OPINION
Editorials
Blog
Columnists
Columnists Home Rod Dreher William McKenzie Mark Davis Carl P. Leubsdorf Editorials
Op-Ed
Local Voices
Letters to the Editor
Letters to the Editor Home Send a Letter Sunday Commentary
North-South Dallas Project
Ask the Editor
Political Forums/Tools
Advertising
Comments 215 | Recommend 66
Email
Print
RSS
Yahoo! Buzz
Editorial: Dallas cop doesn’t deserve his badge
06:54 PM CDT on Thursday, March 26, 2009
The conduct of Dallas police Officer Robert Powell in the Ryan Moats matter beggars belief. A frantic Moats, emergency flashers blinking, had run a red light rushing to Baylor Regional Medical Center in Plano, where his wife’s mother was upstairs dying.
'I can screw you over'
Excerpts from the 17-minute exchange between Dallas police Officer Robert Powell and Ryan Moats last week. The video is available in edited and unedited form at dallasnews.com/video:
Moats: "You really want to go through this right now? My mother-in-law is dying. Right now! … I got seconds before she’s dying, man!"
Powell: "If my mom was dying, I’d probably be a little upset, too, but when I saw flashing red and blue [lights], I’d stop."
Moats: "If you’re going to give me a ticket, just give me a ticket. … All I’m asking you is just hurry up."
Powell: "I can screw you over. I’d rather not do that. … I could charge you with fleeing right now. Understand what I could do. … I could make your life very difficult."
Moats stood outside the emergency room pleading with the officer to let him go so he could say goodbye to his mother-in-law. The officer was unmoved.
“I can screw you over,” he told Moats, as he took his time writing a ticket for running that red light. “I’d rather not do that.”
By the time Powell finished, about 15 minutes after the stop, Jonetta Collinsworth was dead.
Moats didn’t get there in time.
I can screw you over. True enough. And that’s why Robert Powell, despite an otherwise clean service record, has no business on the street as a Dallas cop.
In a society ruled by law, a sacred contract exists between the police and the people they protect and serve. We grant them extraordinary powers and need them to do their duty to keep the rest of us safe. We also expect them to use those powers wisely. When they abuse power — one or all — they cede authority.
Judging from the videotape from the officer’s car, the young cop — 25 years old, with only three years on the job — abused the power of his badge. Yes, Moats violated a traffic law; under the circumstances, who wouldn’t? Powell may have been within his rights to sanction Moats, but how he did it was appallingly unjust and cruel.
Worse, Powell speaks on the tape like a penny-ante sadist relishing the power he had to ruin someone’s evening. Even as hospital personnel emerged to vouch for the family’s desperate situation, Powell remained unmoved. There is no evidence that Powell, who is white, acted out of racist motive toward Moats, a black NFL running back, but that suspicion is on a lot of minds today.
Also Online
What's The Big Story? Find out at dallasnews.com/opinion
Blog: Opinion
When the face of the law belongs to an immature officer who uses it to poke desperate citizens for apparent pleasure, it stains an entire department. Dallas Police Chief David Kunkle has demonstrated time and again that he takes this behavior seriously. We expect that he will oversee a complete investigation and administer appropriate punishment — including dismissal, if warranted by a cool-headed appraisal of the facts.
The truth is, there are Dallas cops guilty of worse fired by Kunkle, only to be reinstated on appeal. If Powell gets pink-slipped for this, he could join them. That might be a legal outcome, but in light of what the Moats incident reveals about Powell’s temperament, an unjust one. What bitter irony that would be.
No appeals judge can take away the penalty of self-knowledge Powell has to live with forever: that in a matter of life and death, he screwed over a fellow human being. Just because he could.