Israel at war

The people who engaged in vandalism or hooliganism of some kind get rightfully arrested. The ones who peacefully protest do not whether or not someone "feels intimidated".
If a patient is afraid to go into the hospital because of the protest, he/she is the only one who is the authority as to whether they feel intimidated or not.

And protests are an intrinsic right.
We already agreed on that.

Does not matter where as long as the legal requirements to conduct protests are taken care of
We already agreed on that as well. Why do you keep repeating yourself? Please show us some document stating what these legal requirements are? How stringent are they?

which the pro-Palestinian protestors seem to have addressed in 99.99% of the cases.
Based on what statistics that you seem to have at your disposal? Have you seen the stats of how many applications that they've submitted? Was the protest on the Avenue Rd. legal? Was it pre-approved? Not that you strongly suspect they did or probably did, but do you definitively know. We know that the cops drove them away, so clearly it was not approved. And again, the devil is in the details. What are these legal requirements as spelled out by Toronto by-laws?

BTW, it is not up to the protesters to decide if they think that they've addressed the legal requirements. They need to apply to the authorities just the same as people who want to parade in Santa Claus or Gay Pride. There is a process that needs to be followed.

So the protest on Avenue Rd. was NOT properly addressed. According to that 99.99% you cited, simple math means that that there have been 9,999 protests that were pre-approved by the authorities, which we both know is a ridiculous number. But that's what happens when you apply hyperbole to your anecdotal and irrelevant personal observations.

I am also disregarding what you call legal/illegal as you are not the legal authority on anything. So it seems you are taking issue with a non-issue.
And you are no expert either, so for you to say what and where how they are allowed to protest is a joke. You seem to want to set one standard to me follow and no standards for yourself.

I showed you the section of the criminal detailing what is a nuisance, yet here you are still claiming that that these protester are allowed to disrupt people's lives.
 
I don't feel any pressing need to engage with "The way to solve the conflict is ethnic cleansing or genocide" actually.

You don't have a clue. And are running. Again.
 
To what end? Most people would agree that violence is bad, peaceful protests are good. So what does that tell you anyway? As far as cops are concerned, their default go to action is "riot control" aka violence. I think the only thing that is important is to think about when protests might become volatile and explode into violence, and act before that happens.

I disagree. The previous peaceful protests asking for the same things were unsuccessful over a period of 10 years. Even then it was just a bunch of black people, yelling something. Only after the 2020 protests, some change was seen.

Of late. Because it is the latest development. However the primary demand of the protests has been to ceasefire and end the genocide. Infact, divestment demands are also to force Israel to end the genocide.

I think a far better comparison is apartheid South Africa.
Up until 2008 Mandela and the AFC were labelled as terrorists by the US.
Global action, protests and BDS like sanctions were what ended apartheid, that's what finally forced governments to act.

So governments supporting Israel will continue to do so until the votes lost supporting Israel outweigh the cash coming in from AIPAC.
We are likely at that moment now, though the governments don't know it yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kautilya
The one thing to note though, is that the US did not have the kind of relationship with South Africa that they do with Israel. But I agree with the last statement. In the US though, the votes lost might not be so much due to support for Palestine but more due to people not wanting American tax payer money going to Israel. I genuinely hope that day comes. If American support for Israel is weakened, this conflict will come to an end due to international pressure.

It wasn't far off, same with Canada, the country backed South Africa until it became too unpopular.
We'll see what happens, but the university protests are looking very Vietnam to Gaza's Tet offensive.

It just gets worse and worse for the US every day.
And there is an election coming up.

 
All bluster and no ideas? Guess what Eggo, if you can't step up to the plate, you can't play the game. Frankie has you on the run too. When you want to join the adult table, feel free to refute what I said with something real. A concrete origional idea or premise.

That’s a quote from the Roman historian Tacitus, lol.
 
No, it's more like the American voters don't want all that tax money going to Ukraine, when Ukraine has absolutely no chance of winning the war with Russia!!
Righties have been saying "Ukraine has no chance" since February 2022. Let me know when Ukraine loses, Mitchy?

Two and a half years is a long, long time to "be losing" a war.

While you're at it, read the Russian casualty losses and tell me what model tanks the Russians are driving these days?
 
Sure. They can feel what they want to feel but that is on them.
No. Nobody else can tell them how they feel. Can I tell you that you support Israel?

No such statistics, or analysis, paralysis are needed, because you do not know stats contrary to what I stated either.
You made the claim of 99.99%. As such I am totally justified to question how you arrived at these claims. You have no idea. You pulled them out of your ass. What are your sources?


The vast majority of protests are legal and lawful and have been. The few cases where there have been issues, have been dealt with. That is all you and I need to know.
Actually, you need to back up your claims with statistical facts. I need to know what the facts are, not your fabricated and admittedly anti-Israeli biased claims.

The fact that they were infact allowed to protest without consequences would negate your uninformed statements on legality and the law, both of which you are not an expert on.
You have no expertise. Are you saying that being forced to cease their protests is not a consequence?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
No one is telling them how to feel. If they "feel intimidated" by the protests, they can continue feeling that way. This is solely their problem and nothing needs to be done about it.

Absolutely no statistics, or analysis paralysis is needed to make these claims.

Are the vast majority of protests allowed? Yes.
Have any protests been shut down? Most likely no. If at all they have been, probably can count on both hands.
Have some disruptive people been removed and charged? Yes.

Hence 99.99% is a reasonable number and no further justification is needed.
Also this shows that protests are a non-issue.

No expertise is needed to report what is observed. The fact of the matter is almost all protests are allowed to take place without consequences.
You have reached the point of Bizarro debating for me to no longer engage you. I only deal with reality.

Yet you felt the need to question my expertise. LOL.
 
I don't think it will be successful though because Germany can adopt its own foreign policy. Plus no one is going to ask Germany to go against Israel. They are in perpetual apology mode (as is the west in general) even though they don't owe them anything today.

The Nicaragua application was not successful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kautilya
I don't think it will be successful though because Germany can adopt its own foreign policy. Plus no one is going to ask Germany to go against Israel. They are in perpetual apology mode (as is the west in general) even though they don't owe them anything today.

It wasn't successful, the ICJ said that there needs to be a conviction for genocide to rule that Germany is aiding genocide.
Its still a warning to other countries, or should be.
Canada included.

Today's news is that should Israel attack Rafah they will block all men of age from leaving.
Srebenica revisited.


Jonathan Cook paints a pretty dark picture of what might happen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu