iPhone 4 Review

Apple promises to fix the software problems. But is a recall in iPhone 4's future?

Now that is funny!

Could Apple be becoming the GM/Toyota of the Tech world!.....
laughing1.gif
 
time is running out to get your refunds or revert back to 3GS

iPhone 4 Customers Have Limited Time and Limited Options

The Apple iPhone revolutionized the smartphone market and has succeeded in breaking down barriers with the IT department and becoming an accepted part of the network and communications environment at many companies. Businesses that embraced the new iPhone 4, though, are faced with a handicapped device and a ticking clock to decide what to do about it.

The nearly two million iPhone 4 users have a long list of seriously debilitating issues with the new smartphone. While Apple continues to come up with ludicrous justifications and ridiculous recommendations, customers are waiting for an actual solution. Users can return the iPhone 4 for a full refund, but the clock is ticking and the options are limited.

It seems like just yesterday that Apple was a paragon of customer service, and a shining example of how to create a culture of devices with exceptional customer experience--devices that "just work". Oh wait. It was just yesterday.

Now, Apple either believes it really is magic, or that its users are just that dumb, or both--because the response so far to the iPhone 4 issues amounts to trying the Jedi mind trick on customers and attempting to convince users there are no issues or that the concerns are being exaggerated.

The official Apple response to the iPhone 4 antenna issue was originally "Gripping any phone will result in some attenuation of its antenna performance, with certain places being worse than others depending on the placement of the antennas. This is a fact of life for every wireless phone."

When that explanation failed to appease the disgruntled masses, Apple did some further investigating and determined that the real signal is fine, but the way iOS calculates and displays the signal strength bars has been wrong for years.

Apple issued a statement saying "Upon investigation, we were stunned to find that the formula we use to calculate how many bars of signal strength to display is totally wrong. Our formula, in many instances, mistakenly displays 2 more bars than it should for a given signal strength. For example, we sometimes display 4 bars when we should be displaying as few as 2 bars. Users observing a drop of several bars when they grip their iPhone in a certain way are most likely in an area with very weak signal strength, but they don't know it because we are erroneously displaying 4 or 5 bars. Their big drop in bars is because their high bars were never real in the first place."

Both of these statements are true (I assume it's true that there is some problem with signal strength calculation), yet ridiculous at the same time. Yes, it's true based on the physics of antennas that holding the device is bound to affect or attenuate the signal--and that holds true for all smartphones. However, it is only the iPhone 4 that has such an issue with these basic laws of physics that it no longer functions as a phone--so apparently the iPhone 4 has a design flaw that doesn't exist in other smartphones.

Assuming that it's true that Apple has miscalculated signal strength for years, that is neither an explanation for the current problem, nor is fixing it a solution for the issues with the iPhone 4. Estimates suggest that nearly 80 percent of the iPhone 4 users upgraded from a previous iPhone model. Those 1.3 million iPhone 4 users were already subject to this alleged miscalculation for years, yet never noticed a problem until switching to the iPhone 4.

With my iPhone 3GS, I used to sometimes get annoyed at how I had to pull the phone away from my ear, and give it a shake to get the display to light up again if I had to enter a code to join a conference call or "press two" for customer service. Now, I long for that experience because instead I have a dysfunctional proximity sensor that enables and disables the display--creating a slow motion strobe effect throughout my calls--and resulting in random buttons being pressed, like turning on speakerphone, or hanging up the call without notice.

Apparently, one Apple Genius explained to an iPhone 4 customer that the problem is with his ear--not the proximity sensor on the iPhone 4. A blogger reported that he was informed that "Apparently, the re-location of the proximity sensor in iPhone 4 causes the sensor to be more likely to be triggered by light 'bouncing around the ear canal'."

The recommended solution? The Apple Genius told the blogger--allegedly with a straight face--"try closing the windows because extra ambient light bouncing around my ear will cause the sensor to light up the screen."


So--to sum up--the iPhone 4 does not have a signal issue, it just displays the signal bar icons wrong, but if you hold the iPhone 4 at just the right angle you might be able to maintain enough signal strength to carry on a call. But, make sure you don't clean your ears too often, and draw the curtains and turn off the lights or your ear might trip the proximity sensor and cause you to inadvertently hang up the call.

