well it seems the difficult contract situation never was. Amazing that 2 teams and leagues could so quickly agree; to be a fly on the wall of several football executive offices...
mlam: I think maybe you aren't too conversant with the CFL. In the past about 15 years only teams coached by Don Matthews have featured power running games by mixing about 50/50 pass/run. It's otherwise a passing league. I generally agree with "all a running back does is take the ball and run until someone stops him from running" of conservative run-based offenses popular in the NFL. Not the case in the CFL.
The Argos, should they land him, would change their offense to accommodate Ricky Williams. WHATEVER they had to do, they would do it....is something talking head broadcasters and fans like to expound on. Realistically it's too risky a season long plan due to smart defenses and injuries. However, if you stress accommodate, I agree: they have potential to become more like an NFL team with 2 incredibly strong running backs. Your same argument was popular when Rocket Ismail was signed for $25million by the Argonauts. It was not WHATEVER they had to do, they would do it., he became an important but not featured part of the offense.
Toronto Argonaut offense plan is becoming increasingly deep and difficult with subterfuge and speed. Any one year player, with no CFL experience, will not dominate like you and others suggest, both from learning a new, complex system and game and because the offensive plan won't feature one player, especially a running back in the pass dominated CFL. Also, a running back is very dependent on the offensive line and last season they really didn't help much the leagues previous rushing leader. So, I maintain that... Should he play 1 year in the CFL, RWilliams will probably be entirely average with flashes of extreme brilliance....will be closer to the truth at season end than your glowing assessment. Regardless, I'm a fan, so it would be great if I'm wrong.
Your last paragraph condemning the CFL is untrue and belies a lack of knowledge of the contractual workings of professional football. I do believe the quality of NFL play and player is generally better, certainly more specialized, but not exclusively so, and not all players desire to play in the NFL.
The trouble with categorical statements, while fun, is that they're so easy to pick apart. But let's be positive, whether we really played or not.