Israel at war

Its pretty impossible to investigate IDF claims
IDF claims they have footage and Times of Israel implied they had seen it. It's not inconceivable that said footage might get released one day if it exists.

It's not impossible that the footage exist but contains some intelligence that would jeopardize operations and so for operational security they can't release it yet. Unlikely, but not impossible.
 
Why are you against saving Gazan lives?
Gaslighting, I call for a ceasefire.

Why do you promote the continued bombing of Gaza and the inherent casualties?
Gaslighting, I call for a ceasefire and sanctions against Israel for apartheid.

Why make the suffering last longer?
Gaslighting, I call for sanctions to end apartheid and end the cycle of violence.

Release the hostages immediately.
Hamas surrender unconditionally and give up control of Gaza.
Not that it is genocide, but the killing would stop immediately.
Being the humanitarian you claim to be (fraudster) you'd be saving thousands of lives of Gazans rather than your drawn out cockamamie plan.

Both sides are committing war crimes.
Both sides should ceasefire and both sides should be investigated.
Arguing that the apartheid occupying power should continue a genocidal occupation in the name of peace is idiotic.

Israel is going to win the war, regardless. Why make more innocent people needlessly die?
How is this different from 2008, 2011, 2014, 2018 and 2021, when Israel made the same claims and tried the same tactics?
The only difference this time is the scale of death and destruction?
Why repeat failure?

How do you think this war will play out, frank?

Biden has already called for a ceasefire.
Netanyahu knows his political career is done if he stops, but without US support he'll have to stop.

Global sanctions will grow.
Israel will be forced to end apartheid.
Palestinians will be given the vote.

Biden urged Netanyahu to agree to ‘three-day pause’ in Gaza fighting: Report

US ‘humiliated every day’ in its relationship with Israel: AJ analyst



 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
No, the beginning of this topic was you saying Covert Ops doesn't operate in hostile territory.

So tell us: why isn't Covert Ops going to be effective in Gaza? Clearly you think you understand the topic better than we do so explain it to us.
In order for Mossad to be effective. They need cooperation from civilians....That won't work in Gaza...
 
IDF claims they have footage and Times of Israel implied they had seen it. It's not inconceivable that said footage might get released one day if it exists.

It's not impossible that the footage exist but contains some intelligence that would jeopardize operations and so for operational security they can't release it yet. Unlikely, but not impossible.

IDF released video on the xitter of the hospital with claims that what Al J says is a water supply is actually a Hamas tunnel.
Qatar released a document confirming there was no tunnel.
Hamas invited the UN to inspect the hospital.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
There's nothing wrong with using a place where children used to play as a base of operations. That's been very common throughout modern warfare. Schools, especially European boarding schools, are great places for makeshift barracks or field kitchens. Church steeples make for great observation posts. Playgrounds and sports fields are nice and open to accommodate a temporary motor pool or an improvised helipad or a bivouac.

The problem is using a place with children currently playing there as a base of operations. And that's not shown in this video. Did Hamas kick the kids out before they moved in? If so, there's nothing wrong with this from what I can see. This is fairly common in MOUT or FIBUA.

Aside from the fact that Hamas are terrorists chucking missiles at civilians, of course. But that's not the topic of this video; this video is implying kids were there being used as human shields. But implication is not proof.

As with all the other videos I've seen from them in this war so far, the IDF aren't releasing anything that conclusively establishes their narrative. If you want to take it on faith that what they claim is actually what's happening, that's your prerogative. Seems like a silly thing to do if you're one of the people calling out "the other side" for doing that though.
Fair enough.

From what I've seen in mainstream, non-propaganda western media, it seems to be generally accepted that Hamas HAS and IS CURRENTLY employing the use of human shields. There are only a few interviews I've seen where that gets challenged.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
Fair enough.

From what I've seen in mainstream, non-propaganda western media, it seems to be generally accepted that Hamas HAS and IS CURRENTLY employing the use of human shields. There are only a few interviews I've seen where that gets challenged.
I've never once claimed Hamas isn't.

