Seriously, do you just make stuff up as you go along?
Yes he does.
Seriously, do you just make stuff up as you go along?
Most people who are "wannabe experts".In general I've just never been a fan of using championships to measure players in team sports. That is just me. Most people will disagree with me and that is fine.
Looks like the only criteria against Peyton just took a big hit.
My argument (in which I am also playing devil's advocate since I've repeatedly said that there is solid arguments to be made for Manning, Montana and Brady) is mostly based as a rebuttal to the "championships measure GOAT" and "it is all on the QB's shoulders" arguments.Before I start my response I have no particular side in the Peyton-Brady debate. Both are near equals in my view. And I thought Peyton has always got a bum deal for his playoff record.
My response is merely that of a devil's advocate
The fact that people are using Manning's win last night as a positive in the debate, can easily have the tables turned against them. Manning has become a game manager at this point. And if your argument is managing the game and him just winning is a big plus, then in essence without knowing it you are making a stronger argument for Tom Brady.
My argument (in which I am also playing devil's advocate since I've repeatedly said that there is solid arguments to be made for Manning, Montana and Brady) is mostly based as a rebuttal to the "championships measure GOAT" and "it is all on the QB's shoulders" arguments.
I may not actually put full faith in what I am posting, but I am ramming those arguments right back down the throats of people who sincerely believe that bull crap. Football is the ultimate team sport. No one player deserves so much credit or so much blame.
Most people who are "wannabe experts".
Bruce Arthur in today's Star (BTW, he actually gets paid for his opinions):
We should remember some things, though. If Peyton Manning won his second Super Bowl by throwing for 141 yards and an interception, then we should by now recognize that quarterbacks aren’t the lone heroes of these mythic stories.
So you're rating PM's whole career based on one (Super Bowl!) game? Seems wrong.
Statistics and records would say otherwise.
Football is the ultimate team sport. No one player deserves so much credit or so much blame.
More passing yards than anybody else, more TDs than anybody else, more wins than anybody else, most games with a perfect passer rating, more 4th quarter comebacks than anyone else, more league MVPs than anyone else. Etc. Etc. When I eye-ball those stats, no one else even comes close. Regardless of era.
How else do we rate an individual player's performance over their career? By looking at their coaches and what kind of schemes they used and the personnel around them? No, we use stats.
The thread is about Peyton Manning. Not Clay Matthews.
Tell who is better than PM. Interested in your thoughts.
Don't care about your demonstrations, don't care about Clay Matthews or what kind of year he had.
Who is a better QB than Manning? What does your "eye-ball" tell you?
The answer is; who gives a shit?
Go start another thread if you care about comparing all these players, year by year. This thread is about PM. Who is a better QB than PM? What does your "eye-ball" tell you?
The answer; who gives a flying fuck? The thread is about Peyton Manning. Not Clay Matthews.
Tell me, who is better than PM. Interested in your thoughts.
Unless you watch every single game ever played by every single player in history, then your "eye-ball" test is bullshit.
Unless you watch every single game ever played by every single player in history, then your "eye-ball" test is bullshit.
Unless you watch every single game ever played by every single player in history, then your "eye-ball" test is bullshit.
Judging PM based on playoff wins? I thought winning was a team effort and not placed solely on an individual. BTW, he's over .500 in the playoff now.
Peyton Manning had virtually nothing to do with that Super Bowl. It was all the defense. Didn't throw for a single TD, picked once, threw for 141 yards, rushed for 0, 56.6 rating. He just happened to be the QB. We would be calling Brock Osweiler a Super Bowl champion if he started with that D behind him. His legacy was secure before this game, but last night neither added or took away from his legacy. He's still one of the all time greats, but he doesn't jump ahead of anyone because of his 2nd Super Bowl because we all know he wasn't a factor in the outcome.
Marshawn Lynch was healthy when they won. And they had better receivers.
Say again?
Those were key factors that led to the Seahawks winning that year. Wilson had less pressure and more to work with.