Munk Debate on Zionism

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto
Shazi, those orders were given to both Israel and Hamas.
His order to return the hostages from Oct.7 were directed at Hamas. Israel took no hostages on Oct.7. They were to busy being raped and slaughtered.

Has Hamas obeyed those orders? Yes or no, Geno. Forget any excuses. Yes or no. Have they returned those hostages immediately and with no qualifications.
 

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
88,810
21,062
113
His order to return the hostages from Oct.7 were directed at Hamas. Israel took no hostages on Oct.7. They were to busy being raped and slaughtered.

Has Hamas obeyed those orders? Yes or no, Geno. Forget any excuses. Yes or no. Have they returned those hostages immediately and with no qualifications.
Shazi, you're lying again.
Both sides were ordered to return hostages and both sides were ordered to ceasefire.
On top of that Israel was ordered to prevent killing Palestinians, allow all aid through and charge those inciting genocide.
You haven't been charged yet, have you?

Clearly Israel is not abiding by the UNSC, ICC and ICJ.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto
Shazi, you're lying again.
Both sides were ordered to return hostages and both sides were ordered to ceasefire.
On top of that Israel was ordered to prevent killing Palestinians, allow all aid through and charge those inciting genocide.
You haven't been charged yet, have you?

Clearly Israel is not abiding by the UNSC, ICC and ICJ.
So you agree, Geno, that Hamas was ordered by the UN to return the hostages taken on Oct.7 and they have not. The UN said to do so unconditionally therefore what Israel does or doesn't do is irrelevant. It is not a condition that gives Hamas permission to disobey the UN. Condemn Hamas for not complying with the UN.
 

Klatuu

Well-known member
Dec 31, 2022
5,011
2,911
113
So you agree, Geno, that Hamas was ordered by the UN to return the hostages taken on Oct.7 and they have not. The UN said to do so unconditionally therefore what Israel does or doesn't do is irrelevant. It is not a condition that gives Hamas permission to disobey the UN. Condemn Hamas for not complying with the UN.
Deflection
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter

southpaw

Well-known member
May 21, 2002
1,711
1,455
113
Every Israeli citizen gets a vote in a free election. That is democracy:

The blacks in S. Africa did not get a vote. That was but ONE aspect of S. African apartheid.
How to claim an apartheid ethnostate is a "democracy": Just exclude half the population from participating.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu and Kautilya

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
88,810
21,062
113
So you agree, Geno, that Hamas was ordered by the UN to return the hostages taken on Oct.7 and they have not. The UN said to do so unconditionally therefore what Israel does or doesn't do is irrelevant. It is not a condition that gives Hamas permission to disobey the UN. Condemn Hamas for not complying with the UN.
How can Hamas return hostages when they are being bombed and every time they go out they are shot by snipers?
How many hostages do you want Israel to kill?

If you want them back, you need a ceasefire.

Did you see what Israel does to their hostages?
fucking nazis

 
  • Angry
Reactions: Klatuu

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
88,810
21,062
113
Your definition of lying is to quote the document?

But sure, go to the muddy language of clause 20 instead of the extremely clear text in clauses 1, 2, and 3.
Yes, when you use partial quotes it is lying.
The UN ceasefire calls for both sides to stop.

Netanyahu negotiated with Hamas and 105 hostages were returned with no killing.
If you want them back, you need a ceasefire.

Meanwhile, Israeli concentration camps are just expanding.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

Frankfooter

dangling member
Apr 10, 2015
88,810
21,062
113
1. Welcomes the new ceasefire proposal announced on May 31, which Israel accepted, calls upon Hamas to also accept it

Instead, Hamas sent a new set of demands.

And the UN, ICC, and ICJ were 100% about Hamas' hostages. The fact that you think Hamas is justified doesn't change what any of those groups said.
You are the shittiest hasbara troll, basketcase.
Biden submitted that ceasefire plan to the UNSC claiming Israel agreed.
When it was passed Netanyahu declared he didn't agree and would never ceasefire until he's implement his final solution and 'finished the job'.


 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto
How to claim an apartheid ethnostate is a "democracy": Just exclude half the population from participating.
Democracy is a term relating to a free election to determine who governs. Every citizen gets to vote. Apartheid is a term that describes how some citizens are discriminated against by governmental policy compared to other citizens and has nothing to do with who or how a person or party comes into power.

They are two separate topics.
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto
Denial of citizenship to certain people in territories that a certain other ethnic group controls is apartheid 101. The black South Africans who resided within the white minority controlled South Africa, were denied citizenship the same way Palestinians who live in Israeli controlled West Bank, are denied citizenship. And denial of citizenship is the tip of the iceberg. Then come the walls, the segregation, the separate laws for each group, the racial discrimination etc.,
Learn history. At one point, blacks in S. Africa were citizens with full rights but the governmental policy of apartheid took many of those rights away. Palis on the West Bank or in Gaza were never citizens. As such no rights of citizenship were ever taken away from them. There is no apartheid and the UN's lack of a resolution saying that bears me out. They passed a resolution in 1963 condemning S. Africa of just that, apartheid. This is documented history. These are my facts and this is my logic.

Please stop with your idiotic claims. I've educated you multiple times already.

You have been educated time and again on this, yet you stick to your illogical diatribes.
I have been educated throughout my life by intelligent and educated people. I would never include you in that group.

respond back to me unless you are willing to use facts and actual logic (not the one you claim they taught you at the UofT). I am saying this out of concern for you because you will inevitably end up pretzeling yourself and making yourself look foolish as you have been for more than 1000 pages in various threads.
Worry about yourself and all the people that mock you for your inability to maintain a coherent conversation. Should I name them all?
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto
Ending the occupation would have ended that need.
No it wouldn't. Hamas has stated that they want to eradicate all Jews in the area. They will keep bombing and attacking.
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto
How can Hamas return hostages when they are being bombed and every time they go out they are shot by snipers?
The UN said UNCONDITIONALLY.

Do you understand English? It means that the UN doesn't give a shit about what's going on around them.

Are you saying NOW that we shouldn't listen to what the UN says? Are you changing your policy regarding statements from the UN?
 

shack

Nitpicker Extraordinaire
Oct 2, 2001
50,345
9,386
113
Toronto

Klatuu

Well-known member
Dec 31, 2022
5,011
2,911
113
Learn history. At one point, blacks in S. Africa were citizens with full rights but the governmental policy of apartheid took many of those rights away. Palis on the West Bank or in Gaza were never citizens. As such no rights of citizenship were ever taken away from them. There is no apartheid and the UN's lack of a resolution saying that bears me out. They passed a resolution in 1963 condemning S. Africa of just that, apartheid. This is documented history. These are my facts and this is my logic.

Please stop with your idiotic claims. I've educated you multiple times already.

I have been educated throughout my life by intelligent and educated people. I would never include you in that group.


Worry about yourself and all the people that mock you for your inability to maintain a coherent conversation. Should I name them all?
Unaware of history. Inculcated with racist ziontology myths from birth.
 

southpaw

Well-known member
May 21, 2002
1,711
1,455
113
Apartheid is a term that describes how some citizens are discriminated against by governmental policy compared to other citizens and has nothing to do with who or how a person or party comes into power.
How to claim an apartheid ethnostate is a "democracy": Deny citizenship to half the population, but also deny them their own state.
 
Toronto Escorts