Court has ruled Emergencies Act during Trucker convoy was unconstitutional

JuanGoodman

Goldmember
Jun 29, 2019
4,901
4,510
113
It was causing a $4 billion loss per day to the Canadian economy. The Police were able to end it. But did it make sense with you for this convoy to then block this flow of goods?
Both Trudeau and Ford agreed with the need to remove this blockade ASAP, unless you believe that it was of no issue to you!!
it was a first real show of resistance to the draconian measures put forth by our government

it had to be done to stop Trudeau from completely running a mock
 
  • Like
Reactions: dvous11

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,870
70,474
113
Do you prefer a different term for "guilty" that would make you feel comforted in his defence?
I have no problem with "the decision to issue the Proclamation does not bear the hallmarks
of reasonableness – justification, transparency and intelligibility – and was not justified in
relation to the relevant factual and legal constraints that were required to be taken into
consideration."

I have no problem with saying the government violated the rights of some people and they should be allowed to sue because of it.

I do have a problem with saying "Mr Trudeau was found guilty" because that isn't what was being determined here.
 

JuanGoodman

Goldmember
Jun 29, 2019
4,901
4,510
113
I have no problem with "the decision to issue the Proclamation does not bear the hallmarks
of reasonableness – justification, transparency and intelligibility – and was not justified in
relation to the relevant factual and legal constraints that were required to be taken into
consideration."

I have no problem with saying the government violated the rights of some people and they should be allowed to sue because of it.

I do have a problem with saying "Mr Trudeau was found guilty" because that isn't what was being determined here.
come on, let us rejoice

it has such a nice ring to it

"Mr Trudeau was found guilty"
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,870
70,474
113
isn't "I hate Trudeau" enough?

"an eye for an eye" I'm sure that's somewhere in the constitution
At least you are honest it is just motivated by hate.

But sure, "an eye for an eye" could work.
That would mean freezing Trudeau and everyone who supported the Emergency Act's accounts for 10 days or so.
 

JuanGoodman

Goldmember
Jun 29, 2019
4,901
4,510
113
At least you are honest it is just motivated by hate.

But sure, "an eye for an eye" could work.
That would mean freezing Trudeau and everyone who supported the Emergency Act's accounts for 10 days or so.
when the leader hates his country and his people

it's only reasonable to expect the same feeling for him by the citizens

10 days will be a good start

also do not forget about couple of organizers going to jail and their bail being rejected
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,870
70,474
113
when the leader hates his country and his people

it's only reasonable to expect the same feeling for him by the citizens

10 days will be a good start
"A good start"
So you are more a "two eyes for one eye" kind of guy.

also do not forget about couple of organizers going to jail and their bail being rejected
What does that have to do with this ruling?
 

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,870
70,474
113
there were more damages done to some protesters then just 10 day frozen bank accounts

some had their operating license suspended
Was that found to be in violation of their rights, though?

it's important when calculating eye for an eye penelty
Oh, I see.
So your revenge should be out of all proportion to the actual violation of the rights?
That's how we need to calculate things?
 

JuanGoodman

Goldmember
Jun 29, 2019
4,901
4,510
113
Was that found to be in violation of their rights, though?
it was caused by unjust deceleration of emergencies act

Oh, I see.
So your revenge should be out of all proportion to the actual violation of the rights?
That's how we need to calculate things?
relax you are exaggerating, you are a smart guy, you don't need to do that

all I said was that 10 days would be a good start

no more no less

lets first find out what all the damages were done and act accordingly
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76

Valcazar

Just a bundle of fucking sunshine
Mar 27, 2014
35,870
70,474
113
it was caused by unjust deceleration of emergencies act
How so?

relax you are exaggerating, you are a smart guy, you don't need to do that

all I said was that 10 days would be a good start

no more no less

lets first find out what all the damages were done and act accordingly
But you just said that things that weren't caused by this violation should be included in the damages.
 

JuanGoodman

Goldmember
Jun 29, 2019
4,901
4,510
113
How so?



But you just said that things that weren't caused by this violation should be included in the damages.
ok you are a good negotiator

I will settle for freezing bank accounts for 10 days for all Liberal party members and their online supporters
 
  • Like
Reactions: mitchell76

roddermac

Well-known member
Sep 17, 2023
1,918
1,585
113
Canada was not "shut down" by the Federal Government of months during the Pandemic. Take your gripe to the Ford Govt. and other Provincial Premiers who for once did the right thing.
After all lives are more precious than paper money!!

Even Ford agreed with the Emergency Powers, as he was helpless. After all it was his responsibility at a Provincial level that failed, and the Federal Govt. then stepped in!!

This noisy disruption including the blockages to the daily lives of the Ottawa citizens was of zero merit!!
I agree that is was the premiers that are responsible for the completely useless lockdowns. It was never about health and safety. The lockdowns were pointless and ruined small businesses and all other aspects of life. You don't shutdown society over a virus with a 99.98% survival rate. You can't eradicate a virus in 2 weeks. And Ford was the only Premier to agree with the EA. All the rest were opposed to it. Tells you all you need to know about Dougie.
 

bver_hunter

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2005
29,999
7,899
113
it was a first real show of resistance to the draconian measures put forth by our government

it had to be done to stop Trudeau from completely running a mock
Next time invite this FreeDumb Truckers to honk day and night in your neighbourhood. The Canadians needed the flow of Essential products as the Health and wellbeing of our seniors etc was in danger of being compromised without their medications. But you right wingers moan and groan about the loss of revenue, but yet bow to these far right extremists who were compromising our trade with our biggest partners!!
 

JuanGoodman

Goldmember
Jun 29, 2019
4,901
4,510
113
Next time invite this FreeDumb Truckers to honk day and night in your neighbourhood. The Canadians needed the flow of Essential products as the Health and wellbeing of our seniors etc was in danger of being compromised without their medications. But you right wingers moan and groan about the loss of revenue, but yet bow to these far right extremists who were compromising our trade with our biggest partners!!
wtf?

they were parked trucks on a few city blocks in Ottawa

how did that stop the flow of essential products?

drive on another street, use Waze
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer

bver_hunter

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2005
29,999
7,899
113
wtf?

they were parked trucks on a few city blocks in Ottawa

how did that stop the flow of essential products?

drive on another street, use Waze
You are hilarious. Did they not block the flow of goods at the border between THE USA AND CANADA?

You desperately try to make them out these extremists to be saints in this whole blockade of the Capital.

Let's see the facts:

'Freedom Convoy' cost downtown Ottawa millions per day, experts estimate
Estimates range from $44 million to $200 million in sales, wage losses

.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer

bver_hunter

Well-known member
Nov 5, 2005
29,999
7,899
113
I agree that is was the premiers that are responsible for the completely useless lockdowns. It was never about health and safety. The lockdowns were pointless and ruined small businesses and all other aspects of life. You don't shutdown society over a virus with a 99.98% survival rate. You can't eradicate a virus in 2 weeks. And Ford was the only Premier to agree with the EA. All the rest were opposed to it. Tells you all you need to know about Dougie.
Why is it that a State like Florida that opened very early and refused to shut down then had a death and infection rate that was much higher than that of the whole of Canada?

It could have been even lower rates in Ontario had Ford not delayed until push came to shove. Subsequently, he toed the line when his own health experts pressured him to shut the economy.

He then did the right thing!!
 

The Oracle

Pronouns: Who/Cares
Mar 8, 2004
28,601
57,847
113
On the slopes of Mount Parnassus, Greece
Why is it that a State like Florida that opened very early and refused to shut down then had a death and infection rate that was much higher than that of the whole of Canada?
Gee you think that the size of Florida vs Canada had any impact!!......Or how about Florida having 22 million inhabitants that are aging in that small land mass!!
 
Ashley Madison
Toronto Escorts