I just said that footage doesn't prove it. Israel keeps claiming they have proof of stuff and then release things like this that prove nothing. I'm starting to feel like they think we're all too stupid to notice and I find that pretty frustrating. Don't you? If they've got proof, why do they keep releasing the videos that don't show proof?

It's got "Iraq has WMDs" level of deception vibes.
 
What do you think of frank's assessment of what's going on? I know you are both, pretty much, on the same side but he claims to call out both, but he never ever will say a particular thing that Hamas did that was wrong.

He is determined to never admit that the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas was an act of terrorism.

He says both sides should be taken to the Hague. He can cite a dozen specific acts as reasons why Israel should be tried but refuses to cite any reasons why Hamas should go.

Does he actually call out both sides with his broad and sweeping, yet ambiguous statements of accusing both sides, or is he being disingenuous because he refuses to back up those those statements of why he thinks Hamas should be tried the same way he backs up why Israel should be tried?
To Kautilya:
I found this following post of yours. I'm a few pages behind and I'm not sure if you replied to the one above.


Kautilya said:
People hate your posts for lying and gaslighting.
Nobody here supports apartheid, genocide, violence or racial hatred (barring a few outliers, who I will not name). To even insinuate that is another example of your lies.
Dude, you lie all the time. You lie and gaslight. So I will back @shack and what he says about your argumentation style.
 
I won't speak for others. I will speak for myself.

I have called out October 7 as a terrorist attack. I consider Hamas as a terrorist group. I do think Hamas need to be neutralized. But how, they take out Hamas is where my dispute is. Not by carpet bombing Gaza.

I also do not believe in taking Hamas to the Hague. They are a terrorist group, so perhaps a covert military operation is needed to take them out or cripple them by targeting their leaders. Israel am not sure how the ICC will be able to do anything, since Israel is not even a signatory to the ICC. I would care more about ousting Bibi and electing a government that is open to ending the conflict via dialogue.
Thanks for the reply. I actually replied to my own post as I found a previous one of yours which answered my questions.
 
as time went on, it was clear that Israel was just collectively punishing the Palestinians. What is wrong with changing one's opinions when you see what is happening right in front of you?
How is it clear? From sources controlled by hamas such as their ministry of health or whatever? Has hamas returned hostages? Does hamas have any incentive not to repeat October 7? Does israel have a way to deal with hamas other than what they are doing now?
 
Fair enough.

From what I've seen in mainstream, non-propaganda western media, it seems to be generally accepted that Hamas HAS and IS CURRENTLY employing the use of human shields. There are only a few interviews I've seen where that gets challenged.

The MSM repeats IDF claims.
But there is no evidence to back up IDF claims.

But again, even if Hamas is using human shields that doesn't mean Israel is then justified in killing civilians.
Its still a war crime.

A war crime you refuse to condemn and activeley support.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu

Hi Everyone , Aaron Dahan (ramaz graduate) has a coffee shop on 71st and Lexington called Caffe Arrone. He has been donating proceeds to Israel since October 7th. Today his baristas came to work wearing palestinian pins. It was reported to him so he went there to confront them and they all quit. His mom Peggy Dahan is now running the store today.

Boycotting that place is justified.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: mitchell76
How is it clear? From sources controlled by hamas such as their ministry of health or whatever? Has hamas returned hostages? Does hamas have any incentive not to repeat October 7? Does israel have a way to deal with hamas other than what they are doing now?

Your racism means you will never accept the word of any Palestinian.
So lets use international sources.



 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
What would you suggest?

Do you have any suggestions other than genocide and ethnic cleansing?

Do you support continuing the occupation?
Do you support continuing apartheid?

Today Netanyahu floated Israel having 'security' control over Gaza, or a return to the pre 2005 situation.
Biden poo pooed that choice.

Netanyahu has no plan, he has no achievable end to this war.
 
Last edited: