Crime Dog McGriff

I was surprised he wasn’t inducted on the first ballot, tbh. All the numbers are there, plus the narrative is strong with him and his postseason lore. More than worthy of HOF.

216 wins and a 6 time all star?.....Over 20 years.

Who are we going to compare him to who is in?
 
Last edited:
Okay, boomer :ROFLMAO:

No offense, but yours is a very redundant take. All of your points were covered/conceded in the two videos. And by Brian Kenny, no less — so cool it with your “for people who follow statistics” lol.

You showed me by calling me Boomer! M

Some of my points were covered, some were not in my response. But my view is not redundant of his as I have arrived at a total different conclusion based purely on the semi-advanced or advanced stats he posted in his videos. That is my problem!

Kenny claimed that they were very close in offensive production prior to Barry taking steroids... said it multiple times. And that is not accurate. Before starting let's make it very clear - my issue is not with Fred McGriff's candidacy.
Your right he did talk about the all around aspects of the game re Bonds —Fine let's talk only about 3 offensive production analytics that he showed on video.

#1) In his first video, the first stats he showed was that Barry Bonds was #1 with runs created of 1320 over a period.... Mcgriff was #2 with 1084. (A bunch of guys were close to McGriff), No doubt this is an outstanding stat to show in support of McGriffs HOF case. He was very underrated in that period. And this is where Kenny should have kept going. But he decided to then veer off into the McGriff vs Bonds comparison for some reason. Its a ridiculous stat to show when he is going to make the claim later on that the two were very comparable in offensive production over that Era. Bonds is 21% higher in runs created!! How is that even close or comparable!

#2) Let's look at the next chart he used that compares the first 10 years of their career, that was extremely cherry picked, (Bonds 86-95), McGriff (87-96). Let's start with his assessment that Bonds OPS+ of 168 in that period is just "Slightly" better than 153.... that is a difference of 10%. Not close to slight at all. McGriff's peak is from year 2 to year 8 of his career. While Bonds only hits his stride at year 5 of his career which he continues to year 13. Remember that Bonds has 13 years before steroids. So Kenny picks a period that conveniently captures all the prime period of McGriff, and misses nearly half of Bonds pre-steroid prime.

If Kenny is going to claim that Bonds is just slightly better than McGriff pre steroids shouldn't he be looking at their year 11, 12 and 13 seasons as well that were also non steroids? Bonds had OPS+ of 188,170, 178 in year 11, 12 and 13 with total offensive WAR of 23.0. McGriff in year 11,12,13 had OPS+ of 111,106 and 142 with offensive WAR of 7.8. Shouldn't those years also be considered in his analysis? That would make the OPS+ difference about 171 vs 145. Are those comparable offensive productions. Bonds is 18% better than McGriff in OPS+ in their first 13 years. That is not close.

3) Later on he shows a start and says there OPS is very close, when Bonds has a .969 vs McGriff's .884. Once again that is not a very close OPS.

Going further if one was to look at offensive WAR in Bonds first 13 years it is 71 vs McGriff's 47. That is a massive difference. A portion of that difference is position related.

There is a reason that Bonds won 3 MVP's and was top 5 in MVP voting 7 times before the end of the 1998 season. Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract (as printed in 1999) had him 16th best player of all time - and this was before the steroid crazy season which began in 2000. And it wasn't just his all around game. He was one of the best offensive players of all time before hitting the juice.


Let's be very clear my attack is not on Fred McGriff. I think he is a very worthy Veterans Committee HOF. You can probably find some old posts of mine here that thought he should have been in the HOF regular ballot similar to Kenny's views. As I probably noted at the time he was hurt by the fact that a number of his best year (1988-1993) were before the juiced baseball era of 1994 (the ball and the players). His last high quality year was 1994, so some of his great years before that were "dwarfed" since they were so close to the juiced era. Also he had lots of walks and a high OBP which did hurt His RBI total — but not the team. New school voters tend to focus more on things like this which does help him as time has passed.
 
Last edited:
216 wins and a 6 time all star?.....Over 20 years.

Who are we going to compare him to who is in?

Closest in terms of generation is probably Mussina .. 80 WAR vs 83 WAR.

There was a large batch from his era that were clear cut HOF pitchers that got in very early - Maddox, Johnson, Clemens (if not juiced), Smoltz, Glavine, Pedro.

There is not many borderline — in or out — pitchers — Mussina, Pettitte and Schilling I suppose are each others comps.

I went back and forth on Schilling as a regular ballot HOF pitcher. And disregarded his being an asshole as that should not be relevant (and his asshole status is not based on his politics).

As a veterans committee candidate he is clearly the best pitcher not in the HOF in my view — so be should get in under that category.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
You showed me by calling me Boomer! M

Some of my points were covered, some were not in my response. But my view is not redundant of his as I have arrived at a total different conclusion based purely on the semi-advanced or advanced stats he posted in his videos. That is my problem!

Kenny claimed that they were very close in offensive production prior to Barry taking steroids... said it multiple times. And that is not accurate. Before starting let's make it very clear - my issue is not with Fred McGriff's candidacy.
Your right he did talk about the all around aspects of the game re Bonds —Fine let's talk only about 3 offensive production analytics that he showed on video.

#1) In his first video, the first stats he showed was that Barry Bonds was #1 with runs created of 1320 over a period.... Mcgriff was #2 with 1084. (A bunch of guys were close to McGriff), No doubt this is an outstanding stat to show in support of McGriffs HOF case. He was very underrated in that period. And this is where Kenny should have kept going. But he decided to then veer off into the McGriff vs Bonds comparison for some reason. Its a ridiculous stat to show when he is going to make the claim later on that the two were very comparable in offensive production over that Era. Bonds is 21% higher in runs created!! How is that even close or comparable!

#2) Let's look at the next chart he used that compares the first 10 years of their career, that was extremely cherry picked, (Bonds 86-95), McGriff (87-96). Let's start with his assessment that Bonds OPS+ of 168 in that period is just "Slightly" better than 153.... that is a difference of 10%. Not close to slight at all. McGriff's peak is from year 2 to year 8 of his career. While Bonds only hits his stride at year 5 of his career which he continues to year 13. Remember that Bonds has 13 years before steroids. So Kenny picks a period that conveniently captures all the prime period of McGriff, and misses nearly half of Bonds pre-steroid prime.

If Kenny is going to claim that Bonds is just slightly better than McGriff pre steroids shouldn't he be looking at their year 11, 12 and 13 seasons as well that were also non steroids? Bonds had OPS+ of 188,170, 178 in year 11, 12 and 13 with total offensive WAR of 23.0. McGriff in year 11,12,13 had OPS+ of 111,106 and 142 with offensive WAR of 7.8. Shouldn't those years also be considered in his analysis? That would make the OPS+ difference about 171 vs 145. Are those comparable offensive productions. Bonds is 18% better than McGriff in OPS+ in their first 13 years. That is not close.

3) Later on he shows a start and says there OPS is very close, when Bonds has a .969 vs McGriff's .884. Once again that is not a very close OPS.

Going further if one was to look at offensive WAR in Bonds first 13 years it is 71 vs McGriff's 47. That is a massive difference. A portion of that difference is position related.

There is a reason that Bonds won 3 MVP's and was top 5 in MVP voting 7 times before the end of the 1998 season. Bill James Historical Baseball Abstract (as printed in 1999) had him 16th best player of all time - and this was before the steroid crazy season which began in 2000. And it wasn't just his all around game. He was one of the best offensive players of all time before hitting the juice.


Let's be very clear my attack is not on Fred McGriff. I think he is a very worthy Veterans Committee HOF. You can probably find some old posts of mine here that thought he should have been in the HOF regular ballot similar to Kenny's views. As I probably noted at the time he was hurt by the fact that a number of his best year (1988-1993) were before the juiced baseball era of 1994 (the ball and the players). His last high quality year was 1994, so some of his great years before that were "dwarfed" since they were so close to the juiced era. Also he had lots of walks and a high OBP which did hurt His RBI total — but not the team. New school voters tend to focus more on things like this which does help him as time has passed.
Too long; didn’t read.

Watch the videos again and stop being so angry. JFC, no one is saying Bonds isn’t the much better player. Especially not Brian Kenny, who lead the charge in bringing sabermetrics mainstream.
 
Too long; didn’t read.

Watch the videos again and stop being so angry. JFC, no one is saying Bonds isn’t the much better player. Especially not Brian Kenny, who lead the charge in bringing sabermetrics mainstream.

You are the person that came out firing with personal insults and now you are accusing me of being angry?

