That's why insisting on a certain form and technique is better, it gets the officials off the hook for guessing intent and instead allows them to make a call based on an observable fact.Ah! Same old, same old... we lawyers spend a great deal of time and energy considering and dealing with the question of intent.
Perry
If you rule that the legal way to challenge for a ball in the air is with the arms at your side or held against your chest, otherwise any contact with the ball or another player will automatically be a foul, intentional or otherwise.
It's like in hockey when two players are about to cross paths in the neutral zone, one guy sticks out his elbow or forearm a half second before and knocks the other guy out, he can't say "well I put my elbow up before his head got there" . No, the mere fact the elbow was out for whatever reason is sufficient for major penalty. The only legal way to make a hit is with the hands on the stick at waist level, or stick on the ice in one hand and the other tucked in against the torso.

