Sorry to see you stopping, I was quite enjoying this discussion....
But, as for youth crime, the kid WAS breaking the law by skateboarding where prohibited.
So, let's look at the progression here:
1) he skates wherever he wants to with no recourse and hey, no one can stop him because they might traumatize him.
2) Someone DOES stop him that teaches him that he can't do whatever he wants wherever he wants.
3) The other two kids were polite and STFU and we let off with nothing more than "don't skate here". The other mouthy kid starts talking back to the cop.
4) The cop does nothing, that teaches the kid that he can say whatever he wants to the cops and they can't do a thing about it. Oh yeah, that teaches him respect all right and to be a lawabiding citizen. Maybe all those adults who ended up getting tazered over a traffic stop were just like this kid?
5) The cop DOES something (like disobeying a police officer) and get's pushed to the ground. What does that teach you? When a cop tells you to do something, you do it..>EOS< But now, the cop is in trouble for his actions. That teaches the kid that you can do whatever you want, ignore the orders of a police officer, and disrespect them.....Oh yeah, that's a good lesson to teach him.....
Now I will tell you something: When I was 12ish I got caught stealing a nerf football at a store. (not a good idea in my neighbourhood) The cop who came to the store grabbed me by the lapels, dragged me out of the store and threw me into the back of the cop car. There (this is before there were plastic barriers) he leaned over the back of the seat and read me the riot act.
Did I steal again? HELL no. Even when I was out with buddies and they started pocketing things I bailed. Even when they broke into a local bakery I bailed....(I didn't know they were going to do it when we started out). They all ended up with criminal records and progressed to harder and bigger crimes.
Nope, sorry, the way I see from personal experience if anyone (cops, teachers, parents, neighbours) catches a kid doing something wrong and DOES SOMETHING ABOUT IT THAT LEAVES AN IMPRESSION I strongly feel that many teens, pre-teens, etc wouldn't go down the wrong path.
But, as for youth crime, the kid WAS breaking the law by skateboarding where prohibited.
So, let's look at the progression here:
1) he skates wherever he wants to with no recourse and hey, no one can stop him because they might traumatize him.
2) Someone DOES stop him that teaches him that he can't do whatever he wants wherever he wants.
3) The other two kids were polite and STFU and we let off with nothing more than "don't skate here". The other mouthy kid starts talking back to the cop.
4) The cop does nothing, that teaches the kid that he can say whatever he wants to the cops and they can't do a thing about it. Oh yeah, that teaches him respect all right and to be a lawabiding citizen. Maybe all those adults who ended up getting tazered over a traffic stop were just like this kid?
5) The cop DOES something (like disobeying a police officer) and get's pushed to the ground. What does that teach you? When a cop tells you to do something, you do it..>EOS< But now, the cop is in trouble for his actions. That teaches the kid that you can do whatever you want, ignore the orders of a police officer, and disrespect them.....Oh yeah, that's a good lesson to teach him.....
Now I will tell you something: When I was 12ish I got caught stealing a nerf football at a store. (not a good idea in my neighbourhood) The cop who came to the store grabbed me by the lapels, dragged me out of the store and threw me into the back of the cop car. There (this is before there were plastic barriers) he leaned over the back of the seat and read me the riot act.
Did I steal again? HELL no. Even when I was out with buddies and they started pocketing things I bailed. Even when they broke into a local bakery I bailed....(I didn't know they were going to do it when we started out). They all ended up with criminal records and progressed to harder and bigger crimes.
Nope, sorry, the way I see from personal experience if anyone (cops, teachers, parents, neighbours) catches a kid doing something wrong and DOES SOMETHING ABOUT IT THAT LEAVES AN IMPRESSION I strongly feel that many teens, pre-teens, etc wouldn't go down the wrong path.