I specifically noted 3 comments / data points in his videos where he said things were very close between them in terms of offensive production analytics (Runs Created, OPS+, OPS) when they were not. But you chose not to read my points -- that's not my problem. Why would I go back to watch the video again - I already agree with his standalone analyis of McGriff. I have already found several data points in his own video that counter his comparison of Bonds being only a bit better than McGriff. And I have already found that he cherry picked data to fit his narrative in that regard.

And my issue is clearly not the use of sabermetrics as I know Kenny pushes that stuff, and I am good with that.

But since you like things sort, I'll keep it short for you.
You are on my ignore list. You are not worth my time.

Thank you. Blank you. Bye
 
Last edited:
Closest in terms of generation is probably Mussina .. 80 WAR vs 83 WAR.

There was a large batch from his era that were clear cut HOF pitchers that got in very early - Maddox, Johnson, Clemens (if not juiced), Smoltz, Glavine, Pedro.

There is not many borderline — in or out — pitchers — Mussina, Pettitte and Schilling I suppose are each others comps.

I went back and forth on Schilling as a regular ballot HOF pitcher. And disregarded his being an asshole as that should not be relevant (and his asshole status is not based on his politics).

As a veterans committee candidate he is clearly the best pitcher not in the HOF in my view — so be should get in under that category.

I didn't see the high WAR until you alerted me to it. Thanks.

Yes with that number he should be highly considered.

Believe as a Yankee fan I'm quite aware of how dominant he was.

While we're at it. If Jim Kaat is in. Should Jerry Koosman get the nod as well? Man Kaat was a great fielding pitcher.
 
You are the person that came out firing with personal insults and now you are accusing me of being angry?

I specifically noted 3 comments / data points in his videos where he said things were very close between them in terms of offensive production analytics (Runs Created, OPS+, OPS) when they were not. But you chose not to read my points -- that's not my problem. Why would I go back to watch the video again - I already agree with his standalone analyis of McGriff. I have already found several data points in his own video that counter his comparison of Bonds being only a bit better than McGriff. And I have already found that he cherry picked data to fit his narrative in that regard.

And my issue is clearly not the use of sabermetrics as I know Kenny pushes that stuff, and I am good with that.

But since you like things sort, I'll keep it short for you.
You are on my ignore list. You are not worth my time.

Thank you. Blank you. Bye
Dude, we are celebrating Fred in the HOF and you come out firing with novels on how he’s nowhere near as great as one of the greatest players of all time… talk about tone deaf LOL. And after accusing me of not following statistics, lol, I still couched my rebuttal with ‘no offense, but your point is redundant’ because the videos acknowledged Bonds was much better.

It was a comparison to show how they were both great hitters and in some categories not far off from one another. No one in their right minds would think they were the same player during that time, and the analysis was just to illustrate how much better McGriff was than his numbers would suggest (as those stats look almost pedestrian by 21st century standards).
 
Thanks for your contribution to a thread on Fred McGriff getting into the HOF.
I was responding to the poster who mentioned Jim Kaat and Jerry Koosman. Some members can walk and talk at the same time, one can't

"While we're at it. If Jim Kaat is in. Should Jerry Koosman get the nod as well? Man Kaat was a great fielding pitcher."

Note: "Walking and talking is a type of dual tasking which requires a lot of mental resources to be able to do safely. A complex cascade of cognitive processes occurs as an individual assesses the hazard associated with continuing to walk and focusing on balance vs. continuing their conversation."
 
Last edited:
I was surprised he wasn’t inducted on the first ballot, tbh. All the numbers are there, plus the narrative is strong with him and his postseason lore. More than worthy of HOF.
If Schilling is HOF worthy then so is Luis Tiant (more wins and better ERA).
 
Luis Tiant has a better ERA than Mussina, Pettitte and Schilling.

I was looking for comparables in Schilling's era -- so I was referring to pitchers that started in the era between say 1985-1995. His era would not include a pitcher who started pitching in the mid 60's

Regarding Tiant's ERA being better - not surprising as he pitched in a much lower run scoring period.
There is a stat called ERA+ that calculates a pitchers ERA relative to his years pitched with 100 being average.

Tiants ERA+ is 114
Schillng is 127
Mussina is 123
Pettitte is 118

To put these into perspective say the average ERA for a period was 3.50. Schilling would be at 2.75 and Tiant would be at 3.14.

Tiant was still a good pitcher -- but there are so many pitchers that pitched around his time that had far better careers that makes it hard to justify him as a HOF ... Carlton, Ryan, Seaver, Palmer, Niekro, Perry, Jenkins -- I'm sure I am missing a few -- it was a great era for long time starters that you just don't see anymore.
 
Last edited:
If Schilling is HOF worthy then so is Luis Tiant (more wins and better ERA).
The post above is a nice introduction to more advanced stat forms of ERA (although the math is slightly off on how much less than the hypothetical 3.50 league average; Schilling and Tiant should be slightly lower).

As for Wins, they serve no use in evaluating a pitcher’s performance, as Wins are a product of circumstances outside of the pitcher’s control.
 
I didn't see the high WAR until you alerted me to it. Thanks.

Yes with that number he should be highly considered.

Believe as a Yankee fan I'm quite aware of how dominant he was.

While we're at it. If Jim Kaat is in. Should Jerry Koosman get the nod as well? Man Kaat was a great fielding pitcher.

Both Kaat, Koosman were before more time. I see they were only all stars 3 and 2 times respectively so neither were consistently dominant.

As an aside, the modern version of Jim Kaat is probably Jamie Moyer - similar career WAR (around 50), 269 wins vs 283 wins, both pitched forever but not a top pitcher in the league very often.

I'm not sure Kaat should be a HOF based on modern analytics (WAR of 53). I think the wins (283) and defensive prowess and the fact that he seemed well respected by his peers got him in the end.
But he was never really consistently amongst the best in his era. Koosman has a WAR of 50, much less wins (222). So many great pitchers that straddled the 70's. I don't think he deserves to get in, even using Kaat as a basline based on the big difference of wins.

I would certainly put Taint well ahead of Koosman and arguably ahead of Kaat as well.
 
Both Kaat, Koosman were before more time. I see they were only all stars 3 and 2 times respectively so neither were consistently dominant.

As an aside, the modern version of Jim Kaat is probably Jamie Moyer - similar career WAR (around 50), 269 wins vs 283 wins, both pitched forever but not a top pitcher in the league very often.

I'm not sure Kaat should be a HOF based on modern analytics (WAR of 53). I think the wins (283) and defensive prowess and the fact that he seemed well respected by his peers got him in the end.
But he was never really consistently amongst the best in his era. Koosman has a WAR of 50, much less wins (222). So many great pitchers that straddled the 70's. I don't think he deserves to get in, even using Kaat as a basline based on the big difference of wins.

I would certainly put Taint well ahead of Koosman and arguably ahead of Kaat as well.

It could argued that neither Koosman or Kaat pitched for very good teams as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maurice93
It could argued that neither Koosman or Kaat pitched for very good teams as well.

True and that hurt their wins total (when they mattered more to the public) and may have cost them a few all star games. But their more advanced stats just don't come close to compare with most of the greats of that time.

The one pitcher who seems to have really benefited from pitching on great teams in that time was Catfish Hunter, who matched his good years with great Oakland teams.

Not my time, so working with some uncertainty here but many great pitchers in that 1965-1980 range didn't pitch for great teams - Jenkins, Perry, Niekro.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
216 wins and a 6 time all star?.....Over 20 years.

Who are we going to compare him to who is in?
I don't think he's worthy of a first ballot vote but he should have gotten in eventually. The only reason he didn't was politics.
216 regular season wins with a 3.46 ERA and 1.137 WHIP with over 3,000 strikeouts. Cy Young runner up 3 times. All star 6 times.
Has an NLCS MVP and a WS MVP with a post season record of 11-2 with a 2.23 ERA and 0.968 WHIP.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle and ETH
Talking about Moyer, Kaat, Koosman and Luis Tiant being considered for the HOF...Roger Clemens has won 7 Cy Youngs.
 
The post above is a nice introduction to more advanced stat forms of ERA (although the math is slightly off on how much less than the hypothetical 3.50 league average; Schilling and Tiant should be slightly lower).
Interesting to note that there is a more advanced stat form of ERA.

As for Wins, they serve no use in evaluating a pitcher’s performance, as Wins are a product of circumstances outside of the pitcher’s control.
Agree. Koufax and Drysdale were great pitchers on weak hitting teams. There was one game where the Dodgers won 1-0, Drysdale hit the HR to win his own game.