I haven't even addressed the exceptionally poor sound quality of calls on the iPhone 4, or the complaints of poor battery life spanning the iPhone 4, previous iPhone models, and iPod Touch devices following the upgrade to iOS4.

Can I just have my old iPhone 3GS back? Well, yes--but only if I act quickly. Apple has responded to the backlash and various law suits by dropping the restocking fee. Any iPhone 4 customer can return the iPhone 4 for a complete refund--as long as it is within 30 days of purchase. For those who purchased the iPhone 4 online, that clock started when the device was shipped, not when you received it and took it out of the box.

The problem is that returning to the iPhone 3GS is really the only viable option available at AT&T. The Android options are improving at AT&T, but are still notably inferior to the compelling Android smartphones available from other carriers. The HTC Aria is a step in the right direction, but AT&T won't have a truly competitive Android smartphone until it unleashes the Samsung Captivate later this year.

Besides, switching platforms is not that easy. What Apple understood, and other mobile OS developers have followed suit on, is that the app culture shackles you to the platform. Businesses have invested in a portfolio of apps to make the smartphone productive. Switching platforms means starting from scratch to find suitable alternative apps, and paying for them all over again.

Customers like me who pre-ordered the iPhone 4 online have a little less than two weeks to take advantage of the option to return the device for a full refund. Hopefully, Apple will stop living in denial, and issuing ridiculous explanations and workarounds, and really address the issues during that time. Otherwise, many iPhone 4 customers will be forced to make a difficult decision between the lesser of two evils.



Source http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/artic.../urnidgns852573C4006938800025775A0055B174.DTL


Canadians should be very thankful that Apple decided to release the iPhone 4 to the rest of the world before selling in Canada. If you buy one now, you can't say you weren't warned.
 
LOL

I don't think you'll find many people returning their iPhone 4s......

OTB
 
Perhaps the iPhone 5 will be better....:p
 
I'm starting to hate Apple fanboys. I was recently banned from a maclife.com fourm because I mentioned the iphone 4 problems and articles about them over there. A moderator even sent me a message simply telling me to 'fuck off'. What a bunch of losers. They seem to want to ignore the problems with Apple's products and act like they don't exist.

It's like they'd defend Mr. Jobs like he's their 'master' or something. I'd say he's their 'CULT' master for they are no different than a cult.
 
Has Apple removed the Defects yet in their prestigious Apple Iphone 4th, Generation Cell Phone?
Or else the newly launched Iphone would badly fail with masse, causing immense loss to Apple Inc and even their reputation would slightly dented:)
 
Lmao

I'm starting to hate Apple fanboys. I was recently banned from a maclife.com fourm because I mentioned the iphone 4 problems and articles about them over there. A moderator even sent me a message simply telling me to 'fuck off'. What a bunch of losers.

LOL!

No need to hate these fanbois. I find them terribly comically amusing as they fanatically defend all things Apple!
A few are no doubt Apple salesmen.....even though they deny it! You can see this in the way they rattle off the Mac sales spiel and Apple talking points at the drop of an AT&T call! What is even more funny is if they are not Apple sales staff as they claim. In this case they are bona fide 'cultists' with no life other than being on a mission from Stevo Jobs to spread the iWord on Apple!
They are an excitable bunch of wide eyed funny fanboi fellows....
woot_jump.gif
 
I'm probably gonna wait until after all these glitches are fixed. damn steven jobs you have to control your temper!
 
Have been snapping quite a few pics (and the occasional short movie) with my iPhone 4 - found out today that I can download those pics and movies to my iPad for a roomier view.... The photos look very good (as does the video but vie not taken enough to speak to it's quality yet) - no computer required, no file management required.

Handy duo these two....

OTB
 
Apple IPhone 4 Fails to Get Consumer Reports Backing

July 12 (Bloomberg) -- Consumer Reports said it isn’t recommending Apple Inc.’s iPhone 4 following tests confirming the handset has a hardware flaw that causes signal quality to degrade.
“The problem seems to be a design flaw, and it is significant,” Mike Gikas, senior electronics editor for Consumer Reports, said today in an interview. The publication has recommended the three previous iPhone models.
Tests were conducted in a room designed to eliminate radio- frequency interference, he said. The results showed that when a user covers the phone’s lower-left side, where two parts of the external antenna meet, the loss of signal strength may lead to dropped calls in areas where AT&T Inc.’s coverage is weak. The tests suggest AT&T’s network, often criticized for spotty iPhone coverage, isn’t responsible for the signal problems.
AT&T is the iPhone’s exclusive carrier in the U.S. Apple says the problem is software-related and involves how the phone displays signal strength. A fix will be released, the company said on July 2.
“If the signal is strong in the area, then you won’t lose the call,” Gikas said. Consumer Reports is published by the nonprofit Consumers Union, based in Yonkers, New York.
Natalie Kerris, a spokeswoman for Cupertino, California- based Apple, didn’t immediately return phone and e-mail messages seeking comment. Mark Siegel, a spokesman for AT&T in Dallas, had no comment.
More Phones Tested
Consumer Reports also tested other phones, including Apple’s older iPhone 3GS, and the Palm Pre, and found they didn’t suffer from the same problems as the iPhone 4, Gikas said.
Gikas suggested that users who experience the problem apply duct tape, which doesn’t conduct electricity, to the gap in order to reduce the chance of causing signal interference.
Apple has faced criticism since the phone went on sale June 24, with consumers complaining about losses of signal strength when holding the phone along its left-side black stripe.
Apple fell $2.34 to $257.29 at 4 p.m. New York time on the Nasdaq Stock Market. The shares have gained 22 percent this year.

source http://www.businessweek.com/news/20...-4-fails-to-get-consumer-reports-backing.html


but...but....Steve Jobs said you're holding it wrong ;)
 
Ouch!

Could Apple be becoming the Tech version of GM/Toyota quality-wise?!?!?.....
mf_w00t2.gif
 
Apple's Arrogance and the iPhone 4 Antenna Debacle

Life must suck today at One Infinite Loop. Just when Apple had hoped the hullabaloo over the iPhone 4's apparently faulty antenna was fading to a soft rumble, Consumer Reports comes along and drops a tactical nuclear strike, declaring the new iPhone unfit for public use. And based on the extensiveness of the venerable publication's in-house testing, it's hard to dismiss CR's take as an ill-informed, kneejerk reaction to a few dropped calls.

Indeed, the Antenna Crisis is getting uglier by the minute, and it's time for some serious crisis control from the folks in Cupertino. Another pseudo explanation, like the one on July 2 that fessed up to an iPhone signal-strength software glitch unrelated to the antenna design, won't cut it this time.

The company is in danger of losing its hard-earned reputation for excellent quality and service. If "bad antenna" is the first thing that pops into a consumer's head when an iPhone 4 ad appears, well, that can't be good for business.

So what are Apple's options? Four possibilities

Free bumpers for all:
This idea has been bandied about by numerous industry observers: Apple issues a mea culpa of sorts and ships a $29 rubber-and-plastic bumper to every iPhone 4 owner at no charge. The thick, non-conductive bumper would remedy the iPhone antenna glitch, but Apple's reputation for technical brilliance would suffer. (Then again, it already has.) Option B: Free duct tape to all. As Consumer Reports and others have noted, a strip of tape strategically applied across the iPhone's antenna gap is an effective if ugly fix.

Massive recall: This, no doubt, would be a worst-case scenario for Apple. The company recalls the millions of iPhone 4s already shipped and repairs the problem--assuming, of course, that a quick and easy fix is possible

Replacement rush job: Ready for the iPhone 4a? How about the iPhone 4G? It may be time for Apple to shorten its annual iPhone upgrade cycle and release a new model ASAP--a phone, of course, that wouldn't suffer from the current model's antenna woes. In a perfect world, iPhone 4 owners would get a free upgrade. While that act of consumer kindness would cost Apple a small fortune, the company has enjoyed gaudy profits in recent years and could certainly afford it.

Do nothing: This would be the stupidest approach, and one that would send potential iPhone 4 users scurrying to Android-based mobile phones, which are already experiencing an explosive growth in market share. Unfortunately, it seems closest to Apple's strategy thus far. With users on Apple support sites and message boards already expressing their doubts about Cupertino's lame explanation for the iPhone's antenna woes, a head-in-the-sand approach would be a disaster.


so far "Apple being Apple" seems to have chosen the do nothing approach
 
I have to say I think you're all running in circles for no reason.... I've not had the problem at all, I know 3 people with the iPhone 4, they don't have the issue either.... now I'll grant you that a sample of 4 is a long way from statistically significant but really....

