Rape By Deception???

But you have to admit persuit of ethnic purity is a beginning and slippery slope.

A beginning to what, and slippery slope to where? For sure its racist IMO, and seems like a form of eugenics. However, I don't see a connection with the horrific torture and slaughtering of 6 million people (many of whom were not Jews). Rather than offering a more extensive list of torture methods used, you may want to look at this before drawing any comparisons: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_human_experimentation

P.S. you may not want to eat dinner closely thereafter.
 
For general information about 11 million people were killed in connection with the Nazi death camps, concentration camps, and death squads; of those about six million were Jews.
 
There is a major difference between unjust convictions in the name of ethnic purity, and the senseless, brutal torture used in efforts to exterminate Jews. I don't think Jews put millions of people in gas chambers or conduct "medical" experiments to see what would happen by things like freezing people, amputating their body parts or removing major organs without anesthesia.

While I do not agree with this conviction whatsoever, this seems to only be about Orthodox Jews, not ALL of them. Most forms of Orthodoxy - in any religion - are the extreme end of a continuum.

There are those whom argue ( and I agree with) that the Israeli government is holding the Palestinians to a subsistence level by keeping them in an open air prison, subjecting them to checkpoints, and demolishing houses in their own land. I haven't even got into how many Palestinians are killed every year by the Israeli army.
 
There are those whom argue ( and I agree with) that the Israeli government is holding the Palestinians to a subsistence level by keeping them in an open air prison, subjecting them to checkpoints, and demolishing houses in their own land. I haven't even got into how many Palestinians are killed every year by the Israeli army.

Interesting. One, the West Bank economy is expanding. Two, Gaza's issues have a lot to do with Hamas and their genocidal program. Three, you concern yourself with a few dozen Palestinians killed by Israel this year, most of whom were directly involved in attacks on Israel yet seem to have little to say about the 150,000ish dead and 2 million refugees in Syria. Four, you take Russia Times as a legitimate news source.
 
A couple of points: Didn't this trial take place a full three years ago? Wasn't there a thread about it at the time? I seem to recall that both are true.

This was the case where an Israeli Court held that “lying about one’s identity to seduce a woman is considered rape.”

An Arab man living in Jerusalem “presented himself as a Jewish bachelor looking for a serious romantic relationship,” a woman agreed to have sex with him. Once she found out that he was neither Jewish nor looking for anything beyond a one-night stand, she pressed charges. The man was convicted of “rape by deception” and sentenced to 18 months in prison.


- - - - - - -

This case does have certain similarities to the situation in California related to People v Morales. Where the California Assembly is currently considering a bill that would expand the definition of rape to include the act of a perpetrator who secures a victim’s consent by impersonating his or her partner.
 
Again are you implying that people should have to date or marry those they do not want to? What difference does it make why they don't want to, they have an absolute right not to.

Making a law prosecuting sex by deception of race but not other things is racist, not same as right to choose.
 
Yet that's not what the law says. THIS violation of the law was a deception about religion but the law covers any deception.

So in Israel, lying about wealth or status to get laid is also rape? If so I like to see case. If not the application of the law is flawed racially.
 
Considering most crimes against a person are only charged if there is a complaint, it is possible that this is the only woman who filed charges under this law.

p.s. According to wikipedia, the original charges were violent rape. The rape by deception was part of a plea bargain. Seems this is just another case of propaganda winning out over truth.

This week, Ha'ir reported that, according to her testimony, the woman had met Kashur on a street in West Jerusalem and chatted with him for a few minutes before he invited her into a nearby building, claiming it was his workplace. Asked why she had agreed, she reportedly told the court: "I looked for someone to put my trust in."

Once inside the building, the woman says she was raped and then left naked and bleeding. Part of her testimony reads: "He said that if I don't stay silent and I don't resist, then it would like end faster and it wouldn't be like ... he wouldn't use force. I still resisted him, and it was forced.

http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/sep/08/rape-by-deception-plea-israel
 
Again are you implying that people should have to date or marry those they do not want to? What difference does it make why they don't want to, they have an absolute right not to.

That is nonsense. All he is saying is if you decided to take someone for face value and fuck them, and if they turned out to not be what you thought, such is life.
 
That is nonsense. All he is saying is if you decided to take someone for face value and fuck them, and if they turned out to not be what you thought, such is life.

The principle is the exact same as fraud. If you intentionally deceive someone for money, it's criminal fraud. If you intentionally deceive someone for sex, it's rape by deception.

Not hard to understand.
 
The principle is the exact same as fraud. If you intentionally deceive someone for money, it's criminal fraud. If you intentionally deceive someone for sex, it's rape by deception.
Not hard to understand.

Would you say it is more serious to lie about your ethnic / religious background to get laid than lying about money and status?
 
Would you say it is more serious to lie about your ethnic / religious background to get laid than lying about money and status?

Same, or perhaps religion is more serious. Religion is pretty important to a lot of people. A lot refuse to date outside their religion.

In any case, an intentional deception.

I would put status as a cross dresser up there too: how would you feel if you got a blow job from a woman who turned out to be a drag queen? If you like ladyboys, sure, I bet many would feel violated.
 
Same, or perhaps religion is more serious. Religion is pretty important to a lot of people. A lot refuse to date outside their religion.

In any case, an intentional deception.

I would put status as a cross dresser up there too: how would you feel if you got a blow job from a woman who turned out to be a drag queen? If you like ladyboys, sure, I bet many would feel violated.

Always check her V before letting her blow you. But I dont care about her race or religion.