downside is it can be almost like having the trial twice in some cases.
 
You are assuming and you know what that means... At the time of the shooting, JF has no way of knowing if SY has a knife, pistol, shot gun, bazooka, grenade or bomb.
So yes, SY is a threat, and given that JF just shot at him, the assumption must be that SY is a threat.

Having said that, I don't believe that the evidence will show that SY was posing a threat to anyone when the final 6 shots were fired.

I am pretty confident that the use of force guidelines don't allow you to assume the individual as a grenade.
 
The judges instructions or lackthereof can easily remove that possibility as can the usual intentional prosecutorial errors.If you try and prove murder 2 in a manslaughter or criminal negligence case..your chance of conviction on the lesser charges is severely hampered and wide open to appeal.

Really? Is that how it works?

Why would you ever need an appeal with intentional crown negligence?
 
You are assuming and you know what that means... At the time of the shooting, JF has no way of knowing if SY has a knife, pistol, shot gun, bazooka, grenade or bomb.
So yes, SY is a threat, and given that JF just shot at him, the assumption must be that SY is a threat.

You cannot shoot people for what they might do or might have. Otherwise the police could just walk down the street shooting everybody they encounter, and at routine traffic stops better shoot the driver through the head before approaching the vehicle. After all, you never know who might be packing!

That is ridiculous. The police need actual, reasonable justification to believe you are a threat. They need to see something they reasonably think is a gun or grenade. Not just assume you might have one.
 
You are assuming and you know what that means... At the time of the shooting, JF has no way of knowing if SY has a knife, pistol, shot gun, bazooka, grenade or bomb.
So yes, SY is a threat, and given that JF just shot at him, the assumption must be that SY is a threat.

Having said that, I don't believe that the evidence will show that SY was posing a threat to anyone when the final 6 shots were fired.

Well, I was just humouring a ridiculous scenario. After the first three shots, SY was lying on the ground, not crouching. You see his feet in a prone position, pointing towards the officer. No longer a threat. Definitely not a threat after the next six and the tasering. JF had no way of knowing what SY was packing other than using his own eyes and "training" or lack of, to determine what kind of threat SY was. The other officers clearly did not see SY as much of a threat otherwise more officers would have opened fire. Police can't go around shooting people because of what they think they might have on them, they need to rely on eye witness accounts, credible information, and/or what they witnessed themselves and their judgement.

The first three shots show a lack of proper police procedure. No perimeter was set up around the streetcar, which would have given the police time and options to handle this situation with minimal use of force. JF still forced the situation by positioning himself too close to SY, and by taking a confrontational (almost to the point of a dare) tone with SY. The next six shots and subsequent tasering was completely unecessary and excessive.
 
Well, I was just humouring a ridiculous scenario. After the first three shots, SY was lying on the ground, not crouching. You see his feet in a prone position, pointing towards the officer. No longer a threat. Definitely not a threat after the next six and the tasering. JF had no way of knowing what SY was packing other than using his own eyes and "training" or lack of, to determine what kind of threat SY was. The other officers clearly did not see SY as much of a threat otherwise more officers would have opened fire. Police can't go around shooting people because of what they think they might have on them, they need to rely on eye witness accounts, credible information, and/or what they witnessed themselves and their judgement.

The first three shots show a lack of proper police procedure. No perimeter was set up around the streetcar, which would have given the police time and options to handle this situation with minimal use of force. JF still forced the situation by positioning himself too close to SY, and by taking a confrontational (almost to the point of a dare) tone with SY. The next six shots and subsequent tasering was completely unecessary and excessive.

Once more, the police had no idea if, until they searched him, he had a second unseen weapon, so he was still a possible threat, down prone or not. I still have a strong belief it was a death by cop scenario.
 
Once more, the police had no idea if, until they searched him, he had a second unseen weapon, so he was still a possible threat, down prone or not. I still have a strong belief it was a death by cop scenario.

Once more, police can't go around shooting people for what they think they might have on them. They have to be sure.
 
Once more, police can't go around shooting people for what they think they might have on them. They have to be sure.

They had already shot him 3 times before they even got close to search,so too late. Even then, he wasn't dead. No one is reporting where the other shots went. Contrary to what some say especially nuttyboi, a 4 inch knife is still a deadly weapon in the hands of a wounded man.

According to one expert, James Jewel, who knows more than most on TERB about what's what, and yes an ex cop, but no friend of the powers to be in the police services, look him up before you dump on him.

A deadly force threat requires three (3) specific elements, a) Weapon, b) Intent and c) Delivery System – ie: the subject must be capable of using the weapon against someone. In this case all three elements exist during the first phase of the confrontation; a) Yatim is armed with an edged weapon capable of causing death or grievous bodily harm, b) he demonstrates the requisite intent with his verbal non-compliance and by waving the weapon around and c) he had a delivery system in that he was in close enough proximity to the officers to attack them with the knife

http://jgjewell.com/2013/07/31/the-shooting-of-sammy-yatin-justified-or-not/

I'll take his analysis of FUJI's any day.
 
