Ft.McMurray is burning.......

Oh fuck off.


What I am doing is called brainstorming

Sigh... more ninja back-editing!

You are not "brainstorming". You are proclaiming that you know what should be done and are accusing oil companies and government or criminal negligence for not being as prescient as you and carrying out your cockamamie schemes in advance!



I do not believe you were a Jet Ranger

When I was younger I "rode along" in a Jet Ranger working a forest fire for two days out of Chapeau.

WTF is a Jet Ranger that you think I claimed I was? Some sort of Super Hero? lol!

I said I RODE ALONG in Jet Ranger (a small helicopter manufactured by Bell) for a few days. Just helping to do shit/grunt work because my friend's company was short handed and needed a hand. Nothing to brag about. I just mentioned it because it gave me first hand knowledge and the feeling of the scale and enormity of even (relatively) small forest fires and I used it as a comparison against the unthinkably large Fort McMurray fires.

I've also witnessed a huge fire driven by the Santa Ana winds in San Diego back in the fall of 2003.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cedar_Fire

Having been that close to forests fire I can comprehend the enormity of them. And having spent time in the Fort McMurray area, and having been on these really cool jet boats that run up and down the Athabaskan River, and having flown around that area, and the oil sands to the north, I also have an idea of the enormity and complexity of the terrain and forests and size of the area.

But don't let my reality get in the way of your "brainstorming"!
 
I do not consider grassfires to be a major issue, nor underbrush, as they do not toss embers hundreds of feet into the air that travel thousands of yards

So, a firebreak, or at least a partial firebreak where applicable, around a modest size town would involve hundreds of thousands of acres? Was such a study ever done? How expensive would such a study be for a company that made billions in profit?


See my tagline where I say stupidity has a certain charm, but ignorance does not?

You don't need a "study" to do simple math. Draw a perimeter around the city, add some factor of say 25% for irregularities of terrain, then multiply that linear dimension by your proposed 1,000 meter wide firebreak and you have your area. Then multiply those acres/hectares by a few hundred trees each acre/hectare/

Then you only have to cut down that many tens of millions of trees! And cart off the brush!

Then what are you going to say to the people who like forests? Who think that trees have some value in our ecosystem?

Ok, back to you!

How about we have Suncor launch satellites with laser beams to clear cut the forest firebreak? And have them pay for automatic sprinklers for the forest!
 
Sigh... more ninja back-editing!

You are not "brainstorming". You are proclaiming that you know what should be done and are accusing oil companies and government or criminal negligence for not being as prescient as you and carrying out your cockamamie schemes in advance!





When I was younger I "rode along" in a Jet Ranger working a forest fire for two days out of Chapeau.

WTF is a Jet Ranger that you think I claimed I was? Some sort of Super Hero? lol!

I said I RODE ALONG in Jet Ranger (a small helicopter manufactured by Bell) for a few days. Just helping to do shit/grunt work because my friend's company was short handed and needed a hand. Nothing to brag about. I just mentioned it because it gave me first hand knowledge and the feeling of the scale and enormity of even (relatively) small forest fires and I used it as a comparison against the unthinkably large Fort McMurray fires.

I've also witnessed a huge fire driven by the Santa Ana winds in San Diego back in the fall of 2003.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cedar_Fire

Having been that close to forests fire I can comprehend the enormity of them. And having spent time in the Fort McMurray area, and having been on these really cool jet boats that run up and down the Athabaskan River, and having flown around that area, and the oil sands to the north, I also have an idea of the enormity and complexity of the terrain and forests and size of the area.

But don't let my reality get in the way of your "brainstorming"!

Now I know what a jet ranger is and doubt you rode in one, but that is of no concern

Yes, I do back edit, but not in a defensive way that is meant to counteract arguments that occur after my post

I am brainstorming and I am suggesting corporate accountability needs to be considered, after all they made billions and corporations have a horrible history of accountability
 
Ok, how do you feel companies with operations a hundred kilometres from this city are responsible to protect it from Mother Nature?

Any town is vulnerable to a single lightning strike.

Is it not enough that the BIG BAD CORPORATIONS have shut down their operations, sent their employees home so that they could house and feed the residents fleeing from the city? For free.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/fort-mcmurray-fire-oilsands-impact-1.3565696

"Suncor

The oil conglomerate's base oilsands plant is about 25 kilometres from the city, and while that site isn't in harms way, the company has removed all non-essential staff from the area as a precaution and to make room for evacuees.
"We are reducing production at our regional facilities in order to allow employees and their families to get to safety," the company said in a statement.
"We're providing transportation and accommodation to the region to support the evacuation," spokesman Paul Newmarch said. "We're making whatever we have available to support the evacuation."

Shell

Shell operates the Albian Sands facility almost 100 kilometres out of town, and while it too is not currently under fire danger, it has been shut down as a precaution, knocking almost 250,000 barrels a day worth of production offline.
"While our operations are currently far from the fires, we have shut down production at our Shell Albian Sands mining operations so we can focus on getting families out of the region," Shell spokesman Cameron Yost said.

"Right now, our priority is providing support for our people, their loved ones and others in the area. Our work camp, the Albian Village, is now open to all evacuated Fort McMurray residents who need a safe place to stay and we are evacuating non-essential staff to make room for those who need it most."
Shell's camp can accommodate up to 2,000 people.
[h=2]Husky Energy[/h]At Husky Energy, which operates the Sunrise oilsands facility about 60 kilometres north of the city, spokesman Mel Duvall said: "At this time, our operations at Sunrise are unaffected.
"We continue to monitor the situation and as a precaution have evacuated non-essential personnel. We have opened up our camp facilities to evacuees and are working with the municipality to accommodate as many people as possible. We are doing everything we can to assist those who have had to leave Fort McMurray in any way we can."
 
See my tagline where I say stupidity has a certain charm, but ignorance does not?

You don't need a "study" to do simple math. Draw a perimeter around the city, add some factor of say 25% for irregularities of terrain, then multiply that linear dimension by your proposed 1,000 meter wide firebreak and you have your area. Then multiply those acres/hectares by a few hundred trees each acre/hectare/

Then you only have to cut down that many tens of millions of trees! And cart off the brush!

Then what are you going to say to the people who like forests? Who think that trees have some value in our ecosystem?

Ok, back to you!

How about we have Suncor launch satellites with laser beams to clear cut the forest firebreak? And have them pay for automatic sprinklers for the forest!

Ball is in my court

Look, you may be right but I say draw that line and do a study then come up with a number than is not so wildly speculative then seriously consider what can be done through the scientific study of boreal fires

Tens of millions of trees seems wildly speculative and you are not destroying an ecosystem FFS and yes, the city would not be quite as pretty with less trees around it

the brush is of smaller concern as it does not ejaculate embers hundreds of feet into the air that travel thousands of yards

You seem content to accept your first thoughts as being definitive


I do not as I understand my ideas are unformed and I refer you to my definition of brain storming in post 52


We just lost, or may lose, an entire town and this was going to happen, just a matter of time

Considering the consequences of doing nothing, were are any proactive studies on prevention? If they exist, and no ideas were feasible, then I am wrong

If some like you was in charge then I assume no studies were done
 
Here is an intelligent, non-ignorant response:


Yoga Face: "Wow, I had no idea of the scale and cost of actually implementing my off-the-cuff idea. Oh well, I suppose there will be some sober second thought after this fire plays out and rebuilding begins"

Instead, you just keep on making yourself look ignorant and trying to make anyone with actual knowledge look like they are full of shit. Why would anyone be motivated to brag about having some peripheral or direct experience with forest fires and the specific area we are discussing?
 
Quick math lesson.

Fort Mac is about 60 square KM.
Let's assume it is perfectly square.
That means that a 1KM band around that square would be 111.5KM long.
That is 17,552 acres.
Average of 300 trees per acre in a boreal forest.
8,265,600 trees.

It will cost pennies to clear those trees and make this firebreak.
 
Ball is in my court

I say draw that line and do a study then come up with a number than is not so wildly speculative then seriously consider what can be done through the scientific study of boreal fires

You seem content to accept your first thoughts as being definitive



I do not as I understand my ideas are unformed and I refer you to my definition of brain storming in post 52

IMHO, you are being ignorant as you have a preconceived notion that nothing could have been done to stop this disaster

LOL!

Although I have not said it directly, and you have put words in my mouth... I will say that NOTHING practical could have been done to stop this disaster.

Clear cutting as you envision it is contrary to just about every policy that affects the real world. You simply cannot bubble wrap or build a wall or moat around everything. There are enormous complexities of other issues that are so far beyond your knowledge that it is a waste of energy to even attempt to educate you when you are so focussed on the ONE risk.

Think wildlife, think soil erosion, think water tables, think landslides etc etc.

Or think costs to the taxpayers to protect Fort McMurray alone, least of all every other town and city with trees around it? I know of the scale of costs to clear cut hydro and pipeline corridors through the wilderness. Use $25,000 per acre at a bare minimum.
 
Sooo.....do we clear cut around all the communities that are surrounded by bush? Just in case?

What about the highways that have fuel trucks driving on them, and are also the escape route?

Where do you draw the line?
 
$438Million, based on my rudimentary calculations.

But that price does not take into consideration any rough terrain nor do your numbers take into consideration the irregular shape that would follow the terrain.

But WTF are we wasting our time for anyways! lol
 
But that price does not take into consideration any rough terrain nor do your numbers take into consideration the irregular shape that would follow the terrain.

But WTF are we wasting our time for anyways! lol

I was just trying to keep my calculations as simple as possible!
It's a Friday afternoon and I am a few decades away from math class, so I'm rusty.
 
I was just trying to keep my calculations as simple as possible!
It's a Friday afternoon and I am a few decades away from math class, so I'm rusty.


Sorry pal, I don't mean to be criticizing your post. We are on the same page. I was just pointing out the smallest of the complexities of Yoga Face's Big Plan.
 
Sorry pal, I don't mean to be criticizing your post. We are on the same page. I was just pointing out the smallest of the complexities of Yoga Face's Big Plan.

Oh I know.
There is much more than just drawing a circle and calculating area.
I just had a few minutes and wanted to see if I could remember my calculations!
 
LOL!

Although I have not said it directly, and you have put words in my mouth... I will say that NOTHING practical could have been done to stop this disaster.

Clear cutting as you envision it is contrary to just about every policy that affects the real world. You simply cannot bubble wrap or build a wall or moat around everything. There are enormous complexities of other issues that are so far beyond your knowledge that it is a waste of energy to even attempt to educate you when you are so focussed on the ONE risk.

Think wildlife, think soil erosion, think water tables, think landslides etc etc.

Or think costs to the taxpayers to protect Fort McMurray alone, least of all every other town and city with trees around it? I know of the scale of costs to clear cut hydro and pipeline corridors through the wilderness. Use $25,000 per acre at a bare minimum.


My God schlong, you cannot be serious

You seem to think I am talking about hundreds of thousands of acres that will leave a barren landscape as far as the eye can see and will destroy water tables and upset eco systems and cause landslides and soil erosion (that can easily be stopped by the grasses and bushes that will grow)

First question is how big does the fire break need to be to have any effect ? then start counting trees but open your freakin' mind and do the study that will cost very little

Trees are all gone now, how much did that cost ?

If the city is going to be rebuilt then I hope they think of the future and study a fire break concept as now all they have to do is stop regrowth, or is that a silly idea to?
 
Well, that settles it, no need to do a scientific study when Schlong already knows the answer, yup, you are absolutely right Schlong . So let us rebuild the town and let the fucker burn down again whenever nature decides without even considering proactive measures


you-are-absolutely-right.gif