Rape By Deception???

WHAT?:Eek:

So much for spooning and the reach over, under, or around.:confused:
http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2011/2011scc28/2011scc28.html
The issue raised was whether a person could perform sexual acts on an unconscious person if the person consented to those acts in advance of being rendered unconscious. Parliament defined consent in a way that required the complainant to be conscious throughout the sexual activity in question. Parliament wanted people to be capable of revoking their consent at any time during the sexual activity. This in turn supported the view that Parliament viewed consent as the product of a conscious mind, since a person who has been rendered unconscious could not revoke her consent. The accused's contention that advance consent could be given to sexual acts taking place during unconsciousness was not in harmony with the provisions of the Criminal Code and their underlying policies. The Court could not accept the accused's contention that an individual could consent in advance to sexual activity taking place while she was unconscious. The jurisprudence consistently interpreted consent as requiring a conscious, operating mind, capable of granting, revoking or withholding consent to each and every sexual act.
 
He didn't take anything, he gave. Auto Mechanics are regulated under a separate set of rules. If you open a garage, you have to be licensed. Also if someone fixed your car and you refused to pay them because they claimed to be Jewish and were instead Arab....good luck with that.

Swap in whatever terms you like to satisfy yourself that courts require no such questioning by fraud victims.

Religion is a protected trait for commercial transactions, but it is commonly accepted as a basis for discriminating sexual partners.
 
http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/2011/2011scc28/2011scc28.html
The issue raised was whether a person could perform sexual acts on an unconscious person if the person consented to those acts in advance of being rendered unconscious. Parliament defined consent in a way that required the complainant to be conscious throughout the sexual activity in question. Parliament wanted people to be capable of revoking their consent at any time during the sexual activity. This in turn supported the view that Parliament viewed consent as the product of a conscious mind, since a person who has been rendered unconscious could not revoke her consent. The accused's contention that advance consent could be given to sexual acts taking place during unconsciousness was not in harmony with the provisions of the Criminal Code and their underlying policies. The Court could not accept the accused's contention that an individual could consent in advance to sexual activity taking place while she was unconscious. The jurisprudence consistently interpreted consent as requiring a conscious, operating mind, capable of granting, revoking or withholding consent to each and every sexual act.

Whoa, I guess it depends a lot on how one regards sleep as being an unconscious state and opens it up to really grey areas, apparently the the courts do. Careful folks, chose those people who choose to 'sleep' with carefully. When they say, 'not tonight dear', heed their words.
 
Whoa, I guess it depends a lot on how one regards sleep as being an unconscious state and opens it up to really grey areas, apparently the the courts do. Careful folks, chose those people who choose to 'sleep' with carefully. When they say, 'not tonight dear', heed their words.

Doesn't matter what she says in the evening, if you wife wakes up as you are feeling her boob and she is not happy about it, you are arrestable for sex assault.
Now if you get a judge alone trial, the judge will have to convict you. If you somehow get a jury trial (I.e. If the offence is more than six months old and the crown must proceed by indictment) you can hope for jury nullification.
 
Doesn't matter what she says in the evening, if you wife wakes up as you are feeling her boob and she is not happy about it, you are arrestable for sex assault.
Now if you get a judge alone trial, the judge will have to convict you. If you somehow get a jury trial (I.e. If the offence is more than six months old and the crown must proceed by indictment) you can hope for jury nullification.

So start with a neck or shoulder rub and let whatever happens happen. Can't remember the last time a neck or shoulder rub was turned down. To paraphrase that olde celtic saying, it better to let sleeping beauties lie.

Or if it was a Coyote Fuck, chew your arm off and run.
 
I think we already moved way beyond the actual case.

Which is extremely sad. The point of the thread seems to be to prove how evil and racist Israel is. The fact of the case show differently but facts don't seem to sway the opinions of people like notty.
 
Swap in whatever terms you like to satisfy yourself that courts require no such questioning by fraud victims.

Religion is a protected trait for commercial transactions, but it is commonly accepted as a basis for discriminating sexual partners.

There is not such legal framework for discriminating sexual partners. Deception and dishonesty have been a long accepted part of male/female sexual interaction.
 
So now you realize that the charges were forcible rape, not some kind of racist judicial system.

Didn't you read the WIKI? One of he judges felt quite clearly the sex was consensual, so if there was a charge for forcible rape, it was likely a false charge by Jewish police against a Muslim man.
 
There is not such legal framework for discriminating sexual partners. Deception and dishonesty have been a long accepted part of male/female sexual interaction.

You aren't trying hard enough, I don't really believe you missed the point.

Unlike commercial transactions, people are entitled to discriminate on the basis of sex, sexual orientation, race, religion, age, national origin, disability, and any other factor they like when choosing sexual partners.

In jurisdictions that have rape by deception laws, the same legal principles will apply to sexual deception as apply to monetary fraud. The courts have a long and rich history in determining what constitutes deception for personal gain.

In fraud cases there is no requirement that the victim have explicitly challenged or questioned the factors on which they were deceived, so there is no reason to expect that to be required in an an analogous rape by deception case. If you fool people into thinking you are a banker, you don't go free by saying "aha but she never actually asked if I was a real banker, after I intentionally gave her the impression I was one".

If you take intentional steps to deceive someone for your own sexual gain, you will fail in court if your defense is "aha but the victim never actually asked my race after I intentionally gave her the wrong impression".
 
Didn't you read the WIKI? One of he judges felt quite clearly the sex was consensual, so if there was a charge for forcible rape, it was likely a false charge by Jewish police against a Muslim man.

Bullshit.

First, one of three judges felt that.

Second, if it was a false rape accusation (and considering she was treated in a hospital afterwards the forcible rape charge seems to have some merit), it would be a case of this one woman not wanting Muslim partners and filing charges, not a case of institutional racism like you are so desperately trying to prove.
 
There is a major difference between unjust convictions in the name of ethnic purity, and the senseless, brutal torture used in efforts to exterminate Jews. I don't think Jews put millions of people in gas chambers or conduct "medical" experiments to see what would happen by things like freezing people, amputating their body parts or removing major organs without anesthesia.

While I do not agree with this conviction whatsoever, this seems to only be about Orthodox Jews, not ALL of them. Most forms of Orthodoxy - in any religion - are the extreme end of a continuum.

You have heard of this place in the Middle East right? Human rights violations en masse (already murders of Palestine civilians in the millions)
 
That is another can of worms. Current state of law in Canada prohibits sexually touching your sleeping wife or husband. Fucked up feminist driven bullshit.

This would be nearly impossible to prove in a court
Even if you argue no consent (B - as asleep) you would need to overcome (E - went to bed together and did not attempt to leave)
If a woman goes to bed with you and does not say no then consent can not be withdrawn


273.1 (1) Subject to subsection (2) and subsection 265(3), “consent” means, for the purposes of sections 271, 272 and 273, the voluntary agreement of the complainant to engage in the sexual activity in question.
Marginal note:
Where no consent obtained

(2) No consent is obtained, for the purposes of sections 271, 272 and 273, where

(a) the agreement is expressed by the words or conduct of a person other than the complainant;

(b) the complainant is incapable of consenting to the activity;

(c) the accused induces the complainant to engage in the activity by abusing a position of trust, power or authority;

(d) the complainant expresses, by words or conduct, a lack of agreement to engage in the activity; or

(e) the complainant, having consented to engage in sexual activity, expresses, by words or conduct, a lack of agreement to continue to engage in the activity.
 
If a woman goes to bed with you and does not say no then consent can not be withdrawn

A Canadian court has disagreed with you and convicted a man of sexual assault.

The court's view is that consent cannot be given in advance, consent must be immediate and conscious. Your view that consent "can not be withdrawn" is wrong-- once the woman is asleep, the consent no longer exists, as she is not immediately consciously consenting.

In the case where the guy was convicted, the woman woke up and claimed that he had been much more aggressive than anything she consented to, and complained to the police. The court found that she HAD consented prior to going to sleep, but that once she was asleep she was incapable of consenting, and her prior consent was irrelevant because it was not immediate and conscious.

I am paraphrasing a bit (court likely used slightly different words) but that was the general idea.
 
The court's view is that consent cannot be given in advance, consent must be immediate and conscious. Your view that consent "can not be withdrawn" is wrong-- once the woman is asleep, the consent no longer exists, as she is not immediately consciously consenting.

First part makes sense - obviously permission given ..say three years ago ... does not mean it is still current and cannot be withdrawn. Actually the concept of being unable to with draw consent at anytime seems a little scary.

The concept that if a woman drifts asleep during a consented love making session suddenly constitutes a rape is ludicrous. Recognizing that a refusal should end any activities, if two partners have set up a loving relationship including night and morning sex acts - there should be an implied consent right through to the morning. I have been awoken (and performed similar acts) with my partner sexually stimulating me - RAPE !!!! The thought that the law (as defined by immediate conscious consent only) would prevent me from 'spooning' my SO at night without waking her up first would be as frustrating for her as it is for me.

A law that is so unrealistic to lovers must have been dreamed up by men hating feminists.
 
The concept that if a woman drifts asleep during a consented love making session suddenly constitutes a rape is ludicrous.

And yet it's the law. You would have to realize she was asleep and intentionally continue, and of course she would have to complain to the police. It is certainly the case that many people break this law, and arguably if your SO really loves you, she isn't going to turn you in to the police.

In the actual case where a woman did turn her partner over, the sex acts were much more intrusive, rough anal sex with some object that led to pain, iirc. She says she consented in advance not knowing how painful it would be, the judge concluded that she couldn't have consented in any case.
 
First part makes sense - obviously permission given ..say three years ago ... does not mean it is still current and cannot be withdrawn. Actually the concept of being unable to with draw consent at anytime seems a little scary.

The concept that if a woman drifts asleep during a consented love making session suddenly constitutes a rape is ludicrous. Recognizing that a refusal should end any activities, if two partners have set up a loving relationship including night and morning sex acts - there should be an implied consent right through to the morning. I have been awoken (and performed similar acts) with my partner sexually stimulating me - RAPE !!!! The thought that the law (as defined by immediate conscious consent only) would prevent me from 'spooning' my SO at night without waking her up first would be as frustrating for her as it is for me.

A law that is so unrealistic to lovers must have been dreamed up by men hating feminists.

If you woman is drifting off to sleep, I'd suggest there's something wrong with your technique. As for the rest, you are totally right. To quote Mr Bumble,

"If the law supposes that," said Mr. Bumble, squeezing his hat emphatically in both hands, "the law is a ass — a idiot. If that's the eye of the law, the law is a bachelor; and the worst I wish the law is, that his eye may be opened by experience — by experience.
 
If you woman is drifting off to sleep, I'd suggest there's something wrong with your technique. As for the rest, you are totally right. To quote Mr Bumble,

Could be the technique - happened to me in my early years on both sides of the ledger. In the early days I would take my SO camping with friends and party into the night (lots of booze). One time after hitting our tent, we were trying different positions and the last one, she lay on her stomach while I lay on top in a sprawled doggie style. I was working my magic (I thought) when I noticed that she was now sleeping. Another time I woke up and the SO was pissed at me and I didn't know why. It turns out I was drilling for heaven the night before when I suddenly collapsed and started snoring in her ear. When I was in my late teens & early twenties, I drank way too much and did a lot of stupid things. Passing out during love making was probably the least embarrassing of the lot.