They had already shot him 3 times before they even got close to search,so too late. Even then, he wasn't dead. No one is reporting where the other shots went. Contrary to what some say especially nuttyboi, a 4 inch knife is still a deadly weapon in the hands of a wounded man.

According to one expert, James Jewel, who knows more than most on TERB about what's what, and yes an ex cop, but no friend of the powers to be in the police services, look him up before you dump on him.



http://jgjewell.com/2013/07/31/the-shooting-of-sammy-yatin-justified-or-not/

I'll take his analysis of FUJI's any day.

Yes, SY had a knife, was ordered to drop it and to not move. He didn't and was shot three times. But to say the other six shots were okay because SY may have had more weapons is just idiotic. He was down, he was not a threat after the first three shots.
 
Utility knives are absolutely a deadly weapon in the hands of someone willing to use it. They are a razor blade with a handle and will cut right to the bone. Seen first hand the damage they can cause to the human body (on a construction site). Google "buck fifty" to see the aftermath of some box cutter attacks in the States.

Still, that may not excuse JF for taking the first three shots and definitely not a reason to take the final six shots.
 
They had already shot him 3 times before they even got close to search,so too late. Even then, he wasn't dead. No one is reporting where the other shots went. Contrary to what some say especially nuttyboi, a 4 inch knife is still a deadly weapon in the hands of a wounded man.

According to one expert, James Jewel, who knows more than most on TERB about what's what, and yes an ex cop, but no friend of the powers to be in the police services, look him up before you dump on him.

http://jgjewell.com/2013/07/31/the-shooting-of-sammy-yatin-justified-or-not/

I'll take his analysis of FUJI's any day.

I agree with the standard you quoted, and will leave it to the SIU to determine whether he really had the delivery system for the first three shots.

But he clearly didn't when he was shot the second time. He was lying on the ground, feet towards the officer. He had no way of stabbing anyone from that position.

The police might have needed to figure out a safe way to approach him, but they could have spent a couple of hours figuring that out, so long as he stayed down.

The second shooting was completely unjustified, and I suspect that is why the cop has been charged with murder.

As your link says:

"I expect questions regarding whether or not a "delivery system" existed after the first three shots were fired will be a live issue in this investigation."

Looks like the investigation has concluded there was no delivery system. It is now a live issue for a jury.
 
I agree with Versatile1 that JF took on a confrontational tone (I thought I heard "if you step forward you will die").

I also disagree with Blackrock that SY was in close proximity to deliver the weapon. He had to step down from the streetcar (Could SY have have jumped off the streetcar and surprised JF? I don't think so). JF already had his gun trained on SY. It's not like JF couldn't back off. He also had police back up. This was not a jail cell where there's no retreat from an attacker.

I also agree with Fuji and others that JF could not assume that SY had any other weapon if he didn't see one or suspect one (this is not a would-be terrorist quickly approaching an embassy in the middle east), especially after the first three shots.
 
I agree with Versatile1 that JF took on a confrontational tone (I thought I heard "if you step forward you will die").

I also disagree with Blackrock that SY was in close proximity to deliver the weapon. He had to step down from the streetcar (Could SY have have jumped off the streetcar and surprised JF? I don't think so). JF already had his gun trained on SY. It's not like JF couldn't back off. He also had police back up. This was not a jail cell where there's no retreat from an attacker.

I also agree with Fuji and others that JF could not assume that SY had any other weapon if he didn't see one or suspect one (this is not a would-be terrorist quickly approaching an embassy in the middle east), especially after the first three shots.

It's the time you don't expect it that can bite you in the ass and can kill you. It's much safer to think yes, be proven wrong, and live.
 
Utility knives are absolutely a deadly weapon in the hands of someone willing to use it. They are a razor blade with a handle and will cut right to the bone. Seen first hand the damage they can cause to the human body (on a construction site). Google "buck fifty" to see the aftermath of some box cutter attacks in the States.

Still, that may not excuse JF for taking the first three shots and definitely not a reason to take the final six shots.

We still have no idea where the last six shots went or why they were discharged. That will come out in court. It 'could be' as simple as keep your fuckin' head down creep and don't even think of fighting back.
 
It's the time you don't expect it that can bite you in the ass and can kill you. It's much safer to think yes, be proven wrong, and live.

Safer for the police, yes of course.

Is this the banner that the police have posted in their locker rooms?

Almost sounds like, shoot first, ask questions later.

Question is: Will Forcillo live inside a prison cell?


P.S. This isn't to say that a cop can't shoot unless he has absolute certainty, but there are many reasonable men at the side of the street who would say 'hmmmmm'. If Forcillo squared off with YS on equal footing and inside a bar or room or even inside the streetcar, well to me, that's a different story where the initial three shots would be more justified.