Ft.McMurray is burning.......

Virtually all of central and northern Alberta farmland was cleared in the last century. Most of it before the arrival of D9 Cats.
It's not that costly and is amazingly fast nowadays. Probably the city didn't even think of it or if so ran into opposition from residents who wanted to keep the forest in their back yard. After the Slave Lake fire maybe they should have considered doing some clearing.
 
Virtually all of central and northern Alberta farmland was cleared in the last century. Most of it before the arrival of D9 Cats.
It's not that costly and is amazingly fast nowadays. Probably the city didn't even think of it or if so ran into opposition from residents who wanted to keep the forest in their back yard. After the Slave Lake fire maybe they should have considered doing some clearing.

Really?
After Katrina should New York consider moving 50 miles inland?
 
I'm saying it's feasible and practical costwise. Moving New York is not.

So, as I mentioned before....where do you start and stop.

With this line of thinking, all settlements within the forested area should have a clearing around them, as I am sure most have an elevated risk for fire.

So, where does one start and stop?
 
Everyone likes their slice of nature so almost no one does make a clearing.
They live with the risk. Usually it's fine.
You may hear some lobbying from insurance companies on this.
 
Quick math lesson.

Fort Mac is about 60 square KM.
Let's assume it is perfectly square.
That means that a 1KM band around that square would be 111.5KM long.
That is 17,552 acres.
Average of 300 trees per acre in a boreal forest.
8,265,600 trees.

It will cost pennies to clear those trees and make this firebreak.

Maybe best if you teach English :)

Who would want to live in a city with no trees. Should we also cut down all the trees in Toronto so they dont fall on homes, cars and hydro lines.
 
Maybe best if you teach English :)

Who would want to live in a city with no trees. Should we also cut down all the trees in Toronto so they dont fall on homes, cars and hydro lines.

You lost the sarcasm in my response.
I posted that to mock how ludicrous another poster's suggestion of clearing a 1KM firebreak around every single city in the world is.
 
I'm saying it's feasible and practical costwise. Moving New York is not.

Here's what the fire chief said:

"I want to be clear," he said at the same news conference where Notley spoke. "With the nature of this fire and the dangerous conditions we have, no size of firebreak would hold this fire from doing anything. This fire jumped the Athabasca River, which is over a kilometre wide."

http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/edmonton/fort-mcmurry-wildfire-funding-1.3570772
 
Here's what the fire chief said:

"I want to be clear," he said at the same news conference where Notley spoke. "With the nature of this fire and the dangerous conditions we have, no size of firebreak would hold this fire from doing anything. This fire jumped the Athabasca River, which is over a kilometre wide."

http://www.cbc.ca/beta/news/canada/edmonton/fort-mcmurry-wildfire-funding-1.3570772



Pfffft.... what does the Fire Chief know! Obviously he is not as intelligent a brainstormer as Yoga Face!

Here is more of what the Fire Chief said. Yoga Face, please refer back to your posts in light of the Chief's statement.

"when asked why a firebreak wasn't built around Fort McMurray to prevent a repeat of what happened in Slave Lake, Morrison offered a blunt assessment.

"I want to be clear," he said at the same news conference where Notley spoke. "With the nature of this fire and the dangerous conditions we have, no size of firebreak would hold this fire from doing anything. This fire jumped the Athabasca River, which is over a kilometre wide."

Morrison cautioned people not to compare the two fires.
Slave Lake was a "wind-driven" wildfire that closed in on the town at great speed, pushed by gusts of up to 100 km/h, he said. This week's Fort McMurray wildfire is "fuel-driven" and grew so quickly because of tinder-dry conditions in an area of the province that hasn't seen any significant rain this spring.
The Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo has an active and effective fire-prevention program in place, Morrison said. But he stressed that no amount of preparedness and no protection measures would have saved Fort McMurray from the flames.


"This fire is jumping kilometres at a time. We're seeing fire spreads where it's creating its own lightning fires out of this fire. This is an extreme, rare, rare fire event. And that's something that's historic for us."
Morrison said wildfires that grow and move quickly are almost impossible to stop once they get rolling.
"These are dangerous, dangerous fires," he said. "Unpredictable. Mother Nature is going to move these fires on us, and we can only do as first-responders what you can do. And that is get people out of the way and try to protect as much of the community as we can."


 
"This is an example of what we expect -- and consistent with what we expect for climate change," said Mike Flannigan, a professor of wildland fire at the University of Alberta who's been studying climate change and wildfire for decades. "This fire is unprecedented," he said, referring to its local impact.
It's impossible for scientists to say global warming caused this specific fire, of course, but polluting the atmosphere is creating conditions that make such disasters more likely, bigger and costlier.

"In Canada, our area burned (by wildfire) has more than doubled since thLe early 70s," Flannigan said. "And we've published work that states that this is because of human-caused climate change.
"We also find -- and other researchers in the United States find -- that as the temperature increases we see more fire."
Hot, dry conditions helped created the perfect conditions for the fire near Fort McMurray. The remote town, which is the gateway to Canada's oil sands region, a hotbed of fossil fuel extraction, saw a high temperature of 91 Fahrenheit on Tuesday. The previous record of 82 degrees was set in 1945, according to government climate data.

Rachel Cleetus, lead economist and climate policy manager for the Union of Concerned Scientists, said climate change is "a significant contributing risk factor" in the Canada wildfires. There are other risk factors, like El Nino and our development patterns. But we can clearly see the climate risk factor because of where [the fire is] playing out geographically.
"We know the northern latitudes are warming faster than anywhere else."
"You definitely see the fingerprints of climate change," she said.

http://www.cnn.com/2016/05/06/opinions/sutter-canada-wildfire-climate/index.html

interesting read..
 

I firmly believe that humans pollute wayyyyyy too much and the effects are myriad. We are selfish pigs and live based on immediate gratification.


But this "journalist" is a biased propagandist using base fear mongering which is evident right from the headline.
[h=1]The fire in Canada looks a lot like climate change -- and that should scare you[/h]

And the rest of his writing is couched in such weasel words that he is barely able to back his position.

Pure drivel, despite the fact that I agree humans need to stop polluting the world we live in.
 
But this "journalist" is a biased propagandist using base fear mongering which is evident right from the headline.
[h=1]The fire in Canada looks a lot like climate change -- and that should scare you[/h]

This is a spring fire, with temperatures in the '30's combined with incredibly dry wood from lesser rain.
A fire of this size in the spring in Canada is very odd, and the combinations of extreme weather events that set up the conditions are along the lines of those predicted through climate change.

Certainly forest fires are not rare in this country, but at this time of year and this size it is quite unusual.
 
This is a spring fire, with temperatures in the '30's combined with incredibly dry wood from lesser rain.
A fire of this size in the spring in Canada is very odd, and the combinations of extreme weather events that set up the conditions are along the lines of those predicted through climate change.

Certainly forest fires are not rare in this country, but at this time of year and this size it is quite unusual.



Agreed that it has been a dry, hot spring. But there have been plenty of forest fires in the spring. What makes this one particularly newsworthy is that it occurred near, and has burned town a city.

I really don't know what to make of the various interpretations of "climate" change vs weather so am agnostic with specific regards to "climate" change. However, I am evangelical in my disgust with humanity and the way we exploit our resources and grossly pollute the earth. I was around when the nickel smelters in Sudbury effectively killed the (non-limestone based) lakes downwind. And all the follow on damages. And the recovery once the pollution stopped. So I am all for reducing pollution of all sorts. And I consider industrial and vehicle emissions as CO2 pollution.

However, I don't think all forest fires are bad, and I don't think that having more spring fires is evidence of global warming.
 
This is how the Ft.McMurray residents feel as of Wed taken off Facebook:

"Hey Canada what the hell are we letting happen right now!!! Our friends, our families are losing everything in Fort McMurray!!!

The city that has brought more money in this country let alone this provence then any other city is burning to the ground and why? Because the Alberta Government has turned its back on the energy sector and doesn't care what happens to Fort Mac. Hundreds of thousands of ppl have lost there jobs and livelihoods over the last year, yet where were the payouts to help them?!

So now while the beautiful city of Fort McMurray burns to the ground you finally win eh notley? The biggest part of The Alberta Oil Industry is about to be no more and where the hell are you?!

Instead of cutting our wild fire budget by 15million dollars and wasting stupid money on carbon taxes, bill 6 and 500million dollars to "Eco friendly training" we might have had more then 28 fire fighters in the city when the fires started.

And where is our military help Justin Trudeau?! Has Rachel not called to ask yet or what?!

Hey Mayor Nenshi, call these losers and teach these god damn children how to deal with a natural disaster and save our friends, save our families, and save what's left of Fort McMurray!!!!!

Do you think this 10,000 hector fire just started last night and engulfed the city?! No, this fire has been raging for weeks and the poor fire fighters of Fort McMurray have been dealing with it since and they have been doing so with no help, no resources, and insufficient equipment. With proper help and equipment when they asked for it they could have contained this fire or redirected it long before it ever even remotely become a concern for the city. But they were denied. And then Mother Nature decided to crank up the thermostat, turn on the fans and turn this fire into an unstoppable wall of fire and sent it straight to the city. And still as of now over half the city has been burned to the ground, and the fire is still growing and there's nothing they can do. And our premier has still not asked for help, still not declared a state of emergency with 80,000 ppl evacuated and losing everything. And now the places that the ppl from Fort McMurray has evacuated too are also under fire warnings and potential evacuation because the fires are still spreading. And as you can see, no one can do anything about it now as its too late. When it could have been dealt with weeks ago and saved our towns, country and wildlife. And let's just hope we can keep this to no loss of life!"


 
So I am all for reducing pollution of all sorts. And I consider industrial and vehicle emissions as CO2 pollution.

.

What do u think a forrest fire emits? CO2 as it is burned fossil fuels. I would like to see some info on the CO2 emitted in this fire vs industry and cars. I suspect manmade pollution pales in comparison