Wake Up Call for NHL ?

wow- interesting read...

this reporter seems to point the finger at the americanization of the sport without clearly saying so...

give me back my canadian hockey, eh?
 
It has always been my believe that there is just not sufficient Amercian interest to justify so many teams. The talents are diluted, as a result.
 
Yeah but without the US support this sport and players wouldn't get these kind of salaries and the sport wouldn't be as popular as it is now....back then in the 80's hockey wasn't really popular in the states as it was in Canada and Gretzky, Messier were making peanuts and not known until they were traded to the states with more indorsments with huge salaries.....theres a bigger market and fan base and alot more tv exposure in the states......
 
true you are wheats....

and (but), hence, we are in the situation that we currently are...
 
The marekt reality is telling us the Amercian 'support' for NHL has more to do with good marketing by teh NHL than the genuine interest in this game by the Americans. Thus the hugh salaries enjoined by the players are not justified.

I don't expect too many people will agree with me, but this is what the market is telling us.

wheats said:
Yeah but without the US support this sport and players wouldn't get these kind of salaries and the sport wouldn't be as popular as it is now....back then in the 80's hockey wasn't really popular in the states as it was in Canada and Gretzky, Messier were making peanuts and not known until they were traded to the states with more indorsments with huge salaries.....theres a bigger market and fan base and alot more tv exposure in the states......
 
The players and the union killed the golden goose.

I've always said that a sucessful TEAM will be supported by the city's fanbase. Most fans don't care who plays for the team, as long as they win. They'll use replacement players and we'll see how long before the bottom half of the PA break ranks. These are the same guys playing for peanuts in the A or I, or even Europe. The union can and will be broken. I hope the owners can stick it out - even at the expense of some of the fringe teams. It's time to cull the herd.
 
wheats said:
Yeah but without the US support this sport and players wouldn't get these kind of salaries and the sport wouldn't be as popular as it is now....back then in the 80's hockey wasn't really popular in the states as it was in Canada and Gretzky, Messier were making peanuts and not known until they were traded to the states with more indorsments with huge salaries.....theres a bigger market and fan base and alot more tv exposure in the states......
I'd have to disagree with your synopsis as to the reason why salaries have risen in hockey. If you recall in the 80's no major sport was making much money compared to how they are now. The growth in salaries has to do more with marketing by the leagues, creative revenue generation and public appetite across the spectrum of ALL major sports. Less so of anything 'US'. heck look at Football across the pond. The players on the major clubs are making 20 times what they were in the 80's. Are you telling me that is because of US support?
 
razorback said:
Replacement players will save the game, and the league, this coming September -- unless the NHL players wake up quickly.
Hockey fans, just like any sports fans, want to see elite talent.
Hard working muckers and mules are a dime a dozen.
Even if just the top 100 players in the world hang tough the NHL will be a joke.

Imagine what the PGA Tour would be without the top 100 players in the world.
Even just the top 5 guys missing would cause the ratings to plunge. :eek:
 
Malibook said:
Even if just the top 100 players in the world hang tough the NHL will be a joke.
Only for a few years until this current top 100 ages and are replaced by the current juniors who are destined to become the top players anyway.
 
The current juniors can afford to wait this out.
Given the rookie salary cap, the top juniors can make more money overseas anyways.

Sidney Crosby has already made it clear that he won't be a replacement player.

Some older mediocre players might consider going against the union and some might actually do it but so what?
Nobody is paying hundreds of dollars to see them anyways?
I think deep down everybody realizes that the NHL needs the best players in the world.

The NHL talent pool is already diluted enough.
An NHL team is not even remotely close to a Canada Cup or Olympic team and a replacement player team would be nothing compared to an NHL team.

Hey, for $10 bucks a seat, they probably will get some fans but overall the level of interest, support, and TV/advertiser cash will be an embarassment to the NHL. :p
 
I'd have to agree with razor and shack. The players have painted themselves in a corner. Crosby is only one amongst many. The rookies have been sold down the river on this deal anyway. So why should they stick it out with the NHLPA. There is no allegiance as they don't have the NHLPA union card anyway. Once they see the league is operating, abnd it will as fan supoprt is firmly behind the owners, the current NHL players will come back. If they don't, let them play elsewhere for a fraction of the salary.
 
The latest NHL moves are setting the stage for the impasse-replacement players scenario. I'd like to see it happen, because the NHLPA will certainly break apart, with the lower 1/2 of the membership not wanting to be left out. Has the league really got a chance of overcoming the legal hurdles in every jurisdiction to do that?
 
I could understand why some people would be so hostile towards the players had they gone on strike but that is simply not the case here.

I could also understand some hostility towards the players had they not made a significant offer of very substantial consessions.

Are people just jealous of the players?
Are they frustrated that they can't afford to go to an NHL game? As if the prices will come down even with the owners' proposal.

How will the NHL be able to win all of the legal battles in all of the jurisdictions in order to go ahead with the Replacement Players Dictatorship they are supposedly considering?
Somehow they are trying to create a fantasy dream that all of these processes and appeals will be resolved in the owners' favour in time to start next season. :rolleyes: