Jays 2023

The Oracle

Pronouns: Who/Cares
Mar 8, 2004
24,927
49,799
113
On the slopes of Mount Parnassus, Greece
Yup, time to pull the plug on Manoah. The Jays can"t afford to throw away every 5th game. He needs to be sent down to the minors to work out issues, perhaps with the guidance of a different pitching coach.
Problem is who do you bring up? Mitch White has been sent to the bullpen in AAA.

You're going to say anyone might be better but.........

Edit..Ross Stripling has been even worse than Manoah. So there's that.
 
Last edited:

funstick

Well-known member
Jul 20, 2017
1,081
2,539
113
It's sad that the cupboard is bare. Anyhow, no matter who they bring up can't do worse and Manoah may figure things out in the meantime
 

Ref

Committee Member
Oct 29, 2002
5,101
1,027
113
web.archive.org
[QUOTE="The Oracle, post: 7962936, member: 38941"

Edit..Ross Stripling has been even worse than Manoah. So there's that.
[/QUOTE]

LOL! He had a career year last season, or perhaps last year was his career.

Aside from missing something in his game this year, Manoah behaved like an asshole last year and players/teams have geared up for him.
 

The Oracle

Pronouns: Who/Cares
Mar 8, 2004
24,927
49,799
113
On the slopes of Mount Parnassus, Greece
[QUOTE="The Oracle, post: 7962936, member: 38941"

Edit..Ross Stripling has been even worse than Manoah. So there's that.
LOL! He had a career year last season, or perhaps last year was his career.

Aside from missing something in his game this year, Manoah behaved like an asshole last year and players/teams have geared up for him.
[/QUOTE]

A coach used to say to us...''When you win say little and when you lose say less''.

Something today's athletes could learn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roadhog and Ref

black booty lover

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2007
9,831
1,754
113
Problem is who do you bring up? Mitch White has been sent to the bullpen in AAA.

You're going to say anyone might be better but.........

Edit..Ross Stripling has been even worse than Manoah. So there's that.

This isn't about winning games at this point. This about getting Manoah right. Your losing every 5 days anyway, so it doesn't really matter who they put in. Manoah needs some rest, and maybe some time experiment is the minors.
 

black booty lover

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2007
9,831
1,754
113
Well it did work for Roy Halladay once upon a time.....
And not Ricky Romero, but personally (and obviously I'm no expert) but at the very minimum, some time off to give him some rest. There has to be a reason his velocity is down. He logged at lot of innings for a guy that made the transition so quick into the majors.
 

hockeyguy19

Well-known member
Jun 26, 2015
292
554
93
When I watched the first couple of games that Manoah pitched this season, I got the impression that he was a little rattled by the pitch clock. I'm no expert here but perhaps that started fucking with his head and just snowballed from there.
 

Toronto Passions

Trusted Since 2001!
Supporting Member
All i know is we need The Rocket. Lol

Life is so much better with Roger. (this literally has nothing to do with anything). IMG_8846.jpeg IMG_8847.jpeg
IMG_8845.jpeg IMG_8848.jpeg
 
Last edited:

Toronto Passions

Trusted Since 2001!
Supporting Member
This isn't about winning games at this point. This about getting Manoah right. Your losing every 5 days anyway, so it doesn't really matter who they put in. Manoah needs some rest, and maybe some time experiment is the minors.
Apparently Ryu is a couple months away.

Philip
 

Toronto Passions

Trusted Since 2001!
Supporting Member

Nad Smith

Well-known member
Nov 23, 2004
1,644
127
63
Good move to send him that far down. Triple A hitters would have hit him hard too. Not much chatter about his weight. Would he be better if he dropped about 20 pounds?

Also jay Jackson should have been kept. He was quite effective Monday night. Pitch him on Saturday as part of bullpen day.

Saw in the Star that it was unfair to boo Manoah. Disagree. Those people paid a lot of money to see a major league game and pitcher. The booing was for waiting one game too many to demote Manoah. I also saw more than usual empty seats. I decided to go to tonight's game and would not want to pay to see last night's game. Did people , like me, deliberately want to avoid seeing another Manoah start?
 

Toronto Passions

Trusted Since 2001!
Supporting Member
Rickey Romero was doing ok until his girlfriend(Miss Junior USA) dumped him. Maybe Manoah got dumped.
I remember recently Romero was talking about Berrios, and how his struggles are mental, and how he needs to fix that. I'm thinking to myself, yes Ricky ummm elephant in the room.

You should copyright the "TML" name.

Philip
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: tml and mandrill

Zoot Allures

Well-known member
Jan 23, 2017
1,980
736
113
Ross Stripling has been even worse than Manoah. So there's that.
What if we kept him instead of getting Bassitt !

I do not think that was wisdom from Jays management as they tried to sign him.


Agree with sentiment that the number one thing is to get Manoah sound
so send him to Florida which is rookie camp, as low as you can go



My 8 solutions LOL

1

Should not be that hard to replace Manoah , after all, it is a fifth starter we are looking for but now
that we are desperate teams will want more , this problem should have been
solved proactively now we have to react and pay the price.

While we are at it, get two end of rotation starters for when someone else goes down


2

Pitching by a commitee of relievers but that wears out the pen so get a couple of relievers who
can pitch 2 or 3 innings instead of another starter and they can also be used between their
designated 5 spot as starters and be used as short relievers and we have improved over Manoah
with only four starters and lengthened bullpen



3

It used to be pitchers would pitch the whole game with only four starters and still
have a long career so why not use four starters then they come out inning earlier than normal ?

Maybe four starters twice then add the fifth starter every other rotation ?

Could starters refuse the extrawork load ?

I know I would refuse risking my career for a team but where is it written in agreement
how much rest a team must give starter ?

Can a player demand rest ?

4

Trade Vlad for a couple of quality starters and problem is solved LOL, I am tired of the
wait till he gets hot and he will carry whole team hype

5

get terbites to solve prolem

6

Hire Donald rump as consultent as he is a super genius who knows everything

7
Hire Tony Robbins as consultent as he is a super genius who knows everything

8

I suspect Manoah may be back strong this year as he is a proven ace

Sandy Alcantra won NL Cy Young last year and is doing his version of a Manoah
with 2 and 5 record with era over 5

stuff happens with pitchers as the small stuff adds up and then you lose confidence
which is a killer in any sport, regardless of talent
 
Last edited:

black booty lover

Well-known member
Oct 21, 2007
9,831
1,754
113
Good move to send him that far down. Triple A hitters would have hit him hard too. Not much chatter about his weight. Would he be better if he dropped about 20 pounds?
Exactly. The issue is you wouldn't be able to work with him as much AAA. He's not some guy on a rehab stint. They need time to evaluate and practice as opposed him actually pitching, traveling with the team...etc.
 

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
39,375
7,062
113
Rickey Romero was doing ok until his girlfriend(Miss Junior USA) dumped him. Maybe Manoah got dumped.
I'm not sure, Kara Lang is not exactly chopped liver.

To quote Frank Zappa, Alek Manoah needs some discipline. He's out of shape, his velocity is down and he's tipping his pitches. This year batters are just waiting on him to serve fat tatters, the worst part, his stamina is gone. He needs tough love, Gary Roberts would know what to do. Since he's back in Florida why not Osmin Hernandez...a former Cuban Special Forces.

 

Toronto Passions

Trusted Since 2001!
Supporting Member
Regarding Manoah, I see them tinkering with his mechanics down there as well. Like they famously did with Roy Halladay. Possibly change his workout regimen.. Maybe even get him using his lower half better to generate more velocity. Possibly even change his arm angle. His release point etc. etc. who knows.

I am happy they did this. Manoah has spent minimal time in the minors prior. He is an elite pitcher that is totally lost. In terms of his return, some reports say by the All-Star break, other reports say by September. When Halladay got sent down, it dramatically reduced his walk ratio after he came back up again. He really developed a new arm angle, and that hard sinker that became impossible to deal with. I am very excited to see what Alek becomes after this.

Philip
 

takrak

Active member
Dec 19, 2006
226
121
43
Every time when Romano comes in to the game to close it's white knuckles I don't have confidance that he will get the job done. He almost blew the save yesterday, a couple of inches houston would of tied the game. Why didn't they leave Bassitt in to start the 9th he was cruising alnog and his pitch count was low, have Romano ready in the pen if required. Another brain fart move by Schneider that would of cost us the game.
 
Toronto Escorts