OTB
 
Of course YOU have no problems.....

I'll bet ya nibs will back ya up on that!

This whole thing is probably a conspiracy thingy to make Apple look rotten!.....
roflmao.gif
 
Apple IPhone 4 Fails to Get Consumer Reports Backing

July 12 (Bloomberg) -- Consumer Reports said it isn’t recommending Apple Inc.’s iPhone 4 following tests confirming the handset has a hardware flaw that causes signal quality to degrade.
“The problem seems to be a design flaw, and it is significant,” Mike Gikas, senior electronics editor for Consumer Reports, said today in an interview. The publication has recommended the three previous iPhone models.
Tests were conducted in a room designed to eliminate radio- frequency interference, he said. The results showed that when a user covers the phone’s lower-left side, where two parts of the external antenna meet, the loss of signal strength may lead to dropped calls in areas where AT&T Inc.’s coverage is weak. The tests suggest AT&T’s network, often criticized for spotty iPhone coverage, isn’t responsible for the signal problems.
AT&T is the iPhone’s exclusive carrier in the U.S. Apple says the problem is software-related and involves how the phone displays signal strength. A fix will be released, the company said on July 2.
“If the signal is strong in the area, then you won’t lose the call,” Gikas said. Consumer Reports is published by the nonprofit Consumers Union, based in Yonkers, New York.
Natalie Kerris, a spokeswoman for Cupertino, California- based Apple, didn’t immediately return phone and e-mail messages seeking comment. Mark Siegel, a spokesman for AT&T in Dallas, had no comment.
More Phones Tested
Consumer Reports also tested other phones, including Apple’s older iPhone 3GS, and the Palm Pre, and found they didn’t suffer from the same problems as the iPhone 4, Gikas said.
Gikas suggested that users who experience the problem apply duct tape, which doesn’t conduct electricity, to the gap in order to reduce the chance of causing signal interference.
Apple has faced criticism since the phone went on sale June 24, with consumers complaining about losses of signal strength when holding the phone along its left-side black stripe.
Apple fell $2.34 to $257.29 at 4 p.m. New York time on the Nasdaq Stock Market. The shares have gained 22 percent this year.

source http://www.businessweek.com/news/20...-4-fails-to-get-consumer-reports-backing.html


but...but....Steve Jobs said you're holding it wrong ;)

However:

Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Consumer Reports ranks Apple's iPhone 4 best smartphone available

By Daniel Eran Dilger
Published: 07:00 AM EST

Despite saying it "can't recommend" iPhone 4 in its blog, Consumer Reports also assigns Apple's newest phone the "highest rated" score as the best smartphone currently available in its official paid research reports.

While waffling between official blog entires that first told users there's "no reason not to buy" iPhone 4 related to its antenna issues, and then backtracking to say it "can't recommend" the phone until Apple addresses its antenna issues with a free fix (after also noting that applying a piece of tape solves the signal attenuation issues it found in testing), Consumer Reports has ranked iPhone 4 the best smartphone on the market.

The group's latest blog entry did note in passing that, despite refusing to give iPhone 4 a "recommended" listing, "its score in our other tests placed it atop the latest ratings of smart phones that were released today."

However, web surfers interested in the group's official comparative rankings probably wouldn't notice that if they only follow the site's official blog and the avalanche of blog responses that its postings have generated, because visiting its online mobile phone rankings page only presents an ad asking visitors to pay for a subscription in order to view its rankings (below).




Once users pay for "complete access to smart phones," Consumer Reports represents a detailed outline of its cellphone rankings where the new iPhone 4 leads the pack with a "highest rated" score of 76 points out of a possible 100. The next-highest ranked phones are Apple's previous generation iPhone 3GS and the HTC Sprint Evo 4G, which are both ranked at 74 points overall.

As noted by John Paczkowski of the Wall Street Journal "Digital Daily" blog, the Consumer Reports paid evaluation rates the display, navigation, web browsing, multimedia and battery life of iPhone 4 as "excellent," gives its phoning and messaging a "very good" ranking, and describes voice quality as "good."
 
OTB, it would appear that Consumer Reports has clearly reversed their course here by not recommending the iPhone 4.
 
Last edited: