Okay, boomer
No offense, but yours is a very redundant take. All of your points were covered/conceded in the two videos. And by Brian Kenny, no less — so cool it with your “for people who follow statistics” lol.
You showed me by calling me Boomer! M
Some of my points were covered, some were not in my response. But my view is not redundant of his as I have arrived at a total different conclusion based purely on the semi-advanced or advanced stats he posted in his videos. That is my problem!
Kenny claimed that they were very close in offensive production prior to Barry taking steroids... said it multiple times. And that is not accurate. Before starting let's make it very clear - my issue is not with Fred McGriff's candidacy.
Your right he did talk about the all around aspects of the game re Bonds —Fine let's talk only about 3 offensive production analytics that he showed on video.
#1) In his first video, the first stats he showed was that Barry Bonds was #1 with runs created of 1320 over a period.... Mcgriff was #2 with 1084. (A bunch of guys were close to McGriff), No doubt this is an outstanding stat to show in support of McGriffs HOF case. He was very underrated in that period. And this is where Kenny should have kept going. But he decided to then veer off into the McGriff vs Bonds comparison for some reason. Its a ridiculous stat to show when he is going to make the claim later on that the two were very comparable in offensive production over that Era.
Bonds is 21% higher in runs created!! How is that even close or comparable!
#2) Let's look at the next chart he used that compares the first 10 years of their career, that was extremely cherry picked, (Bonds 86-95), McGriff (87-96). Let's start with his assessment that Bonds OPS+ of 168 in that period is just "Slightly" better than 153.... that is a difference of 10%. Not close to slight at all. McGriff's peak is from year 2 to year 8 of his career. While Bonds only hits his stride at year 5 of his career which he continues to year 13. Remember that Bonds has 13 years before steroids. So Kenny picks a period that conveniently captures all the prime period of McGriff, and misses nearly half of Bonds pre-steroid prime.
If Kenny is going to claim that Bonds is just slightly better than McGriff pre steroids shouldn't he be looking at their year 11, 12 and 13 seasons as well that were also non steroids? Bonds had OPS+ of 188,170, 178 in year 11, 12 and 13 with total offensive WAR of 23.0. McGriff in year 11,12,13 had OPS+ of 111,106 and 142 with offensive WAR of 7.8. Shouldn't those years also be considered in his analysis? That would make the OPS+ difference about 171 vs 145. Are those comparable offensive productions.
Bonds is 18% better than McGriff in OPS+ in their first 13 years. That is not close.
3) Later on he shows a start and says there OPS is very close, when Bonds has a .969 vs McGriff's .884. Once again that is not a very close OPS.
Going further if one was to look at offensive WAR in Bonds first 13 years it is 71 vs McGriff's 47. That is a massive difference. A portion of that difference is position related.
There is a reason that Bonds won 3 MVP's and was top 5 in MVP voting 7 times before the end of the 1998 season. Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract (as printed in 1999) had him 16th best player of all time - and this was before the steroid crazy season which began in 2000. And it wasn't just his all around game. He was one of the best offensive players of all time before hitting the juice.
Let's be very clear my attack is not on Fred McGriff. I think he is a very worthy Veterans Committee HOF. You can probably find some old posts of mine here that thought he should have been in the HOF regular ballot similar to Kenny's views. As I probably noted at the time he was hurt by the fact that a number of his best year (1988-1993) were before the juiced baseball era of 1994 (the ball and the players). His last high quality year was 1994, so some of his great years before that were "dwarfed" since they were so close to the juiced era. Also he had lots of walks and a high OBP which did hurt His RBI total — but not the team. New school voters tend to focus more on things like this which does help him as time has passed.