World Cup 2018!

So, I guess this is...




..................................................THE END!
 
The TSN panel all agreed that it should not have been a penalty as they were making a case that the Replay just does not fit into the Soccer Games.
I must agree to disagree with them, as we saw time again in previous world cups that some teams were robbed as some goals should not have been awarded and in other scenarios blatant penalties were missed.
To me this was a handball. If you follow the replay closely, the arm was raised and then moved in the direction to make deliberate contact with the ball.
I wanted Croatia to win as they deserved to be in the finals. However France were the better team and rightfully claimed the World Cup

I know little about soccer, but I was under the impression that there were grey areas and an ambit of discretion involved. A player who holds his arm close to his body and who is inadvertently struck by the flight of the ball does not commit handball. The same scenario, but the player has stuck his hand out and is actively moving when struck with the ball commits the foul, even though it is not clearly deliberate. This avoids the situation where all the defenders are jumping around in front of the goal with their arms sticking out - in an attempt to deflect the ball without clearly being deliberate about it.

The latter case is what happened and the ref examined the replay closely several times before awarding the penalty. It was a much considered decision and is unlikely to be clearly wrong.
 
The "hand ball" was a tough call which could go either way. Very similar had contacts in the penalty area have been judged as penalties in this tournament so at the very least this referee's decision can be seen as consistent and predictable.

The judging of intent is always going to be inexact in certain situations, as is the distinction between the "movement of the had towards the ball" as opposed to "the ball towards the hand". AT what point should a player be held responsible if they have hung their arms out in a way the greatly increases the chances of making contact with an oncoming ball (or another player) event though not overtly aiming at it?

I don't like the fact the rule gives no middle options between either doing nothing or a warding a penalty in such cases. But it what it is, and based on other hand ball judgments in the tournament, players had no reason to doubt a penalty kick would be awarded if contact was made with an outstretched arm or hand.
 

I know little about soccer, but I was under the impression that there were grey areas and an ambit of discretion involved. A player who holds his arm close to his body and who is inadvertently struck by the flight of the ball does not commit handball. The same scenario, but the player has stuck his hand out and is actively moving when struck with the ball commits the foul, even though it is not clearly deliberate. This avoids the situation where all the defenders are jumping around in front of the goal with their arms sticking out - in an attempt to deflect the ball without clearly being deliberate about it.

The latter case is what happened and the ref examined the replay closely several times before awarding the penalty. It was a much considered decision and is unlikely to be clearly wrong.

You are absolutely right about the fact that if the hand is close to the body and the ball hits the hand then there is no way it is a penalty. However, in this instant the hand was raised and there was a spontaneous movement of it towards the ball. That helped to deflect the path of the ball. The referee had no choice but to have awarded the penalty.
 
Don’t agree, there must be intent/ deliberate. There was none. General consensus is by the football expert community is that it was not a penalty. It is not reasonable to assume that every player will be able to keep their arms at their side when jumping for a ball. That is not natural.
Aside from that it should never have gone to VAR.
I say the above having played pro football.
 
You are absolutely right about the fact that if the hand is close to the body and the ball hits the hand then there is no way it is a penalty. However, in this instant the hand was raised and there was a spontaneous movement of it towards the ball. That helped to deflect the path of the ball. The referee had no choice but to have awarded the penalty.

I saw it the same way. I guess the referee did too.

Really unlucky for Croatia though who had been slightly the better team up until that point.
 
It was 50/50, the call hinged on whether Matuidi made contact with the ball before Peresic touched it with his hand. The ref concluded that he didn't....Juve prevails over Inter again.
 
Easy to fix with a new rule. Except for goalkeepers, hands must be zip tied behind their backs for the full game.
 
Croatia was great, they were unlucky with that penalty (that wasn't) and the autogoal by Mandzukic. They managed to beat Nigeria, Argentina, Iceland, Denmark and England for a country that small they did very good. France of course is also very good, Giroud sucked, I'm sure he's not happy that he didn't manage to get one in.
I don't know what happened with Brazil, all those great players.. Neymar managed to crown himself the king of diving and the laughing stock of most commentators. I think most games were very good , I'm already missing soccer, but I think Premiere is starting early in August.
 
Don’t agree, there must be intent/ deliberate. There was none. General consensus is by the football expert community is that it was not a penalty. It is not reasonable to assume that every player will be able to keep their arms at their side when jumping for a ball. That is not natural.
Aside from that it should never have gone to VAR.
I say the above having played pro football.

I agree most said it wasen't.
 
Once the group stage is completed and the round of 16 begins only 1 team loses twice.

The team that loses in the semi final and then loses in the 3rd place game.

That was England.

Much joy to be had!
 
Ah! Same old, same old... we lawyers spend a great deal of time and energy considering and dealing with the question of intent.

Ultimately, the only person who knows for sure is whoever is standing trial. All the rest of us have to deduce and infer it from all the surrounding circumstances.

It is the same in futbol. And that is why VAR is so useful. Especially now that video technology is so accurate and reliable. I think that getting it right is important. A judge has lots of time to review and consider evidence which is often contradictory, inaccurate and unreliable. The Referee has to do it in an instant but he now has the benefit of "clear and convincing" evidence": both what he saw, live, and the video replay of other angles of what he saw.

As in a trial, the only opinion that matters is that of the referee. He is in the best position to decide.

The likelihood of error has been substantially reduced. We accepted the possibility of error as part of the game before technology came into use. Why not accept a much lesser risk now?

I, too, thought that Croatia was very unlucky... they deserved to win. But, maybe France was lucky?

Perry
 
So now we move on to the Black Hole WC in 2022.

Italy hated Sepp Blather and lost out in hosting tournaments when he and Michele Platini (UEFA) were in charge. It was a reversal of fortune with the new FIFA President being Gianni Infantino. With his bald head and bushy eyebrows he was hard to miss among the dignitaries.

It was a no brainer that the United States would host in 2026, the Americans played a huge role in getting him elected.

 
Just got back from Russia... had a great time, they really pulled out the RED carpet, have to say that it's probably the best WC I have attended and this time I only went for the latter half. People were amazing from all countries involved even though many left by the time I arrived but those that stayed were fun to party with. The authorities kept a very tight grip on any unwanted behaviour, hooligans were dealt with severely... especially since we all had to carry around ID passes around our necks at all events. Lots of activities to see and participate in, lots of local and foreign food and the partying was non stop and late into the night. Too many stories to tell and the build up to the Final was great but the game truly Rocked ... congrats to the winners France and to Croatia for providing an exciting game.

VBB
 
Just got back from Russia... had a great time, they really pulled out the RED carpet, have to say that it's probably the best WC I have attended and this time I only went for the latter half. People were amazing from all countries involved even though many left by the time I arrived but those that stayed were fun to party with. The authorities kept a very tight grip on any unwanted behaviour, hooligans were dealt with severely... especially since we all had to carry around ID passes around our necks at all events. Lots of activities to see and participate in, lots of local and foreign food and the partying was non stop and late into the night. Too many stories to tell and the build up to the Final was great but the game truly Rocked ... congrats to the winners France and to Croatia for providing an exciting game.

VBB
How were the Russian chicks??
 
How were the Russian chicks??

It was eye candy from all countries... the Russians though hired all these hot chicks to help the tourists, then the restaurants and bars had hot staff ... but during the games ... boy oh boy ... they obviously knew the cameras were about and they flaunted it !!! What you guys here probably didn't see was all the titty flashing going on outside the hotels and stadiums when the team buses rolled by.

I've been to Russia before, it's like where did the ugly ones go.. jk but the numbers were pretty high.

Reading through this thread has since my last prediction post has been fun ... lots of good jest by some, others meh... I believe the use of VAR was correct and glad the players pointed it out and his downward moving hand touched the ball that was kicked from a distance in the penalty area ... Neymar is so ROTPL ... England is England...


VBB
 
It was eye candy from all countries... the Russians though hired all these hot chicks to help the tourists, then the restaurants and bars had hot staff ... but during the games ... boy oh boy ... they obviously knew the cameras were about and they flaunted it !!! What you guys here probably didn't see was all the titty flashing going on outside the hotels and stadiums when the team buses rolled by.

I've been to Russia before, it's like where did the ugly ones go.. jk but the numbers were pretty high.

Reading through this thread has since my last prediction post has been fun ... lots of good jest by some, others meh... I believe the use of VAR was correct and glad the players pointed it out and his downward moving hand touched the ball that was kicked from a distance in the penalty area ... Neymar is so ROTPL ... England is England...


VBB

Sounds like a lot of fun. Cant wait till it comes to Canada . What were the ticket prices? Did you hobby ?
 
Sounds like a lot of fun. Cant wait till it comes to Canada . What were the ticket prices? Did you hobby ?

Ticket prices, depending where you sit, are affordable for the group stages, cheap if your Russian, the group stage of 16 is a slight jump, round of 8 quarterfinals ouch, the Semifinals it doubles... but the 3rd place is a bargain... then the finals is almost double the semifinals, a private box is crazy !!! Scalping is frowned upon and the Russians cracked down on them plus your seats are registered in your name, picture ID has to be worn and with you during the game, and you have to notify them if you are bringing someone as a friend it just gets complicated but you cant give away your seats you have to give them back and they resell them, but there is a transfer process. You have to buy your seats in advance like late 2017, depending on games there is a lottery but there were still seats on sale for games when I was there.

Did I hobby? Oh yeah, the WC draws SPs like bees to honey but it was mainly homegrown talent at a lot of the venues that charged more than usual but lots of variety at different locales, didn't have to go far to get approached and then haggle. Lots of semipro looking to make extra $$$ and party with you, only a few incidents of robbery but if you didn't get too drunk you were okay.

When it comes here I'll have my tickets and travel to the states to watch the finals again.

VBB
 
It is not reasonable to assume that every player will be able to keep their arms at their side when jumping for a ball. That is not natural....
Really? Figure skaters seem to be able to execute dozens of jumps in practice with their arms tucked across their chests until the the moment they land. It's just a matter of making it a priority, teaching that technique and reinforcing it in every practice at every stage of organized soccer.

I would agree though that the roll-out was somewhat unreasonable and unfair to players in general. Going to a zero-tolerance enforcement overnight after an eternity of loose and inconsistent interpretations put everyone off balance.