Scherzer signing is horrible. He's 40 years old and has pitched a total of 88 innings the past two seasons. I would have rather gotten Verlander for that same price.
Its 196, not 88. You only took Max's 2023 stats with Texas, and didn't add the 108 innings he pitched with the Mets in 2023.
As for Verlander over him. I don't see it. Verlander only pitched 88 innings himself last year, and he was far less productive with an ERA of 5.48. The predictive pitch analytic stuff (velocity, spin, contact whiff rate) show that Scherzer was a fair bit better than Verlander last year, as well as the traditional stats. Of course we are still dealing with just 43 innings vs 88. Both come with similar risks. I think the Giants and Jays would be happy to get 100 innings of sub 4.00 era from either one of them.
Last edited:

