You will only give rise to the next wave of Palestinian resistance.
Netanyahu helped create Hamas to separate Palestinians, get rid of them and you may get a united Palestinian resistance.
Killing people won't lead to peace.
There are other options.
Israel at war
- Thread starter Butler1000
- Start date
Netanyahu helped create Hamas to separate Palestinians, get rid of them and you may get a united Palestinian resistance.
Killing people won't lead to peace.
There are other options.
I understood that the first time and I understand the rules of war. You had give the example of rockets being fired from windows. I am asking if ther is something below ground only then what is the proportional response.
Yes I recall this and I know it is not that simple, even the saying "only return fire if fired upon" is not universal.
Every target needs to be considered for collateral damage, you wouldnt drop a 2,000 pound bomb on a stadium filled with civilians because a single missile was fired from it.
Maybe well placed 30 Caliber rounds would be considered "acceptable" in this case.
The response to a threat in an urban battlefield needs to be considered at all times.
Shack will never stop asking the same questions over and over.
There are lots of testimonies from foreign aid workers who have worked in these hospitals across Gaza who say the IDF claims are nonsense.
Not that it would change shack's mind.
So far in this instance it has been considered...Israel didn't just bomb buildings willy nilly...they have strategically picked a few targets...they gave warnings (which terrorist org give warnings?) they always inform the media what they will do next, they inform them results....I'm still waiting for a video of Israeli soldiers dancing around palestinian corpses and parading them in Tel Aviv but so far there's none...maybe @Frankfooter can help me out....
Warning someone you are about to commit a war crime doesn't make it not a war crime.
Israel is now using chemical weapons on civilians, also a serious war crime.
Not sure if you knew this but there was a third bomb being prepped by the US military to be dropped on August 19th, with as many as 7 more bombs to be dropped by the end of October.
"The pilot of the plane that dropped Little Boy, Colonel Paul Tibbets, told varied accounts. According to his earliest recollection, it would take five atomic bombs to force surrender. He had fifteen bombers and trained crews ready to go in case they needed to drop more atomic bombs during the war. "
The only reason the third was not dropped was because President Truman stepped in.
"While the military continued to prepare for a third atomic strike on Japan, President Truman asserted control. When he learned that a third bomb would be ready in about a week, he ordered that there be no more atomic bombs dropped without his direct approval. When Truman was later asked why he wanted to halt nuclear strikes against Japan, he said that the thought of wiping out another 100,000 people and killing “all those kids” was too horrible."
Since then, only a President can authorize the use of US nuclear weapons.
https://outrider.org/nuclear-weapons/articles/third-shot
How do you know those arent Hamas POW's??
Also I'm not seeing any torture (aside from soldiers putting boots to a few faces).
And there's no evidence they were all lynched
Do you have a link to this report?
Don't worry, found it.
My Dad told me this once (he was a war vet fighting "Japos" in the mountanous regions in the PHilippines). After the bombs were dropped...Japanese Imperial army just left their bases...quietly....just left...some did surrender...I guess they were too far out to get news...
Even though the Japanese surrendered the US military continue preparations for a third strike, just in case there was a military coup.
" Even after Japan surrendered on August 15th, there were fears of a militarist coup in Japan that would restart the war. Preparations for the third atomic strike continued until September 2nd—the day the American Occupation of Japan began."
What an extremely stupid leap. You're looking more ridiculous all the time.
In zero countries of the world do non-citizens have the same rights as citizens.
With your logic, it means that every country in the world is apartheid.
Only when someone refuses to answer a simple and fair question over and over and over again.
Watch:
When you saw the attack of Oct. 7, which you've now admitted was an act of terror against Israeli civilians, yet have continued to justify, did you expect Israel to retaliate violently that would result in Gazan deaths or did you think they'd do nothing.
It's also listed on the Wikipedia page.
I think it's been mentioned in very book I read as well.
There are lots of videos out showing white phosphorus bombs. There are also quite a few reports of Gaza doctors facing burns they say they've never seen before.
You keep admitting that Israel is apartheid by forcing Palestinians to live as stateless refugees with zero human rights.
There is no country of Palestine, so Palestinians are living under apartheid rule with as you admit, different rights from Israeli Jews.
They live under a different legal system, with different roads, different social services and walls around them.
Its apartheid.
You keep admitting it.
When Netanyahu allowed 233 settler attacks to occur in 2023, followed by settlers storming the Al Aqsa, did you and he not expect Hamas to respond, as they did in 2021?
Everyone expected Hamas to respond and everyone expected Israel to respond with disproportionate violence on civilians.
The same as happened in 2008, 2012, 2014, 2018, 2021 and 2022.
The idiotic thing is that thinking killing more Palestinians this time will stop this endless cycle of violence.
Every time.
Attachments
