Rape By Deception???

Israel is essentially a European nation grafted onto the middle east. It is not really possible culturally or historically to compare Israel to any nations outside the west.
 
...

If they are not willing to accept Israel's territorial expansion and any other hard line Israel position - like Tibet with China - they really aren't interested in peace.

Except there have been numerous offers of a Palestinian state, starting in 1937 when the Palestinian state would have been 85% of the Mandate. They turned it down. Just last decade, Olmert offered Abbas a Palestinian state on the '67 lines with land swaps, the Palestinian capitol in East Jerusalem, a land connection between Gaza and West Bank, a limited number of refugees to Israel (200,000 according to a former Fatah big shot), and shared authority for holy sites. Abbas responded by walking away without comment.

Of course you continue to ignore that one of the two Palestinian governments refuses to accept any permanent peace that includes Israel continuing to exist.


There was no mainstream Jewish forces, the Jews were still the minority (before the huge immigration influx). Irgun was fighting for a Jewish state - they got it. Their mandate was complete - terrorism had won ! Their leader Menachem Begin was hailed a hero and his terrorist ... oops .. patriotic fighting past helped his political future.
As with many of Israel's critics, your historical knowledge is extremely limited. Irgun was fringe, at most with 4,000 members in the mid 30's with over half returning to Haganah in 1937. As a comparison, Haganah, founded in response to the Arab riots on 1920, averaged over 20,000 members in the 30's. Also worth mentioning is that Haganah forcibly disarmed Irgun during the war following Arab refusal of the partition.

Of course a discussion of Irgun should also mention the reason for their formation, Arab attcks on Jews.
 
Israel is essentially a European nation grafted onto the middle east. It is not really possible culturally or historically to compare Israel to any nations outside the west.

Israel's Jewish population is over 50% descended from Middle Eastern Jews. The most common trait the country has with Europe is a similar political system.
 
Israel's Jewish population is over 50% descended from Middle Eastern Jews. The most common trait the country has with Europe is a similar political system.

But the European Jews the Ashkenazi Jews founded the country and led it in the formative years, mostly socialists BTW like David Ben - Gurion.

The dye was cast.
 
And before Zionism, Jews were the largest ethnic group in Jerusalem.

Of course none of that changes the fact that Israel is a large step ahead on human rights that it's neighbours nor the fact that one of the two Palestinian governments has Israel's destruction as it's number one goal.
 
By anyone, I'm guessing those sympathetic to Israel. You obvious not implying that the displaced Palestinians or any of their Arab neighbours feel that way. Sheesh !

In fact it is Arab League policy to negotiate a peace deal on 67 borders, so by "anyone" I mean anyone who accepts that Israel has a right to exist. Hamas won't accept Israel on 67 borders, 48 borders, or any other borders.

China, Stalin, Hitler, Japan ... you are in good company !

Sorry you got the analogy backwards. It was the Arabs who attacked Israel in a war of aggression. Japan absolutely lost territory after it attacked other nations, why shouldn't the Arabs?

Israel captured that land defending itself from a genocidal Arab attack.

The obvious and winning answer is pragmatism, because giving up that land may somehow appease the Arabs and lead to peace. Appeasement doesn't have a stellar history but it is worth a try.

Yes, most military strategists prefer building civilian communities instead of military outposts to protect against armed aggression. Makes total sense.

You may have noticed a security wall.

If you look at a map you will see that from the sea to the west bank is a very short distance around Netanya.

I guarantee your it worries IDF what will happen if an Arab army parked another armored column there in some future Palestinian state. It could cut Israel in two, dividing north from south before IDF fully realized there was an attack underway.

It is indeed a key Israeli goal to extend a buffer zone around that "wasp waist" to create strategic depth. In fact, the wasp waist is there because cutting Israel in two is exactly what the Arab armies were trying to do in 48. It is the biggest strategic weakness in Israeli geography.

Assuming the Palestinians want a peace in which both sides feel secure, they ought to swap that land for equally good quality land in the east where it is just as good for farming, but not so good for warring.

If they are not willing to accept Israel's territorial expansion and any other hard line Israel position - like Tibet with China - they really aren't interested in peace.

Olmert offered peace on 67 borders with equitable land swaps, on offer that met all the conditions laid out by the Arab League. Anyone interested in peace at least would have made a counter offer, and proposals could be traded until they reach a deal.

Instead of saying "hey thanks, that doesn't work for us, but how about this instead?" guess what the Palestinians did?

They walked away from the table and refused further negotiations.

There was no mainstream Jewish forces, the Jews were still the minority (before the huge immigration influx).

Wrong. Haganah was the armed wing of the Jewish Agency. The JA became the government of Israel, and Haganah became IDF. They very much were the mainstream organizations representing and defending Jews in Palestine.

Haganah had 30,000 men under arms during the civil war, while Irgun had about 600 fighters out of perhaps 4000 members.

Haganah split from Irgun in the 30's specifically over the issue of attacking civilians, Haganah rejected it, while Irgun embraced terrorism and atrocity.

In 46 the Jewish Agency itself branded Irgun a terrorist organization, a view that was ratified at the 1946 World Zionist Conference. Mainstream Jews and Jewish organizations have always repudiated terrorism.

At the a Battle of Haifa, Haganah opened fire on Irgun to drive them out of the city so that Arab residents there would not be harmed, and at the close of the war, Haganah surrounded Irgun and disarmed them at gunpoint.

There certainly were terrorists on both sides, but Israel disarmed them and repudiated terrorism, while the main Palestinians organizations are themselves historically terrorist.

As for allowing them to participate in politics after that were disarmed, that was the right choice. It avoided further war.

Similarly, it is right that President Mahmoud Abbas is being given a chance to try politics instead of violence, even though he was one of the organizers of the Munich Massacre.

Similarly, if Hamas renounce violence, I would support an amnesty for their leaders so that they could participate in politics processes.

As we learned in Northern Ireland, that sort of reconciliation, bringing guys like Gerry Adams or Martin McGuinness into the political process, despite their terrorist origins, is necessary for real peace.
 
And before Zionism, Jews were the largest ethnic group in Jerusalem.

Of course none of that changes the fact that Israel is a large step ahead on human rights that it's neighbours nor the fact that one of the two Palestinian governments has Israel's destruction as it's number one goal.

Palistinians Arabs see Jews the way North Americans Aboriginals see Columbus. An invader who took their land. They want it back.
 
Palistinians Arabs see Jews the way North Americans Aboriginals see Columbus. An invader who took their land. They want it back.

What about the Jews who have lived in the area since antiquity?

How about the 700,000 Jews and their millions of descendants who fled to Israel after they were ethnically cleansed from other Arab states?

Are they invaders in the only home they ever had?

Oh, and they are genetically indistinguishable from Palestinians, the only difference being that the Palestinians converted to Islam a few hundred years back. A lot of the Palestinians descended from Jews, they are both semitic peoples.
 
Palistinians Arabs see Jews the way North Americans Aboriginals see Columbus. An invader who took their land. They want it back.

So you support Hamas in their desire to destroy the only functional democracy in the middle east. That's nice to know.

As it is, plenty of Jews were living there in Ottoman times but that's all history. What is significant now is that the majority of Israelis support a two state peace and have had multiple offers turned down by the more moderate Palestinian government while the less moderate one (or is it the more honest one) still openly desires the destruction of Israel, not the building of a Palestinian state.
 
Did I say I support Hamas? Do I support sending the white settlers of North America back to Europe? There needs to be a just settlement, based on a 2 state policy that puts Israel more or less behind the green line with swaps and their integrity within the 1967 borders is guaranteed by international powers. The hold up to that kind of settlement is Israel not the Arabs. Israel is attempting to create "facts on the ground" with a massive settlement program and catering to some religious fanatics who keep calling the west bank Judea and Sameria.
 
Did I say I support Hamas? Do I support sending the white settlers of North America back to Europe? There needs to be a just settlement, based on a 2 state policy that puts Israel more or less behind the green line with swaps and their integrity within the 1948 borders is guaranteed by international powers. The hold up to that kind of settlement is Israel not the Arabs. Israel is attempting to create "facts on the ground" with a massive settlement program and catering to some religious fanatics who keep calling the west bank Judea and Sameria.

Not even the Arab League thinks 1948 borders are viable. 1967 borders are what everyone agrees should be the basis of a deal.

The Israelis have repeatedly offered that exact deal to the Palestinians, who repeatedly walk away from talks.

Also, even if Fatah ultimately signs, Hamas goes on a terrorist rampage every time a deal is possible and openly says it will never accept a lasting peace with Israel. So even if Israel makes a reasonable deal with Fatah, there's still no peace.
 
I corrected my post to the 1967 borders of course. Although the 1948 borders would be the fair borders they are not viable. When I kept mentioning the Green Line, this is essentially the 1967 borders.

The thing I have greatest hope for is the Arab-Israeli population bomb as the % of Israel that is Arab keeps increasing the internal unfairness will need to be dealt with. This has slowed but the Arab birth rate continues to be higher than the Jewish birth rate + Jewish immigration. Right now it is about 75% Jewish, 21% Arab and 4% Christian and others.

This will change.
 
Did I say I support Hamas? Do I support sending the white settlers of North America back to Europe? There needs to be a just settlement, based on a 2 state policy that puts Israel more or less behind the green line with swaps and their integrity within the 1967 borders is guaranteed by international powers. The hold up to that kind of settlement is Israel not the Arabs. Israel is attempting to create "facts on the ground" with a massive settlement program and catering to some religious fanatics who keep calling the west bank Judea and Sameria.
Interesting that you assign the blame to Israel, a country who's majority supports such a plan and in fact has had several offers along those lines refused by the Palestinians yet don't see fit to mention that one of the two Palestinian governments vows never to accept a two state peace.

Olmert offered Abbas pretty much everything and he had no response. Israel has one concern about any deal and that is its security and considering that major Palestinian factions have vowed to continue terrorism until Israel is destroyed (Hamas, Islamic Jihad, PFLP, and even Abbas's own military wing) it is a sensible concern.
 
Oh, and they are genetically indistinguishable from Palestinians, the only difference being that the Palestinians converted to Islam a few hundred years back. A lot of the Palestinians descended from Jews, they are both semitic peoples.

I think Palestinians are darker. There are alot of blonde, blue eyed Israeli Jews, and a lot of them came from Europe during and after WWII, and Russian Jews more recently, which adds to their "whiteness". I've met a couple of white Jews from Israel, and they speak pretty badly of Arabs and they talk pretty racist tones - just adds to my impression that Israelis hate Arabs and Palestinians from their guts despite their so-called official policy of democracy and equality.
 
I think Palestinians are darker. There are alot of blonde, blue eyed Israeli Jews, and a lot of them came from Europe during and after WWII, and Russian Jews more recently, which adds to their "whiteness". I've met a couple of white Jews from Israel, and they speak pretty badly of Arabs and they talk pretty racist tones - just adds to my impression that Israelis hate Arabs and Palestinians from their guts despite their so-called official policy of democracy and equality.

The Jews who are native to the middle east, about 700k of whom were ethnically cleansed from Arab countries in 48, look like everybody else in the middle east.

Russian Jews, etc, obviously have done Russian mixed in.

The Jews at least are willing to make peace, and Arabs in Israel, despite the racial tension caused by the war, have greater rights and freedoms than Arabs in any other country in the middle east.